Public-Private Partnership in Infrastructure Development Case Studies from Asia and Europe

Transcription

1 Public-Private Partnership in Infrastructure Development Case Studies from Asia and Europe This book, produced by the EAP³N Project with contributions from its members, all of whom are active academics and practitioners in the field of infrastructure PPP, is intended to be as an aid to greater mutual understanding in this area. It is structured into two parts and consists of one Introduction chapter and five case studies, each focusing on a specific project and each highlighting key issues and problem areas.

2 Imprint Scientific series of Chair Construction Economics Editor Bauhaus-Universität Weimar Faculty of Civil Engineering Chair Construction Economics Univ.-Prof. Dr.-Ing. Dipl.-Wirtsch.-Ing. Hans Wilhelm Alfen Marienstraße 7a Weimar, Germany Phone: +49 (0) Availability Publisher of Bauhaus-Universität Weimar Fax: +49 (0) Authors Hans Wilhelm Alfen, Satyanarayana N. Kalidindi, Stephen Ogunlana, ShouQing Wang, Martinus P. Abednego, Andrea Frank-Jungbecker, Yu-Chien Amber Jan, Yongjian Ke, YuWen Liu, L. Boeing Singh, GuoFu Zhao Print Docupoint Magdeburg GmbH Cover Christian Mohr ISBN This publication is also available as digital version under URL

3 Table of Contents 1 AN INTRODUCTION TO PPP CONCEPT What is PPP? Definition and Delimitation of PPP Advantages of PPP: Efficiency Gains Elements Determining the PPP Business Model Basic Model: Urban Development versus Public Service Provision Forms of Privatisation and Privatisation Development Path Kind of Partnership Mode of Sector Financing PPP Contract Models in International Practice Phases of a PPP Project Enabling Framework Legal Framework Regulatory Framework Administrative framework Contractual Framework Project Agreement Project Shareholders and their Perspectives PPP Project Stakeholders Perspective PPP Project Financing Funding Sources and Financial Instruments Financing Strategy Major Issues Financial Package and Risk Profile Risk Management Risk Identification Risk Assessment Risk Allocation Risk Mitigation CASE STUDY I - DIFFERENT RISK PERSPECTIVES IN THE 2ND STAGE CIPULARANG TOLLWAY PROJECT Infrastructure Development in Indonesia Tollroad Development in Indonesia... 43

4 2.3 The 2nd Stage Cipularang Tollway project Project Background Problems Encountered in Project Issues on Differences in Perspectives between the Government and Private Sector Project Success Government s Perspective on Project Success Private Sector s Perspective on Project Success Project Efficiency Government s Perspective on Project Efficiency Private Sector s Perspective on Project Efficiency Project Risks Conclusion CASE STUDY II - GOVERNANCE ISSUES IN THE YEN LENH BRIDGE BOT PROJECT Infrastructure Development in Vietnam BOT Projects in Vietnam Yen Lenh Bridge BOT Project Project Background BOT Project Risk Identification Land Acquisition Delay Delay in Approval from Government Agencies Risk of Transportation Network in Region Influencing the BOT Project Cost Overrun Unrealistic Forecast on Future Economic Development & Demand of the Society Increasing Inflation Rate Incorrect Analysis of Ownership Duration Interest Rate Fluctuation General Corruption and Untrustworthiness of Public Official Actual Traffic Revenues Lower than Estimated Risk Perceptions in the Project Governance Issues in Project Fairness Transparency Accountability Sustainability Effectiveness and Efficiency... 86

5 3.5 Conclusion CASE STUDY III - WARNOWQUERUNG ROSTOCK EXPERIENCES FROM THE FIRST GERMAN PPP ROAD PROJECT UNDER THE F-MODEL Project Background Project Objectives Project Scope and Site Legal Framework Federal Private Road Financing Act of 1994 (FStrPrivFinG) and F- Model Contractual and Financial Framework Stakeholders and Project Structure Sources of Finance Risk Allocation Traffic Forecast Current Developments Lessons Learned CASE STUDY IV - LAIBIN B POWER PROJECT THE FIRST STATE- APPROVED BOT PROJECT IN CHINA Project Background Project Description Project Partners Central Government Provincial Government Sponsor Project Company Lender Customer Supplier Contractor Operator Development Process Initial Planning Prequalification Tendering Tender Evaluation Evaluation Criteria Critical Success Factors

6 5.5 Legislation Driving the Project Basic Deal Structure Concession Agreement (CA) Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) Financial Analysis Government Initiatives Exclusive Concession Granted Power Purchase Guarantee Fuel Supply Guarantee Force Majeure Guarantee Foreign Exchange Guarantee Compensation under Government s Default and Political Risks Tax Incentives Guarantee of Lenders Right Land and Utilities and Other Support Measures Risk Management Tariff Adjustment Chinese Parties Reliability & Creditworthiness Dispatch Constraint Change in Law Exchange Rate & Convertibility Force Majeure Financial Closing Delay in Approval Expropriation Corruption Risk Allocation Summary CASE STUDY VI - THE NATIONAL STADIUM BOT PROJECT FOR BEIJING 2008 OLYMPIC GAMES Introduction Project Objectives State Level Project Level Development Process Project Partners The Public Partner

7 6.4.2 The Private Partner China International Trust and Investment Corporation Beijing Urban Construction Group Corporation Golden State Holding Group Cooperation Project Management Advisors Project Structure Project Scope and Location Project Scope Location Government s Supports and Incentives Basic Deal Structure The BMG s Obligations The Project Company s Obligations The Project Company s Revenues The Competitive Stadiums Sources of Finance The Shareholders of the Project The Financial Arrangements of the Project Insights into Major Issues The Disputes in the Project Disputes among the Project Company s Partners Disputes between the Project Company and The BMG Dispute between the Project Company and the Design Consortium The Impacts of Canceling the Retractable Roof Pros of Canceling the Retractable Roof Cons of Canceling the Retractable Roof Risks in the Project Summary