COMMISSION XVIII XVIII

Transcription

1 XVIII DRAFT AGENDA - WEDNESDAY, 18 July 2018 Version COMMISSION XVIII ON QUALITY MANAGEMENT IN WELDING AND ALLIED PROCESSES XVIII DRAFT AGENDA 71 ST IIW ANNUAL ASSEMBLY WEDNESDAY, 18 JULY :15 AM 12:15 PM, ULUWATU 1 BALI NUSA DUA CONVENTION CENTER BALI, INDONESIA Author: SHAW Robert Robert E. Shaw, Jr., PE President Steel Structures Technology Center, Inc Leelanau Ct. Howell, MI USA phone (734) fax (734) robert.shaw@iiwelding.net rshaw@steelstructures.com

2 Terms of Reference Commission XVIII, formerly SC-QUAL, maintains the goal to identify, create, develop and transfer global best practices in the field of quality management for welding and allied processes. Commission XVIII focuses on quality management systems and the requirements for personnel and companies involved in welding and allied processes. It also develops guidelines on the implementation of quality standards, for example, ISO 3834 Quality requirements for fusion welding of metallic materials. At present, Commission XVIII members are: updating the document "Improving the quality and effectiveness of welding by utilizing the standard ISO 3834" (SC-QUAL-145r4-10) preparing recommendations for auditor requirements involved with the certification of companies, preparing comparative studies of criteria for fabricator company audits preparing ISO/CD Brazing - Quality requirements for brazing of metallic materials jointly with Commission XVII preparing a draft ISO standard on Welding inspection Tasks and responsibilities Commission XVIII looks to undertake new tasks that will exchange knowledge between technical experts, quality managers and production personnel using welding and allied processes. Thus, Commission XVIII acts as an interdisciplinary body for the IIW. Chair: Robert SHAW rshaw@steelstructures.com USA Vice Chair: Mathias LUNDIN mathias.lundin@svets.se Sweden Sunday, 15 July Monday, 16 July Tuesday, 17 July Wednesday, 18 July 6:15 7:30 pm Opening Ceremony Nusa Dua Hall 4 7:30 10:00 pm Welcome Reception Taman Jepu Joint meeting of XVIII Kintamani 2 (lunch and IAB-A WG A#3b meeting, limited 12:30 2:00 pm on Welding seating, advance inspection Tasks reservation required, and responsibilities contact R Shaw) 19:00 23:00 Indonesian Night Jimbaran 12:30-2:00 pm Joint meeting of XVIII and XVIII on ISO CD Brazing Quality requirements Uluwatu 4 ((lunch meeting, limited seating, advance reservation required, contact R Shaw) Young Professionals 7:30 10:30 pm To be announced Cool Night 8:15 10:15 am Commission XVIII Uluwatu 1 10:45 am 12:15 pm meeting 7:30 11:00 pm Gala Banquet Nusa Dua Hall 5

3 Wednesday,18 July :15 am 12:15 pm Room Uluwatu 1 Bali Nusa Dua Convention Center Bali, Indonesia 1. Opening of the meeting and welcome 1a. Introduction of members and participants 1b. Visit from IIW Secretariat, to be determined 2. Adoption of the agenda (XVIII ) 3. Adoption of minutes 3a. Adoption of the minutes of meeting of SC-QUAL held 28 June 2017 at Shanghai International Convention Center, Shanghai, People s Republic of China (XVIII ) 3b. Adoption of meeting notes taken of meeting of XVIII held 17 January 2018 at Institut de Soudure, Villepinte, France (XVIII ) 4. Discussion of organizational structure as a Commission (voting, etc.) 5. Work items - Standardisation 5a. XVIII-258r2-18 Welding Inspection Tasks and Responsibilities DRAFT 05 JUNE 2018 XVIII-258r1-18 Welding Inspection Tasks and Responsibilities Draft showing revisions following meeting of January a1. Report from Monday s joint task group meeting 5a2. XVIII Additional discussion and approval of changes 5a3. PROPOSED - RESOLUTION FOR FORWARDING AN IIW PROPOSAL FOR A DRAFT STANDARD TO ISO (ROUTE I) (using RD004) NOTE: only members specifically designated and submitted by their national member body as their DELEGATE are permitted to vote on this action (one Delegate per country) 5b. XVIII ISO CD Brazing - Quality Requirements for Brazing of Metallic Materials 5b1. Report from Tuesday s joint task group meeting 5b2. XVIII Additional discussion and approval of changes

4 5b3. PROPOSED - RESOLUTION FOR PROGRESSING DRAFT IIW ROUTE II STANDARDIZATION PROJECTS (Standards and Technical Reports) (using RD005) Resolution of voting on a document to be transmitted to ISO for DIS ballot NOTE: only members specifically designated and submitted by their national member body as their DELEGATE are permitted to vote on this action (one Delegate per country) 6. Presentations 6a. XVIII Repair rates in structural steel fabrication Michail Karpenko, a, Holger Heinzel, Thore Broderson, Alan McClintock Heavy Engineering Research Association (HERA), Auckland, New Zealand 6b. Overview: The objective of this study was to examine the rate of weld repairs (also referred to as the non-compliance rate or defect rate) in recent structural steel projects, and to establish key parameters influencing the weld quality levels. The study is based on data from 37 completed structural steelwork projects provided by eight New Zealand steel fabricators. It was made available in the form of 3rd party inspection reports for all welds that were inspected in individual projects. Further information was made available on the project details. The projects covered in this report include various levels of size and complexity. This paper summarises the results of the study and makes recommendations for further research work to optimise inspection requirements based on the defect data analysis with the aim of optimising inspection efforts. 7. Work items Status reports / decisions on future action 7a. Proposed document on Guidance on Risks in Fabrication Industries Ed WHALEN (CAN), Joao Lopes HENRIQUES (AGO) Also see SC-QUAL "ISO Reducing Failure Risk in Welded Components" by David Shackleton, and SC-QUAL "Proposal for a Guidance Document on Welding Risk" draft as prepared by David Shackleton (UK), June b. Comparative studies of criteria for fabricator audits (AISC, IAS, CWB, CISC, ISO 3834, NZS 3834 PLUS, CE / EN , others) Edward WHALEN (CAN) (leader), Sean BLAKE (ZA), Houman HATAMIAN (AUS), Bob SHAW (USA), Michail KARPENKO (NZ), Chris EADY (UK) 7c. Proposed document "Recommendations for auditor requirements for certification of companies" Edward WHALEN (CAN) (leader), Klaus MIDDLEDORF (DEU), Houman HATAMIAN (AUS), Mathias LUNDIN (SWE), Levente BAKOS (HUN), Herman POTGIETER (ZA), Chris EADY (UK)

5 7d. Improving the Quality and Effectiveness of Welding by Utilizing the Standard ISO 3834 Guideline for Company Implementation (SC-QUAL ) (First draft, update to SC-QUAL- 145R4-10) Sean BLAKE (ZAF), Hans-Georg GROSS (EST), Nwaomy OLUJIE (NGA), Houman HATAMIAN (AUS) 7e. Index of Welding Quality Management System Requirements used Globally in Arc Welding Applications (SC-QUAL-217r1-15) Sean BLAKE (ZAF), Houman HATAMIAN (AUS), Ed WHALEN (CAN), Mathias LUNDIN (SWE), Masaharu SATO (JPN) 8. New Business / Additional Presentations 8a. 8b. 9. Terms of Reference 9a. XVIII Commission XVIII Terms of Reference Update and approve as required. (RD008, ADMINISTRATIVE INFORMATION DESTINED FOR THE TMB, Working Unit programme) 9b. Commission XVIII organizational structure 10. Status of SC-QUAL documents recommended for publication 10a. Inspection and NDE protocols in national and international standards for steel construction Robert Shaw (SC-QUAL-192r6-13) WiW has reconsidered publication, and recommends the document be updated and expanded to be published as an IIW booklet 10b. Comparison of ISO 5817 quality criteria to that of national steel construction standards surface imperfections and imperfections in joint geometry Robert Shaw (IIW SC-QUAL-167r3-11, XV-1384r1-11, XIII-2392r1-11) Still In typesetting process for publication as a booklet, designated IIW

6 11. Reports on related activities 11a. Report on ISO/DIS 17607:2017 Steel Structures Execution of Steelwork (see SC-QUAL- 228r2-16) 11b. DIS ballot of Summer 2017 failed. At meeting of ISO TC167 WG3 and TC167 as a whole, October 2017, in Paris, it was decided to withdraw the standard from consideration because there was insufficient time to revise, reballot and get approved by the ISO deadline. Document will be subdivided into six parts and submitted for NP ballot in Fall 2018 as follows -- Steel Structures: Part 1 General, Part 2 Steels, Part 3 Fabrication, Part 4 Erection, Part 5 Welding, and Part 6 Bolting. Part 7 Corrosion protection and Part 8 Riveting are being held back for further consideration of need. 12. Dates and places of the next meetings 12a. Intermediate meetings, Institut de Soudure, Villepinte, France (week of 14 January, XVIII tentatively 16 January 2019) 12b. 72 nd Annual Assembly, Bratislava, Slovakia, July c. 73 rd Annual Assembly, Singapore, July Dates and places of Associated Events 13a. 4th Young Professionals International Conference in Yutz, France August b. IIW South-East Europe International Congress (SEENET) in Belgrade, Serbia October c. Welding and Related Technologies - Present and Future in Kyiv, Ukraine December Review and approval of resolutions, recommendations and administrative items 15. Adjourn