TECHNICAL AND COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE Twelfth Regular Session 21 27 September 2016 Pohnpei, Federated States of Micronesia ANNUAL REPORT ON EASTERN HIGH SEAS POCKET (EHSP) SPECIAL MANAGEMENT AREA REPORTING WCPFC-TCC12-2016-RP06 29 August 2016 Paper prepared by the Secretariat Purpose 1. This paper, as in previous years, provides a summary report on the activities occurring in the EHSP Special Management Area (EHSP-SMA), which is the area of high seas bounded by the Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ) of the Cook Islands to the west, French Polynesia to the east and Kiribati to the north, from 1 January 2015 31 July 2016 based on data held by the Secretariat. The management and reporting arrangements for the EHSP were established through CMM 2010-02 Conservation and Management Measures on the Eastern High Seas Pocket. Report against decisions from WCPFC12 related to EHSP 2. CCMs would recall that WCPFC12 noted that further testing and refinement of the five electronic data standards is required. One of these draft electronic data standards is to be used for the reports required under paragraph 2 of CMM 2010-02. Formal testing of the EHSP data standards was deferred until after the 2 nd meeting of the ERandEMWG (ERandEMWG2) and to draw on the experiences from testing in relation to the two larger data sets which are those related to operational level catch and effort and observer data. 3. The ERandEMWG2, in further discussing these standards, asked CCMs to provide comments on the draft standards by TCC12. 1 CCMs are reminded to provide any comments on the draft electronic standards for CMM 2010-02 paragraph 2 to the Secretariat before TCC12, preferably by 10 September 2016. 2 1 Draft electronic data standards, including the standards to be used for paragraph 2 of CMM 2010-02 can be found in the Attachment 4 of the Summary Report of the ERandEMWG2 at http://www.wcpfc.int/erandemwg2 2 SC12 Summary Report paragraph 131: SC12 noted that CCMs agreed to provide comments on the draft WCPFC E-Reporting standard data fields for logsheet and observer data prior to 10th September 2016, so that the WCPFC Secretariat and Science Services Provider can compile comments for presentation to TCC12. 1
Review of CCMs reporting on implementation of CMM 2010-02 through Annual Report Part 2 4. As at 23 August 2016, Secretariat has received Annual Reports Part 2 from 36 CCMs. Generally, CCMs who did not have any vessels fishing or transiting in the EHSP concluded in their Annual Report Part 2 that the implementation of CMM 2010-02 was not applicable to their flag vessels. As a result, in the draft CMR, CMM 2010-02 was applicable to 9 CCMs. 3 Annex 1 provides a summary of CCMs response in Annual Report Part 2 related to CMM 2010-02 paragraph 2 and 6. Review of available data relevant to reviewing the implementation of the reporting requirements for the EHSP-SMA 5. Paragraph 2 of the measure requires flag vessels to submit entry and exit reports to the Commission in a prescribed format at least 6 hours prior to entry and no later than 6 hours prior to exiting the EHSP. Annex 2 provides a summary of the entry and exit reports received together with the Entry and Exit Alert generated by the Commission VMS, by year. The Secretariat observes that generally, submission of the EHSP entry/exit reports has improved. This may be due to a number of factors including the fact that this obligation is assessed under the Compliance Monitoring Scheme; the work that the Secretariat does in terms of informing CCMs of any reporting gaps early in the year; and/or simply perhaps vessels are becoming more familiar with the reporting requirement, 6. Paragraph 2 of the measure also state that the report shall also contain estimated catch (kgs) onboard. Annex 3 provides a list of vessels by flag and vessel type that submit entry/exit report to the Secretariat in 2015 and Annex 4 provides a summary of the estimated catch as reported in the entry and exit reports and the number of vessels submitting these reports. 7. In accordance with paragraph 6 of the measure, vessels intending to transship (either unloading or receiving) in the EHSP shall indicate this to the Commission, in the reporting format as described in paragraph 2 of this measure. The Secretariat can confirm that no EHSP-SMA entry/exit reports received by the Secretariat for 2015 and January-July 2016 included an indication that a vessel will transship in the EHSP. The Secretariat also confirms that there were no other reported incidences of any transshipment activities occurring in the EHSP in 2015 and January-July 2016. 8. During 2015, the Secretariat confirms receipt of correspondence related to three alleged incidents where a flag CCM was requested by another Member to investigate and clarify reporting related to entry and exit to the EHSP-SMA. One was an alleged infringement detected through High Seas Boarding and Inspection activity and two alleged incidents were detected through CCMs VMS analysis. For the HSBI event, the vessel did not 3 In 2015, 9 CCMs had no vessels on the RFV and consequently, CMM 2010-02 was not applicable to these 9 CCMs in the draft Compliance Monitoring Report covering 2015 activities. Twenty eight (28) CCMs that had vessels on the RFV in 2015 of which 7 CCMs reported in their fish/did not fish report that none of their flag vessels fished beyond their areas of national jurisdiction (see Annex 1 of WCPFC-TCC12-2016-RP06 for a summary of information relating to the fished or did not fish report). The analysis was further refined by looking at the areas fished by these vessels and whether there was any EHSP reports received by the Secretariat or received in the WCPFC VMS to determine if CMM 2010-02 was applicable. 2
submit exit report from the EHSP. In this incident, the flag State response confirmed that the vessel failed to submit the exit report in accordance with the timeframe articulated in the measure and subsequently, the flag CCM suspended the vessel s fishing license for one month. With regards to the two events detected through VMS analysis for nonsubmission of EHSP entry/exit report, the responsible flag CCM responses confirmed that the absence of the report was an oversight on the vessel master s part and the flag CCMs subsequently submitted the relevant report. There was no reported alleged infringement relating to EHSP from January-July 2016. Live list (required under CMM 2010-02 paragraph 5) 9. The Secretariat maintains a live list of all fishing vessels present in the EHSP in the secure page on the WCPFC website, as required by the measure. As reported to TCC11, in August 2015, the display of this live list has changed making it more user-friendly. Vessels detected on VMS in the EHSP are now displayed in a table as well as in a map of the EHSP in the EHSP page on the website. Vessels are also directly linked to the WCPFC RFV providing user with the ability to easily access vessel details on the RFV. A sample screen shot it shown below, CCMs can log into the EHSP secure page (https://www.wcpfc.int/easternhigh-seas-pocket) to view the latest data. 10. During July and August 2016, there was a temporary period when the live list on the website was not available to CCMs, this occurred as a consequence of the VMS transition. 3
Joint work between the VMS service provider and our website contractor enabled necessary technical work re-established the live list display on 26 August 2016. Administrative Note 11. To assist with internal record keeping at the WCPFC Secretariat, copies of entry and exit reports that are required in accordance with paragraph 2 to be submitted the Commission, can be sent to the Secretariat to email: EasternHighSeasSpecialManagementArea@wcpfc.int Recommendation 12. TCC12 is invited to note the report and discuss the activities in the EHSP-SMA. 4
Annex 1: Summary of CCMs responses in Annual Report Part 2 CMM 2010-02 02 (submission of entry/exit report) CMM 2010-02 06 (indication of indention to transship in the EHSP) CCM answer in AR Pt 2 when asked whether CMM 2010-02 para 2 and 6 has been implemented (choice of Yes/No/N/A) from Annual Report Part 2 Summary of further information provided by CCM in AR Pt 2 14 Yes Some CCMs states this is fully implemented; Some provided explanations that this is implemented through national legislation/regulation/license terms and conditions 21 N/A Flag vessels do not fish in the EHSP/beyond areas of national jurisdiction; no flag vessel 1 NO CCM state that relevant action will be informed start from next year 1 outstanding AR Pt 2 report 10Yes Implemented through national legislation/regulation/license terms and conditions 26 N/A No transshipment in EHPS; no flag vessels permitted to transship in Convention Area/high seas; no flag vessel operates in areas beyond national jurisdiction 1 outstanding AR Pt 2 report Annex 2: Summary of entry and exit reports received by WCPFC with the Entry and Exit Alert generated by the Commission VMS by flag for the year 2015. This table does not take into account any recent submissions and updates provided as replies to the 2016 draft Compliance Monitoring Report covering 2015 activities and may be subject to revision. # of Vessels detected ENTRY EXIT CCM # of vessels detected on VMS # of vessels that submitted entry/exit report VMS Alert Manual Report VMS Alert Manual Report Cook Islands 1-1 - 1 - China 32 35 48 44 49 44 Fiji 3-5 - 5 - Japan 1 2 1 3 1 3 Kiribati 3 2 5 2 6 2 Korea 1-2 - 2 - Panama 2 1 3 2 3 2 Chinese Taipei 28 36 73 63 70 64 Vanuatu 1-1 - 1 - TOTAL 72 76 139 114 138 115 5
Annex 4: List of vessels that submitted reports required by CMM 2010-02 paragraph 2 for 2015 CN JP Longliner FENG HUI 18 FENG HUI 7 HAI XING 615 HAI XING 815 HAI XING 816 HAI XING 817 HAI XING 818 HONG YANG 1 HONG YANG 3 LU RONG YUAN YU 168 LU RONG YUAN YU 206 LU RONG YUAN YU 798 LU WEI YUAN YU 188 LU WEI YUAN YU 488 PING TAI RONG 13 PING TAI RONG 19 PING TAI RONG 25 PING TAI RONG 29 PING TAI RONG 39 PING TAI RONG 49 PING TAI RONG 9 SHEN GANG FA 718 SHEN GANG FA 719 SUI YUAN YU 32 ZHONG RONG 32 ZHONG YANG 16 ZHONG YANG 18 ZHONG YANG 19 ZHONG YANG 28 ZHONG YANG 29 Tuna longliner PING TAI RONG NO.6 RONG YUAN YU 86 RONG YUAN YU 87 RONG YUAN YU 88 RONG YUAN YU 89 Tuna longliner KAIGATA MARU NO.86 KAIGATA MARU NO.88 KI FISH CARRIER PA TW SHIN HO CHUN NO.101 SHIN HO CHUN NO.102 FISH CARRIER SHIN HO CHUN NO. 101 Longliner YI SHENG WANG NO.1 Tuna longliner CHANG YI NO.868 CHARNG SHING YUAN NO.168 CHI FA NO.888 CHI HONG NO.899 CHI HSIANG NO.889 CHI TSAI NO.988 CHIUAN FA CHENG NO.166 CHU HUAI NO.368 CHU HUAI NO.628 CHU HUAI NO.668 CHU HUAI NO.826 CHU HUAI NO.886 CHU HUAI NO.888 CHUAN HSIANG NO.368 CHUAN HSIN NO.128 CHUAN SHYANG NO.98 JIN TSAI FU NO.888 LIAN JI FA NO.212 LIEN CHI FA NO.24 MAAN YIH FENG NO.16 MAAN YIH FENG NO.166 MAAN YIH FENG NO.26 MAAN YIH FENG NO.266 MAN YI FENG NO.66 ROEI YIH YU SEA HAWK NO.68 SHIN JAAN SHIN SHIN JAAN SHIN NO.101 SHIN JAAN SHIN NO.102 6
SHIN JAAN SHIN NO.66 YI SHENG WANG YU LONG YU LONG FA NO.168 YU LONG FA NO.22 YU LONG FA NO.36 YU LONG NO.10 YU LONG NO.12 YU LONG NO.18 YU LONG NO.2 7
Weight onboard (kgs) Annex 3: Summary of number of vessels and catch onboard (in kgs) of main species recorded on entry and exit reports submitted in accordance with CMM 2010-02 para 2 14000000 Summary of catch onboard (in kgs) of main species recorded on entry and exit reports by year, submitted in accordance with CMM 2010-02 para 2 12000000 10000000 8000000 6000000 4000000 2000000 0 ENTRY EXIT ENTRY EXIT ENTRY EXIT ENTRY EXIT ENTRY EXIT ENTRY EXIT 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 YFT 50667 256385 490935 710972 911095 1124581 1005718 1526775 792216 1109837 700981 593253 SWO 8592 15902 732231 736077 181239 201411 98573 119704 342868 378281 32310 37801 SKJ 5811 19206 34386 164224 2216511 2214221 56332 723456 64154 119802 1935564 1931480 SHK 62017 101655 90902 123443 47411 57511 56953 58885 316472 316357 6313 275 MLS 380 2194 0 200 0 1000 BLZ 3000 5000 187261 97381 BET 49318 141908 426593 796792 1724436 1901932 732186 892194 585643 655059 524753 448401 ANY 84653 244435 356450 571338 460408 714120 4323893 4588239 3027308 3235664 2342385 2342596 ALB 850689 2335137 2236666 5477025 3487824 5501911 2561337 3808394 1933060 3708690 2690031 2696408 8
12000000 Catch onboard (in kgs) of main species recorded on entry and exit reports by year, by submitting CCM, in accordance with CMM 2010-02 para 2 10000000 8000000 6000000 4000000 2000000 0 CK CN KI TW VU CA CK CN FJ JP TW VU CN FJ FM JP TW US VU CN FJ FM KI TW US CN JP KI TW CN PA TW US 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 YFT 200 41730 259564 5558 0 2630 787852 30578 15210 344717 20920 383331 51141 10434 9416 272679 513100 795575 565064 150412 1025524 724177 67316 912400 81226 908427 579162 623072 92000 SWO 7250 9554 7690 210 1391326 1135 21948 49525 4164 127606 7940 0 3766 53852 189486 77297 2450 36178 102352 55009 58930 539652 67558 24338 45773 SKJ 10130 10200 4687 5000 12850 89811 12742 1220 60107 16880 92322 9024 0 1006 26343 4283000 19037 38804 10214 5502 68776 656492 97443 1324 85189 64684 58360 3744000 SHK 7309 68219 88144 0 40 121622 4590 6448 69545 12100 69844 5170 0 0 29708 200 0 0 58170 57668 0 0 631894 935 4555 2033 MLS 0 760 1814 200 0 0 1000 BLZ 8000 145650 2500 136492 BET 710 46472 126278 17766 0 1550 580296 27915 63678 513574 36372 378047 39434 6945 70922 319902 563000 2248118 323771 93290 808476 374843 24000 538854 276342 425506 571093 402061 ANY 41256 1400 220279 66153 0 1750 280731 28393 92020 493312 31582 444086 90655 23523 21448 472980 0 121836 278452 39801 24000 7991272 578607 478243 63706 5212468 508555 383382 3800000 393599 108000 ALB 4050 379005 2008431 794340 20000 66098 2080964 242417 121674 4690762 491776 3314796 604356 92980 3690 4120041 853872 2430825 336677 37466 3564763 2215866 21814 185944 32181262149583 3236856 9