Architecture for Coalition Cooperation Navy Surface Warfare Future Readiness RDML James P. McManamon Statement A: Approved for Public Release; Distribution is unlimited 24 January 2011 1
Team Ships Organization PROGRAM EXECUTIVE OFFICER SHIPS RDML DAVE LEWIS SWE SUPPORT DEPUTY COMMANDER FOR SURFACE WARFARE RDML JAMES McMANAMON PEO STAFF SURFACE WARFARE DIRECTORATE COMBATANTS OFFICE AMPHIBIOUS & AUXILIARY SEALIFT OFFICE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FLEET READINESS SEA 21A SHIPS ACQUISITION MANAGEMENT OFFICE DIRECTOR DEPUTY DIRECTOR PMS 377 LHD8 / LCAC / LHAR / AADS COMMANDING OFFICER SURFACE SHIP ENGINEERING PLANNING PROGRAM (SURFMEPP) DEPUTY PMS 400D DDG51 PMS 317 LPD-1 7/ JCC(X) PMS 400F CGs / FFGs / DDG51s PMS 500 DDG 1000 PMS 501 LCS PMS 502 CG(X) PMS 325 AUXILIARY SHIPS / SMALL BOATS & CRAFTS PMS 385 STRATEGIC AND THEATER SEALIFT PMS 470 AMPHIBIOUS /AUXILIARY/MINE PMS 333 INACTIVE SHIPS/ SHIP TRANSFERS PMS 326 INTERNATIONAL FLEET SUPPORT PMS 333/336 INACTIVE SHIPS/ SHIP TRANSFERS INACTIVE SHIPS SHIP TRANSFERS 2
PMS 326 Business Base PMS 326 Business Base Total Case Value (TCV) $4.7B Total Capital Avail (TCA) $296.9M Follow on Technical Support (FOTS) Cases TCV $2.778B / TCA $192.2M Combat Systems Cases TCV $2.149B / TCA $76.89M Other Miscellaneous Cases TCV $311.2M / TCA $27.8M Serving as TYCOM to the World s Fleet by adapting USN processes to meet FMS requirements Actively supporting ~150 ships representing 23 countries:» Several ex-usn ships plus foreign built with USN combat systems» Additional countries with stand alone systems (Radar, CIWS, SLQ32, etc.) Legacy Support is provided on >25 different combat systems in 16 countries» Includes AAW, ASUW, ASW, and EW» Includes ASROC, MK 92 FCS, CIWS Blk 0 International FFG Working Group (IFWG) SHIPYARD Upgrades Industrial Training Program Port Engineer OTHER FACILITIES FACDAR Land-based Radar Systems Land-based Test Sites FUNCTIONS International TYCOM Engineering Tech Support Ship Platform/FOTS Overall Program/Project Management $107.4M DSRA / PMA Planning and Execution Maintenance Support Combat Systems Systems Upgrade Coastal and Radar/ Integration Configuration Mgmt/Supply Other & Material Support $63.5M HM&E Support / Upgrades Software, Pubs, Manuals /Training Infrastructure Legacy Systems PLATFORMS Current/ex-USN: FFG 7, MHC, FF1052, LST, LSD, KIDD, LCAC Future: LPD, Ticonderoga Indigenous: DD, DE, DDH, PFG, PCG, PGG, MEKO, DDG, SA AR 5 Other International: Corvette/Frigate Class Ships 3
Product Lines International Fleet Support COMPETENCIES Program/Project Management Financial Management Operation and Maintenance Tech Services Ship Overhaul Support Services Engineering and Logistics PLATFORMS Current/ex-USN: FFG 7, MHC, FF1052, LST, LSD, KIDD, LCAC Indigenous: DD, DE, DDH, PFG, PCG, PGG, MEKO, DDG, SA AR 5 Other International: Corvette/ Frigate Class Ships SHIPYARD Upgrades Industrial Training Program Port Engineers IMA/ISEA Development/Support OTHER FACILITIES FACDAR Land-based Radar Systems Land-based Test Sites FUNCTIONS International TYCOM Engineering Tech Support Overall Program / Project Management DSRA / PMA Planning and Execution Maintenance Support Systems Upgrade and Integration Configuration Mgmt Material Support HM&E Support / Upgrades Software, Pubs, Manuals OJT and Country Tailored Training Infrastructure Legacy Systems 4
Follow On Technical Support Program Representative Process for Technical Support Services FOTS Request from Foreign Customer FOTS Request for Technical Assistance Non-USN Supported Equipt/Systems PMS 326 USN Supported Equipt/Systems Engineering Services Supportability Contract USN Fleet Support Activities Operational and Maintenance Training Sonar Dome X-Ray MTT/LOA 1200 PSI Propulsion Systems Boiler / SSDG / HM&E / LST LM2500 Tech Services NSWCDD-SSES General /Special Tech Support Regional Maintenance Centers Industrial Upgrade Equip / ALT Kitting / Spares Navy Inventory Control Point Industrial Upgrade Tech Assist Puget Sound Naval Shipyard Routine Boiler Inspections Job Planning Spvsr Welding and NDT Boilermaker HM&E - Auxiliary Systems Electronic Warfare / MSO NSWC Crane Surveillance / C2 / ASW NUWC Keyport Communications NAWC-AD St. Indigoes NSDC Dam Neck Configuration Data Panama City Coastal Defense Mk 13 & Mk 26 GMLS Mk 42 5 /54 Gun Systems MK 74 & Mk 68 Gun Fire Control Systems AN/SQS-26 CX & Other Sonar Systems AN/SQS-26 Sonar Dome Rubber Window Replacements TARTAR, Mk 13, MK 92 NSWC-PHD Tech Doc NSWC-PHD NSDSA / ISEA RAST / HRS / SGSI / VLA NAWC Lakehurst HM&E / Combat Systems OEMs PARMs Training Devices NAWC-TSD Orlando Calibration NWAD-PHD Corona Mk 75 Gun Systems NSWC ORDSTA Louisville AN/SQR-17 / AN-SQR-19 AN/SQS-56 PMS 411 5
Initiatives International Frigate Working Group (IFWG) A First Step May 2009 Inaugural IFWG Meeting hosted and chaired by USN May 2010 - Second IFWG Meeting hosted and chaired by Turkey October 2010 IFWG SMART Logistics Team Meeting May 2011 3 rd IFWG Meeting NAS North Island, San Diego CA Participation and leadership at the flag level Several countries briefed major modernization programs Identified opportunities for sharing technology and significant cost savings Charter established, now nine navies Stepped forward in shared logistics Underway demo of Turkey s GENESIS combat management system Limited industry participation NAVICP Mechanicsburg Key opportunity for modernizing future material support Established SMART Acquisition and Inventory Management Team (Turkey & USN lead) Opportunities for shared International logistics Procurement, Sharing, Asset Visibility Interim meeting to be hosted by NAVICP in October 2010 Third Party Transfer Process (USN lead) Pre-approval by US State Dept for transfer of parts & data between IFWG countries DoS coordinating USG interagency review Future with and after SM-1 (USN lead) Explore practical implementation of FFG-7 Anti-Air Warfare modernization Examine broader applicability of Turkish Navy ESSM and RAN SM-2 Blk IIIB programs Standard Missile MK56 Dual Thrust Rocket Motor (DTRM) (RAN & USN lead) Address common concerns: Cost and uncertainty of sustaining viable SM-1 DTRM Explore affordable options Other Initiatives Configuration and Modernization Data Base (Spain lead) Green Ship Initiative (USN lead) Awareness of international responsibilities to operate and maintain our ships in an environmentally conscious manner 6
FMS vs DCS DCS - Management U.S. Government only involved in export license review Procurement contract between U.S. industry & foreign government Contractor directly interfaces with customer No U.S. Government involvement Disputes resolved by foreign government Report to Congress if sale meets 36(c), AECA DCS Financial May represent more risk for seller Freedom from FAR & DFARS may reduce cost Less than economic quantity purchase Commercial banking procedures Prompt incremental and final billing Prompt contract closure FMS - Management DoD Program management Leave the driving to us Experienced personnel familiar with the equipment FMS charges for this management service Administrative Surcharge & Non-Recurring costs Contract administration services (CAS) Defined Services Lines FMS - Financial LOA estimated prices What will the actual cost be? Will LOA payment schedule match actual execution performance profile? When will the case be closed? USG consolidates purchases for better prices Prompt & reliable payments to contractor 7
Surface Ship End-to-End Process Map, Maintenance & Modernization Process Gaps Assessment Plan/Policy IMA Capacity/ Capability Sustainment Program SURFMEPP Avail Execution/Wor k Certification Need for Integrated Assessment Program Need for Integrated Sustainment Program SSLCM scope limitations No Maintenance Material Management Need for sufficiently Engineered Work Packages Availability Schedule Milestones Maintenance and Modernization Integration Establish appropriate Avail Type, Schedule and Duration Insufficient IT support systems Work Package Development, Logistics Lack of QA oversight Reconstitution of IMA Capacity/Capability I Level No Existing Avail Completion/Work Certification Process Gaps Identified 8
Surface Ship Readiness Initiative (SSRI) Fleet Intro Expected Service Life Decom Assess Ship TSRA Continuous Sustainment Process Maintain Readiness Sustainment Execute Avail. Avail Ex. & Work Cert Plan Maintenance SURFMEPP Assessments: Skilled techs performing documented procedures Utilize NMD & other tools Mission specific focus SURFMEPP: Class Maint. Planning Availability Planning Maint. Planning Data Systems Cost Engineering Material Management Avail Ex. & Work Cert: Technical Adjudication of work Event Readiness Test & Certification of work Sustainment: Maintenance Engineering Performance Monitoring Fleet Engineering Support Training & Tech. Docs Obsolescence 9
MAJOR DELIVERABLES 5 - PHASED APPROACH ONGOING TFs READINESS SEA 21 READINESS TASK FORCES COORDINATED + Readiness is defined as the ability of forces, units, weapons systems, or equipments to deliver the outputs for which they are designed. CORE ELEMENTS + Optimal Readiness + READINESS = f(p,e,s,t) HISTORICAL READINESS TRENDS + Task Force Mission: Perform a coordinated, comprehensive, holistic assessment of a system or Class of Ships and develop Actionable Readiness Recommendations. AWS-SPY - 48 Actionable Recommendations - Phase: 5 Phase1: Issue Extrapolation Scope Readiness Task Force Mission Assess Impact and Severity of System Issues MCM CLASS - 51 Actionable Recommendations - Phase: 5 Phase 2: Needs / Requirements Assessment Metrics Deep Dive Evaluation of Current System Requirements Needs Assessment of non-existing requirements Phase 3: Gap Analysis Issues identified in Phase 1 evaluated against system requirements Preliminary Recommendations Formulated LPD 17 CLASS - 100+ Draft Recommendations - Phase: 3 Phase 4: Alternative Analysis and Solution Selection Historical study analysis Alternative solution identification Integration of historical data with preliminary recommendations Feasibility Assessment BMD MISSION - 50+ Draft Recommendations - Phase: 3 Phase 5: Implementation and Control Develop concise Implementation Plan Monitor Execution Timeline Participants include (but not limited to): -USFF -CNSF -NAVPERS -SEA04 -SEA05 -SEA21 -PEO SHIPS -PEO IWS -NAMDC -NAVICP COMPREHENSIVE Obsolete Equipment Departures from Specifications Changes in system employment Adequacy of Training APL / AEL Accuracy 2M Repair Ability FIGHT SUSTAIN Factors Examined Spare Parts Support Past system alterations HOLISTIC Execute Mission Requirements -ISEAs -PYs -SUPSHIP -NAVMAC -CRMC -NSWCs -OPNAV -NAVSUP -CLASRONs -Others System aging factors COSAL Effectiveness LLTM Management ILS Documentation Self-sufficiently Sustain Operations Manning Reductions Past Studies Minimized on-thejob training Parts Obsolescence Metrics INSURV Scores Common Themes Deferred Maintenance Increased Reliance on shore-support Material Unavailability Root Cause Issues Requirements Analysis Readiness Issue Performance Evaluation Requirement Action Lead Preliminary Solution Issue A Requirement A Action Lead A Solution A Issue B Requirement B Action Lead B Solution B Issue C Requirement C Action Lead C Solution C Issue D Requirement D Action Lead D Solution D Issue E Requirement E Action Lead E Solution E Recommendation Selection Recommendation Execution Our Goal: Not to be a reference in a future Readiness study. J.P. McManamon MOBILIZE RESULTS Enable Ships to Get Underway The results of the TF effort will be referenced for years to come as the most comprehensive readiness study ever conducted. -VADM McCoy on AWS-SPY TF 10
AEGIS BMD Technology Evolution 11
PB11 DDGM & CGM Fielding Profiles 12
DDG Modernization Description Provide a comprehensive Modernization strategy for the DDG 51 class ships to ensure a mission relevant service life of 35 years Primary objective is to reduce workload and total ship class ownership costs via HM&E technology insertion and provide warfighting improvements Provides Multi-Mission Signal Processor (MMSP) BMD capability Supports a Force Structure requirement of 313 ships Applies to DDG 51 Class (Flight I & II First, DDG 51-78) 13
DDG Modernization Requirements C4I *NAVSSI BLK 4 *IFF Mode 5 CEC Warfighting Upgrades AAW CIC Display Upgrades Open Architecture Computing Plant VLS Modifications AWS ACB 12 Computer Program Multi-Mission SIGPRO SPY-1D Transmitter Upgrades Multi-Mission BMD SM6/NIFC-CA (IOC FY14) FCS STAMO Upgrades SHIP/FORCE PROTECTION ESSM *CIWS-1B *NULKA *SEWIP *SSTD (ATT) IOC FY13 MK 54 Torpedo/DFCI SQQ-89A(V)15 w/mfta GUN WEAPON SYSTEM MK-160 Mod X Gun Computing System HM&E Modernization Full IBNS Upgrade MCS/DCS Upgrades GEDMS Wireless Communications Digital Video Surveillance Quality of Life Upgrades Advanced Galley Mission Life Extension Upgrades 14