This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers visit http://www.djreprints.com. http://www.wsj.com/articles/russian-strikes-on-remote-syria-garrison-alarm-u-s-1469137231 WORLD MIDDLE EAST Russia Bombed Base in Syria Used by U.S. An outpost near the Jordanian border that is used by U.S. and British special forces was hit by the airstrikes last month Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu visits a Russian air base in Syria in June. PHOTO: VADIM SAVITSKY/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGES By ADAM ENTOUS and GORDON LUBOLD Updated July 21, 2016 7:34 p.m. ET When Russian aircraft bombed a remote garrison in southeastern Syria last month, alarm bells sounded at the Pentagon and the Ministry of Defense in London. The Russians weren t bombarding a run-of-the-mill rebel outpost, according to U.S. officials. Their target was a secret base of operations for elite American and British forces. In fact, a contingent of about 20 British special forces had pulled out of the garrison 24 hours earlier. British officials declined to comment. U.S. military and intelligence officials say the previously unreported close call for Western forces on June 16, and a subsequent Russian strike on a site linked to the Central Intelligence Agency, were part of a campaign by Moscow to pressure the Obama administration to agree to closer cooperation in the skies 1 of 5 21.08.16, 16:23
over Syria. Twice Targeted Russian aircraft bombed a remote outpost in Syria used by U.S. and British special forces in June, and then in July hit a camp housing families of Central Intelligence Agency-backed Syrian fighters. Lions of the East The family rebel camp camp about 50 miles west of At-Tanf was hit by LEBANON Russians on Damascus July 12. Aleppo SYRIA At-Tanf garrison The remote outpost about 10 miles from the Jordanian border was hit by Russians on June 16. IRAQ ISRAEL JORDAN Sources: U.S. officials and rebel commanders 100 miles 100 km The risk that U.S. and British forces could have been killed at the border garrison hardened opposition at the Pentagon and the CIA to accommodating the Russians. But White House and State Department officials, wary of an escalation in U.S. military involvement in Syria, decided to pursue a compromise. Yury Melnik, a spokesman for the Russian embassy in Washington, referred questions about the incidents to the Russian Defense Ministry, which didn't respond to a request for comment. A provisional agreement reached by Secretary of State John Kerry in Moscow last week over Pentagon and CIA objections calls for the former Cold War adversaries to join forces in strikes against the Nusra Front, Syria s al Qaeda affiliate. In exchange for the U.S. easing Moscow s international isolation, Russia would halt airstrikes on the U.S.-backed rebels and restrain the Syrian air force. Talks are still under way between U.S. and Russian experts over the designated areas where the Russians would have to get Washington s approval before conducting strikes. Proponents of the deal in the White House and the State Department say it will allow the U.S. to target Nusra in areas which have been off limits to American attack aircraft for months because of Russian deployments, and will provide a measure of protection to U.S. allies on the ground in Syria whom the Russians and Syrians were targeting in their air campaigns. 2 of 5 21.08.16, 16:23
Critics of the deal at the Pentagon and the CIA say the White House gave in to Russian bullying and voiced doubt that Moscow would abide by the terms of the agreement. They say the U.S. needs to confront the Russians more squarely. White House and State Department officials are wary of intensifying a costly proxy fight that could exacerbate the level of violence in Syria. Since its armed intervention on behalf of Syrian President Bashar al-assad last September, the Russian air force has conducted hundreds of sorties against CIA-backed rebels fighting his government, fueling U.S. anger. Mr. Melnik, the Russian embassy spokesman, said, In reality, the only objective Russia pursues in Syria is fighting terrorism. And we believe that better coordination of Russian and American efforts would contribute to effective pursuit of this objective, as well as to a diplomatic solution of the Syrian crisis. Officials close to Mr. Kerry said he shares the skepticism of military and intelligence officials about Russian intentions, which was why he inserted a clause during the negotiations to allow the U.S. to unilaterally suspend cooperation with the Russians if they started bombing U.S. allies again. U.S. and British special forces based in Jordan cross the border into Syria on missions, helping maintain an unofficial buffer zone on Syrian soil to protect Jordan from Islamic State, U.S. officials said. The special forces would rendezvous with their rebel allies at the garrison, initially used by the CIA. For security reasons, the forces wouldn t spend the night. A contingent of about 20 British special forces pulled out of the facility less than 24 hours before the U.S. tracked Russian aircraft on June 16 flying across Syria to the garrison, according to U.S. military and intelligence officials briefed on the strike. The aircraft dropped cluster munitions on the target, according to U.S. officials and rebel commanders. After that first Russian strike, officers with the U.S. military s Central Command air operations center in Qatar called their counterparts in Russia s air campaign headquarters in Latakia, Syria, U.S. officials said. The American officers told the Russians that the garrison was part of the U.S. campaign against Islamic State and shouldn t be attacked. Roughly 90 minutes after the U.S. warning was delivered, U.S. aircraft circling nearby watched as the Russians launched a second wave of strikes against the garrison. A U.S. military surveillance aircraft overhead tried to hail the Russian pilots directly using the frequencies which the U.S. and Russian governments had 3 of 5 21.08.16, 16:23
agreed to use in emergencies. The Russian pilots didn t respond. U.S. officials said four rebels were killed in the Russian strikes. After the Russian aircraft returned to base in western Syria, the Pentagon demanded that Moscow explain what happened. Russian military officials initially told their Pentagon counterparts that Russian pilots intentionally struck the garrison, but thought it was an Islamic State facility, according to the U.S. officials briefed on the incident. U.S. military and intelligence officials rejected that explanation and said the Russian pilots would have been able to tell from the air that the garrison wasn t an Islamic State facility because of the unique ways in which it was fortified. Among the protective measures surrounding At-Tanf were interlocking sandbag walls that are a signature characteristic of U.S. and British bases in the region. The Russians then told the Americans that the Jordanians had approved of the strikes in advance. U.S. officials said they checked with Amman and were told by their Jordanian counterparts that they had never given Moscow a green light. The Russians later told the Americans that their air command headquarters in Syria wasn t in a position to call off the strikes because officers with U.S. Central Command didn t provide Moscow with the precise coordinates for the garrison. U.S. officials said the Pentagon had never specifically asked the Russians to steer clear of the area around the At-Tanf garrison because it wasn t close to any of the front lines between the Assad regime and opposing forces and because Russian aircraft didn t operate in that part of Syria. Moreover, distrust of Russian intentions ran so deep within the U.S. military and the CIA that U.S. officials didn t want to tell the Russians any more than they had to, officials said. The strike sharpened divisions within the administration. Military and intelligence officials said it showed why Moscow couldn't be trusted. Administration officials in favor of the deal said the strike illustrated why refusing to cooperate with the Russians carried risks. Following the strike, the U.S. gave the Russians some additional information about U.S. operations along the Jordanian border. U.S. officials said they told Moscow to steer clear of the border area. 4 of 5 21.08.16, 16:23
But on July 12, as Mr. Kerry was preparing to fly to Moscow to complete the agreement to increase U.S.-Russian coordination, Russian aircraft targeted another base near the Jordanian border, about 50 miles from At-Tanf, used by family members of CIA-backed fighters and other displaced Syrians, according to U.S. officials briefed on the strike and rebel commanders. Tllass Salameh, a commander with the Lions of the East rebel group which works out of the base, said 200 people were living at the families camp. In the strike, the Russians used cluster munitions, which increased the number of casualties, according to Mr. Salameh and U.S. officials. Mr. Salameh said two young children, aged two and three, were killed along with two young women and a man in his mid-50s. In addition, 48 people were injured, all civilians, he said. Suha Ma ayeh in Amman contributed to this article. Copyright 2014 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com. 5 of 5 21.08.16, 16:23