Application No.: Exhibit No.: Witnesses: A.14-11-016 SCE-6 C. Hart (U 338-E) ADDENDUM TO TESTIMONY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY (U 338-E) ON THE RESULTS OF ITS 2013 LOCAL CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS REQUEST FOR OFFERS (LCR RFO) FOR THE MOORPARK SUB-AREA Before the Public Utilities Commission of the State of California Rosemead, California February 20, 2015
SCE-6: ADDENDUM TO TESTIMONY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY (U 338-E) ON THE RESULTS OF ITS 2013 LOCAL CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS REQUEST FOR OFFERS (LCR RFO) FOR THE MOORPARK SUB-AREA Table Of Contents Section Page Witness I. SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON S COMMUNICATION WITH COMMUNITIES REGARDING ITS LOCAL CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS REQUEST FOR OFFERS FOR THE MOORPARK SUB-AREA...1 C. Hart Appendix A Witness Qualifications -i-
SCE-6: ADDENDUM TO TESTIMONY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY (U 338-E) ON THE RESULTS OF ITS 2013 LOCAL CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS REQUEST FOR OFFERS (LCR RFO) FOR THE MOORPARK SUB-AREA List Of Tables Table Page Table I-1 Communication Log...3 -ii-
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 I. SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON S COMMUNICATION WITH COMMUNITIES REGARDING ITS LOCAL CAPACITY REQUIREMENTS REQUEST FOR OFFERS FOR THE MOORPARK SUB-AREA In April 2013, shortly after the California Public Utilities Commission ( CPUC or Commission ) issued the Long Term Procurement Plan Track 1 decision (D.13-02-015) on February 13, 2013, Southern California Edison Company ( SCE ) representatives began communicating with the counties of Ventura and Santa Barbara and cities within these counties to educate them about SCE s Local Capacity Requirements ( LCR ) Request for Offers ( RFO ) and the reliability issues in the Goleta service area (located in the Moorpark sub-area of the Big Creek/Ventura local reliability area). SCE s communications generally involved some or all of the following messages: 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 The Commission ordered SCE to procure between 215-290 MW of electrical capacity in the Moorpark sub-area; The new generation is necessary to meet long-term local capacity needs largely due to the expected retirement of once-through-cooling generation facilities (Mandalay and Ormond Beach) in 2020 as a result of State Water Resources Control Board regulations; Additional generation in the Goleta service area will help maintain system reliability; SCE s plan to submit its procurement plan to Commission staff for review, and after approval of the plan, SCE will procure 215-290 MW of electrical capacity; and In anticipation of SCE s procurement effort, third-party developers may start looking for potential sites in the Moorpark sub-area. 22 23 24 SCE continued its communications throughout 2013 and 2014, and thus, the communications may have also involved some or all of the following additional messaging at the appropriate points in time: 25 26 SCE launched the LCR RFO in September 2013, with a preference for resources in the Goleta service area to help address reliability concerns in that area; 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 Before the results of the LCR RFO were available, notice was given that bids for Preferred Resources, energy storage and gas-fired generation ( GFG ) were possible; In order to develop GFG in the Goleta service area, Emission Reduction Credits are needed, but are currently unavailable; and A summary of the results of the LCR RFO for the Moorpark sub-area (when they became available). 7 8 9 10 11 From April 2013 to the present, SCE representatives have had approximately 100 meetings and phone calls with local government officials in Ventura and Santa Barbara counties and the cities in those counties, community organizations, and community leaders. Table I-1 below is a list 1 of the organizations and individuals that SCE communicated with regarding the issues identified in the bullet points above and the dates that those communications took place. 1 This list is not exhaustive. There may have been other communications that occurred between SCE representatives and local government officials in Ventura and Santa Barbara counties and the cities in those counties, community organizations, and community leaders that are not reflected in the list at Table I-1. 2
Table I-1 Communication Log CONTACT/ORG NAME DATE Community Development Director, City of Malibu 4/25/2013 Hugh Riley, Assistant City Manager, City of Moorpark 4/25/2013 Paul Casey, Santa Barbara City Administrator 4/29/2013 Maureen Tamuri, Community Development Director, City of Calabasas 4/30/2013 David Bobardt, Community Development Director, City of Moorpark 4/30/2013 Glenn Russel, Director of Santa Barbara Planning & Development 4/30/2013 Mike Kamino, Director of Planning & Development and Community, City of Agoura Hills 5/1/2013 John Prescott, Community Development Director, City of Thousand Oaks 5/1/2013 Jackie Campbell, City of Carpinteria Planning Director 5/1/2013 Peter Lyons, Director of Community Development, City of Simi Valley 5/2/2013 Kim Prillhart, Planning Director, County of Ventura 5/2/2013 Dave Durflinger, Carpinteria City Manager 5/3/2013 Henry Dubroff (Pacific Coast Biz Times) 8/8/2013 Chris Collier (Coastal Energy Alliance) 8/16/2013 Dave Durflinger (City Manager, City of Carpinteria) 8/16/2013 Charlie Ebeling (Public Works Director, Goleta) 8/16/2013 Cathy Feldman (Community Leader) 8/21/2013 Dan Singer (City Manager Goleta) 8/29/2013 Jim Youngson (community leader) 10/10/2013 Michael Hackett (Energy Industry Leader) 10/13/2013 Kristen Miller (Goleta Chamber) 11/2/2013 Supervisor Steve Lavagnino 12/19/2013 Ken Oplinger (SB Chamber) 12/19/2013 Lynda Lang (Carp Chamber) 12/20/2013 Vanessa Patterson (Santa Barbara City College) 1/2/2014 Supervisor Peter Adam 1/7/2014 Supervisor Janet Wolf 1/8/2014 Supervisor Doreen Farr 1/9/2014 Mayor Helene Schneider (Santa Barbara) 1/14/2014 Jim Armstrong (City Administrator, SB) 1/14/2014 Council Member Michael Bennett (Goleta) 1/15/2014 Council Member Roger Aceves (Goleta) 1/15/2014 Steve Amerikaner (attorney/community leader) 1/29/2014 Steve Cushman (community leader) 3/4/2014 Earl Armstrong (community leader) 3/4/2014 3
Table I-1 Communication Log (continued) City of Simi Valley (Eric Levitt, City Manager) 3/10/2014 City of Calabasas 3/11/2014 City of Santa Barbara Reliability Presentation Paul Casey (Asst City Manager), Rebecca Bjork (Public Works Director) 3/13/2014 Craig Case (community leader) 3/14/2014 City of Thousand Oaks (Scott Mitnick, City Manager) 3/17/2014 City of Agoura Hills 3/17/2014 City of Westlake Village 3/18/2014 City of Moorpark (Steve Kueny, City Manager; Hugh Riley, Asst. City Manag 3/18/2014 Santa Paula Reliability City Manager, Mayor Fernandez, Staff 3/19/2014 Oxnard Reliability City Manager, Planning Director, Key Staff 3/19/2014 Ojai Reliability City Manager, Key Department Heads 3/24/2014 Ventura Reliability City Manager, Key Department Heads 3/25/2014 Port Hueneme Reliability City manager, Public Works, Key Staff 3/25/2014 Camarillo Reliability City Manger, Key Department Heads 3/30/2014 County of Ventura (Sue Hughes, Legislative Analyst) 4/1/2014 Larry Davis + Members of Camarillo Noontime Optimist (15) 4/7/2014 Ted williams + Members of Camarillo Kiwanis (12) 4/8/2014 Joe Armendariz (taxpayers assn and business and technology assn) 4/17/2014 Krista Pleiser (realtors assn) 5/8/2014 Julie McGovern (American Red Cross) 5/27/2014 Lisa Rivas (Community Leader) 6/25/2014 Jim McGee (American Red Cross) 6/27/2014 Nancy Lindholm, Oxnard Chamber + Members of Board of Directors (20) + Business Advocacy Group (15) 7/14/2014 Ed Summers + Members of Ventura Chamber Energy Committee (15) 7/23/2014 Captain David Sadecki (SB County Fire) 8/5/2014 Maggie Campbell (Downtown Santa Barbara) 8/18/2014 Kate Schwab (Downtown Santa Barbara) 8/18/2014 Ted Williams + Members of University Club (30) 9/17/2014 Dave Rodriguiz, LULAC President 9/19/2014 Ventura Councilman Jim Monahan 10/2/2014 Ventura Mayor Heitmann 10/2/2014 Gary Cushing + Members of Camarillo Chamber Business Advisory Committee (12) 10/7/2014 Ventura County Public Information Officers (20) 10/8/2014 Kay Runnion, VCCoastal Realtor Association Gov. Affairs Director 10/8/2014 Elaine Freeman, Simi Valley Parks/Rec Director 10/8/2014 4
Table I-1 Communication Log (continued) Sue Chadwick, CLU Board of Regents 10/8/2014 Goleta Valley Chamber of Commerce Public Policy Committee 11/18/2014 City of Santa Barbara Reliability Presentation (Mayor Helene Schnerider, Councilmember Bendy White, Councilmember Randy Rowse, City Manager Paul Casey, Public Works Director Rebecca Bjork) 11/18/2014 Ryan Rockabrand (County OEM) 11/26/2014 Downtown Santa Barbara Board of Directors 12/9/2014 Chris Williamson (Principal Planner) and Greg Nyhoff (City Manager), City of Oxnard 12/2014 Nancy Lindholm, City of Oxnard Chamber of Commerce 12/2014 Gretchen Hewlett (Santa Barbara City College Foundation) & Sheba Lux (Santa Barbara City College Foundation 1/6/2015 Downtown Reliability Presentation 2/5/2015 Hal Conklin (Community Leader) 12/23/2013, 8/25/2014 City of Goleta Reliability Presentation Michelle Greene (City Manager, City of Goleta), Rosemarie Gaglione (Public Works Director), James Winslow (Public Works), Cindy Moore (Sustainability Director) 3/13/2014, 1/21/2015 City of Carpinteria Circuit Reliability Presentation Dave Durflinger (City Manager), Charlie Ebeling (Public Works Director), Jackie Campbell (Planning Director) 3/14/2014, 11/18/2014 Kelle Pistone, Association of Water Agencies Board of Directors 3/6/2014, 11/6/2014 County of Santa Barbara Circuit Reliability Presentation Public Works & General Services Staff; Represenatives from the offices of Supervisor Carbajal, Wolf & Farr) 5/1/2014, 11/10/2014 Assembly Member Jeff Gorrell's Office (Ernie Villegas, District Director) 8/2013 9/2013 Sandy Smith, Sespe Consulting 8/2013 9/2013 Bill Buratto, Buratto and Associates 8/2013 9/2013 Members of Thousand Oaks Utility Visioning Committee 8/2013 9/2013 Supervisor Salud Carbajal 8/9/2013, 12/19/2013, 3/19/2014 9/2013 11/2014 Ventura County Economic Development Association Attend meetings on monthly basis 9/2013 11/2014 Greater Conejo Chamber of Commerce Attend meetings on monthly basis 9/2013 11/2014 Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce Attend meetings on monthly basis Monthly, ongoing meetings with the Sigrid Wright (Community Environmental Council) South County Energy Efficiency Partnership (SCEEP) Monthly, ongoing meetings with the Michael Chiacos (Community Environmental Council and member of South County Energy Efficiency APCD CAC) Partnership (SCEEP) Monthly, ongoing meetings with the Jim Dewey (City of Santa Barbara Energy Manager) South County Energy Efficiency Partnership (SCEEP) Discussed at partnership meetings (facilities/energy managers from each city and the county in attendance as well as CEC staff) Ongoing Ongoing Regular updates at monthly South Coast Energy Efficiency partnership meetings, chamber meetings, and discussions with community leaders Ongoing 5
Appendix A Witness Qualifications
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY QUALIFICATIONS AND PREPARED TESTIMONY OF CATHY HART Q. Please state your name and business address for the record. A. My name is Cathy Hart, and my business address is 10060 Telegraph Rd., Ventura, California 93004. Q. Briefly describe your present responsibilities at the Southern California Edison Company. A. I am the Region Director of Local Public Affairs for Southern California Edison s Northern Region. I manage a team of Region Managers who are the primary representatives of the company to local government elected officials and senior staff as well community leaders and organizations. Q. Briefly describe your educational and professional background. A. I have a Bachelor s degree in Communications and a Master s degree in Public Policy. I have been with Southern California Edison almost eight years. Prior to that I was the executive director of a non-profit business advocacy organization in the Antelope Valley as well as a business owner. Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding? A. The purpose of my testimony in this proceeding is to sponsor portions of Exhibit SCE-6, entitled Addendum to Testimony of Southern California Edison Company (U 338-E) on the Results of Its 2013 Local Capacity Requirements Requests for Offers (LCR RFO) for the Moorpark Sub-Area as identified in the Table of Contents thereto. Q. Was this material prepared by you or under your supervision? A. Yes, it was. Q. Insofar as this material is factual in nature, do you believe it to be correct? A. Yes, I do. Q. Insofar as this material is in the nature of opinion or judgment, does it represent your best judgment? A. Yes, it does. Q. Does this conclude your qualifications and prepared testimony? Appendix A-1
1 A. Yes, it does. Appendix A-2