Organisation de Coopération et de Développement Économiques Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development

Transcription

1 Unclassified NEA/SEN/SIN/WGRISK/A(2016)1 NEA/SEN/SIN/WGRISK/A(2016)1 Unclassified Organisation de Coopération et de Développement Économiques Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development 23-Feb-2016 English text only NUCLEAR ENERGY AGENCY COMMITTEE ON THE SAFETY OF NUCLEAR INSTALLATIONS Working Group on Risk Assessment (WGRISK) Notification of the 17th Meeting of the Working Group on Risk Assessment OECD Conference Centre, Room CC th March 2016 Paris, France JT English text only Complete document available on OLIS in its original format This document and any map included herein are without prejudice to the status of or sovereignty over any territory, to the delimitation of international frontiers and boundaries and to the name of any territory, city or area.

2 17 TH MEETING OF THE WORKING GROUP ON RISK ASSESSMENT OECD Conference Centre, Room CC5, 2 Rue André-Pascal, Paris-16, France th March 2016 The 17 th annual meeting of the CSNI Working Group on Risk Assessment (WGRISK) will take place on th March 2016 in Room CC5 at the OECD Conference Centre, 2 Rue André-Pascal, Paris, France. The meeting will start at 9:30 hours on Wednesday 16 th March 2016 in Room CC5, Conference Centre and is expected to finish by lunch time on Friday 18 th March PLEASE NOTE THAT THE BUREAU IS ALSO MEETING DURING THAT WEEK PLEASE SEE THE DETAILS BELOW THE AGENDAS FOR WHICH WHEN AVAILABLE WILL BE DISTRIBUTED TO YOU SEPARATELY. MEMBERS PARTICIPATING IN THESE MEETINGS ARE URGED TO ARRANGE THEIR TRAVEL ACCORDINGLY. Task group leaders and other delegates wishing to present papers, reports, proposals, etc., are requested to transmit an electronic copy of the paper to the NEA Secretariat Olivia Stefanuto (olivia.stefanuto@oecd.org) or Takayoshi Nezuka (Takayoshi.Nezuka@oecd.org) Andrew White (andrew.white@oecd.org) By 11 th March 2016, at the latest if prior distribution is required. Please note that reproduction of documents takes considerable time and because of the meeting venue the Secretariat cannot guarantee that copies will be available for distribution if received after this date. Alternatively, delegates are invited to bring 40 copies of documents with them for distribution at the meeting. Delegates participating are advised that the security arrangements in force at the OECD include the obligation to present an identity document bearing a photograph. This document may be requested at the time of issuing delegates cards for the meeting. It should also be presented subsequently together with the card every time OECD premises are entered for the outside. It is desirable that the delegates are aware of this requirement in order to avoid any difficulty in obtaining entry. All designated participants should communicate their names and addresses to the NEA Secretariat as soon as possible, but not later than 4 th March In order to assist the administration of this meeting and due to new policies regarding security at the OECD and NEA it is essential that attendees pre-register. Your entry may not be guaranteed to the OECD conference centre if not pre-registered. 2

3 Contact Information: Mr. Andrew White Tel: Fax: andrew.white@oecd.org Mr Takayoshi Nezuka Tel: Fax: andrew.white@oecd.org Ms. Olivia Stefanuto Tel: Fax: olivia.stefanuto@oecd.org For information and planning (if needed) It is beneficial if the names and addresses of the participants to the bureau can be communicated to the NEA Secretariat as soon as possible, but not later than 8 th March WGRISK Bureau Meeting March 14 th 15 th 2016 Task Group Meeting on Task 2015(2) Site Level PSA March 15 th, 2016 OECD, Conference Centre, Room CC24 OECD, Conference Centre, Room CC24 Various documents supporting the agenda items are or will be placed in the WGRISK working area as soon as they become available. The WGRISK Working Area is located on the NEA Website. LOCATION OF THE WGRISK ANNUAL MEETING The address is Room CC5 OECD 2, Rue André-Pascal Paris More information at EQUIPMENT AVAILABLE FOR THE PRESENTATION The meeting rooms are equipped for projection of presentations, using a personal computer equipped with powerpoint. It is also possible to project directly from your own computer but a copy of the presentation must be provided to the Secretariat preferable during but definitely before the end of the meeting for distribution to all WGRISK members. 3

4 TRANSPORTATION The OECD is close to metro, RER, and bus lines. All information can be found at or at (in English, German and Dutch) ACCOMMODATION Participants have to make their own reservation. A list of hotels is available at: MATERIAL DISTRIBUTED PRIOR TO THE MEETING: Please download all material at after 6th March 2016 DINNER: Participants who are interested in a Group Dinner (at your own cost) on the Wednesday 16 th March at 8.00 pm at a reasonably priced local restaurant are invited to inform the secretariat (olivia.stefanuto@oecd.org) of their intention to take part by 11 th March

5 TENTATIVE AGENDA 1. Opening of Meeting 1.1 Chairperson s welcome 1.2 NEA Secretariat welcome 2. Adoption of the Agenda [NEA/SEN/SIN/WGRISK/A(2016)2] 3. Approval of the 16 th WGRISK Meeting Summary Record [NEA/SEN/SIN/WGRISK (2015)1] Exchange of Information 4. The Use and Developments of PSA in NEA Member Countries Delegates are invited to present NEW elements of PSA programmes or NEW developments in guidelines within their respective countries and provide concrete examples. It is expected to have 1 presentation per country. Presentations should be limited to 5 minutes. Information should be restricted to new issues or topics or updated information since the update of the 2010 report on the Use and Developments of PSA in NEA Member Countries (see later in programme of work also). In addition, member countries are requested to highlight any relevant post Fukushima initiatives in this area. Written submissions supporting the presentation would be highly appreciated and will help the NEA Secretariat for the preparation of the Summary Record. 5. Reports on Activities in the Area of PSA by Other International Organisations (IAEA, CEC, WANO, VVER RG, WENRA, etc.) Here, members and or observers from international and other organisations are invited to make an update about their current and planned activities accompanied by a tabled presentation to be distributed. 5.1 IAEA presentation Abdallah Amri 5.2 EC presentation Roberto Pasalacqua 5.3 Presentation of the ASAMPSA_E Project provisionally - Emmanuel Raimond, IRSN 5

6 6. Report by Secretariat 6.1 Update on the actions from the last meeting, current WGRISK programme of work, actions taken by CSNI and CNRA and other recent developments in OECD/NEA 6.2 Tasks completed and reports approved since last annual meeting including: Fire PSA workshop report 6.3 Relevant CSNI and CNRA WGs (e.g., WGHOF, WGAMA, WGFCS, IAGE, WGOE, WGEV, WGELEC) 6.4 Report on Progress for CSNI Fukushima activities up to December Research Projects of relevance 6.5 Overview of updated web pages and feedback from WGRISK members 6.6 Secretariat actions from March 2015 Annual and October 2015 Bureau meeting WGRISK Programme of Work 7. Status report on the PSA insights relating to the loss of electrical sources [Task 2013(1)] 7.1 Presentation by J.-M. Lanore 7.2 Discussion and decisions 7.3 Decision regarding submission to CSNI PRG and CSNI for approval 8. HRA in External Events PSA [Task 2015(1)] 8.1 Presentation by V.N. Dang 8.2 Discussion and decisions 9. Status report on Site Level PSA (Including Multi-unit PSA) Developments [Task 2015 (2)] 9.1 Presentation by Y. Akl 9.2 Discussion and decisions 10. Status report on Status of Practice for Level3 Probabilistic Safety Assessment [Task 2015 (3)] 10.1 Presentation by K. Coyne 10.2 Discussion and decisions 11. Status Report on Use and Development of Probabilistic Safety Assessment in Member and Nonmember Countries [Task 2015 (4)] 11.1 Presentation by J.-M. Lanore 11.2 Discussion and decisions Other International PSA Activities 12. WGRISK participation to international conferences, workshops, etc PSAEA 18 th Technical Meeting on Experiences with Risk-based Precursor Analysis, October 28-30, 2015, Brussels - To be advised 6

7 12.2 PSA 2015, Sun Valley, Idaho (USA), April 26-20,2015 K Coyne, USNRC? 12.3 ARMS-ICRESH15, Lulea, Sweden, June 1-4, Dr Varde, BARC 12.4 ESREL 2015, Zürich, Switzerland, September 7-10, Vinh Dang, PSI 12.4 Expected WGRISK participation in ICONE24 and PSAM13, ESREL2016 and PSAEA Other conferences 12.6 Other participations 13. Other International Meetings/Activities Relevant to WGRISK Members are invited to send material beforehand through NEA Secretariat and make communications during the meeting th International Conference of the Croatian Nuclear Societyto be held 5-8 June 2016 in Zadar 14. Cooperation with other NEA Working Groups, Task Groups or Expert Groups 14.1 Outcome of discussion on Using probabilistic and deterministic methods when making regulatory decisions at 34 th CNRA meeting (Chair) 14.2 Interactions with Database Projects (see also 17.1) 14.3 Interactions with WGEV feedback from Secretariat and discussion 14.4 Further Activities - Secretariat WGRISK Technical Discussion 15. WGRISK Discussion 2016 PSA experience in modelling digital I&C (M. Porthin) 15.1 Nordic experience from the MODIG project (M. Porthin, VTT, Finland) 15.2 Slovakian experience in modelling digital I&C (V. Sopira, RELCO; Slovak Republic) 15.3 Digitalized NPP risk assessment research status in Korea (H.G. Kang, KAIST, Korea) 15.4 Risk-informed Statistical Testing for Digital I&C Systems (K. Coyne, NRC, USA) 15.5 EdF I&C Experience (tbd, EdF, France) 15.6 Modelling digital I&C in PSA German experience (E. Piljugin, GRS, Germany) 15.7 Brief overview on ICDE data collection rules for I&C components(e. Piljugin, GRS, Germany) WGRISK Programme of Work 16. WGRISK Planning 16.1 The Chairperson will review the current WGRISK programme of work and the operating framework given by the CSNI Operating Plan (particularly the CSNI Challenges and Technical Goals) Review and comments on the updated WGRISK Integrated Plan (including current mandate, mandate of Chair and Vice Chairs, mandate of Bureau members, need for more forwardlooking component) 16.3 Approval of the current version of the WGRISK Integrated Plan Determine if there is any particular preparation for the June CSNI presentation 17. WGRISK New Activities 17.1 Members may propose new activities, taken into account the report on the Use and Developments of PSA in NEA Member Countries and the list of CSNI Safety Issues. In any 7

8 Closing Session case, new activities must fit into the CSNI/CNRA Strategic Plan, the CSNI/CNRA Operating Plans and WGRISK Integrated Plan. A proposal template is attached. Formalizing regular links with Database Projects Common ASAMPSA:E/WGRISK workshop ASAMPSA:+.E End-Users Update of the existing CSNI Technical Opinion Paper on Fire Probabilistic Safety Assessment for Nuclear Power Plants /2001) Other CAPS proposals 18. WGRISK Working Methods 18.1 Discussion of group successes, current challenges, and potential improvements 19. Dates of Next Meetings 19.1 Annual Meeting 19.2 Task Group Meetings 20. Other Matters 20.1 Technical Issue Discussion for 2017 possibly PSA for harsh weather conditions 20.2 Election of Chair for 2016 to Election of Vice-Chairs for Bureau Composition 21. Closure of Meeting 8

9 Attachment 1 - New Proposals WGRISK (2016)x Project/Activity Title Objective Scope/Justification/ Deliverables, Expected results and users, Relation to other projects Safety significance/ priority (see priority criteria in Section IV) Technical Goal(s) covered Knowledge Management and Transfer covered Milestones (deliverables vs. time) Lead organization(s) and coordination Participants (individuals and organizations) Resources Requested action from PRG/CSNI PRG Recommendation 9