Grow Your Own Entrepreneurship Based Economic Development Webinar Dell Gines, MBA, CEcD Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Sr. Community Development Advisor
The Federal Reserve Bank The views in this presentation do not necessarily represent the views of the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City nor the Federal Reserve System.
The Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Perspective The mission of the Community Development department of the Kansas City Federal Reserve Bank is to support the economic growth objectives of the Federal Reserve Act by promoting community development and fair and equal access to credit. The Grow Your Own Guide provides a high level overview of what it takes to conduct entrepreneurship based economic development. Our job is to serve as a neutral convener of resources between those who have and those who don t, because we know all segments of the population, including the less advantaged, benefit from both economic growth and fair and equal access to credit.
Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City The Tenth District consist of Nebraska, Oklahoma, Kansas, Colorado, Wyoming and portions of Missouri and New Mexico
ECONOMIC GARDENING Where to From Here?
What is Economic Gardening? An entrepreneurial approach to economic development A focus on stage 2 growth companies A focus on strategic issues Uses corporate level tools Based on New Sciences
Results in Littleton 1987-2012 Jobs 15,000 to 30,000 Sales Tax Revenue $6 million to $21 million No recruiting Not one penny in incentives
National Center Activity 34 programs in 25 states 7 statewide programs 298 companies in 2012 314 companies in 2013 298 Florida Companies Edward Lowe Foundation copyright 2013
Florida Results $5.5M investment from state Jobs created: Direct 2,067.4 Investment per direct job created $2,660 Edward Lowe Foundation copyright 2013
Kansas Results
Recent Improvements Ensuring high fidelity projects Professional training / certification 100 hours Videos / 4 day retreat / mentoring period Program certification National network established Sharing of best practices and issues
Plans for the Future Even more sophisticated tools OneSource Newspatterns and Recorded Future
National Organizations Contacting Entrepreneurial Support Organizations (ESOs) about future collaboration Incubators, angel funding, etc. Discussions with Kauffman Foundation Discussions with federal government agencies
Working with SBDCs Individual state and regional directors National convention presentations National SBDC office conversation
Entrepreneurial Research Continue to dive deeper into well springs of job and wealth creation Severe 80/20 rule Gazelles are rare Steady growth more widespread Stalled growth re-set
Research on EG Outcomes Plans to open discussions with universities to conduct formal evaluations of projects and approaches Constant internal evaluation What do we keep? What do we drop? What do we change? What do we add?
Research on EG Patterns Internal research on: Company archetypes Issue archetypes Wicked problems Failure patterns / no can do
Questions?
Grow Your Own December 4, 2013
My Presentation Federal Reserve 12.04.13 Let s Start with Prosperity Inspiration from the Field Big Picture View Keys to Success Center Resources Questions & Discussion
The areas with STARS are locations where the Center has completed projects. A Decade of Field Work
Prosperity?
Prosperity Defined Economic Opportunity Broadly-Held Community Wealth Entrepreneurial 1. Economic & Social Diversity 2. Resilience from Shocks 3. Higher & Sustained Prosperity
Chase County
6,000 Chase County, Nebraska 5,484 5,310 5,176 Historical Population of Chase County, Nebraska 5,000 4,807 4,939 4,758 4,000 3,613 4,317 4,129 4,381 4,068 3,965 3,975 3,984 3,966 4,006 4,064 3,883 3,816 3,768 3,687 3,616 3,625 3,000 2,000 2,559 Like so many rural counties, Chase County experienced chronic and severe depopulation beginning with the Great Depression. This period preceded by the classic boom, bust and boom cycles. 1,000-70 1880 1890 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
1969 1971 1973 1975 1977 1979 1981 1983 1985 1987 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 Income (thousand dollars) Employment Economic Rebound $16,000 Nonfarm Proprietors, Chase County, Nebraska 800 $14,000 700 $12,000 600 $10,000 500 $8,000 400 $6,000 300 $4,000 200 $2,000 100 $0 0 Nonfarm proprietors' income: real 2010 dollars Number of nonfarm proprietors
Community Renewal 4,500 Contemporary Population of Chase County, Nebraska 4,000 4,068 3,965 3,975 3,984 3,883 3,816 3,768 3,687 3,616 3,625 3,966 4,006 4,064 3,500 3,000 There are relatively few rural counties in the entire Great Plains Region posting sustained positive population growth. 2,500 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Russ & Allo Communications Russ and his wife own the local twice weekly newspaper in Imperial. He a former high school class mate created Allo Communications. Today they are one of the breakout companies fueling Chase County s revitalization. Allo Communications is competing head up with the likes of SPRINT and Century Link. Russ and Allo are charitable and through gifts to the Chase County Community Foundation they are supporting workforce development and educational opportunities for youth.
Economic Development Opportunities in the Post-Great Recession Economy and Society. Big Picture
Great Recession The most significant economic event in our lifetime! A new economic and social world will emerge from this recession.
Great Reset Space exists in our economy and society for creativity and innovation that can lead to a new round of economic and social progress and prosperity. The Long Depression of the 1870s and the Great Depression of the 1930s is evidence that this can be the case with the Great Recession. This is called the Great Reset!
The Reset Process Prosperity Crisis Unraveling New Ventures Opportunity Space New Innovation
Illustration 1995-2001 The Great Expansion The 1990s were a remarkable period in American economic development history. During the 1990s, household net worth grew by a remarkable $22 trillion. No other decade since World War II posted such wealth creation in United States including the 1950s, 1960s and the 1970s.
Challenged 2000s
In just 1 year, 2.5 Million new entrepreneurial startups!
Stage 1 Ventures (2-9) employees Self Employment Dropped 146,241 or 2% 2.6 million more businesses +21% 6 million more jobs +28% $371 billion more in Sales
Defense Contractors Government Contractors Supply Chain Companies Under-Employed Talent Un-hired Graduates Displaced Talent Entrepreneur Opportunities Immigrant Talent Graduate Students Safe Harbor Immigrants Business Failures Retirees Women
Employment Shifts 3 Waves Pre-World War II Self-Employment Smaller Local Employers World War II into the 1990s Large Corporations, Government & Non-Profits 1990s through to Today Swelling Self-Employment & Smaller Ventures Navigating Change
Across America Communities and Regions are Struggling to Find Robust Funding for Economic Development. Keys to Success
#1 -Local Responsibility No community can take its future for granted. Remember Detroit? Every community must create its future. Development is a local responsibility. Central to community success in the 21 st Century is creating and supporting an environment for entrepreneurial behavior.
#2 Smart Game Plan Right Strategy Experience & Learning Smart Game Plan Research Genuine Opportunity
#3 Robust Investment Communities must be renewed socially and economically. There must be constant private and public investment if a community is to renew itself. 1. Public Funding 2. Leveraged Private Investment 3. Community Philanthropy
#4 Key Entrepreneurial Development Systems Chronology 2004 Legislation 2005 Center Created 2006 NetWork Kansas 2007 First E-Communities 5 ½ Years of Experience Impact 39 Communities 339 Business Deals $54 Million Deal Flow 1017 Full-Time Jobs 816 Part-Time Jobs NetWork Kansas Kansas is building one of the most robust and sustainable entrepreneurfocused economic development game plans in North America. There is a system of support that includes NetWork Kansas, the Kansas Small Business Development Centers, communities from urban to rural and hundreds of specialized resource providers. Kansas is growing an entrepreneurial eco-system one community at a time. We are in the process of capturing this story (Fall 2013).
Other Keys #5 Sustained Effort #8 Immigrants & New Residents #9 Real Regional Collaboration
#7 Attributes of an Entrepreneurial Community 1. All 3 Kinds of Es 2. Culture 3. Infrastructure 4. Human Talent 5. Youth
Entrepreneurial Culture It s Entrepreneurial A key attribute of successful entrepreneurs is that they focus on opportunities. It s Positive This is asset-based development and it creates hope based on opportunities. It Leads to Impact It works!
Entrepreneurial Infrastructure Robust Support Network Business Coaching Access to Capital Access to Market Research Access to Places & Spaces Access to Real Time Technology Access to Human Talent Other Entrepreneurs
Entrepreneurs #10 Civic & Social Entrepreneurs. #6 Business Entrepreneurs Lifestyle Growth-Oriented Transition Beth Stube -- Dickinson, North Dakota
Youth Energizing Force
Center Resources
Keys to Economic Success Local Responsibility Smart Game Plan Robust Investment Entrepreneurial Development Systems Sustained Effort Growth Entrepreneurs Attributes of an Entrepreneurial Community Immigrants & New Residents Real Regional Collaboration Civic and Social Entrepreneurs
New Book January 2014 Release Contents Case for Entrepreneurs Entrepreneurial Community Action Framework Working with Entrepreneurs Guiding & Tracking Progress Paper & E Book
E2 University Online Rollout in 2014 Resources: Guides Tools Protocols Training Webinars Exercises & Illustrations Videos, Stories & More University
Web site www.energizingentrepreneurs.org We have produced a new and improved web site with more free resources and better guidance to compensated resources. Give it a spin. Also we have four electronic newsletters that are free. Sign up today and benefit from all the resources covered in our newsletters.
Working with Es Website Beginning next summer and fall we will be offering community and professional webinars on working with entrepreneurs and community-based entrepreneur-focused development.
We Must Dream Again
Questions
Questions & Discussion Don Macke don@e2mail.org www.energizingentrepreneurs.org
New Engines for a New Economy Senior Entrepreneurs Driving Social, Economic, and Environmental Growth in Communities, the Nation, and the World. Webinar, December 2013
Elizabeth Isele Co-Creator and Founder, eprovstudio.com, Babson College, Wellesley, MA Co-Founder and CEO, SeniorEntrepreneurshipWorks.org, Baruch College, New York City, NY Email: elizabeth@seniorentrepreneurshipworks.org Webinar, December 2013
Scope of Presentation Overview of the social, environmental, and economic impact of senior entrepreneurship in today's global longevity economy. How to identify, support, and sustain senior entrepreneurs through programs, policy, capitalization, and research. Webinar, December 2013 63
Paradox of the New Longevity Economy - Passive vs. Proactive Passive: Seniors, aged 50+, as a $3 Trillion Market Opportunity in the US - $15 Trillion Globally Proactive: Seniors, aged 50+, Creating and Driving Economic Markets in the US and Globally Webinar, December 2013 64
Seniors, aged 50+, as a Market Opportunity Many innovators, brand managers, marketers, and product designers, who ignored this market for decades, now want a piece of the trillion dollar pie. Innovation based on what can be sold to this huge and growing, at 10,000 a day, demographic. Products such as medical alert bracelets and adult diapers are palliative in nature, and they highlight and reinforce the debilitating effects of aging. Product innovation aimed primarily at the older olds, age 75 and up. Webinar, December 2013 65
Seniors, aged 50+, Creating and Driving Economic Markets Defining the 50+ Entrepreneur This is a highly creative, powerful, and extraordinary demographic courageous, enlightened and willing to fight for what they believe in. We need to unleash their potential. Recent research in the United States from the MetLife foundation documents 34 million boomers want to start their own businesses. Contrary to a commonly held perception that only young people engage in business start-ups, research by the Kauffman Foundation for Entrepreneurship has established that the highest rate of business start-up activity over the past decade has consistently been among people in the 55-to-64 age bracket. According to the Kauffman Foundation's Index of Entrepreneurial Activity, 1 in 5 new entrepreneurs in 2011 were aged 55-64; almost half of all new entrepreneurs were between the ages of 45 and 64 and this cohort continues to grow. Webinar, December 2013 66
Seniors, aged 50+, Creating and Driving Economic Markets Defining the 50+ Entrepreneur (cont.) In the UK, third age entrepreneurs are responsible for over one quarter of new start-ups. The 2013 GEM (Global Entrepreneurship Monitor) data documents that 50% of new businesses launched by individuals aged 50+ are still in business after five years. Contrast this to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) and the Census which note: "The typical new business started in the United States is no longer in operation five years after being founded. Often, too, as this NY Times article, Retiree Start-ups with Age and Youth as Partners, indicates, seniors are working hand-in-hand with the younger generation to create new businesses. Webinar, December 2013 67
Seniors, aged 50+, Creating and Driving Economic Markets Social Benefits and Economic ROI Derived from Senior Entrepreneurs Individual's health, well-being, and economic self-reliance. Communities' (including employers') health and well-being: Economic - workforce development, job creation, improved productivity and wealth creation as senior entrepreneurs pour investment dollars back into their communities. Environmental - 60% of boomers are building green businesses. And, according to research from the AEO (Association for Enterprise Opportunity), if one in three micro-businesses in the United States hired an additional employee, the US would be at full employment (see http://www.oneinthree.biz). Webinar, December 2013 68
Seniors, aged 50+, Creating and Driving Economic Markets Social Benefits and Economic ROI (cont.) Senior Entrepreneurs and employed adults, aged 65+, contribute $120+ billion in federal taxes* annually to support federal programs and reduce dependency on entitlement programs. Senior Entrepreneurs present new market lending opportunities for lenders. New digital business opportunities. Increased demand for Technology (products, services, e-commerce) to facilitate senior business startups. Intellectual capital: Engaging seniors in both business creation and in supporting new and existing entrepreneurs maximizes the wealth of experience they possess, cultivates intergenerational learning, and ensures knowledge transfer. Webinar, December 2013 69
Seniors, aged 50+, Creating and Driving Economic Markets Social Benefits and Economic ROI (cont.) Collaborative entrepreneurship. Seniors, who may not wish to launch a business of their own, represent a valuable resource for other entrepreneurs. Retired business people have precious know-how and experience that can make it easier to start and run a company than it might otherwise be for an inexperienced founder. We should be encouraging motivated seniors to serve as voluntary mentors, potential buyers of or investors in businesses, or as temporary managers to assist vulnerable start-ups or businesses in transition. Senior Entrepreneurs are driving economic recovery in our communities and in our country, and their experience, extensive networks, and problem-solving expertise mitigate the risk of failure endemic among new business startups. Today's Senior Entrepreneurs are creating a whole new paradigm for aging. The world is beginning to recognize seniors as assets and not liabilities - and it's not a moment too soon! Webinar, December 2013 70
Creating and Sustaining Senior Entrepreneurs Webinar, December 2013
Creating and Sustaining Senior Entrepreneurs through Collaboration SeniorEntrepreneurshipWorks.org, Babson College and its ET&A (Entrepreneurial Thought and Action), and the Lawrence N. Field Center for Entrepreneurship at Baruch College of the City University of New York are working collaboratively to serve senior entrepreneurs throughout the United States and abroad. The collaboration represents a unique approach to support and sustain senior entrepreneurship through programs, policy, capitalization, and research. Webinar, December 2013 72
Entrepreneurship Education Programs A hybrid learning entrepreneurship curriculum tailored to address the needs of the adult learner. Content for senior entrepreneurs is segmented to take the user fully across the entrepreneurial developmental arc: awareness, simulation, incubation/acceleration, launch, and scale. eprovstudio.com SeniorEntrepreneurshipWorks.org IVE (Institute for Virtual Enterprise) GCEE (Global Consortium for Entrepreneurship Education) GEM (Global Entrepreneurship Monitor) eprov Challenge Accelerator Webinar, December 2013 73
Created in the Social Innovation Lab at Babson College, these workshops delivered worldwide - are designed to ignite ideas through Babson s signature ET&A (Entrepreneurial Thought and Action) and Improvisation for seniors to re-imagine/renew their lives rather than retire from them. Webinar, December 2013 74
A free, online, open-source entrepreneurship curriculum, hosted at Baruch College, designed to meet the 50+ entrepreneurs needs. Webinar, December 2013 75
IVE (Institute for Virtual Enterprise) Hosted at Baruch College, IVE is a business & entrepreneurship simulation where students create and operate virtual firms and trade virtual or real products and services through a global e-commerce network of over 4,000 firms across more than 40 countries. IVE provides a package of products and services on an open- access model: The MarketMaker is an integrated bank, credit card, e-commerce/inventory management system and stock market with a realistic web interface resembling the online account management functions of a major financial institution. IVEweBlog - to think, write, and reflect about classroom experiences and resources share IVE partners become part of a global collaborative and are expected to share their innovations. Webinar, December 2013 76
GCEE (Global Consortium for Entrepreneurship Education) Founded by Babson College, GCEE is an alliance of like-minded institutions from around the globe that are committed to entrepreneurship education. GCEE provides a unique opportunity to share best practices, collaborate with member institutions on a variety of initiates, gain in-depth access to Babson's expertise, and remain on the cutting edge of entrepreneurship education. Webinar, December 2013 77
GEM (Global Entrepreneurship Monitor) GEM was initiated in 1999 as a joint venture of Babson College and the London Business School. GEM is the largest and most developed research program on entrepreneurship in the world. Starting with 10 participating countries, the project, now in its 14 th year of operations, has expanded to include 69+ countries. GEM is unique because, unlike most entrepreneurship data sets that measure newer and smaller firms, GEM studies the behavior of individuals with respect to starting and managing a business. GEM nations are members of an entrepreneurship research project which provides access to the collective knowledge of some of the world s most renowned researchers and institutions, and its data has influenced national economic policies. Webinar, December 2013 78
eprov Challenge Accelerator Entrepreneuring is not an individual sport doing it in community amplifies the results. Created in the Social Innovation Lab at Babson College, The eprov Challenge Accelerator is a fast paced design that allows cross-sector members of a community to creatively assist an entrepreneur in addressing a specific dilemma in real-time. Entrepreneurs - new venture creators, intraprepreneurs, community economic development leaders - bring their individual expertise and experience to bare. Entrepreneurs get 2 minutes to rocket-pitch a bite-sized need s/he is facing within their business, organization or community. After 2-hours in this creative environment, the entrepreneur with a challenge walks away with new opportunities and an expanded resource base in multiple dimensions. Webinar, December 2013 79
Guiding Principles Reality based - no rose colored glasses allowed. Replace the noun entrepreneurship with the verb entrepreneuring. Take the intimidation out of entrepreneuring. Recognize there are many different kinds of entrepreneurs. Anyone can become an entrepreneur you don t have to be born one. Entrepreneuring is not an individual sport doing it in community amplifies the results. Unleash the potential for everyone to create a more just, equitable, and mutually beneficial civil society. And, as our friends at The Institute for the Ages have so aptly noted, potential never gets old! Webinar, December 2013 80
Shaping entrepreneurs of all kinds Courtesy, Mischa Richter Webinar, December 2013 81
How Can You Harness the Individual and Collective Experience of Older Adults to Boost and Sustain Prosperity for All Ages? Use Your Curiosity to build new and innovative alliances among public/private stakeholders (including those in this room and others at this conference) invested in the health and well-being of seniors and individual as well as community economic self-reliance. Develop Programs more entrepreneurial education and training programs, including (intergenerational programs.) Advocate for New Public Policy that recognizes older adults as assets and not liabilities. Generate New Research Initiatives to document the social, environmental and economic impact of seniors contributing to our Longevity Economy. Create New Methods of Capitalization for boomer business startups. Webinar, December 2013 82
Thank you! Elizabeth Isele Co-Creator and Founder, eprovstudio.com, Babson College, Wellesley, MA Co-Founder and CEO, SeniorEntrepreneurshipWorks.org, Baruch College, New York City, NY Email: elizabeth@seniorentrepreneurshipworks.org Webinar, December 2013
Contact Dell Gines Sr. Community Development Advisor Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City dell.gines@kc.frb.org (402) 221-5606 For more information & resources http://kansascityfed.org/community/ To sign up for our Community Connections email newsletter please email me at the address above.