CONTRACT-BASED AIR TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM (CATS) Operational Assessment
|
|
- Randolf Webb
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 CONTRACT-BASED AIR TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM (CATS) Operational Assessment A Human in the Loop experiment to assess the CoO concept from ATCO & Pilot point of view Presented by Sandrine Guibert EUROCONTROL Second CATS Workshop Geneva January 26th, 2010 Page: 1
2 Goal Proof of Concept Study, following E-OCVM Idea Implemented Concept V0 V1 V2 V3 V4 V 5 ATM Needs Scope Feasibility Integration Pre-operation Operation CATS Identify ATM performance needs & constraints Scope operational concepts and create validation strategy Iteratively develop and evaluate concept Integrate concept in wider context And confirm performance Industrialisation and procedure approval Implementation E-OCVM Concept Lifecycle Model The CATS operational assessment is focused on the En-route part and covers the V1 level (Scope) and V2 level (Feasibility) of the Level of Maturity. Page: 2
3 Goal Second operational assessment to evaluate the operational acceptability of the CoO and associated TWs concepts from the controllers' and pilots point of view. Operational acceptability will be evaluated in the context of the transfer of responsibility area between two ANSPs, and the relationship between ATCOs and Pilots. Evaluation environment is restricted to 4 2 en-route controller working positions (CWP: EXE + PLN) which manage the traffic and handover the aircraft 4 and two cockpit positions The objectives of the HIL2 experiment is twofold: Analyse the collaboration process between controllers and aircrew regarding the TW management. Analyse the impact of the TW management on the aircrew's activity in the cockpit. Page: 3
4 HIL2 Hypothesis CoO implementation allows safe operations. CoO is still manageable even with increase of traffic as foreseen in CoO implementation affects positively the flight within the sector (flight duration...). Implementation of TWs ensures the respect of schedule. TWs integrate flexibility to cope with uncertainty. The working methods offered to ATCOs and pilots, as a result of the CoO implementation, are feasible and acceptable (task sharing, role and responsibility, as well as the offered support tools). Implementation of CoO does not impose significant additional workload to ATCOs or pilots. Page: 4
5 Methodology Evaluation principles: SESAR KPAs (Key Performance Area): system performance 4 4 KPAs are applicable for CATS Safety Capacity Efficiency Predictability Objectives relating to human performance Page: 5
6 Operational issues evaluation Objectives relating to system performance Objectives relating to human performance SAFETY CAPACITY EFFICIENCY Feasibility and acceptability of the aircrew & ATCos' working methods due to the CoO execution Impact of CoO execution on aircrew & ATCOs' performance Impact of CoO on aircrew & ATCOs' activity PREDICTABILITY Indicators Indicators SAF.LOCAL.ER. PI (1, 2, 3, 5, 6 & 8) CAP.LOCAL.ER. PI (2, 8, 10, 11, 12 & 13) Workload: ISA, NASA-TLX, Interviews, Observations, Performance outcomes, Questionnaire Situation Awareness: SASHA_Q, Interviews, EFF.LOCAL.ER. PI (1, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11) Observations, Performance outcomes, questionnaire Error production and management: Observations, PRED.LOCAL.ER. PI (1 & 2) Questionnaire, Interviews, Performance outcomes Operator's activity: Cognitive processes, Decision making, Risk management, Constraints, etc. Collaborative and R/T activity: Communications (number, time, content, speaker and receiver, etc.) Number of TWs fulfilled Page: 6
7 Experimental environment Traffic: Real traffic Traffic load has been adapted to the airspace Current level of traffic (2008) 2020 traffic load (EUROCONTROL STATFOR) Simulation facilities SkySoft platform (rapid prototyping adapted from SkyGuide simulator) 2 sectors (MI1 & KL1) EXE and PLN on each CWP 2 cockpits (Microsoft Flight Simulator) No pseudo-pilot: Automatic order execution by aircraft Automatic hand over/ assume by feed sectors Page: 7
8 Experimental environment Measured Sectors ACC Sector Min FL Max FL KL1 FL275 FL345 LSAG LIRR LSAGKL1 LIRRMI1 FL275 FL275 FL345 FL345 MI1 FL275 FL345 Crew1 Pilot KL ATCos Crew2 Pilot MI Exe Pln Exe Pln Page: 8
9 Conduct of the experiment Duration: 10 days Dates: 19th. to the 23th. October th. to the 30th. October Location: Skysoft premises Geneva Four controllers experienced in En-route ATC Two experimented pilots One on site pre-training session at Roma ACC and in Airfrance Page: 9
10 Conduct of the experiment Timetable: Day 19 th. October Morning Simulation devices presentation Afternoon Familiarization 20 th. October 21 th. October 22 th. October 23 th. October Familiarization Operational training (session Operational training (session 2) 1) Operational training (session Experimental runs #1, 2 & 3 3) Experimental runs #4, 5 & 6 26 th. October Familiarization and Training Experimental runs #7 & 8 27 th. October 28 th. October 29 th. October 30 th. October Experimental runs #9, 10 & 11 Experimental runs #12, 13 & 14 Experimental runs #15 & 16 Final Debriefing Spare day Page: 10
11 Conduct of the experiment Daily Programme Daily Programme SkySoft arrival Set-up in Operations Room Exercise 1 + Debriefing & Questionnaires Break Exercise 2 + Debriefing & Questionnaires Lunch Exercise 3 + Debriefing & Questionnaires 1630 Leave Page: 11
12 Experimental plan (1) Independent variables: With and without TWs 2 levels of traffic (2008/expected in 2020) Disruptions (nominal & non nominal scenario) 4 similar traffic scenarios Independent variables TWs Traffic load disruptions ATCO X X X Pilot X X Geographic Sector Load 30 Geo Sect Load Geo Sect Load (Avg) Nb of Aircraft :00 16:10 16:20 16:30 16:40 16:50 17:00 17:10 17:20 17:30 Simulation Time Page: 12
13 Experimental Plan (2) Dependent variables: Observations 4 ATCOs performance (Overt The Shoulder OTS rating scales, FAA) 4 Spontaneous verbalisations Performance measurements 4 STCA, Separation Performance Indicators (Intervention type to resolve predicted conflict, Time of intervention before potential LoS, Distance before potential LoS, Localisation of controllers interventions) 4 ATCO orders 4 Flight duration 4 Fulfilled TW Self assessment 4 Workload : ISA & NASA-TLX 4 Situation awareness : SASHA_Q 4 Safety feeling : questionnaire on risks & hazards Post run interviews & Post experimental questionnaires (concept, performance, cooperation, simulation) Page: 13
14 Experimental plan (3) 16 runs and 32 measures: 2 traffic loads per run 8 runs with TW for 2008 & 2020 traffic loads for ATCO 8 runs without TW for 2008 & 2020 traffic loads for ATCO The 4 experimental conditions were compared for each ATCOs team (EXE-PLN for MI1 & EXE-PLN for KL1 ) 16 x 4 measured flight segments for pilots Page: 14
15 ATCOs Workload (ISA) 5.0 ISAWorkLoad KL1_EXE 5.0 ISAWorkLoad MI1_EXE /2008-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:0) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:1.05) 2008/ Impacted -- p = 18 (z:-2.10) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p = 47 (z:-1.68) ISAWorkLoad KL1_PLN 2008/2008-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:0.26) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p = 65 (z:-1.52) 2008/ Impacted -- p = 33 (z:-1.84) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p = 02 (z:-2.84) ISAWorkLoad MI1_PLN /2008-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:0.53) 2008/2008-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:-0.79) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:-0.74) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-5) 2008/ Impacted -- p = 05 (z:-2.57) 2008/ Impacted -- p = 33 (z:-1.84) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p = 21 (z:-2.05) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p = 21 (z:-2.05) Not significant between with TW and without TW Significant between 2008 and 2020 traffic load Page: 15
16 ATCOs Workload self assessment (NASA TLX) 9 8 NASA TLX WorkLoad KL1_EXE 9 8 NASA TLX WorkLoad MI1_EXE /2008-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:-0.95) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.32) 2008/ Impacted -- p < 02 (z:-3.36) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p < 02 (z:-2.94) /2008-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:0.32) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:0.32) 2008/ Impacted -- p < 02 (z:-2.94) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p < 02 (z:-3.36) 9 8 NASA TLX WorkLoad KL1_PLN 9 8 NASA TLX WorkLoad MI1_PLN /2008-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.63) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:0.95) 2008/ Impacted -- p < 02 (z:-2.94) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p = 23 (z:-2.00) 2008/2008-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.63) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:-1.21) 2008/ Impacted -- p = 06 (z:-2.52) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p < 02 (z:-2.99) Not significant between with TW and without TW Significant between 2008 and 2020 traffic load Page: 16
17 Pilots Workload self assessment (NASA TLX) NASA TLX Pilots Significant impact of TW implementation Pilot evaluated this impact as fully acceptable with the workload induced by the other cockpit tasks during the cruise phase. 5 0 Without TW With TW Wilcoxon test: Variable impact results if p<0,05 With-TW / Without- TW Impact P=0, %-75% Min-Max However, experiments should be done to validate the workload induced by the TWs in emergency situations or in high workload conditions. Page: 17
18 ATCOs Situation Awareness (SASHA- Q) SASHA (Situational Awareness for SHAPE) KL1_EXE SASHA (Situational Awareness for SHAPE) MI1_EXE /2008-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:0) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.11) 2008/ Impacted -- p < 02 (z:3.15) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p < 02 (z:3.05) 2008/2008-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-5) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-5) 2008/ Impacted -- p = 04 (z:2.68) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p = 07 (z:2.47) SASHA (Situational Awareness for SHAPE) KL1_PLN SASHA (Situational Awareness for SHAPE) MI1_PLN /2008-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:-1.16) 2008/2008-TW -- Impacted -- p = 26 (z:1.94) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:-0.89) 2020/2020-TW -- Impacted -- p = 06 (z:2.52) 2008/ Impacted -- p < 02 (z:3.26) 2008/ Impacted -- p = 18 (z:2.10) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p = 02 (z:2.84) 2008TW/2020TW -- No Impact -- p = 65 (z:1.52) Not significant between with TW and without TW, except MI PLN. Significant between 2008 and 2020 traffic load Page: 18
19 Pilots Situation Awareness (SASHA- QP) 6,2 SASHA Pilots 6,0 5,8 5,6 5,4 5,2 5,0 4,8 4,6 4,4 4,2 Without TW With TW 25%-75% Min-Max Wilcoxon test: Variable impact results if p<0,05 With-TW / Without- TW No impact P=0,2425 Not significant between with TW and without TW Page: 19
20 OTS Performance OTS overall Performance 2020 (Over The sholders observations) KL1 OTS overall Performance 2020 (Over The sholders observations) MI TW TW 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.37) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:0) Not significant between with TW and without TW Page: 20
21 Acceptability and Usability Concept has been described by pilots and ATCOs as: Feasible & Acceptable TW was manageable, for 2008 as well as 2020, even if TW management is an additional task Traffic volume constrained ATCOs more than the TW Training proposed provided sufficient knowledge on the concept, platform, HMI and tools Pilots and ATCOs find the concept easy to learn and to use Potential improvements: For ATCOs, some aspects regarding the TWs positions within the sector have to be changed in TWs calculation For Pilots, there is a need to more anticipate the following TWs on display. Page: 21
22 ATCOs Orders ATCO GLOBAL Orders/hours KL1_EXE ATCO GLOBAL Orders/hours MI1_EXE /2008-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:1.00) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:0.84) 2008/ Impacted -- p = 08 (z:-2.42) 2008TW/2020TW -- Impacted -- p = 37 (z:-1.79) 2008/2008-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:1.16) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:0.95) 2008/ No Impact -- p = (z:-1.05) 2008TW/2020TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:-0.84) Not significant between with TW and without TW Significant between 2008 and 2020 traffic load for KL Detailed analysis shows: no impact of TW implementation on FL and speed orders impact on Go To orders, as expected, significant in 2008, not in Page: 22
23 RT Communication 2,2 Radio Communication 2,0 1,8 1,6 1,4 Controller communication duration with piloted aircraft shows no significant difference between with TW and without TW whatever the traffic load conditions 1,2 1,0 0, TW 2020TW 25%-75% Min-Max 2020 traffic condition generates longer communication duration, even if it is not significant. Wilcoxon test: Variable impact results if p<0, /2008-TW TW TW/2020TW No impact No impact No impact No impact P=0,0678 P=0,2733 P=0,1441 P=0,1441 Page: 23
24 Working Methods Pilots and ATCOs affirmed that TWs implementation induces no particular changes in their working methods TW management was consider as a task mainly for PLN, for traffic preparation. TW management was consider as a PF task 4 But a need to have party line and maybe TWs on FMS Safety remains the first priority Conflict resolution first then TW achievement Collaboration Aircraft s intentions more shared between operators not impacted between ATCOs 4 PLN able to help the EXE through collaborative tool pilots have the feeling TW implementation could increase slightly the communication between the aircrew. Page: 24
25 Safety: Aircraft Separation 2008 No loss of separation Majority of the traffic is maintained of more than 10Nm and 1000ft Page: 25
26 Safety: Aircraft Separation 2020 No loss of separation A high safety level is maintained whatever the traffic load conditions and/or the TWs conditions The TWs do not impact the controllers anticipation to manage safety Pilots and ATCOs reported in questionnaires that their safety feeling was not impaired by the TWs use Page: 26
27 Efficiency: Flight duration FlightDuration for Pseudo-piloted A/C KL1 FlightDuration for Pseudo-piloted A/C MI /2008-TW 2020/2020-TW 2008/ TW/2020TW -- Impacted No Impact No Impact No Impact -- p = 14 (z:2.21) p = (z:0.84) p > (z:-0.53) p = (z:-0.95) 2008/2008-TW 2020/2020-TW 2008/ TW/2020TW -- Impacted No Impact No Impact Impacted -- p = 05 (z:2.63) p > (z:0.63) p = 71 (z:1.47) p = 47 (z:1.68) Significant between with TW and without TW in both sectors in 2008 conditions Significant between with TW and without TW in both sectors in 2020 condition for Milano only The flight durations "with TW" are closer to the reference than "without TW" whatever the traffic load conditions. Page: 27
28 Efficiency: TWs OUT Target Windows Out (Percentage) KL1 Target Windows Out (Percentage) MI TW 2020-TW 2008-TW 2020-TW 2008TW/2020TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.42) 2008TW/2020TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:0.42) 10 Target Windows Out (Percentage) KL1 10 Target Windows Out (Percentage) MI TW 2020EV-TW 2020-TW 2020EV-TW 2020-TW/2020EV-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.42) 2020-TW/2020EV-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:-0.84) No significant difference (p<0,05) between the two traffic load conditions whatever the controlled sector or event- very low level of TWs OUT Page: 28
29 Efficiency: Fuel Burned Fuel burned FS1_PIL Fuel burned FS2_PIL /2008-TW -- No Impact -- p = (z:0.68) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.11) 2008/ No Impact -- p > (z:-5) 2008-TW/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.42) 2008/2008-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.53) 2020/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:-0.58) 2008/ No Impact -- p > (z:-0.21) 2008-TW/2020-TW -- No Impact -- p > (z:0.11) No significant difference (p<0,05) for the fuel burned by the aircraft whatever the traffic load conditions and the TWs implementation Page: 29
30 Conclusions CoO concept is manageable and acceptable with the 2008 & 2020 traffic loads, without any impact on Safety. CoO improve the predictability in times and routing ATCOs and pilots agreed CoO could optimise ATM system. However, the forecasted increase of traffic remains a limitation. New tools are required to support the traffic load. The number of TWs not fulfilled predicts positive prospect for HIL3. Page: 30
31 Thank you for your attention! Page: 31
TRAINING OF AIR TRAFFIC CONTROLLERS. Rating Training ACS and ADV/ADI (TWR/RAD/AIR/GMC/GMS) and the Assessment Center for Candidates
CROATIA CONTROL LTD. AMENDMENT No. 1 TO REQUEST FOR TENDERS IN THE PROCEDURE FOR AWARDING PUBLIC SERVICES CONTRACTS AS SET OUT IN ANNEX II. B OF THE PUBLIC PROCUREMENT ACT TRAINING OF AIR TRAFFIC CONTROLLERS
More informationMEASURING THE IMPACT OF RADAR SUPPORT OPTIONS ON AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL SITUATIONAL AWARENESS
MEASURING THE IMPACT OF RADAR SUPPORT OPTIONS ON AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL SITUATIONAL AWARENESS Dr John Steele Mr Roger L. Roy Ms Eugenia Kalantzis Op Research Analysts/DGLCD Maj James S. Denford Director Land
More informationCWE Flow-based Market Coupling Project. at EMART Energy 2012
CWE Flow-based Market Coupling Project at EMART Energy 2012 1 Agenda Flow Based Market Coupling: reminder of essentials From ATC Market Coupling to Flow Based Market Coupling: key milestones and main impacts
More informationSESAR 2020 priorities for improved civil-military ATM interoperability
SESAR 2020 priorities for improved civil-military ATM interoperability EUROCONTROL EDA work programme 2017-2018 Edgar REUBER / Juan Ignacio del Valle Senior Military Expert / Project Officer Air Programmes
More informationCWE FB MC project. PLEF SG1, March 30 th 2012, Brussels
CWE FB MC project PLEF SG1, March 30 th 2012, Brussels 1 Content 1. CWE ATC MC Operational report 2. Detailed updated planning 3. Status on FRM settlement 4. FB model update since last PLEF Intuitiveness
More informationModelling and Simulating Airport Surface Operations with Gate Conflicts
Modelling and Simulating Airport Surface Operations with Gate Conflicts Shannon Zelinski Robert Windhorst NASA Ames Research Center Royal Aeronautical Society and AIAA Flight Simulations Conference, London
More informationCONSULTATION ONLY - NOT FOR FURTHER DISSEMINATION
Home Police Pursuits Police Pursuit When a situation falls within the definition of Pursuit, officers will need to decide whether a pursuit is justified, proportionate and conforms to the principle of
More informationLET S DELIVER TOGETHER 2016 CEF TRANSPORT CALLS FOR PROPOSALS SNEAK PREVIEW
LET S DELIVER TOGETHER 2016 CEF TRANSPORT CALLS FOR PROPOSALS SNEAK PREVIEW 29 September 2016 CONTENT 2016 CEF Transport Calls for Proposals 3 Preparing proposals under SESAR Deployment Manager coordination
More information(Non-legislative acts) REGULATIONS
4.5.2013 Official Journal of the European Union L 123/1 II (Non-legislative acts) REGULATIONS COMMISSION IMPLEMENTING REGULATION (EU) No 409/2013 of 3 May 2013 on the definition of common projects, the
More informationDOC Volume 2 of 2
DOC 97-70-13 Volume 2 of 2 PD/2 FINAL REPORT Annex B Controller Subjects and Training Rue de la Fusée 96 B - 1130 Bruxelles Prepared by: A Link Date: June 98 Version: Version 1.0 Annex B: Controller Subjects
More informationWheelTug Pushback Time Savings Analysis
WheelTug Pushback Time Savings Analysis 31 March 2016 WheelTug has collected data on in-service aircraft to calculate the time which can be saved each cycle. A non-wheeltug pushback operation has the following
More informationUNCLASSIFIED R-1 ITEM NOMENCLATURE PE F: KC-10S. FY 2011 Total Estimate. FY 2011 OCO Estimate
Exhibit R-2, RDT&E Budget Item Justification: PB 2011 Air Force DATE: February 2010 COST ($ in Millions) FY 2009 Actual FY 2010 Air Force Page 1 of 12 FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015 To Program Element
More informationCoflight efdp Angelo Corsaro, Ph.D. Software Technologies Scientist
Coflight efdp Angelo Corsaro, Ph.D. Software Technologies Scientist Strategic and Technological Planning Directorate SELEX-SI [angelo.corsaro@selex-si.com] Agenda Group Overview Coflight Programme DDS
More informationEPSRC-KETEP Call for Collaborative Research between the UK and Korea in Smart Grids
EPSRC-KETEP Call for Collaborative between the UK and Korea in Smart Grids Summary Call type: Collaborative research Closing date: 16.00 on 16 December 2015 Related themes: Energy The Engineering and Physical
More informationArmy Ground-Based Sense and Avoid for Unmanned Aircraft
Army Ground-Based Sense and Avoid for Unmanned Aircraft Dr. Rodney E. Cole 27 October, 2015 This work is sponsored by the Army under Air Force Contract #FA8721-05-C-0002. Opinions, interpretations, recommendations
More informationContext paper CWE Intraday
Continuous Improvement Process of Intraday Capacity Calculation after FBMC go live Version 1.0 Date 05-11-2015 Status Draft Final Version 1.0 Date 05-11-2015 Page 1 of 12 Contents 1 General information
More informationBuilding a Smarter Healthcare System The IE s Role. Kristin H. Goin Service Consultant Children s Healthcare of Atlanta
Building a Smarter Healthcare System The IE s Role Kristin H. Goin Service Consultant Children s Healthcare of Atlanta 2 1 Background 3 Industrial Engineering The objective of Industrial Engineering is
More informationSummary Report for Individual Task Perform a Tactical Aerial Reconnaissance and Surveillance Mission Status: Approved
Summary Report for Individual Task 301-350-2205 Perform a Tactical Aerial Reconnaissance and Surveillance Mission Status: Approved Report Date: 19 Aug 2014 Distribution Restriction: Approved for public
More informationREPORT ON THE IMPACT OF THE SUNZIA SOUTHWEST TRANSMISSION PROJECT ON CURRENT AND FUTURE CAPABILITIES OF WHITE SANDS MISSILE RANGE, NEW MEXICO
REPORT ON THE IMPACT OF THE SUNZIA SOUTHWEST TRANSMISSION PROJECT ON CURRENT AND FUTURE CAPABILITIES OF WHITE SANDS MISSILE RANGE, NEW MEXICO Pursuant to pages 327-330 of the Joint Explanatory Statement
More informationThe SPE Foundation through member donations and a contribution from Offshore Europe
Primary funding is provided by The SPE Foundation through member donations and a contribution from Offshore Europe The Society is grateful to those companies that allow their professionals to serve as
More informationSR&ED Program: (Scientific Research and Experimental Development) Should You Apply? Douglas Clay, Research & Technology Advisor
SR&ED Program: (Scientific Research and Experimental Development) Should You Apply? Douglas Clay, Research & Technology Advisor What is the SR&ED Program? a tax incentive program to encourage Canadian
More informationCWE Flow-based Market Coupling Project
CWE Flow-based Market Coupling Project 1 Agenda ATC CWE MC Operations CWE FB MC Project FB implementation status FB theoretical basics Market communication during the external parallel run 2 ATC CWE MC
More informationNATIONAL LANGUAGE PROFICIENCY IMPLEMENTATION PLAN OF THE REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA
NATIONAL LANGUAGE PROFICIENCY IMPLEMENTATION PLAN OF THE REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA The present Language Proficiency Implementation Plan has been developed in accordance with the recommendations set out in State
More informationFlow-Based Market Coupling First lessons
Flow-Based Market Coupling First lessons TSOs in Central Western Europe have set a new benchmark Market integration 2010 > 2014 Extension of the geographic area for market DA allocation 3 A long road to
More informationList all the SESAR members involved in the task, either as main contributor or as partner contributor: Company A; Company B; etc.
Final Project Report Document information Project Title Project Number 07.06.03 Project Manager Deliverable Name Deliverable ID DCB/ASM Scenarios Management EUROCONTROL Final Project Report D01 Edition
More information3. OBJECTIVES AND PRIORITIES:
3. OBJECTIVES AND PRIORITIES: 3.1. Priorities for the objective of optimising the integration and interconnection of transport modes and enhancing the interoperability of transport services, while ensuring
More informationRequest for Proposal Close Air Support Aircraft (A-10 Replacement)
Request for Proposal Close Air Support Aircraft (A-10 Replacement) Background The A-10 Close Air Support (CAS) aircraft is now over 45 years old. While still a very effective CAS aircraft, the A-10 airframes
More informationUtilisation Management
Utilisation Management The Utilisation Management team has developed a reputation over a number of years as an authentic and clinically credible support team assisting providers and commissioners in generating
More information2010 Citation Mustang N678MB S/N
2010 Citation Mustang N678MB S/N510-348 High Sierra Edition Specifications and Summary 2010 CITATION MUSTANG N678MB S/N510-0348 OFFERED AT: $2,150,000 AIRCRAFT HIGHLIGHTS: High Sierra Edition One Owner
More informationAIR FORCE MISSION SUPPORT SYSTEM (AFMSS)
AIR FORCE MISSION SUPPORT SYSTEM (AFMSS) MPS-III PFPS Air Force ACAT IAC Program Prime Contractor Total Number of Systems: 2,900 AFMSS/UNIX-based Systems: Total Program Cost (TY$): $652M+ Sanders (Lockheed
More informationForum Virium Helsinki
Forum Virium Helsinki 1 Forum Virium Helsinki 2 Forum Virium Helsinki 3 Cognitive workload Collect feedback Context of use Cost benefit analysis Evaluate existing system Evaluate prototype Evaluate working
More informationThis interim change updates the paragraph titles of Section 7.
BY ORDER OF THE COMMANDER AIR FORCE MATERIEL COMMAND AIR FORCE MATERIEL COMMAND INSTRUCTION 11-201 1 AUGUST 2007 Incorporating Change, 16 SEPTEMBER 2010 Certified Current On 4 September 2014 Flying Operations
More informationAnnouncement of Opportunity soliciting for proposals using the Human Spaceflight Analogue Parabolic Flight ISLSWG-AO-2016-PFC
Announcement of Opportunity soliciting for proposals using the Human Spaceflight Analogue Parabolic Flight ISLSWG-AO-2016-PFC Images : Novespace/CNES/DLR/ESA Proposals due: December 2nd, 2016 Summary for
More informationSYSTEM DESCRIPTION & CONTRIBUTION TO JOINT VISION
F-22 RAPTOR (ATF) Air Force ACAT ID Program Prime Contractor Total Number of Systems: 339 Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Pratt &Whitney Total Program Cost (TY$): $62.5B Average Flyaway Cost (TY$): $97.9M Full-rate
More informationIDEA II PROJECT A WALK-THROUGH
The Team Detlef Pulsack Team Leader Elena Kostadinova, Key Expert Dr. Ashraf Hamed, Key Expert Financial Expert Legal Expert Transport Expert IDEA II PROJECT A WALK-THROUGH International Consortium ITALY
More information49 USC NB: This unofficial compilation of the U.S. Code is current as of Jan. 4, 2012 (see
TITLE 49 - TRANSPORTATION SUBTITLE VII - AVIATION PROGRAMS PART A - AIR COMMERCE AND SAFETY subpart iii - safety CHAPTER 445 - FACILITIES, PERSONNEL, AND RESEARCH 44505. Systems, procedures, facilities,
More informationIncident Planning Guide Tornado Page 1
Incident Planning Guide: Tornado Definition This Incident Planning Guide is intended to address issues associated with a tornado. Tornadoes involve cyclonic high winds with the potential to generate damaging
More informationCOMPLIANCE WITH THIS PUBLICATION IS MANDATORY
BY ORDER OF THE SECRETARY OF THE AIR FORCE AIR FORCE INSTRUCTION 63-112 9 AUGUST 2006 Incorporating Change 1, 26 July 2011 Acquisition COCKPIT WORKING GROUPS COMPLIANCE WITH THIS PUBLICATION IS MANDATORY
More informationQuality and Safety Considerations You Haven t Thought About
Quality and Safety Considerations You Haven t Thought About Learning Objectives Understand safety from a systems view. Understand & give examples of safety barriers. Be able to take actions to improve
More informationExpected Roadway Project Crash Reductions for SMART SCALE Safety Factor Evaluation. September 2016
Expected Roadway Project Crash Reductions for SMART SCALE Safety Factor Evaluation September 2016 SMART SCALE Safety Factors Evaluation 1. Using Crash Modification Factors for SMART SCALE Safety Evaluation
More informationUNCLASSIFIED. FY 2017 Base FY 2017 OCO
Exhibit R-2, RDT&E Budget Item Justification: PB 2017 Office of the Secretary Of Defense Date: February 2016 0400: Research, Development, Test & Evaluation, Defense-Wide / BA 3: Advanced Technology Development
More informationCOMPLIANCE WITH THIS PUBLICATION IS MANDATORY
BY ORDER OF THE SECRETARY OF THE AIR FORCE AIR FORCE POLICY DIRECTIVE 90-16 31 AUGUST 2011 Special Management STUDIES AND ANALYSES, ASSESSMENTS AND LESSONS LEARNED COMPLIANCE WITH THIS PUBLICATION IS MANDATORY
More informationOpen Proposers Day November, 2014
1 Call Fiche ERS einfügen + Fotos Georg Aufreiter Full Proposers Day April 4, 2017 Elisabeth Nagl Donia Lasinger 2 Agenda Environmental Systems Research: Urban Environments Pilot Call Full Proposal Phase
More informationJean Monnet activities within the Erasmus+ Programme
Jean Monnet activities within the Erasmus+ Programme Context Management of projects Snejina Nikolova Unit A2, EACEA Europe week video-conference Voronezh, 18 May 2017 Erasmus + Programme - How is it managed
More informationMAGTF Summer Training Program
UNITED STATES NAVAL ACADEMY MAGTF Summer Training Program Cruise Guide Name: This page intentionally left blank 1 MIDSHIPMAN MAGTF CRUISE GUIDE This booklet provides general guidelines for Midshipman Marine
More informationTomahawk Deconfliction: An Exercise in System Engineering
TOMAHAWK DECONFLICTION Tomahawk Deconfliction: An Exercise in System Engineering Ann F. Pollack, Robert C. Ferguson, and Andreas K. Chrysostomou Improvements to the navigational and timing accuracy of
More information1 - PROJECT DETAILS 1.1 PROMOTER S INFORMATION. Title and full name of main contact: Position: Investment and Economic Initiatives Manager
Strategic Outline Business Case Please complete this to enable an initial assessment of your project. Once completed, please return by email to callsubmissions@sheffieldcityregion.org.uk by 5pm on 8 th
More informationHEALTH WORKFORCE SUPPLY AND REQUIREMENTS PROJECTION MODELS. World Health Organization Div. of Health Systems 1211 Geneva 27, Switzerland
HEALTH WORKFORCE SUPPLY AND REQUIREMENTS PROJECTION MODELS World Health Organization Div. of Health Systems 1211 Geneva 27, Switzerland The World Health Organization has long given priority to the careful
More informationPoint Mugu Sea Range Scheduling
Point Mugu Sea Range Scheduling Presented by Mr. John Gurka Range Department Naval Air Warfare Center Weapons Division Point Mugu, CA 1 Sea Range Scheduling Goal The goal of Point Mugu Sea Range scheduling
More informationReference. No. 02/16 Issue: 1 Page: 1 of 13 Issue Date: 16/05/16 Focal: Aircrew
Page: 1 of 13 The purpose of this Memorandum is to outline the requirements as well as IAA instructions and procedures for the initial approval and ongoing maintenance of Cabin Crew Training Organisations
More informationPhysical Protection of Nuclear Installations After 11 September 2001
Physical Protection of Nuclear Installations After 11 September 2001 Joachim B. Fechner Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety, Bonn, Germany I. Introduction The terrorist
More informationUSING BIG DATA AND DATA FUSION TO FACILITATE COOPERATIVE TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT
USING BIG DATA AND DATA FUSION TO FACILITATE COOPERATIVE TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT 1 PAS DIT AAN OF VERWIJDER HET 2 From current to a Cooperative Mobility future Current situation Many legacy roadside systems
More informationLV Prasad Eye Institute Final Presentation
LV Prasad Eye Institute Final Presentation Ali Kamil, Dmitriy Lyan, Nicole Yap, MIT Student MIT Sloan School of Management Global Health Lab May 8, 2013 1 Courtesy of Ali S. Kamil, Dmitriy E. Lyan, Nicole
More informationGuidelines for Submission
Guidelines for Submission DEADLINES Papers, Workshops, Symposia: 25 February 2015 Pecha Kucha, Poster and Bursary Applications: 15 April 2015 Please read this document carefully before submitting your
More informationCWE Enhanced FB. Report presentation. March 22 nd, 2011
CWE Enhanced FB Report presentation March 22 nd, 2011 Background The Memorandum of Understanding of the Pentalateral Energy Forum on market coupling and security of supply in Central Western Europe (CWE),
More informationDEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE. SUBJECT: Air Force Guidance Memorandum to AFI , Cockpit/Crew Resource Management Program.
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE HEADQUARTERS UNITED STATES AIR FORCE WASHINGTON, DC MEMORANDUM FOR DISTRIBUTION C FROM: HQ USAF/A3 1630 Air Force Pentagon Washington, DC 20330-1630 AFI11-290_AFGM2017-01 27
More informationUNCLASSIFIED. R-1 ITEM NOMENCLATURE PE D8Z: Central Test and Evaluation Investment Program (CTEIP) FY 2011 Total Estimate. FY 2011 OCO Estimate
COST ($ in Millions) FY 2009 Actual FY 2010 FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015 Cost To Complete Program Element 143.612 160.959 162.286 0.000 162.286 165.007 158.842 156.055 157.994 Continuing Continuing
More informationSESAR Joint Undertaking (SJU) Project Execution Guidelines for SESAR 2020 Exploratory Research 2016
SESAR Joint Undertaking (SJU) Project Execution Guidelines for SESAR 2020 Exploratory Research 2016 Version 1.00.00 7 December 2016 EDITION [01.00.00] Authoring & Approval Authors of the document Name
More informationL'ERC dans Horizon 2020
The European Research Council L'ERC dans Horizon 2020 Monique Smaihi Call Coordinator ERC Executive Agency Scientific Department Paris, 27 Novembre 2013 1 Outline Evaluation Process Preparing an application
More informationCareers. Aviation Training Academy ATS Instructors Engineering Instructors Simulator Support Officers Course Administrators Instructional Designers
22 Careers Careers at ATNS The SHR department is responsible for the implementation of the recruitment processes within ATNS and also to ensure that the Policies and Procedures are adhered to in this regard.
More informationAircrew Training Manual, Utility Helicopter, MI-17 Series
, C1 Change 1 Headquarters Department of the Army Washington, DC, 31 August 2010 Aircrew Training Manual, Utility Helicopter, MI-17 Series 1. Change TC 3-04.35, March 2010, as follows: Remove old pages:
More informationDevelopment of a draft five-year global strategic plan to improve public health preparedness and response
Information document 1 August 2017 Development of a draft five-year global strategic plan to improve public health preparedness and response Consultation with Member States SUMMARY 1. This document has
More information2 Description of the Proposed Action and Alternatives
2 Description of the Proposed Action and Alternatives 2.1 Proposed Action The DON proposes to transition the Expeditionary VAQ squadrons at NAS Whidbey Island from the EA-6B Prowler to the EA-18G Growler
More informationOPERATIONS PLAN Texas Wing Civil Air Patrol. Mountain Training Search and Rescue Exercise Alpine, Texas April 2013
Page 1 of 6 OPERATIONS PLAN Texas Wing Civil Air Patrol I. SITUATION: Mountain Training Search and Rescue Exercise Alpine, Texas 26-28 April 2013 A. On the weekend of 26-28 April, Texas Wing will conduct
More informationDISASTER MANAGEMENT PLAN
DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLAN Purpose This Allen University Disaster Management Plan (AUDMP) will be the basis to establish policies and procedures, which will assure maximum and efficient utilization of all
More informationPEER Request for Proposal: Solicitation TSRP-PEER 17-01
PEER Request for Proposal: Solicitation TSRP-PEER 17-01 Introduction The Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center (PEER) is a multi-campus research center that has continuing funding from the State
More informationTraining and Evaluation Outline Report
Training and Evaluation Outline Report Task Number: 01-6-0444 Task Title: Employ Automated Mission Planning Equipment/TAIS Supporting Reference(s): Step Number Reference ID Reference Name Required Primary
More informationTraining and Evaluation Outline Report
Training and Evaluation Outline Report Status: Approved 20 Mar 2015 Effective Date: 15 Sep 2016 Task Number: 71-8-5715 Task Title: Control Tactical Airspace (Brigade - Corps) Distribution Restriction:
More informationSSF Call for Proposals: Framework Grants for Research on. Big Data and Computational Science
2016-01-28 SSF Call for Proposals: Framework Grants for Research on Big Data and Computational Science The Swedish Foundation for Strategic Research announces SEK 200 million in a national call for proposals
More informationFY19 Warfighting Lab Incentive Fund Project Proposal Background and Instructions
FY19 Warfighting Lab Incentive Fund Project Proposal Background and Instructions Background: The Deputy Secretary of Defense (DSD) Warfighting Lab Incentive Fund (WLIF) Memo, signed 6 May 2016, established
More informationARMY RDT&E BUDGET ITEM JUSTIFICATION (R2 Exhibit)
Exhibit R-2 0602712A Countermine Systems ARMY RDT&E BUDGET ITEM JUSTIFICATION (R2 Exhibit) FY 2005 FY 2006 FY 2007 FY 2008 FY 2009 FY 2010 FY 2011 Total Program Element (PE) Cost 26267 29171 22088 21965
More informationDecreasing Environmental Services Response Times
Decreasing Environmental Services Response Times Murray J. Côté, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Department of Health Policy & Management, Texas A&M Health Science Center; Zach Robison, M.B.A., Administrative
More informationEGNOS Exploitation Grant Plan 2017
EGNOS Exploitation Grant Plan 2017 UPDATED 24 January 2018 V2.0 UNCLASSIFIED Contents CONTENTS... 2 EGNOS EXPLOITATION 2017 GRANT PLAN... 3 A.1 DUAL FREQUENCY MULTI-CONSTELLATION RECEIVERS... 4 A.2 ACCELERATION
More informationGuidance on Training Requirements for Operational Users of A-SMGCS Levels 1 & 2
EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR THE SAFETY OF AIR NAVIGATION EUROCONTROL Guidance on Training Requirements for Operational Users of A-SMGCS Levels 1 & 2 Edition Number : 1.1 Edition Date : 27/11/2006 Status
More informationOgden Air Logistics Center
Ogden Air Logistics Center SIMULATORS SUSTAINMENT MANAGEMENT ADVANCED PLANNING INFORMATION Linda Y. Gay, Deputy Director 508 MASSG/GFMM, Hill AFB UT DSN 777-7823, 801-777-7823 Linda.Gay@hill.af.mil Training
More informationUNCLASSIFIED R-1 ITEM NOMENCLATURE
Exhibit R-2, RDT&E Budget Item Justification: PB 2013 Air Force DATE: February 2012 COST ($ in Millions) FY 2011 FY 2012 Base OCO Total FY 2014 FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 Cost To Complete Total Cost Total
More informationFOREST SERVICE HANDBOOK NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS (WO) WASHINGTON, DC
Page 1 of 18 FOREST SERVICE HANDBOOK NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS (WO) WASHINGTON, DC FSH 5109.17 - FIRE AND AVIATION MANAGEMENT QUALIFICATIONS HANDBOOK Amendment No.: 5109.17-2007-3 Effective Date: August 27,
More informationJEPPESEN JeppView General Info Biak, IDN S ' E ' Mag Var: 3.1 E Elevation: 46' Runway Info Runway ' x 148' asphalt
Airport Information WABB (Frans Kaisiepo) General Info Biak, IN S 01 11.5' E136 06.6' Mag Var: 3.1 E Elevation: Public, IFR, Control Tower, Rotating Beacon, Customs Fuel: Jet Time Zone Info: GMT+9:00 no
More informationPage. II. TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE PROJECT DESCRIPTIONS.. 3 A. Introduction... B. Technical Assistance Areas.. 1. Rate Design Consumer Programs...
TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION............... Page 1 II. TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE PROJECT DESCRIPTIONS.. 3 A. Introduction.... 4 B. Technical Assistance Areas.. 5 1. Rate Design.... 5 2. Consumer Programs...
More informationUNCLASSIFIED R-1 ITEM NOMENCLATURE FY 2013 OCO
Exhibit R-2, RDT&E Budget Item Justification: PB 213 Navy DATE: February 212 COST ($ in Millions) FY 211 FY 212 FY 214 FY 215 FY 216 FY 217 To Complete Program Element 22.63 3.676 32.789-32.789 35.932
More informationAir Traffic Control Career Prep: A Comprehensive Guide To One Of The Best-paying Federal Government Careers, Including Test Preparation For The
Air Traffic Control Career Prep: A Comprehensive Guide To One Of The Best-paying Federal Government Careers, Including Test Preparation For The Initial Air Traffic Control Exams. By Patrick R. Mattson
More informationMission-Based Test & Evaluation Strategy: Creating Linkages between Technology Development and Mission Capability
U.S. Army Research, Development and Engineering Command Mission-Based Test & Evaluation Strategy: Creating Linkages between Technology Development and Mission Capability NDIA Systems Engineering Conference
More informationAMRDEC. Core Technical Competencies (CTC)
AMRDEC Core Technical Competencies (CTC) AMRDEC PAMPHLET 10-01 15 May 2015 The Aviation and Missile Research Development and Engineering Center The U. S. Army Aviation and Missile Research Development
More information1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY FEASIBILITY REPORT In November 2008, Measure R was approved by a significant two-thirds majority, committing a projected $40 billion to traffic relief and transportation upgrades
More informationLEAN Transformation Storyboard 2015 to present
LEAN Transformation Storyboard 2015 to present Rapid Improvement Event Med-Surg January 2015 Access to Supply Rooms Problem: Many staff do not have access to supply areas needed to complete their work,
More informationLocal Energy Challenge Fund
Guidance for applicants to the Local Energy Challenge Fund Managed by Local Energy Scotland as part of the Scottish Government s CARES programme Version 1 15th August 2014 Local Energy Challenge Fund Guidance
More informationdtank Updated: Exploring Moderated Behavior in a Light-weight Synthetic Environment
dtank Updated: Exploring Moderated Behavior in a Light-weight Synthetic Environment Frank Ritter 1, Sue Kase 1, Damodar Bhandarkar 1, Bil Lewis 2, Mark Cohen 3 1 Pennsylvania State University College of
More informationDigital Lives call for proposals
www.snf.ch Wildhainweg 3, P.O. Box 8232, CH-3001 Berne Humanities and Social Sciences Division digitallives@snf.ch Digital Lives call for proposals 1. Subject and purpose of the call for proposals 1.1
More informationEILEEN A. BJORKMAN, PhD CURRICULUM VITAE
EILEEN A. BJORKMAN, PhD CURRICULUM VITAE SUMMARY More than 33 years experience leading diverse personnel in complex, high technology acquisition, research, development, test and analysis organizations
More informationPOSITION PAPER BY ALL CWE NRAs on THE CWE TSOs PROPOSAL for A FB IDCC METHODOLOGY
POSITION PAPER BY ALL CWE NRAs on THE CWE TSOs PROPOSAL for A FB IDCC METHODOLOGY 15 September 2017 1 Context The implementation of DA FB MC in the Central West Europe (CWE) region started on the basis
More informationMethodology for capacity calculation for ID timeframe
Methodology for capacity calculation for ID timeframe NRA approval package Version 1.0 Date 05-11-2015 Status Draft Final Contents 1 Introduction and purpose... 3 2 Definitions... 3 3 General principles
More informationOnline Scheduling of Outpatient Procedure Centers
Online Scheduling of Outpatient Procedure Centers Department of Industrial and Operations Engineering, University of Michigan September 25, 2014 Online Scheduling of Outpatient Procedure Centers 1/32 Outpatient
More informationLogic-Based Benders Decomposition for Multiagent Scheduling with Sequence-Dependent Costs
Logic-Based Benders Decomposition for Multiagent Scheduling with Sequence-Dependent Costs Aliza Heching Compassionate Care Hospice John Hooker Carnegie Mellon University ISAIM 2016 The Problem A class
More informationCOMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, THE COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE AND THE COMMITTEE OF THE REGIONS
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, 19.1.2016 COM(2016) 5 final COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, THE COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE AND THE COMMITTEE OF THE
More informationJAGIC 101 An Army Leader s Guide
by MAJ James P. Kane Jr. JAGIC 101 An Army Leader s Guide The emphasis placed on readying the Army for a decisive-action (DA) combat scenario has been felt throughout the force in recent years. The Chief
More information( ) Page: 1/24. Committee on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures SUBSIDIES
14 July 2017 (17-3798) Page: 1/24 Committee on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures Original: English SUBSIDIES NEW AND FULL NOTIFICATION PURSUANT TO ARTICLE XVI:1 OF THE GATT 1994 AND ARTICLE 25 OF THE
More informationSURGEONS ATTITUDES TO TEAMWORK AND SAFETY
SURGEONS ATTITUDES TO TEAMWORK AND SAFETY Steven Yule 1, Rhona Flin 1, Simon Paterson-Brown 2 & Nikki Maran 3 1 Industrial Psychology Research Centre, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, Scotland, UK Departments
More informationOffice of the Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition, Technology, and Logistics
REPORT ON THE DETERMINATION OF UNACCEPTABLE RISK TO NATIONAL SECURITY FROM A PROPOSED COMMERCIAL WIND TURBINE PROJECT IN THE VICINITY OF NAVAL AIR STATION PATUXENT RIVER AND THE ATLANTIC TEST RANGE Pursuant
More informationOKALOOSA COUNTY EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE Medical Incident Command Policy:
Title: Medical Incident Command Policy: 429.00 Purpose: Policy: This standard operating procedure (SOP) identifies the procedure to be employed when establishing EMS Command. It also designates responsibility
More informationImproving Highway-Rail Grade Crossings Safety in Urban Area of Lagos State, Nigeria
International Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering 2016, 5(2): 32-39 DOI: 10.5923/j.ijtte.20160502.02 Improving Highway-Rail Grade Crossings Safety in Urban Area of Lagos State, Nigeria Olutaiwo
More information