HS&DR (Researcher-led) Panel Meeting Minutes Date Wednesday 26 and Thursday 27 April 2017 Venue Present members The Danubius Hotel, London Members: Rod Taylor Jillian Evans Rob Anderson Mo Aye Sabyasachi Bhaumik Alex Bottle Sarah Finer Anne Forster Tim Freeman David Green Bruce Guthrie Julie Hankin Graham Martin Anne Mason Margaret May Brendan McMormack Virgina Minogue Abeda Mulla Karen Ritchie Jean Simpson Steve Sparks Catherine Walshe Chair Day 1 only Day 1 only Day 1 and AM on day 2 only Day 1 only Apologies Secretariat In attendance Observers David McNally Glenn Robert Stephanie Garfield-Birkbeck Kevin Campbell Ann Saunders Lisa Stockwell Helen Snooks None None The Health Services and Delivery Research programme is managed by NETSCC, HS&DR as part of the NIHR Evaluation, Trials and Studies Coordinating Centre, at the University of Southampton. Alpha House, University of Southampton Science Park, tel: +44(0)23 8059 4304 email: hsdrinfo@southampton.ac.uk Southampton SO16 7NS fax: +44(0)23 8059 5639 web: www.nets.nihr.ac.uk
APPENDIX 1 Panel comments on Outline Proposals 16/116/15 Reducing post-intensive care syndrome in family members of intensive care patients with family engagement and facilitated sensemaking strategies (Dr Valerie Joan Page) The proposal was discussed by the Panel and invited to resubmit. DPM: Brendan McMormack (Lead) & Karen Ritchie Decision: Invited to resubmit 16/116/47 Variations in GP referral rates and specialist care following referral: on changing the pattern of GP referrals to outpatient clinics and improvements in health outcomes (Professor Barry McCormick) Chair: Jillian Evans DPMs: Brendan McMormack (Lead) & Mo Aye Declared a conflict and left the room: Rod Taylor & Anne Mason 16/116/25 Evaluation of the implementation of Freedom to Speak up Local Guardians in NHS Acute Hospital Trusts in England (Dr Aled Jones) DPMs: Graham Martin (Lead) & Abeda Mulla Declared a conflict and left the room: Glenn Robert (absent), Anne Mason & Tim Freeman 16/52/53 How is cancer care best provided to patients in English prisons? Assessing the disease burden in the prison population, experience of diagnosis and support, and of receiving and providing cancer care (Dr Elizabeth Davies) DPMs: Margaret May (Lead) & Steve Sparks Declared a conflict and left the room: Rob Anderson 16/116/48 A randomised controlled trial to compare costs and quality outcomes of home versus inhospital diagnostic testing for sleep disordered breathing in children (Associate Professor Catherine Mary Hill)
DPMs: Anne Mason (Lead) & Virginia Minogue 16/116/36 Understanding and improving the accessibility and quality of mental health services for people with bipolar disorder (Dr Steven Marwaha) DPMs: Tim Freeman (Lead) & Julie Hankin Declared a conflict and left the room: Sab Bhaumik 16/116/35 Understanding and optimizing citizen and community participation in contentious health service decisions and processes: an empirical investigation using case studies and action research (Dr Iestyn Williams) DPMs: Rob Anderson (Lead) & Julie Hankin Declared a conflict and left the room: Graham Martin, Glenn Robert (absent), Tim Freeman & Abeda Mulla 16/116/26 Falls safety decision making for acute hospital patients living with dementia: an ethnographic study (Associate Professor Sarah Goldberg) DPMs: Anne Forster (Lead) & Virginia Minogue Declared a conflict and left the room: Graham Martin & Julie Hankin 16/116/79 Medicines Optimisation in Critical Care Areas (MOCCA) Dr Richard S Bourne DPMs: Bruce Guthrie (Lead) & Karen Ritchie Declared a conflict and left the room: Graham Martin 16/52/93 Reusing comprehensive research datasets to explore ambulance service demand and service delivery (RAD) (Ms Janette Turner)
The proposal was discussed by the Panel and invited to resubmit. DPMs: Steve Sparks (Lead) & Alex Bottle Decision: Invited to resubmit 16/116/67 Care pathway efficiency and patient outcomes: a comparison of rapid access to local diagnostic assessment versus specialist clinic referral for soft tissue sarcoma (Dr Philip Robinson) DPMs: Alex Bottle (Lead) & Margaret May 16/31/87 The Early Youth Engagement in first episode psychosis (EYE-2) study: pragmatic cluster randomised controlled trial of implementation, effectiveness & cost effectiveness of a team-based motivational engagement intervention to improve engagement (Dr Kathryn Greenwood) DPMs: Sab Bhaumik (Lead) & Alison Thompson Declared a conflict and left the room: Anne Forster & Sarah Finer 16/116/46 Safety of reducing antibiotic prescribing in primary care. Systematic new evidence from electronic health records (Professor Martin Gulliford) DPMs: Graham Martin (Lead) & Sab Bhaumik Declared a conflict and left the room: Margaret May & Alex Bottle 16/116/74 Implementation of a brief evidence based cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) intervention for patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and co-existing symptoms of anxiety. OUTReach COPD cognitive behavioural Therapy (Dr Anthony De-Soyza) DPMs: Steve Sparks (Lead) & Mo Aye Declared a conflict and left the room: Sarah Finer
16/116/44 OASIS: Optimal Assessment of older patients receiving Systematic anticancer therapies (Dr Pippa Gail Corrie) DPMs: Alex Bottle (Lead) & Rob Anderson Declared a conflict and left the room: Anne Mason 16/116/10 How can acute hospitals best achieve high quality, cost effective nursing care? Developing processes and tools for evidence-based decision making on best use of the nursing resource: a mixed method study (Professor Andy Charlwood) DPMs: Catherine Walshe (Lead) & Abeda Mulla Declared a conflict and left the room: Anne Mason & Anne Forster 16/116/82 CONCORD: CO-ordiNated Care Of Rare Diseases (Professor Stephen Morris) DPMs: Rob Anderson (Lead) & Alison Thompson Declared a conflict and left the room: Glenn Robert 16/116/08 Sharing information about Diagnosis and Outcome of First Episode Psychosis (FEP) in patients presenting to Early Intervention Services (EIS) An exploratory study and evidence synthesis to inform the development of a conceptual framework (Dr Saeed Farooq) DPM: Anne Mason Declared a conflict and left the room: Sab Bhaumik 16/116/86 Leadership to promote infection prevention and reduce risks of antimicrobial resistance (LEADER) (Professor Dinah Gould) PM: Bruce Guthrie
16/116/13 An investigation of the effects of research activity on clinical outcomes, patient experience and standards of care in the English National Health Service (Professor Eva Judith Ann Morris) Chair: Jillian Evans PM: Tim Freeman Declared a conflict and left the room: Margaret May, Graham Martin, Anne Mason, Anne Forster, Rob Anderson & Rod Taylor 16/116/22 Mixed methods strategies for process evaluations of complex interventions (Dr Sarah Morgan-Trimmer) Chair: Jillian Evans PM: Catherine Walshe Declared a conflict and left the room: Rob Anderson & Rod Taylor