Volkswagen and Audi Settlement Stakeholder Meeting Agenda Monday, November 7, :00 am 11:30 am (CDPHE s Sabin-Cleere Room)

Similar documents
Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) Agenda. MEETING WRAP-UP: Next Month s Agenda Topic Suggestions

WORK SESSION ITEM City Council

Meeting Minutes of the NORTH FRONT RANGE TRANSPORTATION & AIR QUALITY PLANNING COUNCIL

I-25 Funding Gerry Horak. Sean Conway. STAC (Pg. 78) Other Council Member Reports

[page intentionally left blank]

Chapter 5 Planning Issues for Federal Transit Administration Programs

The RTD FasTracks Plan

AGENDA. Regional Transportation Council Thursday, September 13, 2018 North Central Texas Council of Governments

2018 Call for Projects Guidebook

Fixing America s Surface Transportation Act: FAST Act Implications for the Region

$5.2 Billion Transportation Funding Deal Announced, includes $1.5 Billion for Local Streets and Roads

Centre County Metropolitan Planning Organization (CCMPO) Coordinating Committee Meeting Tuesday, March 22, :00 p.m.

Appendix E Federal and State Funding Categories

Association of Metropolitan Planning Organizations Fixing America s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act

Commissioner Partridge turned the meeting over to Commissioner Mark Waller to make a few comments.

SUMMARY OF THE GROW AMERICA ACT As Submitted to Congress on April 29, 2014

Transportation Planning in the Denver Region

ARLINGTON COUNTY, VIRGINIA. County Board Agenda Item Meeting of July 14, 2018

I-25 GAP COALITION MEETING #3 August 24, 2017 Douglas County Fairgrounds Main Event Center 500 Fairgrounds Blvd., Castle Rock MEETING SUMMARY

Appendix 5 Freight Funding Programs

FORMULA GRANTS 5307 Urbanized Area 5337 State of Good Repair 5339 Bus and Bus Facilities Board of Directors Committee Meeting

VW Settlement DERA Option. NACAA May 1, 2017

2018 Regional Solicitation for Transportation Projects

Table of Contents. Page 2

South Dakota Smart Transportation: Save Money and Grow the Economy

Peninsula Corridor Joint Powers Board Legislative Program

»» General Fund revenue allocation for transportation. »» TRANS bond renewal. »» Federal infrastructure funding

A Guide to Transportation Decision Making. In the Kansas City region

Purpose. Funding. Eligible Projects

Candidate Info MTAP Steering Committee 2017 Elections

FUNDING SOURCES. Appendix I. Funding Sources

Washington State Department of Transportation

The Atlanta Region s Transit Programs of Projects

Overview of the Regional Transportation Improvement Program

2007 Annual List of Obligated Projects

2040 Transportation Policy Plan Update. Council Committee of the Whole December 6, 2017

Montana Smart Transportation:

2017 Local Government Partnership Program

On May 21, the TPB approved

Minnesota Department of Transportation Office of Transit. State Management Plan

MDOT OFFICE OF PASSENGER TRANSPORTATION UPDATE Annual Transit Meeting

2018 Regional Project Evaluation Criteria For PSRC s FHWA Funds

Delaware Smart Transportation: Save Money and Grow the Economy

REMOVE II Public Transportation Subsidy and Park-and-Ride Lot Component GUIDELINES, POLICIES, AND PROCEDURES GUIDELINES, POLICIES, AND PROCEDURES

Nevada Smart Transportation: Save Money and Grow the Economy

Texas Department of Transportation Page 1 of 71 Public Transportation. (a) Applicability. The United States Congress revised 49

RULES CONCERNING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE SAFE ROUTES TO SCHOOL PROGRAM

PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION & COMMUTER VANPOOL PASSENGER SUBSIDY COMPONENT REMOVE II PROGRAM GUIDELINES, POLICIES, AND PROCEDURES

REGIONAL 10-YEAR PLAN AND NEXT DECADE OF PROJECTS. Regional Transportation Council December 8, 2016

REPORT ON TRANSPORTATION PLANNING ACTIVITIES

CITY COUNCIL STUDY SESSION MEMORANDUM

STATEWIDE TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM FY Amarillo District May FY 2010 Quarterly Revisions

Long Range Transportation Plan

Transportation Improvement Program for Lake, Porter, and LaPorte Counties, Indiana for

Local Taxes and Highway Tolls: The New Normal

HB2 Quick Guide To view the latest version of the HB2 Policy Guide:

Falling Forward: A Guide to the FAST Act

FY May Quarterly Revision AUSTIN DISTRICT

PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION

PROJECT SELECTION Educational Series

Federal Transit Administration: Section Enhanced Mobility of Seniors and Individuals with Disabilities. Call for Projects.

Program Management Plan FTA Section 5310

Iowa DOT Update 2016 APWA Fall Conference JOHN E. DOSTART, P.E.

TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM

DRAFT FUNDING APPLICATION October 20, 2010

Update on Transportation Funding and Potential Sources for Additional Revenue. June 19, 2017

GUESTS Kevin Wallace, SRTC Eve Nelson, SRTC. Chair Waldref called the meeting to order at 1:32 p.m. Introductions were made.

Part I. Federal Section 5310 Program

2018 Regional Congestion Mitigation Air Quality Improvement Program (CMAQ) Grant Application

2018 POLICY FRAMEWORK FOR PSRC S FEDERAL FUNDS

9. Positioning Ports for Grant Funding and Government Loan Programs

North Texas Commission 2017 Legislative Priorities

Transportation Funding Terms and Acronyms Unraveling the Jargon

APPLICATION INSTRUCTIONS

TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION. Transportation and the Federal Government

DIRECTOR S REPORT TRANSPORTATION BOARD SEPTEMBER 10, 2018

MOVE LV. Show Us the $ + Transportation Funding May 25, 2016, 12 PM MOVE LEHIGH VALLEY

Summary of. Overview. existing law. to coal ash. billion in FY. funding in FY 2013 FY 2014

DEPARTMENT OF RAIL AND PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION REPORT ON AUDIT FOR THE YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2005

Fiscal Year 2018 Competitive Funding Opportunity; Grants for Buses and Bus Facilities Infrastructure Investment Program

SECTION 5310 APPLICATION GUIDELINES FOR 2018 PROJECTS:

THE. ATLANTA REGION S Transit Programs Of Projects

2018 and 2020 Regional Congestion Mitigation Air Quality Improvement Program (CMAQ) Grant Application

HB 2017 Transit Advisory Committee. July 27, 2018

Federal Public Transportation Program: In Brief

FEDERAL TRANSIT ADMINISTRATION

Urban Partnership Communications Plan

Questions & Answers. Elderly Individuals & Individuals with Disabilities (Section 5310), JARC & New Freedom Programs Last Updated April 29, 2009

Puget Sound Gateway Program

RURAL BRIEF AMERICAN RECOVERY AND REINVESTMENT ACT OF 2009 CENTER FOR RURAL AFFAIRS. Department of Agriculture

Massachusetts Department of Transportation (MassDOT) Route 3 South Managed Lanes Project DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES ONLY

BROWARD COUNTY TRANSIT MAJOR SERVICE CHANGE TO 595 EXPRESS SUNRISE - FORT LAUDERDALE. A Title VI Service Equity Analysis

PHOTO COURTESY OF ALISHA JEFFERS A HIGH-LEVEL OVERVIEW OF COUNTY SERVICES, GOALS AND PERFORMANCE.

HB2 Update October, 2014

DCHC MPO Funding Source Overview & Guidance draft January 2015

MPO- *************************** 4:00 18, 2015 *************************** TENTATIVE AGENDA

SUNIGA/LEMAY MULTI-MODAL AND FREIGHT CONNECTIVITY PROJECT

Major in FY2013/2014 (By and ing Source) Municipal Building Acquisition and Operations Balance $1,984, Contributions from Real Estate

Utah Smart Transportation: Save Money and Grow the Economy

MAP-21: An Analysis. The Trust Fund

Transcription:

Volkswagen and Audi Settlement Stakeholder Meeting Agenda Monday, November 7, 2016 9:00 am 11:30 am (CDPHE s Sabin-Cleere Room) Please register here to attend and to present verbal comments DESCRIPTION Colorado anticipates receiving about $61 million from an Environmental Mitigation trust established through a partial settlement of lawsuits against Volkswagen and Audi for installing emissions defeat devices on certain vehicles in violation of the federal Clean Air Act. The Air Pollution Control Division invites you to a public meeting about Colorado s implementation of the settlement and the state s use of the settlement funds. Comments, questions, and concerns will be considered during the meeting and the Division s ongoing planning. PURPOSE Inform the public about the settlement Solicit and listen to stakeholder comments to guide Colorado s implementation of the settlement DESIRED OUTCOMES Understand background and timeline of the settlement Understand how the settlement funds may be used to improve air quality Receive public comment on how Colorado should implement the settlement and spend the funds AGENDA Introduction Summary of settlement background and status of consent decree Timeline Colorado s implementation of the settlement Process of allocating funds and potential issues Questions and answers Public comment (advance registration recommended) Meeting wrap-up MEETING DETAILS Intended Audience: Members of the public and potential receipients of the Volkswagen settlement funds When: Monday, November 7, 2016 Time: 9:00 am 11:30 am Where: Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment 4300 Cherry Creek Drive South, Sabin-Cleere Room (in building A) Denver, CO 80246 Adobe Connect Webcast: https://cdphe.adobeconnect.com/vw/ We look forward to your participation. Please extend this invitation to your organization and others who may be interested. Space is limited, so please limit attendance to two people from each organization. For more information, please visit - https://www.colorado.gov/pacific/cdphe/vw You can submit questions or comments to cdphe.commentsapcd@state.co.us

September 30, 2016 REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENT REGARDING THE VOLKSWAGEN AND AUDI PARTIAL SETTLEMENT The Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) requests public comment on all aspects of Colorado s implementation of the proposed VW and Audi partial settlement. Among other things, the settlement would establish an Environmental Mitigation Trust that allocates about $61 million to Colorado for certain emission reduction projects. Public organizations, private entities, and individuals may receive funding for eligible projects. CDPHE is the state s lead agency to implement the trust. Depending on when the court approves the settlement and the trust is finalized, CDPHE anticipates that Colorado could begin soliciting project applications in mid-2017 and funds would be available by the end of 2017. More information about the settlement can be found at www.colorado.gov/cdphe/vw. Please submit any comments and information by November 7, 2016 to cdphe.commentsapcd@state.co.us or in person at the November 7, 2016 public meeting. CDPHE particularly seeks comment on the following issues regarding the Environmental Mitigation Trust: 1. How the settlement money should be distributed, spent, and accounted for 2. How to maximize the air quality benefits resulting from the trust 3. Whether projects should be fully funded or partially funded (the trust allows reimbursement of 25%-100% of eligible costs, depending on the project category) 4. What process should Colorado use to solicit, review, and approve or disapprove applications for funds? 5. Whether to set aside funds for particular categories of projects or applicants 6. Whether to give preferences to certain fuels, such as diesel, compressed natural gas, propane, hydrogen fuel cell or battery electric 7. The emission reductions achievable from each eligible mitigation measure 8. The costs and benefits of replacing or repowering vehicles with Alternate Fueled or All-Electric engine technologies, as defined by Appendix D-2. 9. The percentage of trust funds, if any, that Colorado should devote to Light Duty Zero Emission Vehicle Supply Equipment 10. Whether to expend trust funds on the DERA Option 11. How to determine whether a proposed project will benefit areas that have been disproportionately impacted by emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx) or other pollutants, and information about such impacts in particular areas of Colorado 12. The criteria for evaluating applications for funds. How should Colorado consider the following factors, and what other factors should it consider? a. Reductions in emissions of NOx and other pollutants

b. Ozone, particulate matter, visibility, climate change, public health and other environmental values c. Project costs and benefits d. The economic impacts of proposed projects e. The geographic distribution of funds f. The division of funds between the categories of eligible projects g. An applicant s status as a government agency, large business, small business, individual person, or other category h. Whether a project applicant is low income, minority, or disadvantaged or operates vehicles in these communities i. Benefits to areas that have been disproportionately impacted by NOx and other pollutants j. The number of affected vehicles registered in the county where the project is proposed or predominantly operated in those counties k. The project s potential to accelerate a broader transition to Alternate Fueled or All-Electric vehicles 13. How should Colorado account for existing programs, such as ALT Fuels Colorado or Charge Ahead Colorado, when implementing the settlement? 14. What are the pros and cons of awarding funds through the processes currently used for ALT Fuels Colorado and Charge Ahead Colorado? What changes, if any, would be needed to adapt the ALT Fuels and Charge Ahead Colorado award processes to the VW settlement? 15. Should Colorado consider the possibility that some projects might occur in the absence of trust funding, or that equipment purchased with trust funds might be quickly sold or moved out of state? 16. CDPHE will conduct public outreach through in-person and online public meetings, presentations to stakeholder groups, Facebook posts, tweets, written comments and traditional media. What additional factors, if any, should CDPHE consider in its public outreach?

VW & Audi Settlement Stakeholder Meeting is in Building A, Sabin-Cleere Room

October 2016 Director's Report Addendum CDOT Transportation Summit 2016 November 1 10:00 am to 6:00 pm NFRMPO has purchased a table of 10 Open to Planning Council Members Please let Terri or Renae know if you would like to attend by October 21. Council/Board Presentations I have made presentations to the Severance, Milliken and Berthoud boards Please let me know if you would like me to make a presentation on the MPO to your board or council Electric Driving Experience An electric driving experience is scheduled for 4:30 to 5:30 pm prior to the Planning Council meeting in Johnstown The electric drive and ride event has been extended to 6:30 pm for the public Air Quality Outreach The Transfort buses still have the Air Quality bus tails on them reminding drivers to take care of the Air The Greeley buses bus backs debuted in August and run through the end of September Staff have attended local events in Milliken, Severance, Loveland, Windsor and Fort Collins handing out the bags and balloons Staff attended the Taste in Timnath Fall Festival on September 24 Staff also delivered one of the Air Quality Banners to Windsor for the Grand Opening of the Recreation Center VW Proposed Partial Consent Decree The Department of Justice has published a notice of a Partial Consent Decree for 2.0 liter engines that operate with the emission defeat software The Governor has designated the CDPHE as the agency to manage the VW program in Colorado There will be public outreach to obtain comments on how the funds should be spent VW is required to establish $2.7B to mitigate excess emissions with funds distributed based on vehicles in that state VW must set aside up to $10.33 to recall at least 85% of the vehicles with the defeat software VW must set aside $2B for Zero Emission charging stations, zero emission education, and to improve access to Zero Emission Vehicles (ZEV) through Car share and rideshare programs Trustee expected to be selected by mid-2017 More information available at http://bit.ly/2aswwj9 Comments may be provided in person on November 7 from 9:00 11:30 am in the CDPHE s Sabin-Cleere Room at 4300 Cherry Creek Drive in Denver or CDPHE has requested written public comment be sent to cdphe.commentsapcd@state.co.us by November 7 An Adobe Connect Webcast is also available to listen to the meeting at the

same time at https://cdphe.adobeconnect.com/vw/ Fix N I-25 The next N I-25 Funding Subcommittee meeting is scheduled for October 7 from 11:30 to 1:00 pm at Perkins at Crossroads The N I-25 Coalition plans to hold a meeting with the State Legislators on December 7 NFRMPO Non-motorized Plan Staff presented to the Loveland Transportation Advisory Board on August 1, Fort Collins Transportation Board on August 17 and the Greeley Citizen Transportation Advisory Board on August 22. HOV 3 HOV three will be initiated in January 2017 HPTE staff will present the change at the I-25 Funding Subcommittee on October 7 NFRMPO Staff Changes The NFRMPO will be conducting in person interviews with four candidates on September 28 and hopes to have an additional planner on board by mid-november if not sooner. NFRMPO hired Ryan Dusil and he will start on October 11. VanGo VanGo staff made a presentation to Estes Park employers on the ability to travel up the canyon with VanGo using a permit provided by CDOT CU has initiated a $15 incentive for Vanpoolers using VanGo MPO/VanGo staff are working with FTA and Transfort to identify a process that allows the sale of FTA funded vans without having to return 80% of the funding The MPO/VanGo Bids for the 2016 FASTER Van purchases closed on September 21 and 3 bids were received but none were completely responsive VanGo is analyzing The MPO/VanGo received a FY 2017 FASTER award of $186K for vehicle acquisition The MPO is working to update an IGA with the City of Fort Collins for the maintenance of the VanGo vehicles The MPO is reviewing an IGA to establish VanGo maintenance in Loveland VanGo will be sending out an RFP for a fare study and an app for NTD reporting. VanGo staff attended US-34 Closure meetings on September 29 and October 4 to offer VanGo services NFRMPO and VanGo Websites The NFRMPO Staff with Greystone assistance has updated the website and the URL will remain the same The new NFRMPO website is live The VanGo website has been updated by Tripspark and will use a new URL of Vangovanpools.org

The VanGo website is expected to go live using the new URL in the next two weeks Bike/Pedestrian Counters The MPO loaned the three mobile counters to Loveland for counts for July 18-26 and again for September 27-October 5 The counters are available For more information on the training or to reserve the counters, contact Aaron Buckley at 970-416-2309 or by email abuckley@nfrmpo.org Mobility Committees The Larimer and Weld County Mobility Committee will meet jointly on October 21 from 10:00 am to 12:00pm at the Windsor Community Recreation Center to kick off the update of the Coordinated Human Services Plan NFRMPO Documents available electronically or as printed copies To assist with public outreach, staff has designed and printed the following documents: o NFRMPO and VanGo Brochures o 2015 Annual Report o 2040 RTP Brochure o Mobility Postcards o Mobility Rider s Guide o Quarterly Newsletter Any Planning Council member who would like extra copies of any of the documents can contact me at tblackmore@nfrmpo.org

North Front Range MPO Area Project Status Updates (6 Oct 2016) Roadway / Segment SH14 I 25 US34 SH56 SH60 US85 US287 SH392 SH402 US287 PR at Ted s Place US287 to I 25 Surface Treatment Crossroads Blvd Interchange / Bridges Truck Climbing Lane Ramp Metering Harmony Rd SB SH392 NB/SB Big Thompson Canyon Flood Repair PEL Study Berthoud East Surface Treatment SH257 PR Status In Design In Design Construction underway Construction underway. Under Advertisement Construction is underway Bids opening Construction is finished Construction is underway Ault to Wyoming Construction is underway O St to Ault ADA ramps & Resurfacing Advertise Fall 2016 Harmony to Mulberry Resurfacing Construction is underway SH1 to LaPorte Bypass Construction is underway Road damage near Larimer CR 17 Advertise Fall 2016 US85 Intersection Construction commencing Larimer CR 9E Ad estimated Fall 2016

STAC Summary September 23 rd, 2016 1) Introductions & July Minutes Vince Rogalski (STAC Chair) a) August STAC Minutes approved without changes. 2) Transportation Commission Report Vince Rogalski (STAC Chair) a) CDOT DTR provided an overview of proposed changes to the 5311 funding program. b) Budget reconciliation for FY15/16 yielded a surplus of $85 million, while federal redistribution produced an additional $48 million. c) RoadX presented on its recent activities and will brief the STAC at a future meeting. d) Approval was granted to move forward on the construction of a new Region 2 headquarters building in Pueblo. e) STAC Chair Vince Rogalski is serving on the Legislature s Efficiency & Accountability Committee, currently focused on evaluating the collection and documentation of FASTER vehicle fees. 3) TPR Reports TPR Representatives 4) Policy Directive 14 Current Performance & Strategies Debra Perkins-Smith (CDOT Division of Transportation Development) a) CDOT staff reviewed PD14 performance measures with the TC this month and will use this information as part of the budget-setting process. b) Some proposed changes to performance measures include: i) Employing a Planning Time Index (PTI) to measure mobility, with a goal of 90% of state highways achieving a 1.05 PTI (currently at 85%). ii) Adopting a statewide (rather than regional) transit infrastructure goal of having 65% of rural transit vehicles be in fair, good, or excellent condition (currently at 81%). c) Additional funds are being requested to address deficiencies in surface treatment, preventative bridge maintenance, and other assets failing to meet current targets. d) The TC will be asked to approve these goals, targets, and metrics via resolution in October. e) STAC Discussion: STAC members note that growing population and VMT may skew perceptions of safety data such as crash rates and also that marijuana and electronic distractions present unique and emerging challenges to improving transportation safety. 5) Revenue & Contingency Reconciliation Maria Sobota (CDOT Division of Accounting & Finance) a) CDOT has successfully reduced its cash balance by $800 million over the past 2.5 years and maintains policies to identify areas of risk to upcoming projects, including the erratic schedule of federal funding resolutions. Currently their model identifies a 1 in 1,000 chance of such a project delay. b) Updated SB 228 forecasts indicate yearly transfers as follows: i) FY15/16 $199 million (completed) ii) FY16/17 $158 million (approved by the Legislature) iii) FY17/18 $100-$200 million (forecast by OSPB and Legislative Council) iv) FY18/19 $100 million (forecast by OSPB and Legislative Council) c) Annual debt service payments of $167 million will expire in December of 2016 and have already been redirected to support asset management goals. d) The Transportation Commission Contingency Reserve Fund (TCCRF) has approximately $108 million available from increased revenues, federal redistribution, roll-forwards, etc. and are being requested to fund programs and projects including:

i) $15 million for Bridge Enterprise ii) $1 million for striping iii) $11.5 million for TSMO bottleneck improvements, safety patrol expansion, and operations enhancements iv) $13.7 million for RoadX connected vehicle pilot on I-70, Big Data platform, and statewide broadband collaboration v) $12 million for risk & resiliency efforts, including flood repair matches e) The Transportation Commission will be asked to approve these budgetary changes in October. 6) Break 7) National Highway Freight Program Jeff Sudmeier (CDOT Multimodal Planning Branch) a) The new FAST Act freight programs are prompting several new corridor designations, including critical urban, critical rural, and national multimodal freight corridors. Annual funding for the formula freight program will be roughly $15 million annually. b) CDOT is kicking off the Multimodal Freight Plan (MFP) and State Freight & Passenger Rail Plan (SFPRP) to identify the long-term process for targeting freight investments for FY18/19 and beyond. c) A working group of region planners and environmental staff have formed to help identify freight project selection criteria that are robust, straightforward, transparent, and easily understood. Five basic eligibility requirements (3 federal and 2 state) have been established, plus additional criteria from the State Highway Freight Plan and Statewide Transportation Plan goal areas (including safety, mobility, maintenance, and economic vitality), and resiliency and funding leverage. d) STAC Discussion: STAC members urge caution with a funding leverage criteria that could lead to a pay-to-play system. 8) 10-Year Development Program Jeff Sudmeier (CDOT Multimodal Planning Branch) a) The 10-Year Development Program consists of higher priority, unfunded projects that could be addressed within a 10-year window. b) The Tier 1 list totals $2.5 billion and the Tier 2 list totals an additional $5 billion. c) CDOT staff is requesting STAC input on the 10-Year Development Program list as it is finalized. Transit, bike/ped, and operations projects are under development but will be added before the list is finalized. d) STAC Discussion: STAC members would like to see geographic equity and Tier 1 / Tier 2 dollar totals reflected on the final document. 9) Rest Area Study Joshua Laipply (CDOT Chief Engineer) a) CDPHE recently closed the rest area at Deer Trail, spurring a broader evaluation of CDOT s rest areas throughout the state. b) There are 27 rest areas in the state that would require roughly $15 million to upgrade to B+ condition and $5-$6 million per year to maintain. c) Currently staff is developing rest area assessment criteria that will eventually be used to develop a CDOT policy for rest areas. d) Next steps include development of a draft policy, integrate CDOT truck parking study findings, finalizing evaluation, and developing strategies for each site. e) STAC Discussion: STAC members clarify that not all rest areas are currently ADA compliant, confirm that CDOT is not allowed to develop concessions on rest areas within the public ROW, and are informed that CDOT is working to develop a multi-state truck parking locator pilot as a part of RoadX. 10) STAC Workshop & Elections Vince Rogalski (STAC Chair) a) STAC members discussed various approaches to improving the efficiency of STAC meetings, such as providing meeting materials further in advance and with clearer indication of the type of input requested by CDOT staff. An annual schedule indicating key points of STAC input would help members

prepare for meetings and consult with their local colleagues beforehand. Establishing a minimum timeframe for sharing materials would also be helpful in preventing rushed decision-making. b) During the October meeting, STAC will meet with Transportation Commissioners Gary Reiff (Chair) and Sidny Zink (Vice Chair) to discuss the enhanced advisory relationship between the STAC and TC created by HB16-1018. The bill s sponsor, Representative Terri Carver, will also be in attendance. c) STAC Discussion: STAC members feel that the intent of the Legislature was to foster a closer working relationship between the STAC and TC, akin to that of a Planning Commission. STAC members feel that they will offer the TC a valuable window on the needs and desires of the traveling public. 11) Other Business Vince Rogalski (STAC Chair) a) The next STAC meeting will be held on Friday, October 28 th. 12) STAC Adjourns

VanGo Metrics 2016 VanGo is the nationally recognized vanpool program of the North Front Range Metropolitan Planning Organization (NFRMPO). This dashboard (VanGo Metrics) provides a snapshot of the program"vitals" 1) Sales and Marketing, 2) Operations, and 3) Billing. The document will be updated online monthly to provide transparency regarding the operating efficiency of the program to the hundreds of vanpoolers it serves. 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 1/4/2016 1/18/2016 2/1/2016 Weekly Vanpool / Vanpoolers 2/15/2016 2/29/2016 3/14/2016 3/28/2016 4/11/2016 4/25/2016 5/9/2016 5/23/2016 6/6/2016 6/20/2016 7/4/2016 7/18/2016 8/1/2016 8/15/2016 8/29/2016 9/12/2016 9/26/2016 10/10/2016 Active Vanpools Occupany % Active Vanpoolers 10/24/2016 11/7/2016 11/21/2016 12/5/2016 12/19/2016 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Guaranteed Ride Home Yellow Cab Metro Cab Cost $350.00 $300.00 $250.00 $200.00 $150.00 $100.00 $50.00 $ Other, Events / Fair, 8 Formation, 1 Climate wise, 5 Other, 3 Events / Fair, 20 Out of Region Visits Formation, 5 In Region Visits Business, 56 Business Formation Events / Fair Climate wise Other Business, 48 Business Formation Events / Fair TMO / DRCOG Other 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Visits by Week 0 1/4/2016 2/4/2016 3/4/2016 4/4/2016 5/4/2016 6/4/2016 7/4/2016 8/4/2016 9/4/2016 10/4/2016 11/4/2016 12/4/2016 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 In Region Out of Region SmartTrips.org Tracking (restated) Match Searches Commutes Miles Saved 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 Email and Phone Tracking by Week TOTAL CALLS TOTAL EMAILS Company Rep 4 Craigslist 35 Twitter 2 KUNC Radio 9 ValuAds 11 Facebook 2 Formation Meeting 14 Website 46 KUNC Radio 4 Twitter Company Rep 1 Craigslist 15 ValuAds 6 36 Facebook 8 Formation Meeting 29 Medical & Mobility 20 Phone Tracking Source Saw Van 86 Email Tracking Source Website 63 Saw Van 54 DRCOG 34 DRCOG 23 Medical & Mobility 21 Current Vanpooler 263 Article Current Vanpooler 189 One Way & Other 48 January to Date Article 5 One Way & Other 32 Phone Tracking Region NA Out of Region 143 Out of Region 162 In Region Out of Region NA Email Tracking Region NA In Region Out of Region NA In Region 346 In Region 411 400 10 Billing Accounts 350 9 8 300 7 250 6 200 5 150 4 3 100 2 50 1 Self Pay Accounts Automatic Payment Accounts Recurring Payment Sign ups Incentives Paid, Late Fees Received $ $100 $200 $300 $400 $500 $600 $700 $800 $900 $1,000 January February March April May June July August September October November December Rider Incentive Disbursed Late Fee $ Amount 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 $5,000.00 $4,500.00 $4,000.00 $3,500.00 $3,000.00 $2,500.00 $2,000.00 $1,500.00 $1,000.00 $500.00 $ Account Attention Late Payments Processed Declined Payments Collections 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Sent To Recouped KEY Sales and Marketing VanGo Operations VanGo Billing Phone 1.800.332.0950 Website www.smarttrips.org / www.nfrmpo.org Last Updated: 10/6/2016

North Front Range Transportation & Air Quality Planning Council Member & Alternate Roster- 2016 Revised 10/04/2016 MPO REPRESENTATIVE MPO ALTERNATE FORT COLLINS/Transfort GERRY HORAK Chair BOB OVERBECK PO Box 580 PO Box 580 Fort Collins, CO 80522 Fort Collins, CO 80522 W 221-6505 C 970-217-2993 W (970) 817-1411 Fax 224-6107 (city) Fax 224-6107 (city) ghorak@fcgov.com boverbeck@fcgov.com EATON KEVIN ROSS Vice Chair BRAD MOOS 1500 Falcon Ridge Road 110 Walnut Ave. Eaton, CO 80615 Eaton, CO 80615 C (970) 381-5172 (970)-481-9201 kross@eatonco.org moosfarms@gmail.com BERTHOUD JENNIFER BAKER JEFF HINDMAN PO Box 131 PO Box 1759 Berthoud, CO 80513 Berthoud, CO 80513 (970) 532-2643 Fax 970-532-0640 (303) 819-7199 jbaker@berthoud.org jhindman@berthoud.org EVANS JOHN MORRIS MARK CLARK 1100 37 th Street 1100 37 th Street Evans, CO 80620 Evans, CO 80620 Daytime: (970) 673-5719 Cell: (970) 542-3949 Fax 330-3472 (city) jmorris@evanscolorado.gov mclark@evanscolorado.gov GARDEN CITY *NO MEMBER CURRENTLY *NO ALTERNATE Garden City, CO Gardencity1938@aol.com GREELEY TOM NORTON ROBB CASSEDAY City of Greeley 1304 38 th Ave. 1000 10 th Street Greeley, CO 80634 Greeley, CO 80631 970-336-4292 W 350-9772 970-350-9772 tom.norton@greeleygov.com Robb.Casseday@Greeleygov.com JOHNSTOWN -TROY MELLON 1115 Country Acres Drive Johnstown, CO 80534 W 970-350-6547 C 970-371-9687 H 970-587-4757 tmellon@townofjohnstown.com *NO ALTERNATE LARIMER COUNTY TOM DONNELLY STEVE JOHNSON PO Box 1190 P.O. Box 1190 Fort Collins, CO 80522 Fort Collins, CO 80522 W (970) 498-7003 Cell: 290-2431 W 498-7002, Cell (970) 218-6625 Fax (970) 498-7006 Fax 498-7006 (county) tdonnelly@larimer.org / donnelt@larimer.org johnsosw@co.larimer.co.us

MPO REPRESENTATIVE MPO ALTERNATE LASALLE PAULA COCHRAN SHARON LOOKHART Town of LaSalle Town of LaSalle 128 N. 2 nd St. 128 N. 2 nd St. LaSalle, CO 80645 La Salle, CO 80645 Town: 284-6931 Cell: 347-7838 Town: 284-6931 Cell: 590-3286 Fax 284-6983 Fax 284-6983 pcochran@lasalletown.com slookhart@lasalletown.com LOVELAND JOAN SHAFFER DAVE CLARK 500 E. 3 rd Street, Suite 330 500 E. 3 rd Street, Suite 330 Loveland, CO 80537 Fort Collins, CO 80522 W (970) 669-0030 Cell: 290-2431 W 498-7002, Cell (970) 218-6625 joan.shaffer@cityofloveland.org dave.clark@cityofloveland.org MILLIKEN LINDA MEASNER LERON EHRLICH PO Box 158 2457 Birdie Drive Milliken, CO 80543 Milliken, CO 80543 Cell: 970-577-4375 Cell: 970-545-0550 jmeasner@aol.com lehrlich@millikenco.gov SEVERANCE DONALD R. BROOKSHIRE ALISON KOSTER Town of Severance, Donald R. Brookshire, Mayor 207 Aspen Grove Way PO Box 339 Severance, CO 80550 Severance, CO 80546 970-686-1218 970-686-1218 dbrooks@frii.com alison.koster@townofseverance TIMNATH PAUL STEINWAY AARON PEARSON 4800 Goodman Street 5821 Red Bridge Drive Timnath, CO 80547 Timnath, CO 80547 970-224-3211 970-460-9268 psteinway@timnathgov.com apearson@timnathgov.com WELD COUNTY SEAN CONWAY Past Chair JULIE COZAD 1150 O Street, P.O. Box 758 1150 O Street, P.O. Box 758 Greeley, CO 80632 Greeley, CO 80632 W 356-4000 ext. 4200 C 518-6999 W 970-356-4000 ext. 4209 C 970-515-2424 sconway@co.weld.co.us jcozad@co.weld.co.us WINDSOR KRISTIE MELENDEZ MYLES BAKER 301 Walnut Street 301 Walnut Street Windsor, CO 80550 Windsor, CO 80550 D 215-5495 C (714) 924-4672 Fax 674-9742 kmelendez@windsorgov.com mbaker@windsorgov.com CDPHE- CHRIS COLCLASURE 4300 Cherry Creek Drive South Denver, CO 80246-1530 W 303-692-3269 C 303-916-1698 F 303-782-5493 chris.colclasure@state.co.us *NO ALTERNATE TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION KATHY GILLILAND JOHNNY OLSON CDOT Region 4 247 Sloan Road 10601 West 10 th Street Livermore, CO 80536 Greeley, CO 80634 H 493-7783 W 350-2103 C (970) 381-2206 C 576-4124 Fax 350-2177 kgilliland@hughes.net Revised: 10/04/2016

NORTH FRONT RANGE MPO STAFF 419 Canyon Ave., Suite 300 Fort Collins, CO 80521 FAX: 970-416-2174 TERRI BLACKMORE- Executive Director 416-2174 tblackmore@nfrmpo.org ADMINSTRATIVE STAFF RENAE STEFFEN Administrative Director/DBE Liaison Officer 416-2315 rsteffen@nfrmpo.org CRYSTAL HEDBERG Operations & Finance Manager 416-2638 chedberg@nfrmpo.org MERIDETH KIMSEY- Accounting Clerk/ NTD Reporter 416-2252 mkimsey@nfrmpo.org TRANSPORTATION PLANNING STAFF BECKY KARASKO - Regional Transportation Planning Director 416-2257 rkarasko@nfrmpo.org AARON BUCKLEY Transportation Planner 416-2309 abuckley@nfrmpo.org ALEX GORDON Transportation Planner II/ Mobility Coordinator 416-2025 agordon@nfrmpo.org MEDORA KEALY Transportation Planner 416-2293 mkealy@nfrmpo.org RYAN DUSIL Transportation Planner 224-6191 rdusil@nfrmpo.org VANGO TM STAFF SHANE ARMSTRONG- Van Pool Services Coordinator 221-6859 sarmstrong@nfrmpo.org VAL VOLLMAN- Administrative Specialist 221-6243 sarmstrong@nfrmpo.org Revised: 10/04/2016