54th EIWA Tournament At Pittsburgh 3/14-3/15/58 1958 Team Champion Outstanding Wrestler Fletcher Award Sheridan Award Cornell - 64 Points Joe Gratto - Lehigh John Johnston - Penn State None Final Team Scores Number of Individual Champs in parentheses 1 Cornell 64 (2) 2 Lehigh 49 (3) 3 Syracuse 45 4 Penn State 35 (1) 5 Pittsburgh 27 (1) 6 Rutgers 22 (1) 7 Navy 17 8 Princeton 11 9 Pennsylvania 10 9 Franklin & Marshall 10 11 Harvard 8 11 Army 8 13 Yale 7 14 Brown 4 15 Temple 1 15 Columbia 1 Champions and Place Winners Wrestler's seed in brackets, [US] indicates unseeeded. 123 1st: Dave Auble [1] - Cornell (6-2) 2nd: Ed Carlin [3] - Syracuse 3rd: Andy Fitch [4] - Yale (4-2) 4th: Jerry Weisenseel [2] - Army 130 1st: John Johnston [1] - Penn State (4-2) 2nd: Carmon Molino [2] - Cornell 3rd: George Creason [4] - Syracuse (7-6) 4th: Stu Moyer [3] - Pittsburgh 137 1st: Joe Gratto [1] - Lehigh (5-3) 2nd: Guy Guccione [US] - Penn State 3rd: Vic DeFelice [2] - Pittsburgh (WDF) 4th: Lester Austin [4] - Syracuse 147 1st: Dick Santoro [1] - Lehigh (3-2) 2nd: Dick Vincent [2] - Cornell 3rd: Bill Fortenbaugh [3] - Princeton (6-4) 4th: Joe Yeats [4] - Franklin & Marshall 157 1st: Dave Johnson [1] - Pittsburgh (2-1) 2nd: Steve Friedman [2] - Cornell 3rd: John Driscoll [3] - Lehigh (4-3) 4th: Bill Macaleer [US] - Princeton 167 1st: Charles Crosby [2] - Rutgers (7-6) 2nd: Bill Murphy [US] - Syracuse 3rd: George Gray [US] - Penn State (9-5) 4th: Bob Foster [3] - Harvard 177 1st: Peter Davidson [4] - Lehigh (7-6) 2nd: Bill White [2] - Syracuse 3rd: Dick Garretson [3] - Rutgers (3-1) 4th: John Gardner [US] - Cornell UNL 1st: Dave Dunlop [3] - Cornell (1-1, 3-2) 2nd: Tony Stremic [1] - Navy 3rd: Frank Traendly [4] - Pennsylvania (WDF) 4th: Charles Pfrommer [2] - Franklin & Marshall
1958 EIWA Championship Page 1 of 4 123 Weight Class Malcolm Whitmore, Brown Andy Fitch, Yale [4] Art McCall, Temple Bob Szekley, Pittsburgh Dave Auble, Cornell [1] Myers, Harvard John Harrell, Rutgers Bob Myers, Lehigh Stan Singer, Pennsylvania James McKinney, Navy Jerry Weisenseel, Army [2] Chris Fischbacher, Princeton Andy Fitch Fall 3:32 Art McCall 5-2 Dave Auble Fall 0:46 Bob Myers 5-0 James McKinney 11-5 Jerry Weisenseel Fall 4:38 Andy Fitch 6-4 Dave Auble 6-0 Jerry Weisenseel 5-2 Dave Auble 4-0 Dave Auble 6-2 Ed Carlin, Syracuse [3] Tyrell, Franklin & Marshall David Clark, Columbia Gordon Danks, Penn State Ed Carlin Fall 0:08 Gordon Danks 5-0 Ed Carlin 8-1 Ed Carlin 3-1 Andy Fitch 4-2 130 Weight Class Jack Pickleman, Princeton George Seaver, Brown Gene Capporelletti, Temple George Creason, Syracuse [4] Gene Kessler, Navy Tom Monaco, Rutgers John Johnston, Penn State [1] Phil Schrefer, Yale Ed Slater, Lehigh John Watkins, Harvard Carmon Molino, Cornell [2] Phil Suraci, Columbia George Seaver Fall 1:39 George Creason Fall 5:20 Gene Kessler 2-0 John Johnston Fall 1:20 John Watkins 5-2 Carmon Molino Fall 5:29 George Creason 3-1 OT John Johnston Fall 8:07 Carmon Molino Fall 3:27 John Johnston Fall 8:12 John Johnston 4-2 Kerr, Franklin & Marshall Stu Moyer, Pittsburgh [3] Alan Black, Pennsylvania Mike Eckman, Army Stu Moyer 9-1 Alan Black 7-2 Stu Moyer 5-0 Carmon Molino 6-2 George Creason 7-6
1958 EIWA Championship Page 2 of 4 137 Weight Class Lester Austin, Syracuse [4] Dave Kornbluh, Temple Joe Longton, Navy James Carter, Cornell Joe Gratto, Lehigh [1] John Hyde, Army Gordon Muse, Franklin & Marshall Laidlaw, Yale Bill Cadwallader, Pennsylvania Robert Kozol, Harvard Vic DeFelice, Pittsburgh [2] John Cummings, Brown Lester Austin Fall 2:14 Joe Longton 12-2 Joe Gratto 9-1 Gordon Muse 5-0 Bill Cadwallader 6-0 Vic DeFelice 7-0 Lester Austin 4-1 Joe Gratto 7-2 Vic DeFelice 11-4 Joe Gratto 6-2 Joe Gratto 5-3 Guy Guccione, Penn State Edward Flynn, Princeton Dick Bakalor, Columbia Tom Grifa, Rutgers [3] Guy Guccione 8-0 Tom Grifa 5-2 Guy Guccione 10-3 Guy Guccione 2-0 Vic DeFelice Med FFT 147 Weight Class Joe Yeats, Franklin & Marshall [4] Keith Eveland, Brown Richard Johnson, Navy Don Kovalchik, Rutgers Bill Waples, Syracuse Robert Senter, Pittsburgh Dick Santoro, Lehigh [1] Sam Walensky, Temple John Noble, Harvard Jim Kinter, Pennsylvania Dick Vincent, Cornell [2] Ken Phillips, Army Joe Yeats 5-0 Don Kovalchik 5-3 Bill Waples 6-4 Dick Santoro Fall 3:48 John Noble 7-5 Dick Vincent 6-0 Joe Yeats 7-0 OT Dick Santoro 11-5 Dick Vincent 4-0 Dick Santoro 6-1 Dick Santoro 3-2 Earl Poust, Penn State Easter, Yale Bill Fortenbaugh, Princeton [3] Henry Younes, Columbia Earl Poust 6-1 Bill Fortenbaugh 4-0 Bill Fortenbaugh 5-3 Dick Vincent 3-1 Bill Fortenbaugh 6-4
1958 EIWA Championship Page 3 of 4 157 Weight Class Lou Winner, Brown Dale Minard, Navy Bill Macaleer, Princeton Gordon Carberry, Syracuse [4] Steve Weddel, Harvard Horace Taylor, Franklin & Marshall Sam Minor, Penn State Dave Johnson, Pittsburgh [1] Ed Hawthorne, Rutgers Tom Miller, Yale Ed Oppenheimer, Columbia Steve Friedman, Cornell [2] Dale Minard 3-2 Bill Macaleer 3-2 Horace Taylor 7-1 Dave Johnson 7-1 Ed Hawthorne 7-1 Steve Friedman 6-0 Bill Macaleer DFT Dave Johnson 8-2 Steve Friedman 9-0 Dave Johnson 5-3 Dave Johnson 2-1 John Driscoll, Lehigh [3] Lazar, Temple Bruce Brenner, Pennsylvania Tex Lenart, Army John Driscoll Fall 3:55 Tex Lenart 7-6 John Driscoll 3-0 Steve Friedman 2-0 John Driscoll 4-3 167 Weight Class Bill Murphy, Syracuse Henry Stoever, Princeton Tony Phillippi, Brown Bob LaRouche, Pennsylvania [4] Tom Alberts, Pittsburgh [1] Ray Norton, Temple John Kohr, Yale George Gray, Penn State Charles Crosby, Rutgers [2] Dave Thomas, Franklin & Marshall Waler Fillius, Cornell Bob Gunst, Lehigh Bill Murphy Fall 8:09 Tony Phillippi RD Tom Alberts 10-0 George Gray 3-0 Charles Crosby 11-8 Waler Fillius 6-5 Bill Murphy 4-1 George Gray 7-4 Charles Crosby 13-3 Bill Murphy 12-9 Charles Crosby 7-6 Bob Foster, Harvard [3] George Brainerd, Navy Dale Baxter, Columbia Art Bair, Army Bob Foster 7-5 Art Bair 5-0 Bob Foster 5-2 Charles Crosby 12-7 George Gray 9-5
1958 EIWA Championship Page 4 of 4 177 Weight Class Alex Skirpan, Pittsburgh Norman Baker, Yale Illiff, Franklin & Marshall Pete Davidson, Lehigh [4] Jim Thompson, Temple Doug Volgenau, Navy [1] Dave Callard, Princeton John Gardner, Cornell Gene Roberts, Brown Crum, Army Bill White, Syracuse [2] Ron Bender, Pennsylvania Alex Skirpan 7-1 Pete Davidson Fall 7:22 Doug Volgenau Fall 1:57 John Gardner 5-2 Gene Roberts 2-1 Bill White 6-1 Pete Davidson 13-6 John Gardner 5-4 Bill White 10-1 Pete Davidson 3-2 Pete Davidson 7-6 Thomas Hill, Harvard Dick Garretson, Rutgers [3] Henry Barone, Penn State Gene Appel, Columbia Dick Garretson 8-1 Henry Barone 6-1 Dick Garretson 5-2 Bill White 4-1 Dick Garretson 3-1 UNL Weight Class Frank Traendly, Pennsylvania [4] Angelo Anzivino, Brown Ted Quedenfeld, Temple Ted Robbins, Harvard Francis Schaeffer, Lehigh Thomas Hall, Pittsburgh Tony Stremic, Navy [1] Dave Fringer, Princeton Dick Sherrill, Yale Bob Novogratz, Army Marty Lavanhar, Syracuse Charles Pfrommer, Franklin & Marshall [2] Frank Traendly Fall 11:45 OT Ted Robbins Fall 5:30 Thomas Hall 4-2 Tony Stremic Fall 5:29 Bob Novogratz 6-5 Charles Pfrommer 4-0 Frank Traendly 4-2 Tony Stremic 2-1 Charles Pfrommer 5-2 Tony Stremic RD Dave Dunlop 1-1, 3-2 Carlos Henriquez, Columbia Jim Sierk, Rutgers Ray Pottios, Penn State Dave Dunlop, Cornell [3] Carlos Henriquez 7-1 Dave Dunlop 2-0 Dave Dunlop 8-2 Dave Dunlop 3-2 Frank Traendly Med FFT