Revalidation FAQs for Trainees () Q1 What is the purpose of revalidation? The purpose of revalidation of a Doctors Licence to Practice is to give patients greater confidence in the profession and support the individual in maintaining and improving their practice. Q2 What is a Responsible Officer? This is a senior clinician in a Designated Body who ensures that the doctors for whom they act in this nominated capacity, continue to practice safely and are properly supported and managed in maintaining their professional standards Q3 What is a Designated Body? This is the organisation that a licenced doctor has a professional, educational or employment connection with that provides them with support for revalidation. For postgraduate trainees, this is Health Education West Midlands Q4 Who is my Responsible Officer? Your Responsible Officer (RO), as a postgraduate trainee in the West Midlands, is Professor Elizabeth Hughes, Director of Education & Quality and West Midlands Regional Postgraduate Dean. Q5 How will the GMC know who my Designated Body is? Health Education West Midlands notify the GMC of the trainees they have and this is then uploaded to GMC connect. Q6 How can I find out further information? The GMC have information on their website which can be found at http://www.gmcuk.org/doctors/revalidation/12383.asp Q7 What do I need to do for this process? You will already produce much or all of the evidence required for revalidation as a matter of course during your training, through meeting the requirements of your curriculum and periodic discussions with your educational supervisor. Specialty trainees will need to complete an enhanced Form R. The Form R is the document that all Specialty trainees sign annually, and this enhanced version requires you to answer questions about whether you have been involved in any complaints or investigated incidents over the last year. You will need to send this form back to the appropriate person at Health Education West Midlands; you will be given full contact details
Q8 In relation to completing the Enhanced Form R, what is a significant event? The GMC state that a significant event (also known as an untoward or critical incident) is any unintended or unexpected event, which could or did lead to harm of one or more patients. This includes incidents which did not cause harm but could have done, or where the event should have been prevented, which is significant enough to be investigated by your employing organisation. It is an expectation that all doctors as part of the requirements for revalidation are required to record and reflect on significant events in their work with the focus on what they have learnt as a result of the event/s. You only need to record this information on your form R if any formal investigations have not been completed and resolved, or if they have not been included in your portfolio. Q9 The Enhanced Form R asks for my revalidation date, what should I enter? You should have had notification from the GMC for this. All trainees who revalidate at 5 years, will revalidate again at CCT. For trainees who gain full registration with a licence to practise after December 2012, your revalidation date will be set to 5 years after full registration (or to your expected CCT date where this comes first). Q10 Where can I find the GMC programme approval number and/or Health Education West Midlands Reference Number/National Training Number? This information is completed by Health Education West Midlands. For the GMC survey this information will be provided to you through the survey from the information provided by Health Education West Midlands direct to the GMC. Q11 What role does my employer have in my revalidation? Your employer will be supplying information to Health Education West Midlands in order to inform the revalidation process through your ARCP. This is called a Collective Exit Report and asks the employer about any unresolved concerns about a trainee s conduct. If there are concerns on-going the employer should complete an exception report for Health Education West Midlands and provide the trainee with a copy. An exit report will be generated for every episode of employment since the last ARCP, and it is the employers responsibility to produce this. A failure of an employer to produce adequate information should not be detrimental to the trainee. Q12 How often will my employer be asked for this information? Information will be collected quarterly or a time appropriate to an ARCP that might fall outside these dates.
Q13 How will I know if I have been recommended or not for revalidation? The recommendation for revalidation to the GMC will occur every 5 years, and again at CCT, or at the point of CCT where this comes first. An ARCP will be held every year and if there are ever any concerns that might affect a trainee s possible revalidation these will be discussed face-to-face and recorded in the ARCP outcome form. The outcome of ARCP panels should always be passed to the trainee and their employer. You will receive a formal notification of your revalidation decision from the GMC. Q14 My revalidation date has been deferred by the RO as my CCT is not until October 2015. The GMC however has notified me that my new date is July 2014? A deferral cannot be made for longer than 12 months so your RO will continue to defer until you reach CCT or 5 years from date of full registration gained after December 2012 Q15 How is my grace period accounted for? The Dean will remain the Responsible Officer until the end of the period of grace. Q16 Who is the Postgraduate Dean responsible for? The Postgraduate Dean is only responsible for Trainees in GMC approved Health Education West Midlands training programmes and posts. This will include LATs and trainees who are currently out of programme. The Postgraduate Dean is NOT responsible for any locums including LAS's, Trust grade jobs, staff grade posts and other non-training grade posts. Q17 If I get an outcome other than a 1 in my ARCP does that mean I will not get revalidation? Not at all. It is quite possible to get an outcome 3 or 4 for failure to pass key exams, but unless there are other problems (e.g. conduct or health) it would have no effect on your revalidation decision. Q18 What if I change my Designated Body between now and revalidation commencing? The GMC will be working with deaneries to capture the change of designated body for trainees who change deaneries in August and September 2012. Trainees will be able to see the details of their prescribed connection and revalidation submission date by logging onto GMC Online after December 2012.
Q19 What happens if I am absent for a period of time or have a break from my Training programme; what effect will this have on my revalidation? If you are absent or take a break from the training programme which is approved by Health Education West Midlands (meaning that you do not give up your training number), then your revalidation date and prescribed connection will remain the same, and you do not need to do anything else. This might include taking up an out of programme training or research post, or going on maternity or long term sick leave. If your revalidation date happens to fall whilst you are out of training, your Responsible Officer will have the option to defer your revalidation. Deferral of the revalidation recommendation does not have any impact on your licence to practice, and is not a detrimental judgement. Q20 What is a Serious Incident? A serious incident is defined by the National Patient Safety Agency as an incident that occurs in NHS-funded services and care which results in: Unexpected or avoidable death of one or more patients, staff, visitors or members of the public; Serious harm to one or more patients, staff, visitors or members of the public or an outcome which requires life-saving or major surgical/medical intervention, Permanent harm, a reduction in life expectancy, prolonged pain or psychological harm; A scenario that prevents or threatens to prevent a provider organisation s ability to continue to deliver services, e.g., actual or potential loss of personal/organisational information, damage to property, reputation or the environment, or IT failure; Allegations of abuse; Adverse media coverage or public concern; A Never Event these are updated annually and currently include: wrong site surgery one or more retained instruments post-operatively chemotherapy administered via the wrong route misplaced nasogastric or oro-gastric tubes not detected prior to use in-patient suicide using non-collapsible rails in-hospital maternal death from postpartum haemorrhage after an elective Caesarean section inadvertent administration of intravenous concentrated potassium chloride
Q21 What is the difference between a Serious Incident, a Critical Event, a Significant Event and a Serious Untoward Incident? In the past a range of terms - Serious Incident, Critical Event, Significant Event, Serious Untoward Incident - have been used to describe occurrences in health care where harm or the risk of harm to patients has occurred. These terms were used interchangeably by some however due to individual preferences, certain terms were preferentially used in different settings e.g., clinical governance meetings, root cause analysis documents and the reflective logs of individual doctors. In 2010, the National Patient Safety Agency (NPSA) developed a national framework for the notification, management and learning from serious incidents in the NHS - National framework for reporting and learning from serious incidents requiring investigation. This was completed following consultation and collaboration with key stakeholders including the Care Quality Commission, the Department of Health, the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency, the NHS Litigation Authority, Monitor and the Independent Advisory Service. This publication replaced individual Serious Untoward Incident policies produced by Strategic Health Authorities and Commissioning Primary Care Trusts. It also unified much of the terminology surrounding such incidents around the term Serious Incident. Q22 Why does Health Education West Midlands need to be informed? As part of the revalidation process, the GMC now requires all employers to notify the Health Education West Midlands when a doctor in postgraduate training (DrPGT), on an approved training programme, is involved in an SI. The communication channel is through the Responsible Officer The RO in the employing Trust or Local Area Team/CCG (often the Medical Director or a delegated individual) will have responsibility for doctors not in postgraduate training they will also relay the relevant information to Health Education West Midlands RO about trainees. As a postgraduate trainee in the West Midlands, your Responsible Officer (RO) is Professor Elizabeth Hughes, Director of Education & Quality and West Midlands Regional Postgraduate Dean. Q23 What does it mean to me as a trainee if I am implicated in an SI? As part of the requirements for revalidation, it is expected that all doctors will record and reflect on serious incidents in their portfolios, with a particular focus on what they have learnt as a result of the event(s). As a trainee you will also need to complete an enhanced Form R annually. This will require you to answer questions about any complaints or SIs over the last year. You will only need to record information on your Form R if any formal investigations arising from a SI have not been completed and resolved, or if completed investigations have not been reflected upon in your portfolio. If you have been involved in a SI your employer will be asked to provide a brief summary of the SI Investigation. If this has been resolved satisfactorily with no on-going concerns about your fitness to practise and you have reflected upon this appropriately, it will not affect your revalidation recommendation. If there are unresolved concerns, your employer will be asked to give a brief summary and the anticipated date of the outcome of any investigation. Should this happen at the time that you are due to be revalidated then your RO will request a deferment in order to give time for the investigation to conclude.
Q24 How can ensure that I benefit from the experience of being involved in an SI? SIs can be powerful learning experiences that can provide opportunity for reflection and learning across a broad range of areas from the specifics of clinical event to aspects of communication, team-working, record keeping and professionalism. It is therefore important to take time to consider any learning needs that might have been identified through an SI and to discuss with your educational supervisor and other colleagues about how to begin to approach addressing these. It is important to incorporate any learning needs into your personal development plan and to approach in a structured, realistic way alongside your other learning objectives. Usually SIs involve more than one person and sometimes whole teams are implicated. Therefore there may well be the opportunity to work together on planning and addressing learning needs Q25 How might being involved in an SI affect my future career? SIs happen. One of the reasons to identify them and act upon them is to try to ensure they do not happen again, but unfortunately working in the complexity of health care sometimes unforeseen events and consequences arise. Being involved in an SI can therefore give you the opportunity to demonstrate your professionalism and ability to reflect and adapt. This will be useful for your training record and can provide you with easy worked up answer to that sometime difficult interview question: Tell us about a time when things did not go well for you. How did it make you feel? What did you do? Q26 I am a trainee on a team where an SI has happened but I was not directly involved with the patient at the time. What should I do We hope that you will raise the issue with both your clinical and educational supervisors as well as reflecting upon it in your portfolio scenarios such as these also have a probity element. Your supervisors will also be encouraged to follow the RO communication channel, as it is only through an atmosphere of openness that patient safety and quality of care can be improved. You might also seek advice from the Professional Support Unit at West Midlands Health Education West Midlands, which will be able to advise you further.