Gotcha! The Medical Chart: Anticipating the Lawyer s Review Clinical Professor Division of Emergency Medicine Stanford University School of Medicine Always Remember. What we chart is every bit as important as how we treat the patient. It shouldn t be But it is. At least in the medical-legal world. Tell the Story Anyone reading your chart a few years from now must be able to see a movie of the encounter. Anything you would want your defense attorney and expert witness to know should be apparent from your medical record. This also applies to any potential plaintiff s attorney or prospective plaintiff s expert. Most lawsuits are aborted without our ever knowing we were being considered for litigation. Your record should make it clear to the patient s lawyer and to any expert who reviews your record on behalf of the patient That you gave excellent care and That a lawsuit would be a waste of their time and money. 1
Your goal in charting is that your record should speak for itself and for you. You should not have to explain your actions or thoughts several years later after being sued. Prior Medical Record Case C-2 Review the past medical record, ideally before you see the patient. You ll often be surprised at what you can learn! Nursing and Paramedic Notes Cases 10 & C-3 What can we learn from these cases? Nursing notes are part of the medical record READ THEM!!! Same for paramedic notes! Beware of notes Written during the course of Tx Completed after patient is discharged. Superb Charting is Worth the Effort! 2
Case C-4 What an we learn from this case? Superb charting Years of litigation and potentially bad outcome avoided Dictation allowed inclusion of full details and timing Case C-4 What an we learn from this case? Always consider dictating your chart, at least the medical decision making portion Explain WHY you sent that chest pain patient home. Don t assume the reason is obvious Juries don t know what is obvious to doctors Case C-5 Be Truthful! Don t Guild the Lilly While the permanent sensory loss may have been defendable, the physician s credibility was not The case settled prior to trial Had the charting been more realistic, this case probably would have been won by the physician - or perhaps never even filed. Case C-5 Credibility is Crucial! If you chart something you cannot back up (like cranial nerves II-XII being normal) - even if you gave excellent care - the jury may not believe you about other aspects of your care. Case C-5 Be particularly careful with template charts. Resist the temptation to slash & burn. Document only what is accurate. Place your check marks and slashes very carefully. Similar principles apply to electronic medical records. 3
Case C-6 Medical Clearance for Psychiatry Clearance for Psychiatry Can a patient really be medically cleared? What constitutes an adequate evaluation? What should your medical record state? Case C-6 Medical Clearance for Psychiatry Sample wording: At this time there is no evidence of a non-behavioral medical emergency that would preclude transfer of care to the psychiatric service (or another facility) for further psychiatric as well as medical evaluation. Temporary Admission (Holding) Orders Case C-7 What can we learn about temporary (holding) orders? Crucial issue Who is in charge of the patient? Communication is essential! Between physicians Between physicians and nurses. Case C-7 What can we learn about temporary (holding) orders? Must be appropriate - both right now and later Must cover contingencies What to look for What to do When to do it Whom to call 4
Case C-7 What can we learn about temporary (holding) orders? Must specify Who is in charge. When that M.D. will see the patient. To call that M.D. for questions or problems That physician must agree. Timing of Orders DOCUMENTATION!!!!! Case C-8 What can we learn about timing of orders? Do it! Signing out Against Medical Advice Case 24 What can we learn about Leaving Against Medical Advice (AMA) Patient must be mentally competent. Potential consequences of AMA decision should be explained. Option of returning to ED should be offered Appropriate follow up should be arranged Chart should document all of this. Some Specific Issues Endotracheal Intubation 5
Case No. 11 What can we learn about intubation? Document as many of these as you can Good, symmetric lung fields No gastric sounds Vapor in tube Good compliance with bagging Good O2 saturation Good CO2 variation Good Vital signs Lack of collapse on insufflation of turkey baster if used Some Specific Issues Hostile Patients Case C-9 What can we learn about hostile patients? Chart the patient s exact words Include the profanity and the threats If security needs to be called, document why. It s usually because of fear of violence. Call security before the situation escalates. Some Final Thoughts What have we discussed today? Accuracy Don t chart what you didn t do Cranial nerves II - XII Detailed review of systems Review the prior medical record Read nursing and paramedic notes Beware of unfinished or unavailable notes when you do yours What have we discussed today? Time your orders Explain your thought process Dictate whenever possible Medical clearance for psychiatry Temporary (holding) orders Leaving against medical advice Documentation of intubation Exact words of hostile patient 6
Other important things to remember Write legibly Even better, DICTATE - at least make your through process clear With electronic records, beware of the cut & paste trap After care instructions The progression of the disease process As in appendicitis and others Everyone of us makes an occasional mistake Even when we don t, the specter of litigation is always there We never know which patient may be a potential danger to us The vast majority of times, what we do for our patients is correct Our chart must make this absolutely clear that we gave good medical care Our chart is our best opportunity to state our case. We should not have to explain ANYTHING later should there be litigation Our chart should preempt the possibility of litigation. Good plaintiff s attorneys reject 90% of cases that come to them Reputable emergency medicine expert witnesses reject the majority of plaintiff s cases they re asked to review Investigative reporters favorite question What did you know? And when did you know it? Your question to yourself re charting What did I do? And why did I do it? Does my chart reflect this? If our records accurately reflects these questions And if we provide good care and have good rapport with our patients We will rarely be sued And if we are sued We will usually win! 7