Telemedicine and Health Reform Jonathan Neufeld, PhD Clinical Director Upper Midwest Telehealth Resource Center 1
telehealthresourcecenters.org Links to all TRCs National Webinar Series Reimbursement, Marketing, and Training Tools
UMTRC Services Presentations & Trainings Consultation Technical Assistance Connections with other programs Program Design and Evaluation Information on current legislative and policy developments
Definitions and Concepts - I Telehealth and Telemedicine Sometimes used interchangeably Two types of distinctions - Telemedicine = billable interactive clinical services Telehealth = Broader field of distance health activities (CME, etc.) Clinical remote monitoring (usually at home)
Basic Concept
Explosion of Health Services Patients, doctors, hospitals, pharmacies Nursing homes Specialty hospitals, surgery centers, etc. Purchasers, wellness services Internet, PDAs, cell phones Lifestyle drugs and services Social networks, ubiquitous communication Any service, any place, any time.
Historical Snapshot of Telemedicine Used at Nebraska Psychiatric Institute in 1955 Developed extensively by NASA in 1960 s VA started in 1990 s CCHT Program Pilot in VISN 8 in 2003 63% reduction in ER visits, 88% reduction in SNF days 2012 Utilization: 0.5 M patients; 1.5 M episodes Added by Medicare in 1996 (multiple updates) Regulations requiring Medicaid and commercial coverage in states began about the same time Wave of equipment and program grants, projects
Definitions and Concepts - II TM is not a service, but a delivery mechanism for health care services Most TM services duplicate in-person care Some are made better or possible with TM Reimbursement equal to in-person care
Definitions and Concepts - III New payment model conundrum Many of the benefits of TM are only available under new payment models Motivations of FFS are unaligned Example: Home Monitoring Increase adherence Reduce re-hospitalizations Improve outcomes *** Billing FFS for monitoring fails ***
Getting Value from Telehealth Strategies Dependent Upon: Revenue Stream Cost Avoidance Shared Savings Improved Quality **Each may appeal to different stakeholders
Recent Headline Telemedicine helps hospitals double revenue.
A Better Type of Value Triple Aim: Better Care Better Health Lower Cost Patients have a better experience They (all) get healthier It all costs less (to everyone)
Future Health Care Outcome goal: population health Overall and within target sub-populations Measure: inpatient days per 1000 Healthier people stay out of the hospital Intervention targets: Patient engagement in self-care, bio trends Pt knowledge, skills, attitudes, behaviors
Future Health Care Providers will be accountable for patient behaviors (or at least patient engagement) How does Telemedicine fit in?
Telemedicine Reimbursement (FFS) Medicare Limited CPTs Rural areas Medicaid State-specific IN, IL, MI yes; OH no (but possible soon) Private Payers Most provide coverage similar to Medicare
New Models of Reimbursement Direct Contracts Managed Care ACOs Work Site Clinics Vertical Integration
Re-ordering the Clinical Enterprise
Three Basic Types or Domains Hospitals & Specialties Specialists see and manage patients remotely Integrated Care Mental health and other specialists work in primary care settings (e.g., PCMH s, ACO s) Transitions & Monitoring Patients access care (or care accesses patients) where and when needed to avoid complications and higher levels of care
Value Varies by Domain Hospital & Specialty Care Market aggregation, using the long tail Integrated Primary Care and Health Homes Service aggregation, one stop shopping Transitions Continuity, engagement, momentum Right service, right place, right time.
New Challenge Right service, right place, right time. Right for what? Or for whom? Right Goal? Right Outcome Measure? Maybe research can tell us
Research Context 20+ years of rigorous research (varies) 11 current standards/guidelines documents Summary of Findings: When used appropriately, medical care delivered via telemedicine is as effective as satisfactory (to patients and providers) as efficient as the same services delivered via traditional inperson medical care.
Caveats: Research Context 1. Every telemedicine program is different 2. Some telemedicine services are novel (most are not) 3. Some services offset other services 4. Not all medical treatments are effective (but we still provide them)
Value Factors 1. Payment: FFS vs. Risk-based/Alternative 2. Medical Staff: Salaried vs. Independent 3. Treatment Focus: Chronic vs. Acute Care 4. Temporal Horizon: Present vs. Future
A Lesson from Psychotherapy The Therapeutic Alliance: Therapist and patient respect each other Therapist and patient like each other Therapist and patient agree on goals Most therapeutic outcome is predicted by these three factors.
Session Rating Scale (v 3.0)
Federal Telemedicine Law & Policy Professionals are regulated at the state level (doctors, nurses, counselors, etc.) Medicare: Pays for certain outpatient professional services (CPT codes) for patients accessing care in rural counties and HPSAs in rural census tracts. *No regs; only conditions of payment. Medicaid: Telemedicine is a cost-effective alternative to the more traditional face-to-face way of providing medical care that states can choose to cover.
Indiana Telemedicine Law & Policy Medical Board/Licensure Indiana medical license includes: Providing diagnostic or treatment services to a person in Indiana when the diagnostic or treatment services: are transmitted through electronic communications; and are on a regular, routine, and non-episodic basis or under an oral or written agreement to regularly provide medical services.
Indiana Telemedicine Law & Policy Prescribing Except in institutional settings, on-call situations, cross-coverage situations, and [when supervising NPs], a physician shall not prescribe, dispense, or otherwise provide, or cause to be provided, any legend drug that is not a controlled substance to a person who the physician has never personally physically examined and diagnosed unless the physician is providing care in consultation with another physician who has an ongoing professional relationship with the patient, and who has agreed to supervise the patient's use of the drug or drugs to be provided.
Indiana Telemedicine Law & Policy Medicaid Reimbursement (April 1, 2007) The member must be present and able to participate in the visit. The audio and visual quality of the transmission must meet the needs of the physician located at the hub site. When ongoing services are provided, the member should be seen by a physician for a traditional clinical evaluation at least once a year, unless otherwise stated in policy. In addition, the hub physician should coordinate with the patient s primary care physician.
Indiana Telemedicine Law & Policy Medicaid Reimbursable Codes Consultations 99241 to 99245 and 99251 to 99255 Office or other outpatient visit 99201 to 99205 and 99211 to 99215 Individual psychotherapy 90832 to 90840 Psychiatric diagnostic interview 90791, 90792 End stage renal disease services (ESRD) G0308, G0309, G0311, G0312, G0314, G0315, G0317, and G0318 90862 deprecated; replaced by E&M codes
Indiana Telemedicine Law & Policy Documentation 1. Documentation must indicate the services were rendered via telemedicine. 2. Documentation must clearly indicate the location of the hub and spoke sites. 3. All other IHCP documentation guidelines for services rendered via telemedicine apply, for example chart notes and start and stop times. Documentation must be available for post-payment review.
Indiana Telemedicine Law & Policy Documentation 4. Providers must have written protocols for circumstances when the member must have a hands-on visit with the consulting provider. The member should always be given the choice between a traditional clinical encounter versus a telemedicine visit. Appropriate consent from the member must be obtained by the spoke site and maintained at the hub and spoke sites.
Indiana Telemedicine Law & Policy Medicaid Special Conditions IHCP reimburses for telemedicine services, only when the hub and spoke sites are greater than 20 miles apart. Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHC) or Rural Health Clinics (RHC) are only reimbursed for handson services and are therefore not permitted to bill for telemedicine services.
Indiana Telemedicine Law & Policy EA 554 (effective July 1, 2013) Medicaid will reimburse home health agencies for telehealth services Use of telecommunications and information technology to provide access to health assessment, diagnosis, intervention, consultation, supervision, and information across a distance. Medicaid will reimburse FQHCs and RHCs for telemedicine services Medicaid will reimburse regardless of distance between provider and patient
Review of Key Points TM is a delivery mechanism, not a service TM usually replicates in-person care TM provides multiple types of value TM value is embedded in larger movements in health care Reimbursement is now available for Indiana RHCs and FQHCs (awaiting regs) Licensed home health agencies will be reimbursed for telehealth (monitoring) services.
Contact Information Jonathan Neufeld, PhD (574) 606-5038 jneufeld@indianarha.org www.telehealthresourcecenters.org