{Human, Soar}-in-the-loop

Transcription

1 {Human, Soar}-in-the-loop Visual Guidance through Reasoning Mohamed El Banani University of Michigan - Ann Arbor 37 th Soar Workshop June 7, 2017 Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

2 Overview 1 Motivation 2 Hybrid Intelligence 3 Application: Viewpoint Estimation 4 Conclusion Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

3 Motivation Motivation Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

4 Motivation Motivation Can an agent use its reasoning and interaction capabilities to improve its perception? Source: thejetsons.wikia.com Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

5 Hybrid Intelligence Hybrid Intelligence Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

6 Hybrid Intelligence What is Hybrid Intelligence? Hybrid Intelligence has been studied under di erent names: Hybrid Intelligent Systems: Computational architectures integrating neural and symbolic processes. [4] Human-in-the-loop Systems: The system asks humans to make judgments whenever the computer is less confident resulting in the most accurate, trustworthy system. [1] Symbiotic Autonomy: [...] a robot reasons about, plans for, and overcomes its limitations by proactively asking humans in the environment for help. [6] Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

7 Hybrid Intelligence Reasons for Hybrid Intelligence Di erent intelligent systems have di erent strengths: Symbolic Rule-based systems work very well when the environment can be abstracted in such a way that allows rules to be applied. Connectionist systems work very well when a general pattern exists in the data. Humans can flexibly deal with anomalies and novel cases, and they think out of the box. Systems that are able to leverage the strengths of all those systems are likely to perform better than any single one of those sytems. Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

8 Viewpoint Estimation Viewpoint Estimation Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

9 Viewpoint Estimation Task Description Estimate the agent s viewpoint from a 2D image. A richer description than location or object class. Source: PASCAL 3D+ Dataset [7] Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

10 Viewpoint Estimation Typical Approaches Match image to a 3-D model.[2] Train a neural network.[3] Source: Top: FPM [2]. Bottom: Render For CNN [3] Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

11 Viewpoint Estimation Human-in-the-loop Viewpoint Estimation Source: Click-Here CNN [5] Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

12 Viewpoint Estimation Soar-in-the-loop Viewpoint Estimation Why use Soar? 1 Interface to minimize expected human input. 2 Provide an autonomous agent with more control over its perception. Source: Nate Derbinsky Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

13 Viewpoint Estimation SVS meets Deformable Parts Models Part detectors combined with a parts model could allow for reasoning about part relations. SVS would support the parts model and spatial reasoning. Source: Max Planck Institute Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

14 Conclusion Conclusion Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

15 Conclusion Conclusion Nuggets: 1 Hybrid Intelligence allows one to leverage di erent intelligent systems (including humans). 2 Auxillary input can be used to improve the performance of a deep learning vision system. 3 Soar could use its reasoning and interaction capabilities to improve its perception. 4 Integrating deep learning with Soar. Coal: 1 To be implemented! Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

16 Conclusion References I Clare Corthell. Hybrid intelligence: How artifical assistants work, May [Online; posted 28-May-2017]. Joseph J Lim, Aditya Khosla, and Antonio Torralba. Fpm: Fine pose parts-based model with 3d cad models. In European Conference on Computer Vision, pages Springer, Hao Su, Charles R. Qi, Yangyan Li, and Leonidas J. Guibas. Render for cnn: Viewpoint estimation in images using cnns trained with rendered 3d model views. In The IEEE International Conference on Computer Vision (ICCV), December Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

17 Conclusion References II Ron Sun and Lawrence A Bookman. Computational architectures integrating neural and symbolic processes: A perspective on the state of the art, volume 292. Springer Science & Business Media, Ryan Szeto and Jason J Corso. Click here: Human-localized keypoints as guidance for viewpoint estimation. arxiv preprint arxiv: , Manuela M Veloso, Joydeep Biswas, Brian Coltin, and Stephanie Rosenthal. Cobots: Robust symbiotic autonomous mobile service robots. In IJCAI, page 4423, Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

18 Conclusion References III Yu Xiang, Roozbeh Mottaghi, and Silvio Savarese. Beyond pascal: A benchmark for 3d object detection in the wild. In IEEE Winter Conference on Applications of Computer Vision (WACV), Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19

19 Conclusion Human-in-the-loop Performance Source: Click-Here CNN [5] Mohamed El Banani (Soar Group) {Human, Soar} in the loop June 7, / 19