Annexure III List of Projects Reviewed for Outcome Evaluation 1. SOCIAL MOBILISATION AROUND NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT FOR POVERTY ALLEVIATION 2. RAJASTHAN MISSION ON LIVELIHOODS (RMOL) 3. THE NATIONAL STRATEGY FOR THE URBAN POOR: 4. ENDOGENOUS TOURISM PROJECT (ETP) 5. JAL BHAGIRATHI PROJECT 6. RURAL DECENTRALIZATION AND PARTICIPATORY PLANNING FOR POVERTY REDUCTION 7. PUBLIC-PRIVATE COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIP (PPCP) 8. CAPACITY BUILDING OF ELECTED WOMEN REPRESENTATIVES AND FUNCTIONARIES OF PANCHAYATI RAJ INSTITUTIONS 9. SUPPORT TO OPERATIONALIZATION OF THE NATIONAL RURAL EMPLOYMENT GUARANTEE ACT 10. CAPACITY BUILDING FOR DECENTRALIZED URBAN GOVERNANCE 11. CAPACITY BUILDING FOR ACCESS TO INFORMATION 1
Annexure IV Documents/Reports reviewed for the Outcome Evaluation 1. UNDP Document: Social Mobilisation around Natural Resources Management for Poverty Alleviation. 2. Micro Plans prepared by Ama Sangathan, Koraput 3. UNDP RMOL Progress Reports (July-Sept and Oct-Dec 2006; Jan-Mar 2007) 4. UNDP RMOL Review Meeting Minutes (10 th April draft) 5. RMOL PPTs (for Steering Committee Mtgs. Nov 06 and April 07; Review of PA phase). 6. Draft Livelihood Strategy for Rajasthan (July 2007) 7. Note sent on July 23 rd 2007 by Prema Gera, UNDP for the outcome evaluation on livelihoods 8. Project Fact Sheets, UNDP, for all the projects reviewed 9. Project Documents, UNDP, for all the projects reviewed 10. N.C. Saxena : Midterm Evaluation Report, GOI-UNDP Project National Strategy for Urban Poor, India, April 2007. 11. Website www.nationalstrategyforurbanpoor.org 12. National Strategy for Urban Poor, MoH&UPV and UNDP, undated. 13. Urban Poverty (Newsletter of National Resource Center on Urban Poverty), Vol 2, No.2, Feb 2007. 14. Urban Environ Vision (Information Bulletin of Regional Centre for Urban and Regional Studies of the AIILSG, Mumbai), Vol 1, Oct-Dec 2006 15. Special Issue on Urban Informal Sector, National Resource Center on Urban Poverty, Pune and Mumbai, Nov 2006. 16. Special Issue on Security of Tenure, National Resource Center on Urban Poverty, Pune and Mumbai, Dec 2006. 17. Mayors Forum for Fight against Urban Poverty (booklet), MoH&UPV, AAILSG and UNDP, undated. 18. A Researchers Colloquium on Urban Poverty, Centre for Good Governance, MoH&UPV and UNDP, undated. 19. National Programme on Capacity Building for Urban Poverty Alleviation Programme Overview, MoH&UPV, Govt. of India, New Delhi. 20. Draft Report Evaluation Study of Rural Tourism Scheme, Mott Macdonald Pvt Ltd., Jan 2006. 21. Workplans of project sites submitted to Ministry of Tourism in Dec 2004-2005 22. Check list for selection of Local Implementation Partners, R.K. Anil and Kavita Maria, UNDP-ETP, March 26 th 2004. 23. Site Selection Criteria (slide presentation), R.K Anil, UNDP-ETP. 24. Gender Related Concerns in Tourism (internal note), R.K Anil, UNDP ETP Project, Feb 10 th 2005. 25. Tourism Perspective Plan a Framework, (slide presentation), R.K Anil, UNDP ETP Project 26. Weaving and Tourism Perspective Plan, Bhoodan Pochampally (Endogenous Tourism Project), Akshara Network for Development Support Services, Hyderabad. 2
27. Website www.exploreruralindia.org 28. Rural Tourism in India, UNDP, undated. 29. Crafts of Rural India (pamphlet for mela in Dilli Haat, 13 th to 15 th October, 2006), GoI Ministry of Tourism and UNDP. 30. ETP Newsletter, Vols II-V, UNDP, New Delhi. 31. Comments by Meenakshi Kathel on Rural Tourism Handbook on incorporating gender concerns 32. External Evaluation of the Project on Vulnerability Reduction Through Community Empowerment and Control of water in The Drought Prone Areas of Marwar Regions of Rajasthan, Institute of Development Studies, Jaipur, Dec 2005. 33. Evolution of Water Rights (undated), Jal Bhagirathi Foundation, Italian Coopertaion and UNDP. 34. Looking to the Future (undated), Jal Bhagirathi Foundation, Italian Coopertaion and UNDP. 35. Turbulent Waters (undated), Jal Bhagirathi Foundation, Italian Coopertaion and UNDP. 36. Leading Change 2001-2004, (undated), Jal Bhagirathi Foundation. 37. Towards a Sustainable Water Future Strategies to address competing claims (undated), Jal Bhagirathi Foundation, Italian Coopertaion, Unicef, Sida and UNDP. 38. Together We Harvest a Dream A Promising Move, (undated), Jal Bhagirathi Foundation, Italian Coopertaion and UNDP. 39. Website : www.jalbhagirathi.org 40. Rural decentralization and participatory planning, Orissa State, working report, April, 2007 41. Capacity building of EWRs and functionaries of PRIs in Angul district of Orissa, A brief report by Institute for Socio-Economic Development (ISED), Bubaneshwar 42. Rural Decentralization and participatory planning for poverty reduction, Orissa State report by National Institute of Public Finance & Policy (NIPF&P), New Delhi, March, 07 43. Rural Decentralization and participatory planning for poverty reduction., Overall report of 4 States by NIPF&P, February, 07 44. Government of India-UNDP Country Program (2003-07), Program review report, February, 07 45. The RTI, 2005 published by Centre for Good Governance, Harish Chandra Mathur Rajasthan Institute for Public Administration, Jaipur 46. Women Power to the forefront. The Angul Initiative by Sarojini Nayak, ISED, January, 06 47. Implementation of NREGS in AP, CGH, JK and MP in May and June, 2006 by Centre for Budget & Governance Accountability, New Delhi, September, 06 48. Evaluation and impact assessment of NREGS in Bihar,MoPR. 49. Monitoring & evaluation of NREGS, with special focus on gender issues by Indian School of Women s Studies & Development, New Delhi, October, 06 50. Proceedings and recommendations of the workshop on PPCP: Challenges, opportunities and way forward. MP Rural Livelihoods project, Bhopal, March, 07 51. Project workshop report on a review of I year activities of RTI Project prepared by HCM RIPA, Jaipur, 06 3
52. The UN Country Team in India Solution Exchange Business Pan, 2008-2012, May, 2007 53. Report by Ms. Supriya Kumar on her visit to Dungarpur. 54. PPCP for development of Backward districts Paper prepared by UNDP 55. Memorandum of Understanding between the Government of Rajasthan and CII, August, 06 56. Summary of III Meeting of CII-Industry Group on Dungarpur, May, 05 57. Background and objectives, CII-Government of Rajasthan Workshop on Water, Energy and Livestock Resources Development and Management in Dungarpur, August, 05 58. Draft Recommendations of the above mentioned workshop, August, 05 59. A background note for Round table on PPCP for Sustainable Livelihoods in Poorest Regions, Jaipur, November, 06 60. Minutes of the meeting of the working group on Jatropha Plantation, Wasteland, Watershed Development and Soil Conservation, Department, Government of Rajasthan, Jaipur, November, 05 61. RBAP Private Sector Strategy 2006-07 62. Consolidated Reply : India/Engaging the private sector in human development, prepared by Laurel Gascho and Geoff Prewitt, September, 06 63. Growing Inclusive Markets, A UNDP led partnership for progress toward the MDGs, June, 07 4
Annexure V List of Partners/Stakeholders met during the evaluation 1. Social Mobilisation Project Partners (in a meeting held on 21 st May, 2007 in Delhi) 2. Ama Sangathan and WIDA in Koraput, Orissa 3. Mr.Sachin Sachdeva (Aravalli) 4. Astha, Samarthak Samiti, FES Udaipur 5. CEO, DRDA Udaipur ; 6. CEO, DRDA, Koraput 7. District Collector, Udaipur 8. District Collector, Puri 9. UNVs in Koraput and Jaipur 10. RMOL office bearers and staff in Jaipur 11. Dr. P.K. Mohanty, National Project Director, NSUP. 12. Mr. Alkesh Sharma, National Project Coordinator, NSUP Project. 13. Mr. Ashok Malhotra, Programme Officer, HDRC, UNDP. 14. Mr. Suraj, UNDP 15. Mr. R.K. Anil, Program Officer-ETP, UNDP 16. UNV, ETP Project 17. Ms. Prema Gera, Programme Advisor, HDRC, UNDP 18. Mr. Amitabh Kant, ex-national Director, ETP Project. 19. ETP Consultant, UNDP. 20. Ms. Banaja Mohapatra, Intach Coordinator, Raghurajpur Project 21. Pipli, DSS official 22. Executive Director, Samode 23. Mr. A. Tripathy, Secretary, Department of Tourism, Orissa 24. Mr. Prithviraj Singh, CEO, Jal Bhagirathi, 25. Block Coordinator, Jal Bhagirathi. 26. Mr. Ajit Saxena, UNDP 27. Ms. Supriya Kumar, UNDP consultant 28. Mr. Harsh Singh, UNDP Office in Delhi on PPCP concept. 29. Mr. B.K. Sinha, Additional Secretary, MOPR 30. Mr. Anil Bahuguna, Director, MOPR 31. Mrs. Amita Sharma, NPD-NREGA & JS, MoRD 32. Dr. R.V. Singh, Special Secretary, Planning and Coordination, Govt. of Orissa 33. Ms. Nivedita Pradhan, Mayor, Cuttack Municipal Corporation 34. Representatives of Pallichetana, NIPDIT and the Xavier Institute of Management, Bubhaneshwar 35. Mr. Balaji Pandey, Executive Director, ISED, Bhubaneshwar 36. Mr. Amitabh Singh, DEBATE, Madhya Pradesh 37. Mr. Pradeep Kumar Jena, UNDP, Orissa 38. Mr. Ram Lubayya, Principal Secretary, RDPR, Govt. of Rajasthan 39. Mr. Rakesh Hooda, Director General, HCM RIPA, Jaipur 40. Mr. M.K. Khanna, Senior Adviser, Planning Commission & NPD-Decentralized Planning Project 41. Mr. A.K. Mehta, Director, Urban Governance 5