NOTICE. City of Titusville P.O. Box South Washington Ave. Titusville, FL 32781

Transcription

1 City of Titusville P.O. Box South Washington Ave. Titusville, FL AGENDA NOTICE OF WORKSHOP MEETING HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD August 4, 2014 Council Chamber at City Hall 555 S. Washington Titusville, FL :00 PM NOTICE All persons who anticipate speaking on any Public Hearing item must fill out an Oath Card to be heard on that agenda item and sign the oath contained thereon.these cards are located on the table near the entrance to the Council Chamber or may be obtained from the Recording Secretary. This meeting will be conducted in accordance to the procedures adopted in Resolution # Those speaking in favor of a request will be heard first, those opposed will be heard second, and those who wish to make a public comment on the item will speak third. The applicant may make a brief rebuttal if necessary. A representative from either side, for or against, may cross-examine a witness. Anyone who speaks is considered a witness. If you have photographs, sketches, or documents that you desire for the Commission to consider, they must be submitted into evidence and will be retained by the City. Please submit such exhibits to the Recording Secretary (1) CALL TO ORDER (2) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE (3) ROLL CALL (4) APPROVAL OF MINUTES A. Approve Minutes from July 7, 2014 (5) OLD BUSINESS B. Accept the Preliminary Application for Historic Designation submitted by Kevin and Catherine Riley, owners, of property located at 1120 Riverside Drive. This item was tabled from the July 7, 2014, meeting to review the budget and receive additional information. C. Continue discussion on how to inform the Board when a demolition or other permit is submitted to alter a potentially historic structure. D. Continue discussion on ways to market the downtown. Charlie Mars of the Space Coast Walk of Fame Museum has agreed to meet with the Board and discuss their marketing efforts. (6) NEW BUSINESS

2 E. Discuss the merits of establishing a Historic Rehabilitation Investment Incentive for the state of Florida with State Representative Tom Goodson. (7) WORKSHOP FORMAT DISCUSSION F. Workshop Format Discussion. Continue planning for a workshop to be held the Tuesday, October 21, 2014, in the City Council's Chambers between 6-8 p.m. For your information, enclosed are materials used during the workshop held in (8) PETITIONS AND REQUESTS FROM PUBLIC PRESENT (9) ADJOURNMENT Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Historic Preservation Board respect to any matter considered at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The City desires to accommodate persons with disabilities. Accordingly, any physically handicapped person, pursuant to Chapter Florida Statutes, should at least 48 hours prior to the meeting, submit a written request to the chairperson of the meeting that the physically handicapped person desires to attend.

3 Category: (4) Item: A. City of Titusville "Gateway to Nature and Space" REPORT TO COUNCIL To: From: Historic Preservation Board Members Peggy Busacca, Planning and Growth Management Director Subject: July 7, 2014 Department/Office: Recommended Action: Approve Minutes from July 7, 2014 Summary Explanation & Background: Alternatives: Item Budgeted: Source/use of funds/budget Book Page: Strategic Plan: Strategic Plan Impact: ATTACHMENTS: Description Upload Date Type July 7, /17/2014 Backup Material

4 Historic Preservation Board Regular Meeting July 7, 2014 The Historic Preservation Board (HPB) of the City of Titusville, Florida met in regular session in the Council Chamber, located at 555 South Washington on Monday July 7, 2014 at 1:00 p.m. Chairman Kiesel called the meeting to order at 1:00 p.m. Present were Vice Chairman Petyk, Secretary Adams, Member Hoover, Member Megivern, Member Gaetjens and Member Adams. Member Foster and Member Duell were absent. Also attending was Principal Planner Brad Parrish, City Engineer Woody Rice and Recording Secretary Laurie Dargie. Member Megivern motioned to approve the minutes from the June 2, 2014 meeting. Secretary Adams seconded. There was a unanimous voice vote. Chairman Kiesel said that Member Megivern asked if the Board would move the order of the agenda items and start with petitions and requests from public present. All Members agreed to change order of agenda. Petitions and Requests from Public Present Jane Speidel of 602 Indian River Titusville, Florida came to speak to the Historic Preservation Board regarding her property. Ms. Speidel said that she was not happy with the proposed CIRCA date of her house being Ms. Speidel said that she spent 2 hours with a gentlemen at the County Clerk s Office going through information. Ms. Speidel said that the deed books show information regarding the Brady s in Ms. Speidel said that her attorney from 1984 said that the house never left the Brady s family until she bought the house. Ms. Speidel said that the property was sold from Mary Titus to Mr. Brady in Ms. Speidel said she would suggest that CIRCA be used on the plaque because CIRCA means approximately or roughly and her reasoning is because no proof can be found when the house was actually built. Ms. Speidel said that the date should be 1887 because this is the date that LOT 4, which is the property that the house is on, was sold from Mary Titus to Mr. Brady. Chairman Kiesel asked Mr. Parrish if this information should be sent to Littlejohn Engineering. Vice Chairman Petyk said she would agree with Ms. Speidel s information and to use the CIRCA 1887 on the plaque. Mr. Parrish said that the Historic Preservation Board has the final decision on what goes on the plaque. Mr. Parrish said that if the information only enhances the report it does not have to go back to City Council. Vice Chairman Petyk made a motion to move forward with using the CIRCA 1887 on the plaque for the Brady House plaque for property 602 Indian River. Member Megivern seconded. There was a unanimous voice vote.

5 Historic Preservation Board Meeting -2- July 7, 2014 Ms. Speidel said she appreciates what the Historic Preservation Board has done and hopes that more citizens will come forward and go through this process to designate historical properties. Mr. Parrish said that he spoke to Eddie Browder with Littlejohn Engineering regarding the information that was received from Mr. Francis at the last Historic Preservation Board meeting pertaining to the name of the house and Mr. Browder did agree with the information that the name should be the Dobson House. Vice Chairman Petyk made a motion to move forward with using the name Dobson House on the plaque for property 902 Indian River. Member Megivern seconded. There was a unanimous voice vote. Kevin Riley of 1120 Riverside Drive Titusville, Florida came to speak to the Board regarding his property. Mr. Riley gave 3 handouts with information regarding his property. Mr. Riley briefly went over the handouts, which was a timeline of the property, tax records and mortgage deed. Mr. Riley believes the house was built between 1913 and Mr. Riley said that he thought 1914 was the date that the house was built. Mr. Riley said he would like to use both names Conkling/Riley on the plaque to differentiate the house from other homes. Secretary Adams asked what the three structures are on the property. Mr. Riley said the house is one; a shed is another and garage. Robert McCandless, Chairman of the Administration Committee with 1 st Baptist Church of Titusville came to speak in regards to the application for local historic designation or answer any questions. Mr. Parrish said that Staff did not recommend moving forward with this application because of the incompleteness. Mr. Parrish said that one of the requirements was not met which is having the majority of the Trustees identified signing approval for the application. Mr. McCandless said he will see what he can do to get what is needed. Mr. Parrish said that everything else looked good for the Historic Preservation Board to review. Vice Chairman Petyk made a motion to table Mr. Riley s application for review and 1 st Baptist Church of Titusville s application for completeness and further review. Member Megivern seconded. There was a unanimous voice vote.

6 Historic Preservation Board Meeting -3- July 7, 2014 Old Business Protection of older Historic structures from demolition Mr. Parrish invited City Engineer Woody Rice to attend the Historic Preservation Board meeting to give feedback on the Board s request for somehow flagging properties that have historical value. Mr. Rice said that a new software is being implemented and this software has the capabilities to flag properties and show an alert so that the person entering in permits can be notified that something should be checked out before proceeding. Mr. Rice said that this alert is also going to be used for letting staff know when persons or businesses cannot pull permits for other reasons such as being illegal. Mr. Rice said that alerts would stop permits from being issued. Mr. Rice said that he does not want the alert system to be misused and has another idea that he is going to check into with the software company to see if a checklist can be made on each property allowing for staff to check boxes that apply to specific properties. Mr. Rice said that a check box could be made specifically for properties with historic value, which would notify staff that it should be looked into a little further. Mr. Rice said that he will be able to run reports to show all the properties who had the check box. Mr. Rice said he will speak to the software company in regards to setting up this specific checkbox notification for the historical properties. Chairman Kiesel said that the purpose for asking for properties to be flagged is so that the Historic Preservation Board has an opportunity to contact the property owner and have the chance to discuss or explain other options for saving historical properties. Secretary Adams asked if Mr. Parrish can be given reports on a weekly bases instead of monthly. Mr. Rice said that the reports can be run as often as the person needing information runs the report. Mr. Rice said that the reports that City Staff has are inaccurate therefore, the lists really need to be looked over thoroughly before being entered into the system. Chairman Kiesel said that the Board should work on getting a short list put together of the properties that should for sure be flagged in the system. Secretary Petyk asked who did the last report for the City. Mr. Rice said Janus did the last report in Historical Designation Plaques Discussion took place amongst the members regarding going forward with ordering the plaques since they have all the correct information now. Secretary Petyk said that the Members need to be more thorough in making sure that all information is correct before approving the application so that the plaques can be ordered quicker. Member Gaetjens said that he agrees that the application should really be looked at closer to make sure the information is correct. Member Megivern made a motion to go forward with ordering the Historical Designation plaques for 602 Indian River and 902 Indian River. Vice Chairman Petyk seconded. There was a unanimous voice vote.

7 Historic Preservation Board Meeting -4- July 7, 2014 Chairman Kiesel said that he would like to come up with an idea to make the plaque presentation a big deal. Chairman Kiesel said that the plaques can maybe be presented at a City Council. The Historic Preservation Board members were all in agreement that they would like to make this be a big deal. Member Gaetjens asked how long will it take for the plaques to be done. Mr. Parrish said he is not sure about that yet. Member Gaetjens asked when does the Historic Preservation Board receive additional budget money for the year. Mr. Parrish said the new budget year starts in October Chairman Kiesel said at the next meeting in August the funding for upcoming designations should be discussed. Mr. Parrish said that enough money is left in the budget to get the 2 plaques now. Chairman Kiesel asked for the balance of the budget by the August meeting. Mr. Parrish said he will have that information. Member Gaetjens said the review of the applications can be started by the Board Members now so that once funding is received they can forward the paperwork to Littlejohn Engineering for their approval. New Business Workshop Format Discussion Chairman Kiesel asked for input regarding the workshop. Vice Chairman Petyk asked if a date has been set. Member Gaetjens said that the week of October th was discussed but a specific day was not picked. Chairman Kiesel asked what kind of format was going to be used at this workshop. Member Megivern said he thought that the Board was leaning towards the format used when the workshop was done at Parrish Hall. Chairman Kiesel said he believes that incorporating both workshop formats was discussed a little at the last meeting but nothing definite was decided. Member Gaetjens asked how many people should be expected, 50-75? Chairman Kiesel said they had 28 people signed up. Mr. Parrish said only 5 people signed the roster. Vice Chairman Petyk said that the first workshop was a longer event with people coming and going. Mr. Parrish said that Eddie Browder with Littlejohn Engineering suggested having Chelsea come to explain the economic benefits of Historic designations at the workshop. Vice Chairman Petyk asked if Chelsea would have to be paid to come to the workshop. Mr. Parrish said that the travel expenses would have to be paid which is about $ Chairman Kiesel said that the PowerPoint presentation needs to go more smoothly. Secretary Adams said that any information for Melbourne needs to be removed from the presentation. Vice Chairman Petyk asked what time of the day should the workshop be held. Member Gaetjens said that evening workshops are better for the public to attend because of working. Vice Chairman Petyk said that she cannot attend anything on Wednesday nights. Member Gaetjens said that 6:00pm to 8:00pm would be a good time for the workshop. Vice Chairman Petyk suggested Tuesday October 21, Chairman Kiesel said that he believes the workshop should be held at City Hall, Council Chambers. All the Historic Preservation Board Members were in agreement of the meeting day, time and location. Chairman Kiesel asked that all the Member think about the workshop format and bring ideas and input at the August meeting. Member Adams said that it would be nice for the workshop to be videotaped. Secretary Adams asked Mr. Parrish if he can find out if refreshments can be available at the workshop.

8 Historic Preservation Board Meeting -5- July 7, 2014 Reports Vice Chairman Petyk asked what is going to be discussed when Representative Goodson comes to meet with the Board. Mr. Parrish said Mr. Goodson is coming to answer questions and discuss next year s Legislative session on tax incentive programs. Mr. Parrish said that Charlie Mars was also going to come to a future meeting to talk about the Space Walk of Fame. Member Gaetjens said that the first Monday of the month is September 1, 2014, which is Labor Day. Member Gaetjens wanted to bring this up to discuss when the September meeting should take place. The Board Members asked if the meeting can be scheduled for Monday September 8, 2014 in the Round Room. Mr. Parrish will confirm that the date and room is available for Monday September 8, Mr. Parrish said he is still trying to make contact with someone at the Train Station. Mr. Parrish said he is also trying to reach out to David Johnson but has not been successful as of yet. Adjournment 2:45 p.m.

9 City of Titusville "Gateway to Nature and Space" Category: (5) Item: B. To: From: Subject: REPORT TO COUNCIL Historic Preservation Board Members Peggy Busacca, Planning and Growth Management Director Nomination Form 1120 Riverside Drive Department/Office: Planning and Growth Management Recommended Action: Accept the Preliminary Application for Historic Designation submitted by Kevin and Catherine Riley, owners, of property located at 1120 Riverside Drive. This item was tabled from the July 7, 2014, meeting to review the budget and receive additional information. Summary Explanation & Background: Pursuant to Section 48-7(a) of the Code, the owner of any property in the City may petition the Historic Preservation Board for designation of their property as an individual resource, site or archaeological site or zone by submitting a preliminary application for historic designation to the Historic Preservation Officer. The Historic Preservation Board shall either accept or deny the application only after written verification that the applicant is the owner of record or their authorized agent. By accepting the application, the Historic Preservation Board must set a date for a public hearing and shall direct staff to complete the designation report and notify the proper parties of the public hearing as provided below. The applicants, Kevin and Catherine Riley, are the owners of the property located at 1120 Riverside Drive. Alternatives: 1. Accept the preliminary application for historic designation for review by the historic preservation officer. 2. Do not accept the preliminary application for historic designation. Item Budgeted: Source/use of funds/budget Book Page: Strategic Plan: No. 1 Enhance the Quality of Life of our CitizensNo. 2 Promote Economic Development Strategic Plan Impact: ATTACHMENTS: Description Upload Date Type No Attachments Available

10 Category: (5) Item: C. City of Titusville "Gateway to Nature and Space" REPORT TO COUNCIL To: From: Subject: Historic Preservation Board Members Peggy Busacca, Planning and Growth Management Director Protection of Older Historic Structures from Demolition. Department/Office: Planning and Growth Management Recommended Action: Continue discussion on how to inform the Board when a demolition or other permit is submitted to alter a potentially historic structure. Summary Explanation & Background: At the July 7th meeting Woody Rice suggested adding an option to the CitizenServe program that his staff uses to receive and track permits. He also recommended selecting a short list of properties to include in his demo permit flag test. One suggestion could be to select some or all of those listed as eligible for national status. Enclosed is a condensed version of the historic resources survey. There are an estimated 93 eligible sites out of 184 listed. Alternatives: 1. Select a short list of properties based on eligibility on the national register. 2. Select a short list of properties based on other criteria. 3. Other action. Item Budgeted: Source/use of funds/budget Book Page: Strategic Plan: Strategic Plan Impact: ATTACHMENTS: Description Upload Date Type Survey 7/24/2014 Backup Material

11 No FMSF # Site Name/Address Year Built Style National Register Status 1 8BR Julia Street c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 2 8BR00421 About an Inch Salon/214 Julia Street 3 8BR00427 Shear Essence Salon and Spa/7 13 Main Street c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 4 8BR00428 Babcock Home Furniture/15 21 Main Street c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 5 8BR00429 Banana Alley Antiques/106 Main Street 1913 Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 6 8BR S Washington c Mission Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 7 8BR00509 Brevard County Historical Society/301 S Washington 8 8BR00510 Hardware/305 S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 9 8BR00511 Faith City Church/Downtown Dance Studio/ S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 10 8BR S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 11 8BR S Washington 1912 Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 12 8BR S Washington 1910 Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 13 8BR00516 Comfort Keepers/327 S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 14 8BR00517 The Downtown Gallery/ S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 15 8BR00520 Kloiber s Cobbler/337 S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 16 8BR S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 17 8BR00523 The Book Rack/346 S Washington c Frame Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 18 8BR S Washington 1957 Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 19 8BR02888 Southern Room Lounge and Package/345 S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 20 8BR02889 Kutryb Eye Institute/407 S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 21 8BR Indian River c Queen Anne Revival Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 22 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 23 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 24 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible

12 No FMSF # Site Name/Address Year Built Style National Register Status 25 8BR Indian River c Colonial Revival Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 26 8BR Indian River c Neo Classical Revival Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 27 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 28 8BR Indian River c Bungalow Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 29 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 30 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 31 8BR Indian River c Bungalow Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 32 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 33 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 34 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 35 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 36 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 37 8BR Indian River c Mission Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 38 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 39 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 40 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 41 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 42 8BR Riverside Drive c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 43 8BR Riverside Drive c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 44 8BR Riverside Drive c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 45 8BR Riverside Drive c Bungalow Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 46 8BR Brevard Street c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 47 8BR Brevard Street c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 48 8BR Grace Street c Frame Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 49 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 50 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 51 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible

13 No FMSF # Site Name/Address Year Built Style National Register Status 52 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 53 8BR Indian River c Ranch Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 54 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 55 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 56 8BR02845 Crestwood Apartments/1039 Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 57 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 58 8BR Indian River c Ranch Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 59 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 60 8BR Indian River c Ranch Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 61 8BR Indian River c Minimal Traditional Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 62 8BR Indian River c Ranch Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 63 8BR Indian River c Ranch Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 64 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 65 8BR Indian River c Ranch Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 66 8BR Riverside Drive c Ranch Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 67 8BR Riverside Drive c Ranch Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 68 8BR St. Johns Street c Masonry Vernacular Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 69 8BR Broad Street c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 70 8BR Garden Street c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 71 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 72 8BR Indian River c Queen Anne Revival Ineligible 73 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 74 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 75 8BR Julia Street c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 76 8BR Julia Street c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 77 8BR00426 Shuler and Shuler Real Estate Auctioneer/428 Julia Street c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 78 8BR Main Street c Frame Vernacular Ineligible

14 No FMSF # Site Name/Address Year Built Style National Register Status 79 8BR Orange Street c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 80 8BR S Palm c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 81 8BR S. Palm c Beaux Arts Ineligible 82 8BR S Palm c Mediterranean Revival Ineligible 83 8BR S Palm c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 84 8BR S Palm c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 85 8BR S Palm c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 86 8BR Riverview Place c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 87 8BR S Washington c Mission Ineligible 88 8BR S Washington c Bungalow Ineligible 89 8BR00527 The Broome Law Firm/ Indian River c Mission Ineligible 90 8BR00529 Nationwide Insurance and c Mission Ineligible Financial/1003 S Washington 91 8BR00530 Law Office of Kathleen MacMahon c Mission Ineligible Crannell/1007 S Washington 92 8BR00531 Chef Larry s/1111 S Washington c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 93 8BR S Washington c Mediterranean Revival Ineligible 94 8BR02809 Captain Hooks Bait & Tackle/ 103 A. Max Brewer Memorial Parkway c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 95 8BR Broad Street c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 96 8BR02813 Baldwin Shopping Center/101 c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Broad Street 97 8BR Broad Street c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 98 8BR Garden Street c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 99 8BR02816 Titusville Bait Shack/425 Garden Street c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 100 8BR02817 LaRu s Upscale Thrift/450 Garden c Frame Vernacular Ineligible Street 101 8BR S Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 102 8BR02820 First United Methodist Church/206 S Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 103 8BR S. Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible

15 No FMSF # Site Name/Address Year Built Style National Register Status 104 8BR02822 Sunrise Bread Company/315 S c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Hopkins 105 8BR02823 Budget Motel/605 S Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 106 8BR02824 AT&T Building/624 S Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 107 8BR02825 City Auto s and Electric/700 S c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Hopkins 108 8BR02826 Three Oaks Motel/707 S Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 109 8BR S Hopkins c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 110 8BR02828 Hermann Bach Paving Stones, c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Inc./1011 S Hopkins 111 8BR02829 Lemuel s Auto Sales/1023 S c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Hopkins 112 8BR02830 Nissan Fischer Collision Center/1138 S Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 113 8BR02831 Advent Electric LLC/1210 S Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 114 8BR S Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 115 8BR S Hopkins c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 116 8BR02834 Indian River Professional Center/320 Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 117 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 118 8BR Indian River c Unknown Ineligible 119 8BR02856 Emma Parrish Theatre/301 Julia Street c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 120 8BR02857 Florida Retina Institute/308 Julia c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Street 121 8BR N Lemon c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 122 8BR N Lemon c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 123 8BR N Lemon c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 124 8BR N Lemon c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 125 8BR N Lemon c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 126 8BR S Lemon c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 127 8BR S Lemon c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 128 8BR S Lemon c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 129 8BR S Lemon c Frame Vernacular Ineligible

16 No FMSF # Site Name/Address Year Built Style National Register Status 130 8BR S Lemon c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 131 8BR02868 U.S. Space Walk of Fame c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 132 8BR02869 First Baptist Church c Neo Classical Revival Ineligible 133 8BR Main Street c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 134 8BR02871 L&L Accounting, Bookkeeping c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 135 8BR Orange St. c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 136 8BR Orange Street c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 137 8BR N Palm c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 138 8BR S Palm c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 139 8BR S Palm c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 140 8BR S Palm c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 141 8BR02882 Indian River Masonic Lodge #90 c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 142 8BR02883 Sand Point Office Center c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 143 8BR02884 Papa John s Pizza/3 S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 144 8BR02885 Canaveral National Seashore c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Headquarters/212 S Washington 145 8BR02890 Titusville Fire & Emergency Services/550 S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 146 8BR S Washington c Frame Vernacular Ineligible 147 8BR02892 Slagle Automotive/701 S c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Washington 148 8BR S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 149 8BR S Washington Avenu South c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 150 8BR02895 Masjid Al Mu min/1011 S c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Washington 151 8BR S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 152 8BR02897 Dusty Rose Antiques and c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible Collectibles/1101 S Washington 153 8BR S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 154 8BR02899 Stephen M. Brewer Attorney at Law/1209 S Washington c Ranch Ineligible

17 No FMSF # Site Name/Address Year Built Style National Register Status 155 8BR02900 Insurance World/1210 S c Other Ineligible Washington 156 8BR02901 Gas Kwik/1220 S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 157 8BR02902 Titusville Yacht Club/Coast Guard Aux./4749 S Washington c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 158 8BR Wilson c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 159 8BR Wilson c Masonry Vernacular Ineligible 160 8BR Orange Street c Frame Vernacular Ineligible for National Register; potentially eligible for designation by City of Titusville 161 8BR00177 St. Gabriel's Episcopal Church/ S Palm 1887 Gothic Revival National Register Listed 162 8BR00524 Pritchard House/424 S Washington 1891 Queen Anne Revival National Register Listed 163 8BR00560 Titusville Various Various National Register Listed 164 8BR00397 The Wager House/8 South Street c Frame Vernacular National Register Listed; Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 165 8BR00399 Judge George Robbins House/703 Indian River 166 8BR00480 The Spell House/1200 Riverside Drive c Dutch Colonial Revival National Register Listed; Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible c Queen Anne Revival National Register Listed; Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 167 8BR00521 Aker Eye Vision Source/Chops Restaurant/ S Washington 1888 Masonry Vernacular Non Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 168 8BR02887 VITA/323 S Washington 1900 Masonry Vernacular Non Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 169 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Non Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 170 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Non Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 171 8BR Indian River c Frame Vernacular Non Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 172 8BR Riverside Drive c Frame Vernacular Non Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 173 8BR Riverside Drive c Frame Vernacular Non Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 174 8BR Riverside Drive c Bungalow Non Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 175 8BR Indian River c Ranch Non Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 176 8BR Indian River c Masonry Vernacular Non Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 177 8BR St. Johns Street c Masonry Vernacular Non Contributing to Potentially National Register Eligible 178 8BR00425 Palace Apartments/422 Julia Street c Mission Potentially National Register Eligible 179 8BR00465 Brevard County Courthouse/506 S Palm c Neo Classical Revival Potentially National Register Eligible

18 No FMSF # Site Name/Address Year Built Style National Register Status 180 8BR S Palm 1901 Masonry Vernacular Potentially National Register Eligible 181 8BR00468 Titusville Train Depot/420 Pine c Mission Potentially National Register Eligible Street 182 8BR2935 c Various Various Potentially National Register eligible 183 8BR00508 Main Street Real Estate/300 S Washington c Beaux Arts Potentially National Register Eligible; Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville 184 8BR00514 Caffe Chocolat/ S Washington c Mission Potentially National Register Eligible; Contributing to National Register Listed Titusville

19 City of Titusville "Gateway to Nature and Space" Category: (5) Item: D. To: From: Subject: REPORT TO COUNCIL Historic Preservation Board Members Peggy Busacca, Planning and Growth Management Director Downtown Marketing Discussion Department/Office: Planning and Growth Management Recommended Action: Continue discussion on ways to market the downtown. Charlie Mars of the Space Coast Walk of Fame Museum has agreed to meet with the Board and discuss their marketing efforts. Summary Explanation & Background: Member Foster requested this item be on the agenda. On June 2nd, Marcia Gaedcke with the Chamber of Commerce met with the Board to discuss marketing the downtown area. Charlie Mars of the Space Coast Walk of Fame Museum has agreed to meet with the Board and discuss their marketing efforts. Alternatives: Item Budgeted: Source/use of funds/budget Book Page: Strategic Plan: Strategic Plan Impact: ATTACHMENTS: Description Upload Date Type No Attachments Available

20 City of Titusville "Gateway to Nature and Space" Category: (6) Item: E. To: From: Subject: REPORT TO COUNCIL Historic Preservation Board Members Peggy Busacca, Planning and Growth Management Director Florida Historic Rehabilitation Investment Incentive Department/Office: Planning and Growth Management Recommended Action: Discuss the merits of establishing a Historic Rehabilitation Investment Incentive for the state of Florida with State Representative Tom Goodson. Summary Explanation & Background: On May 5, 2014, the Historic Preservation Board discussed the City of Melbourne s letter of support to their Florida House Representative for legislation to establish a Historic Rehabilitation Investment Incentive program. The Board requested the City send a similar letter of support to the Legislature. After some consideration of their request, the staff decided to contact House Representative Goodson s office to determine if such a letter from Titusville would be accepted. At the recommendation of Mr. Goodson s secretary, the Board formally extended an invitation to Representative Goodson to attend a meeting to discuss the merits of such a program for the state of Florida. Many property owners struggle with deciding whether to rehabilitate a historic structure or demolish it. Frequently, the high costs of rehabilitating structures lead to eventual demolition of our local history. The City s Historic Preservation Board has expressed their support for legislation that would help to make preservation projects more economically feasible. A Historic Rehabilitation Investment Incentive program could help preserve the historic fabric of our community, drive economic development, stabilize real estate values, revitalize Main Street and promote cultural tourism. Attached for your review is an outline of the program and the invitation letter to Rep. Goodson. Alternatives: This is an informational item only. No action is required. Item Budgeted: Source/use of funds/budget Book Page: Strategic Plan: No. 1 Enhance the Quality of Life of our CitizensNo. 2 Promote Economic Development Strategic Plan Impact:

21 ATTACHMENTS: Description Upload Date Type program outline 7/8/2014 Backup Material Invitation 7/8/2014 Backup Material

22 Our historic tax credits have made the preservation of our older buildings not only a matter of respect for beauty and history, but of course for economic good sense. President Ronald Reagan 1984 The Florida Historic Rehabilitation Investment Incentive Florida can make itself more competitive in attracting private capital investment in jobcreating historic rehabilitation projects if it becomes the 36 th state to enact a state historic rehabilitation investment incentive. 35 states including almost all of the states in the Southeast have enacted historic rehabilitation investment incentives to make historic rehabilitation projects economically feasible by encouraging private capital investment. Because Florida does not have a historic rehabilitation tax credit, it is missing out on impactful, job-creating private capital investment that is being attracted to other states. Historic rehabilitation investment incentives are proven winners for states. They have made projects economically feasible, driven economic development, created jobs and spending, brought underused and vacant buildings back into active commerce, caused real estate values and real estate tax revenue to appreciate, revitalized main streets and downtowns throughout states, and promoted heritage tourism. A study of the economic and fiscal impacts of a Florida historic rehabilitation investment incentive found that for every dollar the state will invest in the Florida Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credit, $2.66 in new state tax revenue will be collected and $4.98 in combined new state and local tax revenue will be collected. (continued)

23 Florida trades that would see more jobs, work, and income because of a historic rehabilitation investment incentive include construction, architecture, engineering, real estate, and others. Without an incentive for investment in rehabilitation, many Florida buildings will continue to be underused, neglected, or demolished, destroying an important physical link to Florida s heritage. For many years, it has been thought Florida could not have a historic rehabilitation investment incentive because it does not have an income tax. A Florida historic rehabilitation investment incentive would provide a tax credit of 25% of the amount of qualified rehabilitation expenditures spent on qualified historic buildings and would be earned only after all qualified rehabilitation expenditures are completed. Like several other Florida incentives designed to encourage investment from insurance companies, the credit would be applied against the state insurance premium tax. In 2012, Florida collected $704 million in insurance premium taxes. Building owners earning federal historic rehabilitation tax credits typically admit investors into partnerships and allocate the tax credits to investors; investors then utilize the tax credits to offset their tax liability. Similar to the federal credit, for the Florida credit, building owners would earn the credits and investors would be allocated the credits. Insurance companies doing business in Florida, would utilize the credits to offset their insurance premium tax liability. Both North Carolina and South Carolina utilize their insurance premium taxes to incentivize the rehabilitation of historic buildings. Organizations across Florida likely to express support for a historic rehabilitation investment incentive include: o Historic preservation organizations o Downtown development districts o Chambers o Architects o Engineers o Construction contractors o Realtors o Developers o Municipal officials

24 City of Titusville June 12, SOUTH WASHINGTON AVENUE TITUSVILLE, FLORIDA (321) POST OFFICE BOX 2806 ( ) Fax (321) The Honorable Tom Goodson Florida House of Representatives 400 South Street, Suite 1C Titusville, FL Dear Representative Goodson: A City of Service The City of Titusville Historic Preservation Board would like to invite you to one of their regularly scheduled meetings to discuss legislation to create a Florida Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credit. Property owners struggle with deciding whether to rehabilitate a historic structure or demolish it. The high costs of rehabilitating structures could lead to eventual demolition of our local history. Indeed, the recent revelation of the planned demolition of the Green Gables house, a structure of significant historic and architectural importance not only to the City of Melbourne, but to the region as well, is an excellent reason the City supports such legislation. The City of Titusville has many threatened historic structures and the City is concerned we will lose cherished sites. Redevelopment pressures near our downtown Downtown Titusville are increasing as development begins to pick back up. Developers and property owners will have to decide between (1) rehabilitating old structures, or (2) opting for new construction. Legislation that helps to level the playing field and make preservation projects more economically feasible would be most desirable. Rehabilitation incentives preserve the historic fabric of a community, drive economic development, stabilize real estate values, revitalize Main Streets and promote cultural tourism. The City believes that it is the public s best interest to preserve and protect significant historic resources throughout the State of Florida. Let s become the 36 th state to offer historic rehabilitation incentives. Thank you for considering the City s perspective on this important benefit and we hope you will accept our invitation. The Historic Preservation Board meets at 1pm the first Monday of each month in the City Council s Chambers located in City Hall at 555 S Washington. The Board s next meetings are July 7 th and August 4 th. Please call or me if you are able to attend either meeting or to schedule another time. (321) , Bradley.Parrish@Titusville.com. Sincerely, Brad Parrish, Principal Planner

25 Category: (7) Item: F. City of Titusville "Gateway to Nature and Space" REPORT TO COUNCIL To: From: Subject: Historic Preservation Board Members Peggy Busacca, Planning and Growth Management Director Workshop Format Discussion Department/Office: Planning and Growth Management Recommended Action: Workshop Format Discussion. Continue planning for a workshop to be held the Tuesday, October 21, 2014, in the City Council's Chambers between 6-8 p.m. For your information, enclosed are materials used during the workshop held in Summary Explanation & Background: Alternatives: Item Budgeted: Source/use of funds/budget Book Page: Strategic Plan: Strategic Plan Impact: ATTACHMENTS: Description Upload Date Type 2012 Program 7/8/2014 Backup Material

26 H ISTORIC PRESERVATION E DUCATIONAL WORKSHOP I Own a Historic Building...What Do I Do Now? November 9, 2012 St. Gabriel s Church 414 Pine Street Titusville, Florida am 4pm Lunch on your own Come learn about the exciting field of Historic Preservation as it relates to our great City! This seminar is designed to provide an overview of historic preservation, opportunities in the City of Titusville, and how to navigate renovations and tax incentives. This workshop will appeal to the novice of historic preservation, as well as the seasoned professional. The seminar will be held in the Historic St. Gabriels Church and participants will have an opportunity to tour the beautiful structure built in Questions? Call Darsi Davis darsidavis@titusville.com Titusville Historic Preservation Board

27 AGENDA 11:00 11:15 Welcoming Remarks Debbie Petyk, Titusville Historic Preserva on Board; Father Goodridge, St. Gabriel s Church 11:15 11:45 Introduc on to Historic Preserva on Joseph Adams, Titusville Historic Preserva on Board 11:45 12:00 St. Gabriel s Church Anniversary Celebra on Update Mike Van Heusen, St. Gabriel s Church12:00 12:30 12:00 12:30 St. Gabriel s Church History Brief and Open House Billy Rhodes, St. Gabriel s Church 12:30 1:30 LUNCH ON YOUR OWN 1:30 2:30 Renova on Challenges & Contractor Tricks of the Trade Panel Discussion: Daniel McGivern, Allen Kiesel, Michael Boonstra 2:30 3:00 The Economics of Historic Preserva on Roz Foster, Brevard County Historic Preserva on Board, Titusville Historic Preserva on Board. 3:00 3:30 Tax Incen ves for Historic Preserva on Projects Roland Hoover, Historic Preserva on Board 3:30 4:00 City of Titusville Voluntary Historic Preserva on Program Courtney Barker, City of Titusville staff

28 SPEAKERS Joseph Adams has a BA degree in history form Mercer University in Macon, Georgia and has done graduate work in historic preserva on at the University of Georgia in Athens. He has 20 years of experience in museums and is currently on the interpre ve staff of Fort Christmas Historical Park. Courtney Barker is the City s Planning & Growth Management Director and serves as the staff liaison to the Historic Preserva on Board. She has been an urban planner for approximately 12 years. Michael J. Boonstra currently serves as head of the Genealogy Department at the Central Brevard Library in Cocoa as Archivist for the Brevard Historical Commission and is Past President and Board Member Emeritus of the Brevard Heritage Council, the County's oldest historic preserva on group. Michael has personally restored several old houses in Cocoa and Rockledge and also serves as a consultant to other historic homeowners and building contractors with their renova on projects. Roz Foster Has been ac ve in preserving Brevard County History since 1996 with restora on and documenta on of historic Lagrange Church & Cemetery, researching, wri ng and conduc ng Historic Downtown Titusville tours. Member of the Brevard County Historical Commission since 1996 and the Titusville Historic Preserva on Board. Recipient of the 2007 Caroline Rosse er Most Outstanding Woman in Florida History Award and President and Founder of the North Brevard Heritage Founda on, Inc. restora on, opera ons & management of the historic Pritchard House, and organiza on behind Brevard Heritage Park. Roland Hoover has a BS in educa on from The University f Central Missouri and holds a MS from Goeorgia College and State University in Business. He has taught American History in Missouri's capital city, the historic City of Jefferson. He has lived in several other states where he always absorbed local history. He is now re red from the Missouri Department of Transporta on and a resident of, and member of the historic preserva on board of, the City of Titusville. Allen Kiesel originally from Pennsylvania, graduated from the University of Miami in 1991 with a Bachelor of Architecture degree. He has been working in the architecture field since then, most recently with Michael A. Penney, Architect in Titusville. Dan MeGivern has lived in Titusville since 1983, becoming a Florida cer fied residen al building contractor in He has concentrated on remodeling older homes, enjoying the challenges of the building restora on process. Billy M. Rhodes is the historian of St. Gabriel s Church and has a BA in Educa on from the University of Florida in Social Studies Educa on, a MA in Educa on from the University of Central Florida and an Educa onal Specialist in Curriculum and Instruc on from the University of Central Florida with an emphasis in history. He has taught in the Brevard Public Schools for 30 years and was employed as an adjunct instructor at Brevard Community College teaching American History and Poli cal Science. Mr. Rhodes is a Lay Eucharis c Minister at St. Gabriel s and a member since 1964.

29 The City s Historic Preserva on Board The Titusville Historic Preserva on Board was created in early 2012 to create a Historic Preserva on Program for the City, and to implement the Program in the future. The Board is comprised of individuals that have a background in construc on, engineering, architecture, and history. The Board meets monthly and has created the City s Historic Preserva on Code, which is a voluntary historic preserva on program for individual site designa ons. The Board is also focusing on educa onal and informa onal workshops for the North Brevard Area. Mee ng Dates for 2013 January 7th February 4th March 4th April 1st May 6th June 3rd July 1st August 5th September 3rd October 7th November 4th December 2nd All mee ngs begin at 1pm in the City Council Chambers of City Hall at 555 S. Washington. All mee ngs are open to the public and are subject to Florida Sunshine provisions. The Historic Preserva on Board welcomes your a endance, support and ideas for historic preserva on. www. tusville.com