43rd Annual Guns & Missiles Symposium 21-24 April 2008 PGK and the Impact of Affordable Precision on the Fires Mission Doug Storsved Chief Systems Engineer ATK Advanced Weapons PGK Precision Guidance Kit Slide 1
Affordable Precision Possible Today Discussion Topics: PGK Program and Status Technology People Impact on Conducting Fire Missions with PGK Ideas on Modern Battlefield Roles of Conventional and Precision Munitions U.S. Army photo US Army Photo by Spc. Katherine M. Roth Strengthened Capability for the Warfighter Slide 2
155mm Artillery Effectiveness Gap Defined 2000 Why LCCM (Low Cost Competent Munition)? Conventional Munitions are Less Effective at Longer Ranges 1.00 Relative Effectiveness 0.80 0.60 0.40 0.20 Existing 155mm Projectile Inventory Conventional HE/DPICM Effectiveness Improvement Required Here 5 10 15 20 25 30 Gun-Target Range (KM) Stephen Pearcy (Ch, PMMD, FSAC), LCCM: More than Competent 6 th International Cannon Artillery Firepower Symposium, 21 June 2000 2004 Why CCF (Course Correcting Fuze)? CCF capability would significantly and economically enhance the accuracy of existing artillery projectiles both improving efficiency and decreasing the combat logistical burden. we should energetically and aggressively pursue development, testing, procurement, and fielding of this capability for our Soldiers. General Byrnes Commanding General of US Army Future Force Slide 3
Types of Precision Munitions Non-Precision (Area) Munition Precision Munition Precision Guided Munition Precision Smart Munition Non-Precision 100 X 10 X 1 X Precision Munition Precision Guided Precision Smart Munition/submunitions subject to all ballistic conditions on the way to the AIMPOINT. Munition corrects for ballistic conditions using guidance and control up to the AIMPOINT or submunitions dispense with terminal accuracy less than the lethal radius of effects. Submunitions are subject to ballistic conditions to the AIMPOINT. Munition senses coded energy reflected from a target and uses guidance and control to the TARGET. A laser designator in the loop is required for target designation. No inertial navigation or midcourse guidance. Munition/submunitions autonomously searches, detects, classifies, selects, and engages TARGET(s). Has a limited target discrimination capability. Mortars Artillery (Cannon, Rocket) Air-Delivered Munitions 120mm Mortar Ammunition M934 1 X 10 X 10 X 100 X XM395 PGMM 155mm Cannon-Fired Artillery Ammunition Unguided 155mm GPS-Guided PGK GPS-Guided Excalibur Approved for Public Release, POA 299-08, 22 CFR 125.4(b)(13) applicable 221mm Rocket-Launch Artillery Ammunition 178mm Rocket-Launch Artillery Ammunition GMLRS - Guided Multiple-Launch Rocket System PAM - Precision Attack Munition Slide 4
Affordable Precision Concept Studies Self-Guided (2D) ARTILLERY OBSERVER Course-Corrected (1D) ARTILLERY OBSERVER GPS TARGET GPS TARGET Range-Extended, GPS/INS Affordable Precision Technology Focuses On the Knee In the Cost/Accuracy Curve Terminally-Guided ARTILLERY Command-Guided GROUND TRACKING ARTILLERY Autoregistration GROUND TRACKING OR GPS TRANSLATOR ARTILLERY OBSERVER CMD LINK DESIGNATOR OBSERVER OBSERVER GPS ADJUSTED ROUNDS TARGET FIRST ROUND TARGET TARGET Munition Cost Self-Guided (2D) and Course-Corrected (1D) Terminally-Guided Command-Guided Any Practical GPS Application Must Have SASSM Autoregistration No Guidance No Guidance ARTILLERY ADJUSTED ROUNDS OBSERVER FIRST ROUND TARGET Adjusted Fire 0 50 100 150 200 250 Accuracy (mcep) Slide 5
Years of Technology Development Led to PGK CY93 1 2 3 4 CY94 CY95 CY96 CY97 CY98 CY99 CY00 CY01 CY02 CY03 CY04 CY05 CY06 CY07 CY08 CY09 CY10 CY11 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 LCCM: More Than Competent, Pearcy, 6 th International Cannon Artillery Firepower Symposium, June 2000 Development of a Course Correcting Fuze (CCF) Capability, US Army Memorandum, May 2004 PGK Down-Select, May 2007 PGK Production Decision, April 2009 Miniaturized GPS Receivers UK Technology Demos Demo At YPG Course Correcting Fuze 1-D Course Corrector Concepts 1-D ARL (Hollis) UK Team STAR 1-D+ BAE Systems CCF 2-D Course Corrector Concepts 2-D ACT II DAAE30-95-C-005 Canard Controlled 155mm Hybrid Course Corrector Concepts ONR Sponsored Demonstration Draper 2-D Demo At YPG CM-ATD LCCM Contracts Autoregistration Fuze 1-D+ Demo At YPG MEMS Inertial Sensors ATK IR&D 1D CCF Draper ATK 2-D 2-D NSWC-DD ANSR ATK IR&D 2-D 2D CCF NSWC-DD GIF A TECH DEMO Fly-Off at YPG US Patent B TD 10 months Precision Guidance Kit MILESTONE SDD SDD-Inc1 Production Ready 22 months C LRIP P1 SDD-Inc2 Q FRP-P2 P1 SPIRAL 2 P3 Slide 6
Precision Guidance Kit (PGK) What is PGK? GPS Guidance Kit with Fuzing Functions Replaces the standard 155mm artillery projectile fuze PGK GPS guidance greatly improves the accuracy of conventional artillery in the inventory 50m CEP vs. 175m CEP Maintains >90% of range capability of conventional projectile Requires no battery Has no one-shots or canard deployments Operational Benefits Reliable - one moving part Transforms existing artillery inventory into affordable precision weapons Uses COTS inertial sensors Improves combat effectiveness Full 2D Guidance to Impact Reduces collateral damage Reduces logistics footprint Slide 7
PGK Precision Guidance Kit for 155mm Ammunition PGK Video PGK Video Slide 8
PGK Field Testing Technical Demonstration Program Competitive Fly-Off 18 M549A1 Rounds @ 20.5 km Demonstrated < 50m CEP 83% Reliability 2D Guidance Has Potential To Be Very Precise (Repeatable) Round 88 (ATK 51) 19 April 2007 10:20 M795 M549A1 M107 Round 89 (ATK 25) Round 90 (ATK 47) 19 April 2007 10:34 19 April 2007 10:47 Early SDD Field Test Objectives: Expand Aerodynamic and Guidance Characterization of PGK across family of 155mm Projectiles Validate Consolidation and Packaging to SDD-1 Electronics Form Factor Confirm System Performance of Second Source GPS Supplier Slide 9
What Level of Precision is Needed? Area Munition 120m Radius Circle Open Area Housing Density Can Vary Widely Over Small Distances Between Terrain Elements Selecting Munitions with Increasing Levels of Precision May Be Most Cost-Effective Precision Guided Munition Mosque Densely-Packed Urban 10m Radius Circle Area Precision Munition 50m Radius Circle Sparsely-Packed Urban Slide 10
Logistics Cost is Driven by Tonnage/Volume 155mm Munitions Mix Can Be Established in the Field at the Fuze-Level, Not at the Munition-Level Unguided Conventional 155mm Projectiles Convert to a Precision Munition by Simply Replacing the Fuze with a PGK (Precision Guidance Kit) Precision Munition Precision Munition Area Munition PGK-1 Fuze Precision Munition Precision Smart Munition Area Munition Precision Guided Munition Projectile Propelling Charges M934 XM395 PGMM M795 M549 Conventional 155mm Projectiles with Standard Fuzes or with PGKs M982 Excalibur Precision Attack Munition (PAM) Guided Multiple Launch Rocket System (GMLRS) Slide 11
Non-Precision Conventional Mission Fuze Storage In-Bore & Flight Fire Control Solution Gun Azimuth & Quadrant Elevation Platform Receives Fire Mission Unpack Projectile US Army Photo US Army Photo Planning the Mission Propelling Charge 5km Reference Ballistic Trajectory Unpack Fuze Install Fuze on Projectile CMD 10km 15km Set Fuze CMD Preparing the Round Setting the Fuze Firing the Round From M777A2 20km Place Projectile on Ammo Tray Load & Ram Projectile Load Propellant 25km Target Aimpoint Close Breech Block Insert Initiator US Army Photo Fire Projectile Slide 12
Non-Precision Conventional Mission Fuze Storage In-Bore & Flight Platform Receives Fire Mission Unpack Projectile US Army Photo US Army Photo Planning the Mission 5km Reference Ballistic Trajectory Unguided Ballistic Trajectory Unpack Fuze Install Fuze on Projectile CMD 10km 15km 95m CEP Fuze Setting Set Fuze 112m CEP CMD Preparing the Round Setting the Fuze 20km Place Projectile on Ammo Tray Firing the Round From M777A2 139m CEP Load & Ram Projectile Load Propellant 25km BIP (Ballistic Impact Point) Area Close Breech Block Insert Initiator US Army Photo Fire Projectile Slide 13
Precision PGK Mission PGK with Cover Storage Setting In-Bore & Flight US Army Photo GPS Platform Receives Fire Mission Unpack Projectile PGK EPIAFS EPIAFS Setter Coil PIK Planning the PGK Mission 5km 10km 15km 20km 50m CEP Reference Ballistic Trajectory 50m CEP 2D Guided Trajectory Gun-Target Location Trajectory Information GPS Crypto Keys GPS Information Precise Time Fuze Setting Power Unpack PGK Install PGK on Projectile CMD Install EPIAFS Set PGK CMD Remove PGK Cover Place Projectile on Ammo Tray US Army Photo Load & Ram Projectile 50m CEP Load Propellant 25km BIP (Ballistic Impact Point) Area Close Breech Block Insert Initiator Fire Projectile Slide 14
Comparative 155mm Projectile Accuracies The Most Cost-Effective Munition Will Be Chosen Based on Mission Need: Target Defeat Capability Collateral Damage Risk 15 km 20 km 25 km 30 km 50 m 50 m 50 m 50 m 273 m PGK - M549A1 112 m 139 m 95 m All using 1/2 hour old Meteorological data M549A1 Circles represent accuracy in terms of CEP (Circular Error Probable) at different operational ranges from the firing platform Slide 15
Operational Benefit Today s Capability: 183m CEP* PGK: 50m CEP Gun-Target Line 27km Village Destroyed Refinery Destroyed Target May Have Been Hit Gun-Target Line 27km Target Destroyed Minimal Collateral Damage KV4201 50m radius circle Grid 100m squares Many Rounds Grid 100m squares Few Rounds * M109A6 (Paladin) at 27km: 155mm (HE) M549A1 Improves Munition Accuracy Greatly Reduces Possibility of Collateral Damage Increases Number of Kills per Basic Load of Ammunition Slide 16
PGK Missions Suppression Danger Close Counter-Battery Troops in Open PGK performs the same missions as conventional 155mm HE munitions, but with better effectiveness consistent with a 50m CEP accuracy. Slide 17
Precision Munition Analysis Case 1: Conventional Munitions: Conventional 155mm and 105mm artillery munitions Conventional 120mm mortar munitions 2006 Precision Munition Analysis Issues: For the modular Brigade Combat Team: What are the cost and logistics impacts of using precision? How do these munitions affect force effectiveness? What is the relative collateral damage from these munitions vice dumb munitions? Precision munitions: PGK, Excalibur, PGMM Case 2: Precision Munitions: 155mm Excalibur 155mm PGK Munition (30m CEP capable) 105mm PGK Munition (30m CEP capable) 120mm PGMM and conventional mortar munitions Factor Operational Effectiveness Cost Effectiveness Impact to HBCT Increased war-fighting capability by 48% Reduced US losses by 36% Increased overall cost of munitions expended by 7-18%, but this will be significantly reduced due to 2 nd and 3 rd order effects (logistics) Excalibur (8) PGK (13) M795 (52) Logistics Effectiveness Reduced number of munitions by 38% Reduced tonnage of Army munitions expended by 19% Open desert scenario example Collateral Damage example Slide 18
PGK Fills the Effectiveness Gap Effectiveness Conventional PGK Low Cost Competent Munition (LCCM) Analysis in 2000 is consistent with New Vectors Force-on-Force Analysis PGK with 30m CEP Reduces the Required Number of Rounds by 55% to 68% Averaged across all ranges and both effects (neutralize, destroy) TLE = 25m Number of Munitions Required Mix 5km Conventional 7km 10km Mix PGK 15km PGK 20km 25km Cost of Munitions 30km Slide 19
Precision Reduces the Number of Rounds 60m PGK Analysis www.newvectors.net Matt Finley 703-626-8509 Matt.finley@newvectors.net Accuracy of PGK Round (CEP) 50m 40m 30m PGK Threshold 37% 39% PGK Objective Accomplish the Same Mission with 1/3 the Rounds 55% 68% 50m CEP 25m TLE 20m 61% 74% 13m CEP 61% 78% 10m 30m CEP 20m CEP 0m All Cases 25m TLE Results averaged across all ranges and both effects (neutralize, destroy) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Reduction in the Required Number of Rounds Slide 20
What Does This Mean to the Mission Cost? Round Cost is Only a Small Percentage of Mission Cost Reduced Round Savings Has Multiplying Effect on Mission Savings New Vectors Study Only Considered The Round Cost X X X X Transit Cost Loiter Cost Supply Chain In Theatre Depot Costs Sortie Costs Re-Supply Fire Mission Munition/Round When the system and logistics costs are added to the cost of the rounds fired, a reduction of 55% to 68% in rounds fired makes an all-precision stockpile a realizable goal. Slide 21
Affordable PGK Fills an Effectiveness Gap Munition Choice: Commander s Intent (Pk Level, etc.) Available Weapon & Target Pairings Rules of Engagement (Collateral Damage) Approach Limitations (End-Game Trajectory) Light Armor Artillery Revetments SS Missile Sites There is no single value or accuracy threshold for PGMs Rear Adm James Winnefeld, USJFCOM, J9 Joint Innovation and Experimentation (JI&E) Directorate Briefing to Precision Strike Association Vent Holes Rooms Bunkers Bridges Shelters Aircraft Trucks SAM Sites Troops in Open Large Buildings/Facilities 1 2 3 5 10 20 30 50 100 Adequate Total Circular Error Probable (CEP) - meters 200 300 500 Affordable Precision Solutions Will Change the Fires Paradigm from an Inventory of Conventional and Precision Munitions to Precision and Very High Precision Munitions Precision Very High Precision Conventional with Precision Guidance Kit GMLRS NLOS-PAM Excalibur PGMM Number of Missions Mission Munition Mix Is Integral to FCS (Future Combat System) Vision Slide 22
Precision Munition Analysis Study Findings PGMM (1km 7km) PGMM is the most cost and logistically effective munition Provides the least collateral damage Personnel protected by point target structures Conventional Projectiles (2km 30 km) Cost effective at shorter ranges where delivery accuracy is good and collateral damage is not a concern PGK (8km 27 km) Is generally the most cost effective munition beyond 10km Requires only 12-51% of the number of conventional rounds At most ranges is cost effective and reduces logistical burden PGMM PGK Conventional Excalibur Excalibur (8km 40km) Is only tube-launched capability beyond 30km Is the only artillery round accurate enough to reduce collateral effects Is most logistically effective over 155mm operational range with a significant improvement in effectiveness Personnel protected by buildings, command posts, urban warfare targets Slide 23
Affordable Precision Possible Today Technology People U.S. Army photo Soldier of the 2-4 Infantry, 4th Brigade Combat Team, 10th Infantry Division operates AFATDS US Army Photo by Spc. Katherine M. Roth An artilleryman plans to launch a 155mm round from a howitzer of the 1st Armored Division s 4th Battalion, 27th Field Artillery Regiment. Strengthened Capability for the Warfighter Slide 24