HS&DR Panel Meeting Public Minutes Date 20 th June 2018 DAY ONE Venue Present members Apologies Secretariat In attendance Observers Quoracy Information Kensington Suite, Millennium Gloucester Hotel, London Members: Peter Brindle Judith Smith Alison Allam Jan Filochowski Suzanne Ii Umesh Kadam Suzanne Mason Richard McNally James Rimmer Sasha Shepperd Lois Thomas Carl Thompson Adele Webb Charlotte Williams Iestyn Williams Elizabeth Wade Nicola Hilton Paul McDonald Liz Mear Carmel Hughes Amber Young Stephanie Garfield-Birkbeck Kevin Campbell Suzy Hopper Naomi Kerr Louise Wallace Nil Nil Chair Deputy Chair Voting members: 20 (Quoracy = 13) Voting members present at meeting: 14 (70%
APPENDIX 1 Panel comments on Stage 1 Proposals (Day One) Researcher-led stage one proposals: 18/12 - Predicting failure of quality of care in NHS healthcare service provider organisations, and evidence for the interventions that lead to sustained improvement 18/12/04 - An exploration of the antecedents of medical engagement and its impact on organisational performance in English acute hospital trusts (Professor Ian Kirkpatrick) Conflict: Iestyn Williams, Judith Smith (not present) 127430 - Towards a framework for partnering as an intervention for improvement: lessons for NHS providers from a realist synthesis of theoretical, empirical, and stakeholder evidence (Dr Ross Millar). Conflict: Iestyn Williams, Judith Smith (not present) 18/12/01 - Failure and sustainable improvement of quality of care in NHS healthcare service provider organisations: detecting downturn, preventing decline, tackling breakdown and supporting sustainable recovery (Mr Alan Boyd) Conflict: Judith Smith (not present) 127397 - Faster and more effective interventions to remedy organisational failure for healthcare quality: realist evidence syntheses (Professor Rod Sheaff) Commissioned stage one proposals: 18/09 - Health services and interventions for children and young people who have experienced online-facilitated abuse, including online grooming
127424 - Di-MeSH: Developing and evaluating a digitally-mediated self-help intervention for young people who have experienced online sexual abuse (Dr Sandra Bucci) Commissioned stage one proposals: 18/10 - Research on interventions to improve the patient and family experience of complaints management and the decision to litigate against the NHS 18/10/02 - Patient and family involvement in serious incident investigations: Co-designing national and local guiding processes. (Associate Professor Jane Kathryn O'Hara) Conflict: Umesh Kadam, Carl Thompson 127275 - evidence-based Opportunities for Improving patient-centred learning from complaints (VOICE) (Dr Erik Mayer) Conflict: Carl Thompson 127309 - Complaints Mitigation and Prevention of Litigation: An Insight National Training Scheme (CoMPLAINTS) (Professor Julian Bion) Conflict: Judith Smith, Iestyn Williams 127364 - Understanding pathways and predictors of complaints for improved management and experience (Dr Caroline Sanders) Conflict: Umesh Kadam Page 2 of 6
127367 - Mapping the patient complaints journey: harnessing the power of language to recalibrate complainant responses. (Dr Catrin S. Rhys) 127434 - Quantifying the elements of patient experience which lead to complaint, dissatisfaction and litigation (Professor John A Groeger) Researcher-led stage one proposals: 18/11 - Improving the participation and conduct of health services research in nursing and care homes at scale 127234 - Developing research resources And minimum data set for Care Homes' Adoption and use (the DACHA study) (Professor Claire Goodman) Conflict: Richard McNally, Carl Thompson 127379 - Co-design and implementation of a digital minimum data set for patient health and well-being within care homes for the elderly (Dr Sally Victoria Fowler-Davis) Conflict: Suzanne Mason (not present) Page 3 of 6
DAY TWO Date Venue Present members Apologies Secretariat In attendance Observers Quoracy Information Thursday 21 st June 2018 Kensington Suite, Millennium Gloucester Hotel, London Members: Peter Brindle Judith Smith Alison Allam Jan Filochowski Carmel Hughes Suzanne Ii Umesh Kadam Richard McNally Lois Thomas Carl Thompson Adele Webb Charlotte Williams Iestyn Williams Amber Young Elizabeth Wade Nicola Hilton Paul McDonald Liz Mear Suzanne Mason James Rimmer Sasha Shepperd Stephanie Garfield-Birkbeck Kevin Campbell Suzy Hopper Louise Wallace Nil Nil Voting members: 20 (Quoracy = 13) Chair Deputy Chair Voting members present at meeting: 13 (65%) Page 4 of 6
APPENDIX 2 Panel comments on Stage 1 Proposals (Day Two) NIHR Themed call stage one proposals: 17/112 Mental Health Themed Call 17/112/15 - Prospective and Retrospective Observational, (Greater) Manchester, Implementation Study and Staged Evaluation-Liaison Mental Health Services (PROMISSE- LMHS). (Prof Elspeth Guthrie) 17/112/16 - Interpersonal Counselling for Adolescent Depression delivered by Youth Mental Health Workers without Core Professional Training: A Feasibility Randomised Controlled Trial. (Dr Paul Wilkinson) Conflict: Carmel Hughes 17/112/11 - Developing and trialling a novel intervention to improve discharge of people recovered from psychosis from secondary to primary care and GP care of people recovered from psychosis in the community. (Dr Sarah Sullivan) Chair: Judith Smith Conflict: Peter Brindle 127293 - Increasing and Improving Partnership with Carers in Mental Health Care: A Study Exploring the Implementation of the Triangle of Care in England. (Dr Julie Ridley) Conflict: Lois Thomas 127295 - A Realist Evaluation of Recovery Colleges: an intervention to promote recovery of mental health service users and tackle stigma through blurring identities of staff, patients, tutors and students. (Dr Mary Catherine Leamy) Page 5 of 6
17/112/14 - Improving access, experience and outcomes of mental health crisis care: a mixed method, intersectional evaluation of the models, impacts and costs of crisis cafés in England (the CAFÉ study) (Dr Steve Gillard) Conflict: Judith Smith, Iestyn Williams 127314 - Evaluating the management of transition within and between services for young people with mental health issues to improve the delivery of care (Dr Karen Newbigging) Conflict: Judith Smith, Iestyn Williams 17/112/17 - MY-CATS: Mental health in Young people - Change and Transformation of Services (Associate Professor Mina Fazel) Conflict: Sasha Shepperd (not present) 127253 - Psychiatric Emergency Assessment and Care Enhancement (PEACE) Project (Dr Nicola Jayne Kalk) 127270 - The Northern Ireland arm of the Dutch OptiMum Trial: Treatment for Pregnant Women Experiencing Trauma Associated with Childbirth (Professor Marlene Sinclair) Page 6 of 6
Page 7 of 6