A National Approach to Decentralizing Economic Development Policies The Case of Chile

Transcription

1 A National Approach to Decentralizing Economic Development Policies The Case of Chile Juan Llisterri, Inter-American Development Bank Urban/Local Economic Development: The Agency Question World Bank, May 14, 2008 Content Centralized Decentralization? 1. The national and sub-national context 2. The RDA Program 3. Program and Regional Governance 4. Current situation 5. Preliminary Lessons 1

2 Centralized Decentralization? How everything started Presidential commitment Starting decentralization by economic development policies Asking the national agencies to prepare the program: CORFO (Ministry of Economy) and SUBDERE (Ministry of Interior) Organizing a brainstorming workshop with all public national stakeholders: Agriculture (INDAP, Sernapesca) Labor (SENCE) Tourism (Sernatur) Foreign trade (ProChile) Public Works Territory and Economic Development A controversial concept among economists Gaps in territorial development (income, human development, social capital) Uneven factor market development in different regions Pending political debate Market failures justify an intervention on territorial bases 2

3 1. The national and sub-national context A. The Chilean Economy B. Political decentralization C. Shortcomings of previous national programs and instruments for productive development D. Previous Experiences of LED in Chile: ITP, Bio-Bio, Chile Emprende and Todo Chile. A. The Chilean economy 16 million people 20 years of growth GDP per head, US$ ppp 13,896 Current-account balance (% of GDP) 2.3 FDI inflows 6.7% GDP Inflation th WEF ranking 12 regions ( ) Metropolitan Area Regional/sector concentration 3

4 B. Low level of decentralization National Government (President and Parliament) Regional Governments chaired by intendentes, appointed by the President of the Republic Municipalities: elected Most ministries and institutions for economic development have offices in every region National Regional Development Fund (Deputy Secretary for Regional Development) Corporación de Fomento (CORFO) C. Shortcomings in previous delivery of public programs Fragmentation (many agencies and programs) Lack of flexibility (programs designed according national agencies objectives) Supply of programs often miss-match local needs Poor access and high transaction costs Difficult coordination among public agencies and with local private sector 4

5 D. Previous experiences Integrated Territorial Programs Innova Bio-Bio Chile Emprende: micro and small enterprises in local economic development Todo Chile, attraction of FDI 2. The RDA Program A. Objectives B. Creation of RDA and design of Regional Agendas C. Competitiveness Enhancement Programs: Public-Private-Partnership D. Monitoring and Evaluation and institutional reengineering E. Complex execution 5

6 A. Objectives To contribute to the decentralization of productive development policies make them more effective at the regional level improve competitiveness of micro and SME that are part of regional clusters and value chains Strategy: develop local capabilities for Defining regional development agendas Aligning public resources to regional needs Fostering coordination with private sector B. Creation of RDA and design of the Regional Agendas Setting-up 13 RDA, all at once (+2) Structuring Public-Private Strategic Councils Hiring RDA Directors and technical staff Hiring international consultants to contribute to regional agendas with cluster analysis Involving local stakeholders (private sector, universities and civil society) Approving Regional Agendas 6

7 C. Competitiveness Enhancement Programs (CEP) Map relevant clusters/value chain and prioritize them according to the regional agendas Formulate CEP, define actions to achieve their specific goals (regulatory and private or public investments). Specific methodology (cluster analysis) Action plan to be funded by the program or not Co-fund, with other public instruments available in the Region, the implementation of the CEP: Governance and management of the CEP Club goods (not fully appropriable): training, business advisory services, technical assistance, at the level of the cluster D. Monitoring and evaluation Management information system Institutional Reengineering At the local and national level Some of the expected results 40% of public resources invested in the region for economic (productive) development have been assigned through the RDA. Baseline 0% 80% of participating firms value positively collective action Increase in collective activities among firms 7

8 Program budget (US$ million) Administration M&E Comp. 1. Creation of RDA Comp. 2. R. Agendas & CEP Comp. 3. Execution CEP Comp. 4. M&E and institutional adaptation PPF Total 1.5 m 13.5 m 1.7 m 19.0 m 2.5 m 1.8 m 40.0 m E. Complex program execution CORFO, the executing agency. Need to coordinate different levels National level Political-Strategic Ministerial Committee National Services Committee Technical Coordinating Unit Regional Development Agencies Public-Private Strategic Council Local cluster governing structure 8

9 E. Complex program execution [2] Regulatory instruments Presidential instructions Protocol for coordination of National Services Binding regional agreements RDA and Regional Governments and agencies that provide technical/financial support for executing CEP Financial (budgetary) management Execution structure Comité Ministerial Político- Estratégico Nivel Local Nivel Regional Nivel Nacional Comité de Servicios Nacionales Gobernanzas Locales de Aglomerados Productivos VP Ejecutivo CORFO Unidad Técnico Coordinadora Agencias Regionales de Desarrollo Productivo Unidades de Apoyo en CORFO Empresas Beneficiarias Líneas quebradas muestran líneas de inter-relación/comunicación 9

10 Regional Development Agencies Public-Private Strategic Committee (Chaired by by the Intendente ) Executive Secretary (Few highly qualified staff) National Services with economic development programs CORFO INDAP SERCOTEC PROCHILE SENCE FOSIS Sernatur Comités PL PL Programas de de CT internacional Others Private Sector Leading Enterprises (RSE) Chambers Associations Consortia and firms networks Entidades vinculadas a factores críticos transversales SRM OP SRM Education SRMs Economy, Agriculture SRM National Good COREMA UCR GORE Regulatory supervisory entities Universities and technology Centers Provinces, Municipalities Others 3. Program and Regional Governance Issues of program governance: control of the budget Regional/local governance: National vs regional vs provincial vs local Private sector representation and empowerment RDA act as CORFO s local units will gain independent status in the future Mixed response from Regional Governments 10

11 4. Current situation 13 (+2) ARD have been created and staffed The complex execution structure is working Regional Agendas have been prepared and installed in all regions International consultants have been hired for Training local teams Preparing the CEP with local experts of CEP CEP are being prepared and will start to be implemented within this year Resources from different ministries have been forcefully allocated to the RDA 5. Preliminary Lessons [1] Institutional complexity can be overcame only with a strong political support AND a relatively efficient public sector Resistance to decentralization is also displayed in territorial offices of national services The leading role of politically appointees intendentes has to be counterbalanced Professional selection of RDA staff is key 11

12 5. Preliminary Lessons [2] Entrepreneurs welcome provocation of a deep strategic review to prepare the CEP RDA local teams, when properly trained in the use of appropriate analytical tools (i.e. cluster analysis) play a critical role RDA can become intelligent institutions and (together with local firms) prompt international competitiveness analysis 5. Preliminary Lessons [3] Considerable progress has been reached in a very short time but The decentralization in economic development programs should be coupled with a parallel (if not previous) political decentralization Most of the RDA still need to consolidate and prove to be (politically and budgetary) sustainable in the long run It will be very interesting to follow-up the experience 12

13 THANK YOU 13