HS&DR (Researcher-led) Panel Meeting Minutes Date Venue Present members Apologies Secretariat In attendance Observers Wednesday 5 and Thursday 6 July 2017 Millennium Gloucester Hotel, London Members: Rod Taylor Jillian Evans Mo Aye Sabyasachi Bhaumik Alex Bottle Sarah Finer Anne Forster Tim Freeman David Green Julie Hankin Anne Mason Brendan McMormack David McNally Virgina Minogue Abeda Mulla Rebecca Randell Karen Ritchie Jean Simpson Steve Sparks Alison Thompson Catherine Walshe Robert West Glenn Robert Rob Anderson Bruce Guthrie Cathy Pope Margaret May Stephanie Garfield-Birkbeck Kevin Campbell Ann Saunders Jo Tier Louise Wallace None Chair Day 1 only Chair Day 2 only, in attendance day 1 & 2 Day 1 only Day 1 only Day 1 only Day 1 only PM of day 1 Jonathan Bisson, Director of Health and Care Research Wales Day 1 The Health Services and Delivery Research programme is managed by NETSCC, HS&DR as part of the NIHR Evaluation, Trials and Studies Coordinating Centre, at the University of Southampton. Alpha House, University of Southampton Science Park, tel: +44(0)23 8059 4304 email: hsdrinfo@southampton.ac.uk Southampton SO16 7NS fax: +44(0)23 8059 5639 web: www.nets.nihr.ac.uk
APPENDIX 1 Panel comments on Outline Proposals 16/116/42 Developing, testing and evaluating a methodology for improving flow performance and productivity in high-volume macular treatment clinics: a mixed model approach (Dr Konstantinos Balaskas) DPM: Mo Aye (Lead) & Rob Anderson 17/05/20 Harm reduction for people who self-harm on mental health wards: a realist evaluation (Dr Karen James) DPMs: Sab Bhaumik (Lead) & Alex Bottle 17/05/29 A hyperacute Bundle of Care for Delivering improved outcomes in IntraCerebral Haemorrhage (ABCDICH): evaluation of impact on death and disability in a national stepped wedge cluster randomised trial (Dr Adrian Robert Parry-Jones) The proposal was discussed by the Panel and invited to resubmit. DPMs: Jillian Evans (Lead) & Anne Forster Decision: Invited to resubmit 17/05/34 Advanced Clinical Practitioners in the Emergency Department A mixed-methods evaluation of a new model of care (ACED) (Associate Professor Mark-Alexander Sujan) DPMs: Sarah Finer (Lead) & Brendan McCormack Declared a conflict and left the room: David McNally & Catherine Walshe
17/05/03 Safe, effective and efficient vital signs monitoring to identify the deteriorating patient: A retrospective observational study to derive an evidence-based protocol for patient surveillance on the general hospital ward (Professor Jim Briggs) The proposal was discussed by the Panel and shorlisted. DPMs: Julie Hankin (Lead) & Anne Forster 17/05/83 How is the nursing workforce deployed and organised, and staffing levels planned, to meet the needs of acute medical and surgical patients in England and Wales, and what are the comparative advantages, disadvantages, costs-consequences and budget impacts of different national and local approaches? (Professor Davina Allen) DPMs: David McNally (Lead) & Anne Mason Declared a conflict and left the room: Brendan McCormack 16/116/43 The dynamics of frailty in older people: modelling impact on health care demand and outcomes to inform service planning and commissioning (Dr Bronagh Walsh) DPMs: Margaret May (Lead) & Virgina Minogue Declared a conflict and left the room: Anne Forster, Brendan McCormack & Robert West 17/05/26 Understanding and improving the quality of care for prisoners (Dr Tracey Farragher) DPMs: Abeda Mulla (Lead) & Glenn Robert Declared a conflict and left the room: Anne Forster, Robert West & Rebecca Randell 17/05/88 Effectiveness of multiple risk behaviour interventions in people with severe mental illness (Dr Nicholas Meader)
DPMs: Steve Sparks (Lead) & Alison Thompson Declared a conflict and left the room: Anne Mason 17/05/23 Development of a new domestic abuse training and referral pathway for health visiting teams in England: A mixed methods study using Q-Methodology (Dr Caroline Bradbury-Jones) DPMs: Catherine Walshe (Lead) & Rob Anderson Declared a conflict and left the room: Brendan McCormack 17/05/32 Optimising early detection, treatment and management of healthcare professionals with health problems or disabilities A mixed method study (Dr Claire Henderson) DPMs: Alex Bottle (Lead) & Mo Aye Declared a conflict and left the room: Julie Hankin 17/05/62 Developing patient-centred, feasible alternative care for emergency department users with epilepsy. A model for service design (Dr Adam J. Noble) DPMs: Virginia Minogue (Lead) & Tim Freeman 17/05/55 Eye Donation from Palliative and Hospice care contexts: investigating Potential, Practice, Preference and Perceptions (EDiPPPP) (Dr Tracy Long-Sutehall) DPMs: Anne Forster (Lead) & Sab Bhaumik
17/05/68 Listening and Learning from Older People in Care Homes: a participatory approach to implementing a complex intervention and its evaluation (Professor Brendan George McCormack) DPMs: Tim Freeman (Lead) & Jillian Evans Declared a conflict and left the room: Brendan McCormack 17/05/45 Constructing the entire care pathway of bowel cancer patients undergoing emergency surgery to improve their quality of care (Dr Kate Walker) DPMs: Anne Mason (Lead) & Sarah Finer 16/123/15 The effectiveness of non-nhs service provision and data collection for improving health inequalities in first-generation migrants: A mixed-methods evaluation of third sector health interventions delivered by Doctors of the World UK (Professor Jon S Friedland) DPMs: Margaret May (Lead) & Abeda Mulla Declared a conflict and left the room: Alex Bottle 17/05/73 A feasibility study and pilot randomised controlled trial to establish methods for assessing the acceptability and clinical and cost effectiveness of HOme Modifications for older people compared with usual care: HOME Study (Professor Suzanne Richards) DPMs: Karen Ritchie (Lead) & Glenn Robert Declared a conflict and left the room: Sarah Finer & Robert West
17/05/44 Achieving closure? Improving outcomes when care homes close (Professor Jon Glasby) DPMs: Brendan McCormack (Lead) & David McNally Declared a conflict and left the room: Tim Freeman 17/05/28 The AVERT (Acute VErtebral fracture augmentation) multi-centre, randomised controlled, feasibility study (Professor Opinder Sahota) DPMs: Mo Aye (Lead) & Brendan McCormack 17/05/30 Thinking ahead about medical treatments in advanced illness: A qualitative study of barriers and enablers in end-of-life care planning with patients and families from Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic (BAME) backgrounds. (Professor Christina Faull) DPMs: Anne Mason (Lead) & Julie Hankin 17/05/33 Delegation and supervision of bedside care in acute hospitals by registered nurses to healthcare support staff: a cluster-randomised trial with embedded process evaluation of the effectiveness of the nurse delegation and supervision checklist (NDSC) (Professor Helen Therese Allan) DPMs: Karen Ritchie (Lead) & Anne Forster Declared a conflict and left the room: Tim Freeman 17/05/41 Delays in hospital discharge for frail older people: what are the hidden challenges and how can they be addressed? (Dr Sabi Redwood)
DPMs: Steve Sparks (Lead) & Alex Bottle Declared a conflict and left the room: Tim Freeman 17/05/103 AssessmenT of cognitive Impairment by non specialist staff in British Multi Ethnic older adults: TIME (Dr Waquas Waheed) DPMs: Tim Freeman (Lead) & Catherine Walshe 17/05/110 Exploring the local operation and impact of Healthwatch in England five years on: using actor network theory to optimise patient and public voice in NHS commissioning and service provision (Professor Glenn Robert) DPM: Julie Hankin (Lead) & Rob Anderson Declared a conflict and left the room: David McNally 17/05/96 Emergency care of older people (Honorary Professor Simon Conroy) DPM: Sarah Finer (Lead) & Margaret May Declared a conflict and left the room: Anne Mason 17/05/25 Evaluation of how the NHS delivers a service to diagnose and treat teenagers, young adults (TYA) and adults with inherited and acquired aplastic anaemia, to provide recommendations for future service delivery (Professor Judith Marsh) DPM: Julie Hankin
17/05/52 Cognition AssessmenT HOspital Decision CATHODE (Professor Christopher Fox) DPM: Alison Thompson Declared a conflict and left the room: Brendan McCormack & Robert West 17/05/101 Understanding trends in alcohol-related harm in England 2000-2014: an analysis of Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey data with linkage to the NHS Central Register (Dr Orla McBride) DPM: David McNally Declared a conflict and left the room: Brendan McCormack 17/05/71 PACE ICU: a study to determine the feasibility of a cluster randomised trial of PACE (Psychosocial Assessment and Communication Evaluation) tool to improve family communication, psychosocial support and decision-making during clinical uncertainty in intensive care units (Dr Richard Harding) DPM: Virginia Minogue Declared a conflict and left the room: Catherine Walshe 17/05/43 idama: A mixed methods study to Improve the experience of Discharge Against Medical Advice (DAMA) for hospital and community healthcare practitioners, patients and relatives in the English NHS (Dr Laura Machin) DPM: Alison Thompson Declared a conflict and left the room: Catherine Walshe & David McNally
17/05/12 Offering chaperones for intimate examinations in primary care: how, why and with what consequences? (Professor Sue Ziebland) DPM: Catherine Walshe Declared a conflict and left the room: David McNally 17/05/87 Evaluating the impact of dementia on surgical outcomes (Dr Sarah Smith) DPM: Mo Aye 17/05/80 Systems working and the integration of services for managing complex drug resistant infections: a clinical, social and economic evaluation of services for Multidrug Resistant Tuberculosis in the United Kingdom (Professor Onn Minn Kon) DPM: Steve Sparks 17/05/92 Examining burnout in general practitioners and indicators of suboptimal patient care using the Clinical Practice Research Datalink ( Dr Maria Panagioti) DPM: Sarah Finer 17/05/85 Alcohol related mortality among primary care patients with long term conditions: A Retrospective Cohort Study (Dr Duncan Stewart)
DPM: Tim Freeman Declared a conflict and left the room: Anne Mason 17/05/61 Enhancing public advisor involvement in research: exploring recruitment, retention and potential benefits for participants (Dr Susan Baxter) DPM: Julie Hankin PPI:Jean Simpson 17/05/107 Combining Geographic Information System and Simulation to design an efficient and equitable organ allocation system (Professor Thierry Chaussalet) DPM: Anne Mason