The Dietetic Workforce in British Columbia: Survey Report

Similar documents
Nursing Practice In Rural and Remote Newfoundland and Labrador: An Analysis of CIHI s Nursing Database

Nursing Practice In Rural and Remote Ontario: An Analysis of CIHI s Nursing Database

Nursing Practice In Rural and Remote Nova Scotia: An Analysis of CIHI s Nursing Database

Nursing Practice In Rural and Remote New Brunswick: An Analysis of CIHI s Nursing Database

Chapter F - Human Resources

AB Nursing Homes Regulations Consultation

Occupational Therapists. A guide for newcomers to British Columbia

End-of-Life Care Action Plan

2010 National Physician Survey : Workload patterns of Canadian Family Physicians

THE LABOUR MARKET FOR OCCUPATIONAL THERAPISTS

Guidelines. Working Extra Hours. Guidelines for Regulated Members on Fitness to Practise and the Provision of Safe, Competent, Ethical Nursing Care

Therapeutic Recreation Regulation in Canada 2015: Comparison of Canada s Health Professions Acts

Enabling Effective, Quality Population and Patient-Centred Care: A Provincial Strategy for Health Human Resources.

Background: As described below, 70 years of RN effectiveness makes it clear that RNs are central to a high-performing health system.

Full-time Equivalents and Financial Costs Associated with Absenteeism, Overtime, and Involuntary Part-time Employment in the Nursing Profession

Nursing Education Program of Saskatchewan (NEPS) 2-Year Follow-Up Survey: 2004 Graduates

PUBLIC HEALTH AND PREVENTIVE MEDICINE RESIDENCY PROGRAM

Leaving Canada for Medical Care, 2016

Pan-Territorial Dietetic Internship

The Strategy for Patient-Oriented Research in Ontario the Ontario SPOR SUPPORT Unit (OSSU)

Standardization of the Description of Competencies of Western Canadian Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN) Practitioners Project


Nursing Education Program of Saskatchewan (NEPS) Exit Survey:

The Prevalence and Impact of Malnutrition in Hospitalized Adults: The Nutrition Care Process

Careers in Patient Care: A Look at Former Students from Nursing and other Health Programs that Focus on Patient Care

Florida Licensed Practical Nurse Education: Academic Year

This report describes the methods and results of an interim evaluation of the Nurse Practitioner initiative in long-term care.

Quick Facts Prepared for the Canadian Federation of Nurses Unions by Jacobson Consulting Inc.

Volunteers and Donors in Arts and Culture Organizations in Canada in 2013

Fastest Growing Industries: Health Care. A guide for newcomers to British Columbia

North Zone, Alberta Health Services, Alberta

Ministry of Health Patients as Partners Provincial Dialogue Report

How Can We Create a Cost-Effective System of Primary and Community Care Built Around Interdisciplinary Teams?

The Nature of Nursing Practice in Rural & Remote Canada. Telehealth Presentation: September 27, 2004 Chinook Health Region

Original Article Nursing workforce in very remote Australia, characteristics and key issuesajr_

STANDARDS OF PRACTICE 2018

Trans Care BC. Program Update. April 2018

Strategies for Patient Oriented Research: The PEI Primary and Integrated Healthcare Innovation Network. March 16 th, 2017 W.J.

Planning to Improve the Health of a Diverse Population

Data Quality Documentation, Hospital Morbidity Database

HEALTH AUTHORITY ENGAGEMENT SURVEY REPORT 2017 HEALTH AUTHORITY ENGAGEMENT REPORT

Anesthesiology. Anesthesiology Profile

A Framework. for Collaborative Pan-Canadian Health Human Resources Planning

Canadian Engineers for Tomorrow

PA Education Worldwide

Age-friendly Communities

Canadian Hospital Experiences Survey Frequently Asked Questions

Nunavut Nursing Recruitment and Retention Strategy November 06, 2007

Patients as Partners Provincial Dialogue Event Summary. March 31, 2014

GPSC Fee Items for A GP For Me/Attachment & In-patient Care

Four Initiatives for Healthcare Change in BC

2018 PRE-BUDGET CONSULTATION

Medical Radiation Technologists and Their Work Environment

Medical Radiation Technologists. A guide for newcomers to British Columbia

Dietitians of Canada (Ontario) Response to. The Health Professions Regulatory Advisory Council. Interprofessional Collaboration Discussion Guide

How BC s Health System Matrix Project Met the Challenges of Health Data

Primary Health Care The foundation of our health care system

NCLEX-RN 2015: Canadian Results. Published by the Canadian Council of Registered Nurse Regulators (CCRNR)

Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) An Overview

Ambulatory Cancer Care

Dietitians of Canada (Newfoundland and Labrador)

Occupational Therapists in Canada, 2011 Database Guide

Industrial & Manufacturing Engineers. A guide for newcomers to British Columbia

Prince Edward Island s Healthy Aging Strategy

Program Design: Mental Health and Addiction Nurses in District School Board Program

Competencies for Public Health Nutrition Professionals: A Review of Literature

Common Caregiver Public Policy Initiatives: Support for caregivers, support for health system

Family and Community Support Services (FCSS) Program Review

HEALTHY BRITISH COLUMBIA S REPORT ON NATIONALLY COMPARABLE PERFORMANCE INDICATORS

SUMMARY. Workshop Summary WORKSHOP. Julia Langton, Kim McGrail, Sabrina Wong July 2015

PROCLAMATION. "BC AWARE 2016: Be Secure, Be Aware, days" (January 25- February 5, 2016)

SASKATCHEWAN ASSOCIATIO. Program Approval for New & Dissolving RN or RN Re-Entry Education Programs

CASN 2010 Environmental Scan on Doctoral Programs. Summary report

NCLEX-RN 2017: Canadian and International Results. Published by the Canadian Council of Registered Nurse Regulators (CCRNR)

A Canadian Perspective of Baby Friendly Initiative & Nova Scotia, IWK Health Centre BFI Highlights

Education: Making a Difference

Related Electronic Written Submissions (

Hand cleaning compliance in healthcare facilities, Q3 of 2016/2017

Family Service Practice Audit

The Patient s Voice. Key findings from LHIN engagements with patients, families and caregivers. September 2015

South Carolina Nursing Education Programs August, 2015 July 2016

Quality Improvement Plan (QIP) Narrative for Health Care Organizations in Ontario

Low Molecular Weight Heparins

College of Dietitians of Alberta Dysphagia Best Practice Guidelines: Addendum to the College of Dietitians of Ontario s Dysphagia Policy

PRIMARY HEALTH CARE: A NEW APPROACH TO HEALTH CARE REFORM

Community Health Centre Program

Statutory Regulation in Canada

BCPhA Submission: Select Standing Committee on Finance and Government Services Budget 2017 Consultations

Health Directors Association. Survey Results

June Jurisdictional profiles on health care renewal An appendix to Progress report 2012: Health care renewal in Canada

Stable Physician Workforce Recommendations to stabilize the physician workforce in Nova Scotia

Dietetic Scope of Practice Review

Electrical & Electronics Engineers. A guide for newcomers to British Columbia

Jurisprudence Learning Module. Frequently Asked Questions

Application Guide. Call for Applications Caregiver Education and Training. February 2017

The Art and Science of Evidence-Based Decision-Making Epidemiology Can Help!

2006 Strategy Evaluation

Building Research Capacity within the BC Health Authorities

Primary Care Workforce Survey Scotland 2017

Joint Position Paper on Rural Maternity Care

Transcription:

The Dietetic Workforce in British Columbia: Survey Report May 2016 www.dietitians.ca l www.dietetistes.ca

Acknowledgements This work was done with the support and guidance of the Dietitians of Canada (BC) Dietetic Workforce Committee. The committee thanks all dietitians in BC who participated in the survey and acknowledges Tracy Lister and Estelle Dufresne for their contributions to the survey and report development, as well as the College of Dietitians of British Columbia (CDBC) for the dissemination of the survey and contributions to this report. Dietitians of Canada (BC) Dietetic Workforce Committee Members and Representation: Lois Barney, MBA, RD, Northern Health Authority Theresa Cividin, MA, RD, Vancouver Coastal Health Lorrie Cramb, MEd, RD BC Ministry of Health Laura Cullen, MBA, RD, Langara College Tina Hartnell, MBA, RD, Fraser Health Anne Holtzmann, RD, Marquise Hospitality, Compass Canada Fern Hubbard, MEd, College of Dietitians of BC Frances Johnson, MSc, RD, Providence Health Care Suzanne Johnson, RD, First Nations Health Authority Tamar Kafka, MSc, RD, UBC Dietetics program Sonya Kupka, MAdEd, RD, Dietitians of Canada Ryna Levy-Milne, RD, PhD, Provincial Health Services Authority Monica Liefhebber, MPA, RD, Vancouver Island Health Authority Karol Traviss, MSc, RD, UBC Dietetics program Sandra Turnbull, RD, CEC, Interior Health. Dietitians of Canada. 2016. This report is published by Dietitians of Canada. A copy can be downloaded at www.dietitians.ca. Permission is granted to reproduce copies of the report in its entirety for personal or educational purposes, provided credit to the publishers is granted. DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE i

Executive Summary Dietitians expertise reduces malnutrition, prevents and delays progression of chronic diseases, decreases symptoms associated with diseases, improves food service and quality, and enhances food security 1, 2. Registered dietitians (RDs) are the only nutrition professionals regulated by the British Columbia (BC) Health Professions Act, are governed by ethical guidelines and standards of practice, and have extensive education and training in nutrition to ensure they work to the highest standard by providing evidence based nutrition information. There are over 1200 registered dietitians in BC. Unregulated nutrition practitioners are increasingly entering the nutrition practice landscape in BC. The general public and many health care professionals and policy makers assume these unregulated practitioners have an education and scope of practice equivalent to a registered dietitian. This misperception contributes to the use of unregulated nutrition practitioners to fill gaps in nutrition services, raising concerns regarding quality of care and risk to patients and clients. A key enabling strategy for improving the health of British Columbians is an engaged, skilled, well-led and healthy workforce 3. Dietitians of Canada BC Region is committed to working with the BC Ministry of Health, Health Authorities, the University of British Columbia, the College of Dietitians of BC, and others to achieve and maintain quality, appropriate, cost-effective, and timely nutrition services through an accessible dietetic workforce in BC. The purpose of this summary is to present the results of the 2015 survey of the dietitian workforce in British Columbia. Survey results confirm there are significant challenges in the sustainability and growth of the dietetic workforce. The current BC dietetic workforce is at capacity: Unregulated nutrition practitioners are increasingly entering the nutrition practice landscape in BC. raising concerns regarding quality of care and risk to patients and clients. Only 2% of survey respondents were seeking additional employment, indicating limited capacity within our existing workforce to maintain existing and meet increased demand for dietitian services. In an average week in 2015, 57% of respondents worked more hours than they were paid for (up from 18% in 2008 4 ), primarily to meet patient/client needs. This demonstrates that there is high demand for the existing services and there are dietitian workload issues. BC Government priorities are not being met with current dietetic services: The shortage of dietitians as well as the emergence of unregulated nutrition practitioners in the province means many British Columbians lack access to credible nutrition information. This threatens the ability to implement provincial healthy eating priorities and achieve meaningful improved outcomes for population and patient health in the following priority areas: Improved access to primary care through a primary care home model BC s primary care home model is built around interdisciplinary teams and functions, yet only 3% of dietitians reported working in primary care services associated with a physician s office. This is the equivalent of about 36 dietitians as compared to over 500 dietitians on family health teams and in community health centres in Ontario 5. DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE ii

Reduced demand on hospitals by improving care for the frail elderly In Canada, 45% per cent of older adults admitted to hospital medical and surgical units are malnourished 6, 55% in BC 7, increasing length of stay and associated health care costs. And yet, no BC dietitians reported having the majority of their time dedicated to serving the frail elderly in the community to mitigate and prevent malnutrition. This is a result of the limited home health nutrition services provided. Reduced demand on hospitals by improving care for those with mental illness and substance use issues As experts advising on diet, food and nutrition, dietitians have an important role in mental health promotion, disease prevention and treatment of mental health conditions 8, yet very few BC dietitians are employed in mental health and addictions or substance abuse (4%). Improved delivery of rural health services The majority of BC dietitians provide care in large and urban settings with a population of over 75,000 residents. There is limited to no full time work for dietitians to provide direct client care in rural and remote communities. Improved access to surgical services and procedures Patients with poor nutrition status prior to surgery are at increased risk of poor outcomes and complications that can lead to increased length of stay in hospital 9, 10. More than half (54%) of the dietitians surveyed did not have any relief coverage for absences greater than three consecutive days. Lack of relief coverage has a direct effect on patient care as medical nutrition therapy is delayed or not provided. Other challenges facing the BC dietetic workforce: Ten percent of the workforce is forecasted to retire in the next three years. The anticipated retirements and departures from dietetic practice will result in a further shortfall within three years of approximately 100 dietitians in BC. Expansion of services related to government priorities and population growth is forecasted to be sizable in some large and urban parts of the province. Additional dietitian positions are anticipated to provide the nutrition care necessary for effective services and improved outcomes for patient health. This will further challenge rural and remote communities to successfully recruit for their positions. UBC offers the only dietetics education program in the province and the number of graduates continues to be insufficient to address workforce demands. BC currently relies on registrants from other jurisdictions to meet almost 40% of their supply requirements. This level of out of province recruitment is not sustainable. The BC dietetics workforce has grown by an average of 2% per year half the national average of 4% 11. This slow growth rate has contributed to the limited capacity within the dietetic workforce. Further reductions through anticipated retirements and plans to leave the dietetics profession will make it difficult to maintain existing services and leaves no opportunity to meet the future needs. These findings demonstrate the need to increase the BC dietetic workforce to better meet government priorities, to address food and nutrition challenges that threaten the health of the population, and to sustain our health care system. DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE iii

Table of Contents Acknowledgements... i Executive Summary... ii BC Dietetic Workforce Survey... 1 Introduction...1 What is the profile of the survey respondents?...1 What is the current capacity of the BC dietetic workforce?...2 What is the potential attrition?...3 Where are dietitians currently working?...4 How is dietitian client care time aligned with BC government priorities?...6 Where were dietitians trained?...7 How is the future dietetics workforce affected by current education and training in BC?...8 How Does the BC Dietetic Workforce Compare to Other Provinces?... 8 Conclusion... 9 References... 10 FIGURES Figure 1: Age distribution of dietetic workforce survey respondents and registrants of the College of Dietitians of BC... 1 Figure 2: Status of employed dietitians... 2 Figure 3: Decreasing capacity in the BC dietetic workforce: Dietitians workload and relief coverage... 3 Figure 4: Timing of planned retirement of dietitian respondents over the age of 55... 3 Figure 5: Geographic distribution of survey responses, compared to population distribution... 4 Figure 6: Employers of survey respondents... 5 Figure 7: Areas of practice... 6 Figure 8: CIHI (2012) Dietitians in Canada per 100,000 population... 8 Figure 9: CIHI (2012) Dietetic training capacity in Canada... 9 DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE iv

BC Dietetic Workforce Survey THE DIETETIC WORKFORCE IN BC: SURVEY REPORT INTRODUCTION Registered dietitians are the only nutrition professionals regulated by the British Columbia (BC) Health Professions Act. Dietitians are governed by ethical guidelines and standards of practice, and have the most extensive education and training in nutrition a to ensure they work to the highest standard by providing evidence based nutrition information. Dietitians expertise reduces malnutrition, prevents and delays progression of chronic diseases, decreases symptoms associated with diseases, improves food service and quality, and enhances food security 1, 2. Unregulated nutritionists are increasingly entering the nutrition practice landscape in BC. The general public and many health care professionals and policy makers assume these unregulated practitioners have an education and scope of practice equivalent to a dietitian. This misperception contributes to the use of unregulated practitioners to fill gaps in nutrition services, raising concerns regarding quality of care and risk to patients and clients. A key enabling strategy for improving the health of British Columbians is an engaged, skilled, well-led and healthy workforce 3. Dietitians of Canada BC Region (DC) is committed to working with the BC Ministry of Health (the Ministry), Health Authorities, the University of British Columbia, the College of Dietitians of BC (CDBC), and others to achieve and maintain quality, appropriate, cost-effective, and timely nutrition services through an accessible dietetic workforce in BC. In March 2015, DC invited all dietitians in BC to complete an electronic survey to describe BC s dietitian workforce. Among the 1228 registrants of the CDBC, 514 responded to the survey (42% response). WHAT IS THE PROFILE OF THE SURVEY RESPONDENTS? The survey respondents are reflective of the dietetic workforce in BC. The age distribution is consistent with CDBC registrants (Figure 1), with a slight under-representation from 40 to 49 year olds and slight over-representation of 55 to 59 year olds. The gender distribution was consistent in that almost all (98%) of survey respondents and CDBC registrants (97%) are female. Figure 1: Age distribution of dietetic workforce survey respondents and registrants of the College of Dietitians of BC CDBC Registrants Workforce Survey 15% 14% 14% 14% 16% 16% 14% 12% 11% 12% 12% 11% 9% 8% 6% 6% 2% 3% 2% 2% 1% 1% Years 20-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70+ a All dietitians in BC must have a minimum of a four-year bachelor s degree in dietetics and completion of a supervised internship program with a minimum of 1250hours approved by the CDBC Board, or academic and practical training assessed by the CDBC to be substantially equivalent. DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 1

WHAT IS THE CURRENT CAPACITY OF THE BC DIETETIC WORKFORCE? Most (97%) of the survey respondents were employed. Among the respondents who were not employed, the primary reasons were studying or retirement. Only 2% of dietitians were seeking additional employment, indicating limited capacity within our existing workforce to maintain existing and meet increased demand for dietitian services Among employed respondents, just over half (54%) were employed full-time (Figure 2). Over one-third of respondents (36%) were employed part-time. Self-employment was the most common employment status of the remaining 10% of respondents. Only 2% of dietitians were seeking additional employment. This highlights the limited capacity within our existing workforce to meet increased demand for nutrition services. Figure 2: Status of employed dietitians Self Employed 10% Part Time 36% Full Time 54% One in five responding dietitians (21%) worked in multiple positions. Clinics and facilities that employ dietitians for limited part-time positions (e.g. one day a week) may find that such positions become increasingly difficult to fill as the workforce declines. If this happens, critical work undertaken by dietitians will not be done. Alternatively, under qualified nutrition practitioners may be hired to replace dietitians, increasing public risk. In an average week in 2015, 57% of respondents worked more hours than they were paid for (up from 18% in 2008 4 ), primarily to meet patient/client needs (77%). Respondents also worked the extra, unpaid hours to complete administrative tasks (69%), to compensate for lack of sick or vacation relief (27%) or to act as a preceptor for students (24%). This demonstrates that there is high demand for the existing services and indicates there are not enough employment positions to address current workload issues or enough dietitians to sufficiently meet client/patient needs. More than half (54%) of the dietitians did not have any relief dietitian coverage for absences greater than three consecutive days (up from 45% in 2008). Only 7% had their position fully covered and 39% had emergency or partial coverage. Respondents stated that full relief coverage was not provided due to lack of funding and lack of available relief staff. This is concerning as 70% of the respondents primary employment was in a unionized dietitian position which typically involves direct patient care. Lack of relief coverage has a direct effect on patient care as medical nutrition therapy is delayed or not provided. Patients with poor nutrition status prior to surgery are at increased risk of poor outcomes and complications that can lead to increased length of stay in hospital 9,10. DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 2

Figure 3: Decreasing capacity in the BC dietetic workforce: Dietitians workload and relief coverage 2008 2015 Working extra, unpaid hours 18% 57% No Relief Coverage 45% 54% Almost one-third of all survey respondents indicated they might leave their current position in the next year, most often to work in a different practice area or for career advancement. This movement within the workforce is desirable, but difficult to manage when at full capacity as positions inevitably sit vacant during transitions, leaving services unfulfilled. WHAT IS THE POTENTIAL ATTRITION? Over half (56%) of the respondents over the age of 55 were planning on retiring from their current positions within three years and almost all (95%) were planning to retire in fewer than ten years. This would translate into 120 dietitians in BC retiring within the next three years 10% of the workforce based on the CDBC database, which has 215 registrants aged 55 to 64. In addition to these retirements, 3% indicated that they are planning to leave their current position in the next year because they no longer want to work in dietetics, which could amount to an additional 111 dietitians leaving the BC workforce within three years. This amounts to about 230 dietitians exiting the workforce within three years. Over half (56%) of the respondents over the age of 55 were planning on retiring from their current positions within three years. Figure 4: Timing of planned retirement of dietitian respondents over the age of 55 10 or more years 4% Within 1 year 15% 5 to 9 years 30% In 2 years 20% in 4 years 10% In 3 years 21% DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 3

The average number of dietitians entering into the BC workforce as UBC graduates, internationally trained and migrating from other provinces was 4% (43 per year as measured by new registrants with the CDBC), which is lower than the national average of 6% 11. The slow growth rate of the BC dietetic workforce contributes to its existing limited capacity. The anticipated retirements and departures from dietetics will result in a further shortfall within three years of approximately 100 dietitians in BC. This will make it difficult to The anticipated retirements and departures from dietetics will result in a further shortfall within three years of approximately 100 dietitians in BC. maintain existing services and leaves no opportunity to meet the increased demand for dietetic services related to government priorities and population growth which is forecasted to be sizable in some parts of the province. WHERE ARE DIETITIANS CURRENTLY WORKING? Most survey respondents worked in the Vancouver/Coastal area (32%), followed by the Fraser Valley (28%), Vancouver Island (20%), the Interior (9%) and the North (4%). Figure 5 illustrates how the survey responses align with the size of the population served. In addition, 5% of dietitians worked in a provincial role and less than 1% worked in other provinces, nationally, or internationally. These results do not necessarily reflect actual positions, as participation in the survey was voluntary. However, there is currently no accurate data that better captures the regional distribution of all dietitians in BC. Figure 5: Geographic distribution of survey responses, compared to population distribution % of BC population in Region % of BC Dietitians based on survey respondents 32% 35% 26% 28% 17% 20% 16% 9% 6% 5% Vancouver/Coastal Fraser Valley Vancouver Island Interior North DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 4

Figure 6 shows that health authorities were the most frequently cited primary employer (73%), followed by selfemployment (8%), private facilities (6%), provincial government (3%) and post-secondary academic institutes (2%). Other employers included industry, private facilities/clinics, and non-profit organizations. Provincial Government 3% Private Facilities 6% Figure 6: Employers of survey respondents Post Secondary Academic Institutes 2% Other 8% Self Employment 8% Health Authorities 73% For respondents with a second employment position, self-employment was most common (30%), followed by health authorities, private facilities, post-secondary academic institutes and community agencies. About one-half (48%) of responding dietitians indicated that their primary area of practice was providing nutrition care in a hospital setting. Sixteen percent of respondents worked in residential care, 9% in public and population health, and 8% in health care administration (Figure 7). BC s primary care home model is built around interdisciplinary teams and functions, yet only 3% of dietitians reported working in primary care services associated with a physician s office. This is the equivalent of about 36 BC dietitians working in primary care compared to over 500 dietitians on family health teams and in community health centres in Ontario 5 suggesting the dietitian role in team-based care in a primary care setting is under-utilized in BC. An additional 3% provided nutrition counseling not associated with a physician's office, demonstrating more opportunity to integrate dietitians within primary care as part of the interdisciplinary team in the Primary Care Home model. This is the equivalent of about 36 BC dietitians working in primary care compared to over 500 dietitians on family health teams and in community health centres in Ontario. DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 5

Only 4% of respondents indicated a role in home and community care, 4% in mental health and addictions or substance abuse, and 2% in Aboriginal health. This is concerning as there are insufficient dietitians positioned to support these vulnerable populations which have been identified as priority areas for the BC government 3. Figure 7: Areas of practice Healthcare Administration 8% Primary Care (public & private) 6% Mental Health & Addictions 4% Aboriginal Health 2% Food Services/ Industry 3% Public Health 9% Hospitals 48% Home & Community Care 4% Residential Care 16% HOW IS DIETITIAN CLIENT CARE TIME ALIGNED WITH BC GOVERNMENT PRIORITIES? The BC dietetics workforce grew by an average of 2% per year (2009 to 2013), which is half the national average of 4% per year 11. This slower growth in the dietetic workforce negatively impacts the profession s ability to meet BC government priorities. Targeting services to key population segments The BC Ministry of Health divides the population into key segments according to health status and service use 3. Respondents were asked to indicate how they allocate their client care time amongst these population segments. Three quarters of responding dietitians (76%) provided direct client care. Respondents client care time focused on populations with highly complex chronic conditions and the frail and elderly in residential care. This is consistent with the previously cited areas of practice, which identified hospitals and residential care facilities as the largest employers of dietitians. The lack of dietitian services for this population [frail elderly] in community settings is reflective of the small number (4%) of respondents working in home and community care. DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 6

In Canada, 45% per cent of older adults admitted to hospital medical and surgical units are malnourished 6, 55% in BC 7, increasing length of stay and associated health care costs. And yet, no BC dietitians reported having the majority of their time dedicated to serving the frail elderly in the community to mitigate and prevent malnutrition. The lack of dietitian services for this population in community settings is reflective of the small number (4%) of respondents working in home and community care. As experts advising on diet, food and nutrition, dietitians have an important role in mental health promotion, disease prevention and treatment of mental health conditions 8 yet very few BC dietitians are employed in mental health and addictions or substance abuse (4%). Populations receiving the least amount of dietitian time were: pregnant women, healthy newborns, healthy individuals, and people in end of life care. There were also minimal direct nutrition interventions by dietitians to promote healthy growth and development, and to prevent disease. Dietitians play a critical role in providing evidence-based nutrition information to the public. The shortage of dietitians and replacement of dietitians with unregulated nutrition practitioners in the province means many British Columbians lack access to credible nutrition information. This threatens the ability to implement provincial healthy eating priorities, including increasing vegetable and fruit intake, and the ability to achieve meaningful improved outcomes for population and patient health as part of the Ministry s strategic agenda Access to health care in rural and remote communities The BC Ministry of Health has made a commitment to improve access to health care in rural and remote communities, recognizing that one of the challenges is less availability of health care providers. Survey respondents were asked how much time they worked (excluding travel) in settings with defined sizes of population. Most of the direct client care time provided by dietitians was in large and urban settings with a population of over 75,000 residents. When direct client care dietetic services were provided to small urban, rural, small rural or remote areas, it was most often less than half a day per week. This suggests that there is limited to no full time work for dietitians to provide direct client care in more rural and remote communities. This notion is reinforced by responses when asked to describe situations where there were difficult-to-fill positions and to provide insights as to why recruitment to these positions was challenging. Almost half (45%) thought that a limiting factor was insufficient work to sustain a living (for self or partner), followed by the type of work (34%), the location being in a remote area or in isolation (30%), the salary (19%) and lack of mentors in the area (11%). Expansion of services related to government priorities and population growth is forecasted to be sizable in some large and urban parts of the province. Additional dietitian positions are anticipated to provide the nutrition care necessary for effective services and improved outcomes for patient health. This will further challenge rural and remote communities to successfully recruit for their positions. WHERE WERE DIETITIANS TRAINED? Over half of all survey respondents (53%) completed their training in BC (up from 49% in 2008), followed by Alberta (14%), Ontario (8%) and Saskatchewan (6%). Four percent of respondents were internationally trained and primarily came from the United States and Australia. This is consistent with the finding that BC relies on registrants from other jurisdictions to meet almost 40% of their supply requirements, compared to the national average of 36% 11. DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 7

HOW IS THE FUTURE DIETETICS WORKFORCE AFFECTED BY CURRENT EDUCATION AND TRAINING IN BC? The only nationally accredited dietetics program in BC is the University of British Columbia (UBC) Dietetics Major, which is situated within the Faculty of Land and Food Systems at UBC Vancouver. UBC oversees the campus-based and the internship practicum curriculum and provides province wide support; however, the health authorities manage coordination of the site-based placements. As of September 2015, this UBC program admits up to 36 students each year, an insufficient number of graduates to address workforce demands. BC currently relies on registrants from other jurisdictions to meet almost 40% of their supply requirements 11. This level of out of province recruitment is not sustainable. The health authorities are at or are near capacity within existing resources to coordinate student placements and to support dietitians who preceptor dietetic interns, limiting the ability to expand the UBC program. There is an opportunity to address recruitment challenges and expand the capacity of our future workforce because BC retains a high percentage (an average of 82%) of their graduates 11. When respondents were asked what would be helpful for them to start preceptoring dietetic interns or preceptoring more interns, the most frequent response was partial relief to cover some of the workload, followed by being asked to be a preceptor, partnering with another dietitian to share the workload, and increased training for preceptors. A key theme from survey respondents comments was that preceptoring students/interns is not valued or supported by management (particularly non-dietitian managers). UBC program admits up to 36 students each year. BC retains a high percentage (an average of 82%) of their graduates. How Does the BC Dietetic Workforce Compare to Other Provinces? The BC dietetics workforce has grown by an average of 2% per year half the national average of 4% 11. This slow growth rate has contributed to the limited capacity within the dietetic workforce. The 2012 Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) data showed that BC and Ontario had 25 dietitians per 100,000 population, the lowest ratios in the country and less than the national average of 30 dietitians per 100,0006 (Figure 8). Figure 8: CIHI (2012) Dietitians in Canada per 100,000 population 25 28 30 31 25 36 44 56 45 34 30 BC AB SK MB ON QC NB NS PE NL AVG # dietitians per 100,000 DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 8

Another comparison that can be made with other provinces is the number of training spots for dietitians relative to the size of the existing workforce. This is an indicator that reflects the province s local capacity to match attrition, expand and provide needed services. In 2011, BC had the lowest training capacity in Canada (Figure 9). Figure 9: CIHI (2012) Dietetic training capacity in Canada 34% 24% 11% 8% 7% 6% 6% 6% 3% PEI NS MB ON SK QC NB AB BC Percent Training Capacity Conclusion The BC dietetic workforce is at capacity. With the anticipated retirements and departures from dietetics, there will be a further shortfall of 100 dietitians in BC within the next three years, making it difficult to maintain existing services and leaving no opportunity to meet the increased demand for dietetic services related to government priorities and population growth. There are considerable differences among provinces regarding their ability to meet the need for qualified dietitians, their reliance on dietitians from other jurisdictions, and trends in new graduate mobility. Compared to other provinces, British Columbia has the fewest dietitians per capita, the least dietetic graduates relative to the size of the workforce, and the slowest workforce growth. However, there is good retention; once registered in BC, dietitians tend to stay, as do BC graduates. The dietetic workforce issues identified are relevant to Dietitians of Canada-BC Region, the BC Ministry of Health, Health Authorities, the University of British Columbia, and the College of Dietitians of BC. It is important that these groups consider the issues and collaborate on a plan of action that addresses the health needs of British Columbians. DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 9

References 1 British Dietetic Association (2015). Know Your Worth Trust a Dietitian. Impact of Nutrition and Dietetic Service. http://www.trustadietitian.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/impact-of-nutrition-and-dietetic-service.pdf\ 2 American Dietetic Association (2007) Healthy Land, Healthy People. Building a Better Understanding of Sustainable Food Systems for Food and Nutrition Professionals http://www.hendpg.org/docs/sustainable_primer.pdf 3 BC Ministry of Health (2014) Setting Priorities for the BC Health System http://www.health.gov.bc.ca/library/publications/year/2014/setting-priorities-bc-health-feb14.pdf 4 Dietitians of Canada (2008) Workforce Analysis of Dietitians in British Columbia http://www.dietitians.ca/member/resources-from-a-z/health-human-resources/workforce-analysis-of-dietitiansin-bc.aspx 5 Dietitians of Canada (2015). The Dietitian in Ontario Primary Health Care Survey Report. http://www.dietitians.ca/downloads/public/2015-ontario-phc-rd-workforce-survey-report.aspx 6 Allard, J.P., Keller, H., Khursdheed, N.J., et al. Malnutrition at Hospital Admission Contributors and Effect on Length of Stay: A Prospective Cohort Study from the Canadian Malnutrition Task Force. Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition, 2015, pp. 1-11. doi 0148607114567902 7 Vesnaver E, Keller H. (2015). Canadian Malnutrition Task Force Individual Site Report: Nanaimo Regional General Hospital (unpublished data). 8 Dietitians of Canada (2012). Promoting Mental Health Through Healthy Eating and Nutritional Care. Retrieved from http://www.dietitians.ca/downloads/public/nutrition-and-mental-health-complete-2012.aspx 9 Ionescu, D. (2011). Implementing fast track in modern surgical practice: focus on colorectal surgery and nutritional aspects. Nutritional Therapy & Metabolism. 29(4):168-177. http://www.erassociety.org/ 10 Abdelhamid, Y., Chapman, M. and Deane, A. (2016). Peri-operative nutrition. Anaesthesia. 71(Suppl. 1); 9-18. 11 Dietitians of Canada (2016) Registered Dietitians in Canada A Compilation of Provincial Workforce Data http://www.dietitians.ca/downloads/public/compilation-of-provincial-workforce-data-jan2016.aspx DIETITIANS OF CANADA I PAGE 10

1 British Dietetic Association (2015). Know Your Worth Trust a Dietitian. Impact of Nutrition and Dietetic Service. http://www.trustadietitian.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/impact-of-nutrition-and-dietetic-service.pdf\ 2 American Dietetic Association (2007) Healthy Land, Healthy People. Building a Better Understanding of Sustainable Food Systems for Food and Nutrition Professionals http://www.hendpg.org/docs/sustainable_primer.pdf 3 BC Ministry of Health (2014) Setting Priorities for the BC Health System http://www.health.gov.bc.ca/library/publications/year/2014/setting-priorities-bc-health-feb14.pdf 4 Dietitians of Canada (2008) Workforce Analysis of Dietitians in British Columbia http://www.dietitians.ca/member/resources-from-a-z/health-human-resources/workforce-analysis-of-dietitians-in- BC.aspx 5 Dietitians of Canada (2015). The Dietitian in Ontario Primary Health Care Survey Report. http://www.dietitians.ca/downloads/public/2015-ontario-phc-rd-workforce-survey-report.aspx 6 Allard, J.P., Keller, H., Khursdheed, N.J., et al. Malnutrition at Hospital Admission Contributors and Effect on Length of Stay: A Prospective Cohort Study from the Canadian Malnutrition Task Force. Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition, 2015, pp. 1-11. doi 0148607114567902 7 Vesnaver E, Keller H. (2015). Canadian Malnutrition Task Force Individual Site Report: Nanaimo Regional General Hospital (unpublished data). 8 Dietitians of Canada (2012). Promoting Mental Health Through Healthy Eating and Nutritional Care. Retrieved from http://www.dietitians.ca/downloads/public/nutrition-and-mental-health-complete-2012.aspx 9 Ionescu, D. (2011). Implementing fast track in modern surgical practice: focus on colorectal surgery and nutritional aspects. Nutritional Therapy & Metabolism. 29(4):168-177. http://www.erassociety.org/ 10 Abdelhamid, Y., Chapman, M. and Deane, A. (2016). Peri-operative nutrition. Anaesthesia. 71(Suppl. 1); 9-18. 11 Dietitians of Canada (2016) Registered Dietitians in Canada A Compilation of Provincial Workforce Data http://www.dietitians.ca/downloads/public/compilation-of-provincial-workforce-data-jan2016.aspx