Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff

Similar documents
Benchmark Data Sources

2017 Quality Reporting: Claims and Administrative Data-Based Quality Measures For Medicare Shared Savings Program and Next Generation ACO Model ACOs

Improving Quality of Care for Medicare Patients: Accountable Care Organizations

Shared Savings Program ACO Public Reporting Instructions. with Pre-Populated Template

United Medical ACO Participation Criteria

ACO GPRO 2016 Ready to Report Basics GPRO ACO Random Sample Reporting January 17, 2017 to March 17, 2017

Decoding the QPP Year 2 Quality Measure Benchmarks and Deciles to Maximize Performance

3/29/2013. Effective ACO Compliance. Objectives THE HEALTH CARE DILEMMA: ARE ACOS THE ANSWER? HCCA Compliance Institute April 21, 2013

Practice Implications for Accountable Care Organizations

ACO Update. LVHN Scholarly Works. Lehigh Valley Health Network. Lehigh Valley Health Network. Spring 2017

Accountable Care and the Laboratory Value Proposition. Les Duncan Director of Operations Highmark Health - Home and Community Services

ACO Name and Location. ACO Primary Contact. Organizational Information

2017/2018. KPN Health, Inc. Quality Payment Program Solutions Guide. KPN Health, Inc. A CMS Qualified Clinical Data Registry (QCDR) KPN Health, Inc.

ACO Name and Location. ACO Primary Contact. Organizational Information

CMS Transforming Clinical Practices Initiative and. The Southern New England Practice Transformation Network (SNE PTN)

2017 CMS Web Interface Quality Reporting. Questions & Answers January 2018

CMS Quality Payment Program: Performance and Reporting Requirements

Quality Measurement Approaches of State Medicaid Accountable Care Organization Programs

ACO Name and Location ACO Primary Contact

Shared Savings Program ACO Public Report

MIPS Scoring: Explanation and Estimation 2/7/2017 and 2/10/2017

The Quality Payment Program: Overview & Roles and Responsibilities

ACO Name and Location. ACO Primary Contact. Organizational Information

Quality Measurement, Population Health and Payment Reform

Shared Savings Program ACO Public Reporting Instructions. with Pre-Populated Template

MIPS Advancing Care Information: Tips, Tools and Support Q&A from Live Webinar March 29, 2017

Strategic Implications & Conclusion

Virtual Group Participation Overview Fact Sheet

ACO Name and Location. ACO Primary Contact. Organizational Information

2016 Physician Quality Reporting System (PQRS) Reporting Updates

Quality Payment Program MIPS. Advanced APMs. Quality Payment Program

Accelerating the Impact of Performance Measures: Role of Core Measures

MACRA Implementation: A Review of the Quality Payment Program

Review of the 2016 Annual Quality and Resource Use Reports. October 19, 2017

Registering for PQRS Reporting and Understanding the Implications and Proposed Policies for the Value based Payment Modifier

IMPLICATIONS OF THE 2018 FINAL RULE FOR SOLO PRACTITIONERS AND SMALL GROUP PRACTICES

What Have we Learned from the Pioneer ACO Model?

Stage 3 and ACI s Relationship to Medicaid MU Massachusetts Medicaid EHR Incentive Program

22 Days til MIPS Data Submission! Get Ready!

Advancing Care Information- The New Meaningful Use September 2017

QUALITY PAYMENT PROGRAM

Maximizing Your Potential Under MIPS Oregon MACRA Playbook Conference

MIPS Checkpoint. Beth Hickerson Quality Improvement Advisor. PHA Lunch and Learn May 19, Value Driven. Health Care. Solutions.

Goals & Challenges for Outpatient Quality Directors. Quality HealthCare Consulting, LLC CEO: Jennifer O'Donnell, MHA, PCMH-CCE

St. Vincent s Health Partners

QUALITY PAYMENT PROGRAM SMALL UNDERSERVED RURAL SUPPORT LAN WEBINAR JUNE 8, :30-4:30PM ET PREPARING FOR MIPS IN THE SMALL GROUP PRACTICE

MACRA and MIPS. How Medicare Meaningful Use and PQRS are Changing

Quality Payment Program Year 2: 2018 MIPS Participation. An Introductory Guide for CRNAs in 2018

The Quality Payment Program: Your Questions Answered

2017 Transition Into Value Based Care

MACRA Fall into Place. By Stephanie Cecchini, CPC, CEMC, CHISP, AAPC Fellow, AAPC MACRA Prof

Quality Payment Program

The MIPS Survival Guide

Medicare Physician Payment Reform

Agenda. Surviving the New Program Requirements and the Financial Penalties Under MIPS 9/9/2016. Steps to take to prepare for MIPS

Denise Hudson, NR-CMA Health Informatics Specialist Health Services Advisory Group (HSAG) April 13, 2018

Getting Ready for the Maryland Primary Care Program

2017 Transition Year Flexibility Improvement Activities Category Options

ACO Name and Location. ACO Primary Contact. Organizational Information. Page 1 of 8

PPS Performance and Outcome Measures: Additional Resources

Stage 2 Meaningful Use: Menu Objectives and Clinical Quality Measures. James R. Christina, DPM Director Scientific Affairs APMA

MACRA Frequently Asked Questions

MACRA Quality Payment Program

Medicare Advantage Star Ratings

2015 Updates to the Physician Quality Reporting System (PQRS) & the Value-based Payment Modifier

Meaningful Use Measures: Quick Reference Guide Stage 2 (2014 and Beyond)

WELCOME. Kate Gainer, PharmD Executive Vice President and CEO Iowa Pharmacy Association

SVS QUALITY AND PERFORMANCE MEASURES COMMITTEE (QPMC) New Member Orientation

Exhibit 1. Medicare Shared Savings Program: Year 1 Performance of Participating Accountable Care Organizations (2013)

Registering for PQRS reporting and understanding implications and proposed policies for the Value Based Payment Modifier

Value Based P4P Program Updates MY 2017 & MY 2018

2017 Physician Fee Schedule Impact on Medicare ACOs REGULATORY UPDATES

Merit-Based Incentive Payment System: 2018 Performance Year

MIPS/APM Proposed Rule Summary On Monday, May 9, 2016 the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) published in the Federal Register the

Submitted electronically:

Patient Experience Heart & Vascular Institute

Cleveland Clinic Implementing Value-Based Care

Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting (IQR) Program

Slide 1. Slide 2 Rural Princeton. Slide 3 Agenda Rural ACO RURAL ACOS CAN WORK AND LEAD THE WAY

MIPS (Merit-based Incentive Payment System) Clinical Practice Improvement Activities

MIPS Program: 2018 Advancing Care Information Category

Kate Goodrich, MD MHS. Director, Center for Clinical Standards & Quality. Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) May 6, 2016

CMS Priorities, MACRA and The Quality Payment Program

March Data Jam: Using Data to Prepare for the MACRA Quality Payment Program

Table 1: MIPS Exemptions. Exemption Individual Determination Group Determination Treatment under MIPS Already Finalized EXEMPTIONS Low-Volume

=======================================================================

Michelle Brunsen & Sandy Swallow May 25, , Telligen, Inc.

The Merit-Based Incentive Payment System (MIPS) Survival Guide. August 11, 2016

MACRA & Implications for Telemedicine. June 20, 2016

Overview of Quality Payment Program

MEANINGFUL USE STAGE 2

Denise Hudson, NR-CMA Health Informatics Specialist Health Services Advisory Group (HSAG) August 10, 2018

Understanding PQRS and the Value-Based Modifier: CMS Plan to Achieve High Value Care through Transforming Payment Systems

MIPS Improvement Activities: Quality Insights Tips, Tools and Support Transcript from Live Webinar

Meaningful Use 2016 and beyond

Making Sense of What s Next: Value Based P4P Measurement & MACRA. Mike Weiss, DO September 23, 2016

ACO Information Required to be Published on ACO Website per CMS Regulations

Quality Reporting: PQRS, CQM, GIQuIC. Erin Dettrey Product Manager, Analytics Sylvia Cohen gadvisor Team Lead Laurie Parker GIQuIC Executive Director

2016 Requirements for the EHR Incentive Programs: EligibleProfessionals

Erin Page

Transcription:

Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff All Shared Savings Program ACOs April 11, 2017 Sandra Adams, RN; Rabia Khan, MPH Division of Shared Savings Program Medicare Shared Savings Program

DISCLAIMER This presentation was current at the time it was published or uploaded onto the web. Medicare policy changes frequently so links to the source documents have been provided within this document for reference. This presentation was prepared as a service to the public and is not intended to grant rights or impose obligations. This presentation may contain references or links to statutes, regulations, or other policy materials. The information provided is only intended to be a general summary. It is not intended to take the place of either the written law or regulations. We encourage readers to review the specific statutes, regulations, and other interpretive materials for a full and accurate statement of their contents. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Disclaimer 2

Agenda Introduction 2017 Quality Measurement: Domains and Measures 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission Quality Performance Scoring Alignment with the Quality Payment Program Public Reporting Timeline, Resources, and Assistance Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Agenda 3

Introduction Accessing Slides Overview of Quality Measurement Approach Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Introduction 4

Accessing Slides Please login to the ACO Portal (https://portal.cms.gov) and click on today s event ACO contacts maintained in the Health Plan Management System (HPMS) have access to the SSP Portal and receive the ACO Spotlight newsletter. If you do not have access to the Portal, please work with your ACO to obtain the quality webinar slides and the ACO Spotlight newsletter for quality updates and webinar announcements. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Introduction 5

Overview of Quality Measurement Approach The quality measurement approach in the Shared Savings Program is intended to: Improve individual and population health Address quality aims such as prevention, care of chronic illness, high prevalence conditions, patient safety, patient and caregiver engagement, and care coordination Support the Shared Savings Program goals of better care, better health, and lower growth in expenditures Align with the Quality Payment Program Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Introduction 6

2017 Quality Measurement Domains and Measures Quality Measurement: Domains Quality Measures: Aim 1: Better Care for Individuals Quality Measures: Aim 2: Better Health for Populations Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Measurement Domains and Measures 7

Quality Measurement: Domains 31 quality measures are separated into the following four key domains that will serve as the basis for assessing, benchmarking, rewarding, and improving ACO quality performance: Better Care for Individuals Patient/Caregiver Experience Care Coordination/Patient Safety Better Health for Populations Preventive Health Clinical Care for At Risk Populations Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Measurement Domains and Measures 8

Quality Measures Aim 1: Better Care for Individuals 1. Patient/Caregiver Experience Clinician/Group CAHPS ACO-1 CAHPS: Getting Timely Care, Appointments, and Information ACO-2 CAHPS: How Well Your Providers Communicate ACO-3 CAHPS: Patients' Rating of Provider ACO-4 CAHPS: Access to Specialists ACO-5 CAHPS: Health Promotion and Education ACO-6 CAHPS: Shared Decision Making ACO-7 CAHPS: Health Status/Functional Status* ACO-34 CAHPS: Stewardship of Patient Resources *Measure is pay for reporting all years of the agreement period Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Measurement Domains and Measures 9

Quality Measures Aim 1: Better Care for Individuals (cont.) 2. Care Coordination/Patient Safety ACO-8 Risk-Standardized, All Condition Readmission ACO-35 Skilled Nursing Facility 30-Day All-Cause Readmission Measure ACO-36 All-Cause Unplanned Admissions for Patients with Diabetes ACO-37 All-Cause Unplanned Admissions for Patients with Heart Failure ACO-38 All-Cause Unplanned Admissions for Patients with Multiple Chronic Conditions ACO-43 Ambulatory Sensitive Condition Acute Composite (AHRQ Prevention Quality Indicator (PQI) #91) ACO-11 Use of Certified EHR Technology ACO-12 Medication Reconciliation Post-Discharge ACO-13 Falls: Screening for Future Fall Risk ACO-44 Use of Imaging Studies for Low Back Pain* *Measure is pay for reporting all years of the agreement period Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Measurement Domains and Measures 10

Quality Measures Aim 2: Better Health for Populations 3. Preventive Health ACO-14 Preventive Care and Screening: Influenza Immunization ACO-15 Pneumonia Vaccination Status for Older Adults ACO-16 Preventive Care and Screening: Body Mass Index (BMI) Screening and Follow-Up Plan ACO-17 Preventive Care and Screening: Tobacco Use: Screening and Cessation Intervention ACO-18 Preventive Care and Screening: Screening for Clinical Depression and Follow-Up Plan ACO-19 Colorectal Cancer Screening ACO-20 Breast Cancer Screening ACO-42 Statin Therapy for the Prevention and Treatment of Cardiovascular Disease* *Measure is pay for reporting all years of the agreement period Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Measurement Domains and Measures 11

Quality Measures Aim 2: Better Health for Populations (cont.) 4. Clinical Care for At-Risk Populations Depression ACO-40 Depression Remission at Twelve Months* Diabetes ( all-or-nothing Composite)** ACO-27 Diabetes Mellitus: Hemoglobin A1c Poor Control ACO-41 Diabetes: Eye Exam Hypertension ACO-28 Hypertension (HTN): Controlling High Blood Pressure Ischemic Vascular Disease ACO-30 Ischemic Vascular Disease (IVD): Use of Aspirin or Another Antithrombotic *Measure is pay for reporting all years of the agreement period **The diabetes composite (with two component measures) is scored as one quality measure. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Measurement Domains and Measures 12

2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission Quality Reporting Methods Quality Reporting Methods: Patient Experience Survey Quality Reporting Methods: Claims Data Quality Reporting Methods: Quality Payment Program Data Quality Reporting Methods: CMS Web Interface Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission 13

Quality Reporting Methods Quality data collected via: Patient Survey Claims Quality Payment Program data CMS Web Interface Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission 14

Quality Reporting Methods: Patient Experience Survey Measure Data used Who will gather this quality information? ACO-1 CAHPS: Getting Timely Care, Appointments, and Information ACO-2 CAHPS: How Well Your Providers Communicate ACO-3 CAHPS: Patients' Rating of Provider ACO-4 CAHPS: Access to Specialists ACO-5 CAHPS: Health Promotion and Education ACO-6 CAHPS: Shared Decision Making ACO-7 CAHPS: Health Status/Functional Status ACO-34 CAHPS: Stewardship of Patient Resources CAHPS for ACOs Survey includes Clinician and Group Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers & Systems (CG CAHPS) core measures, supplemental items, and program specific items ACOs select CMSapproved Survey Vendors to administer the survey Timelines/ Key Dates ACOs select approved vendor for CAHPS in the fall of 2017 Survey will be administered beginning in November 2017 Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission 15

Quality Reporting Methods: Claims Data Measure Data used Who will gather this quality information? ACO-8 Risk-Standardized, All Condition Readmission ACO-35 Skilled Nursing Facility 30-Day All-Cause Readmission Measure ACO-36 All-Cause Unplanned Admissions for Patients with Diabetes ACO-37 All-Cause Unplanned Admissions for Patients with Heart Failure ACO-38 All-Cause Unplanned Admissions for Patients with Multiple Chronic Conditions ACO-43 Ambulatory Sensitive Condition Acute Composite (AHRQ Prevention Quality Indicator (PQI) #91) ACO-44 Imaging Studies for Low Back Pain Medicare beneficiaries demographic information and claims data CMS Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission Timelines/ Key Dates No ACO action needed 16

Quality Reporting Methods: Quality Payment Program Data Measure Data used Who will gather Timelines/ this quality Key Dates information? ACO-11 Use of Certified EHR Technology Information on Participation and Advancing Care Information category from Quality Payment Program CMS Detailed specifications for this measure will be available in a Measure Information Form (MIF) posted on the Shared Savings Program website: https://www.cms.gov/medicare/medicare-fee-for-service Payment/sharedsavingsprogram/Quality-Measures-Standards.html Each ACO participant TIN is responsible for submitting data on the MIPS Advancing Care Information category on behalf of its eligible clinicians in the form and manner specified by MIPS. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission 17

Quality Reporting Methods: CMS Web Interface Data Measure Data used Who will gather this quality information? Timelines/ Key Dates Care Coordination/Patient Safety ACO-12 Medication Reconciliation Post-Discharge ACO-13 Falls: Screening for Future Fall Risk Preventive Health ACO-14 through ACO-20 and ACO-42 (all measures in this domain) Clinical Care for At Risk Populations ACO-27, ACO-28, ACO-30, ACO-40, and ACO-41 (all measures in this domain) 1. Medicare beneficiaries demographic information and claims data files 2. Patient medical records (paper/ehr/ registry) from within and outside of the ACO 1. CMS will provide patient samples (with the same patient in multiple samples when possible) with selected patient information. 2. ACOs must enter and submit data into the CMS Web Interface for at least 248 consecutively ranked beneficiaries (or 100 percent of beneficiaries if there are fewer than 248 beneficiaries available) in each sample. ACOs set up necessary accounts and roles to access the CMS Web Interface by the end of December 2017. ACOs download patient ranking file in early January 2018. ACOs enter clinical information into the CMS Web Interface (manually or via XML) from mid-january to mid-march (8 weeks) each year, following the performance year. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission 18

Quality Reporting Methods: CMS Web Interface The CMS Web Interface is the system ACOs must access and use to report quality data to CMS. ACOs do not need to register for Web Interface reporting. However, ACOs must get the necessary accounts and roles to access the CMS Web Interface Guidance on accessing the CMS Web Interface will be provided later this year Using 2017 3rd Quarter assignment, we will identify assigned beneficiaries eligible for quality reporting. A sample of these beneficiaries will be populated into the CMS Web Interface for quality reporting. More information on this process can be found in the 2017 Sampling Methodology document, which will be posted to the Quality Payment Program web page during the summer Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission 19

Quality Reporting Methods: CMS Web Interface Approximately 2 weeks prior to the opening of the CMS Web Interface submission period, ACOs will be able to download their Patient Ranking file (i.e., the list of beneficiaries sampled and their ranks) and supporting information, which includes: 14 patient samples, each patient s rank order number in each module, the TIN or CCN at which the patient received the most care, and 3 NPIs from whom the patient received the most care. To prepare for reporting, ACOs will have an opportunity to access a training version of the CMS Web Interface prior to the submission period. Beginning in January 2018, ACOs will have approximately 8 weeks to complete quality reporting for their patient sample for 2017 reporting. ACOs must completely report on a minimum of 248 beneficiaries in each module or 100 percent of consecutively ranked beneficiaries if they have fewer than 248 beneficiaries available in the sample. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission 20

Quality Reporting Methods: CMS Web Interface ACOs may enter data manually or import data via an Extensible Mark-up Language (XML) interface. ACOs should use the supporting documents and other materials provided for 2017 to make the most of your valuable resources: Visit the Quality Payment Program Education & Tools website for the CMS Web Interface measure documentation. The specifications are located in the Quality Measures Specifications zip file under the Documents and Download heading, For Registries, Qualified Clinical Data Registries, and EHR Vendors. Following the 8-week submission period, ACOs may be selected for the 2017 Quality Measures Validation Audit. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff 2017 Quality Reporting: Methods and Requirements of Data Submission 21

Quality Performance Scoring Quality Performance Pay for Performance Phase-In Pay for Performance Implications for ACO Compliance Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Quality Performance Scoring 22

Quality Performance CMS designates the quality performance standard for each ACO based on its performance year.* The quality performance standard is the criteria that an ACO must meet in order to be eligible to share in any savings earned. An ACO s final sharing rate based on quality performance is used to determine the ACO s eligibility for shared savings and liability for shared losses. Performance Year Pay for Reporting or Pay for Performance To be eligible to share in savings, if earned, the ACO must: 1 Pay for Reporting (P4R) Completely and accurately report all ACO quality measures. This qualifies the ACO to share in the maximum available sharing rate for payment. 2 and 3, and Pay for Performance (P4P) Completely and accurately report all quality subsequent measures and meet minimum attainment on at agreement periods least one measure in each domain. *Quality Performance Standard is the same regardless of ACO track Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Quality Performance Scoring 23

Pay for Performance Phase-In Under Pay for Performance (i.e., ACO s second and subsequent performance years/agreement periods): Increasing number of measures are phased into pay for performance each year ACOs must meet minimum attainment level (30th percentile benchmark) to receive points for pay for performance measures Shared savings payments are linked to quality performance by comparing performance to benchmarks and awarding points based on a sliding scale High performing ACOs receive higher sharing rates for earned shared savings 2015 starters and ACOs 2016 2017 in their 2 nd Agreement starters starters Pay for Performance Measures in 2017 24 17 0 Pay for Reporting Measures in 2017 7 14 31 Total Measures in 2017 31 31 31 *Note: New measures introduced to the Shared Savings Program will be set at pay for reporting for 2 years before the phase-in schedule applies, unless the measure was finalized as pay for reporting all years. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Quality Performance Scoring 24

Pay for Performance Phase-In Determining if a measure is P4R vs. P4P for your ACO Using the 2016 and 2017 Benchmark Guide, you can look at the column of the phase-in schedule associated with your performance year and determine if the measure is in P4R or P4P. However, there are several exceptions, because new measures are P4R for 2 years before transitioning to P4P. Helpful hints for understanding the new measure phase-in: If the 2016 column of the benchmarking document displays Yes*, this means that the measure was introduced in 2015. The measure will be P4R for all ACOs in 2016. The phase-in schedule displayed does not apply until 2017. If the 2016 column of the benchmarking document displays No**, this means that the measure was introduced in 2017. The measure will be P4R for all ACOs in 2017. The phase-in schedule displayed does not apply until 2019. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Quality Performance Scoring 25

Pay for Performance ACOs performance on each pay for performance measure is compared to the measure s benchmark (which is the same across all ACOs). ACOs earn points for each measure based on a sliding scale (see next slide) For more information on the benchmarks, please refer to the Quality Measure Benchmarks for the 2016 and 2017 Reporting Years, available on the Shared Savings Program website: https://www.cms.gov/medicare/medicare-fee-for-service Payment/sharedsavingsprogram/Quality-Measures-Standards.html Performance, for measures identified as pay for performance, below the minimum attainment level (i.e., below 30% or below 30th percentile benchmark) would earn zero points for that measure Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Quality Performance Scoring 26

Quality Performance Scoring: Part 1: Measure Scoring ACO Performance Level Quality Points (all measures except ACO-11) ACO-11 points 90 th percentile benchmark 2 points 4 points 80 th percentile benchmark 1.85 points 3.7 points 70 th percentile benchmark 1.7 points 3.4 points 60 th percentile benchmark 1.55 points 3.1 points 50 th percentile benchmark 1.4 points 2.8 points 40 th percentile benchmark 1.25 points 2.5 points 30 th percentile benchmark 1.10 point 2.2 points <30 th percentile benchmark No points No points Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Quality Performance Scoring 27

Quality Performance Scoring: Part 2: Quality Improvement (QI) Reward ACOs in PY2 and beyond may also earn up to 4 Quality Improvement Reward points in each domain. Methodology used to determine Quality Improvement Reward points mirrors Medicare Advantage s Five Star Rating Program* Domain Improvement Score = Net Improvement number of eligible measures Net improvement = Number of significantly improved measures minus number of significantly declined measures. Eligible Measures = Measures in use in the previous performance year and the current performance year. In cases where the ACO shows a statistically significant decline on a measure, but in both years, the ACO s performance rate on the measure is above 90% (or, in the case of certain measures, above the 90th percentile benchmark), the change will be considered no change. *For more information on the Medicare Advantage 5 Star Rating Methodology, see: http://www.cms.gov/medicare/prescription-drug Coverage/PrescriptionDrugCovGenIn/Downloads/2015-Part-C-and-D-Medicare-Star-Ratings-Data-v4-16-2015.zip Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Quality Performance 28 Scoring

Quality Performance Scoring: Part 2: Quality Improvement (QI) Reward Quality Improvement Points are determined by taking the Domain Improvement Score and comparing it to the following table: Domain Improvement Score Quality Improvement Points 90+ percent 4.0 points 80+ percent 3.56 points 70+ percent 3.12 points 60+ percent 2.68 points 50+ percent 2.24 points 40+ percent 1.8 points 30+ percent 1.36 point 20+ percent 0.92 point 10+ percent 0.48 point < 10 percent No points Total points earned in a domain cannot exceed the total possible points in the domain. 29

Quality Performance Scoring: Part 3: Domain Score To calculate each domain score, the number of points earned by the ACO across all measures in the domain, including any quality improvement points earned, is divided by the number of possible points in the domain and multiplied by 100 to create a percentage. This results in a domain score for each of the four domains. 30

Quality Performance Scoring: Part 3: Domain Score Measure Performance Rate Highest Benchmark Passed Points Earned Total Possible ACO-14 76.68% 70th percentile benchmark of 75.93% 1.70 2 ACO-15 91.82% 70th percentile benchmark of 84.55% 1.70 2 ACO-16 67.17% 60th percentile benchmark of 66.35% 1.55 2 ACO-17 90.68% 90th percentile benchmark of 90.00% 2.0 2 ACO-18 46.51% 80th percentile benchmark of 39.97% 1.85 2 ACO-19 81.40% Satisfactorily Reported P4R 2.0 2 ACO-20 80.53% Satisfactorily Reported P4R 2.0 2 ACO-21 85.90% Satisfactorily Reported P4R 2.0 2 ACO-42 82.10% Satisfactorily Reported P4R 2.0 2 Subtotal from measures 16.80 18 Quality Improvement 55% >50 percent improvement 2.24 4 Reward Total 18 (not 19.04)* 18 NOTE: The Preventive Health Domain is used in this example and assumes ACO is in PY2 of first agreement period *Quality improvement points earned is capped at the possible points earned in the domain based on the number of measures in the domain. In this case, there are 9 measures in the domain, each worth 2 possible points, totaling 18 points. 31

Quality Performance Scoring: Part 4: Overall Quality Score After a score has been calculated for each domain, the four domain scores are averaged to calculate a final overall quality score. Domain Points Earned Total Possible Points Domain Score Patient/Caregiver Experience 14.80 16 92.50% Care Coordination/Patient Safety 20.50 22 93.18% Preventive Health 18.00 18 100% At-Risk Population 7.85 8 98.13% Overall Quality Score 95.95% OOOOOOO QQOOQQQ SSSOO = 92.5% + 93.18% + 100% + 98.13% = 99. 99% 4 The final overall quality score is used to calculate each ACO s sharing rate. 32

Implications for ACO Compliance ACOs who do not meet the quality performance standard will not be eligible to share in savings, if earned. Failing to meet the quality performance standard may also result in a compliance action such as a corrective action or termination. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Quality Performance Scoring 33

Alignment with the Quality Payment Program Overview MIPS APM Scoring Advanced APMs Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Quality Performance Scoring 34

Overview of Alignment The Quality Payment Program has identified the Shared Savings Program as an Alternative Payment Model (APM). ACOs in Track 1 of the Shared Savings Program do not meet the Advanced APM definition. ACOs in Tracks 2 and 3 are Advanced APMs. Eligible clinicians (ECs) in Track 1 ACOs will be assessed under MIPS using the APM scoring standard. When ECs participating in Shared Savings Program Track 2 or 3 ACOs meet the Qualifying Participant (QP) threshold for the year, they are excluded from the MIPS reporting requirements and payment adjustment. If ACOs do not meet the QP threshold, then ECs will be assessed under MIPS using the APM scoring standard. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Alignment with the Quality Payment Program 35

Overview of Alignment For 2017, for MIPS ECs participating in Shared Savings Program ACOs, a final score is assessed across 4 performance categories for the APM entity group (the MIPS ECs participating in the ACO). The final score for the APM entity group is applied to each MIPS EC that bills under the TIN of an ACO participant in the ACO. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Alignment with the Quality Payment Program 36

Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Alignment with the Quality Payment Program MIPS APM Scoring MIPS Performance Category Quality Cost Source: 81 Federal Register 77260 APM Entity Submission Requirement Shared Savings Program ACOs submit quality measures to the CMS Web Interface on behalf of their participating MIPS eligible clinicians. MIPS eligible clinicians will not be assessed 37on cost. Performance Score The MIPS quality performance category requirements and benchmarks will be used to determine the MIPS quality performance category score at the ACO level. Performance Category Weight 50% N/A 0%

MIPS APM Scoring MIPS Performance Category Improvement Activities APM Entity Submission Requirement ACOs only need to report if the CMSassigned improvement activities scores is below the maximum improvement activities score. 38 Performance Score Performance Category Weight CMS will assign the same improvement 20% activities score to each APM Entity group based on the activities required of participants in the Shared Savings Program. The minimum score is one half of the total possible points. If the assigned score does not represent the maximum improvement activities score, ACOs will have the opportunity to report additional improvement activities to add points to the APM Entity group score. Advancing All ACO participant All of the ACO participant TIN scores will be 30% Care TINs in the ACO submit aggregated as a weighted average based on Information under this category the number of MIPS eligible clinicians in each according to the MIPS TIN to yield one APM Entity group score. group reporting requirements. Source: 81 Federal Register 77260 Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Alignment with the Quality Payment Program

Advanced APMs Shared Savings Program ACOs in Tracks 2 and 3 are Advanced APMs. When ECs participating in Shared Savings Program Track 2 or 3 ACOs meet the QP threshold for the year, they are excluded from the MIPS reporting requirements and payment adjustment. ECs who are QPs for the year receive a 5% APM incentive payment. Each ACO participant TIN participating in a Shared Savings Program Advanced APM, must submit data on the Advancing Care Information (ACI) performance category (in the form and manner specified by MIPS). The Shared Savings Program will use the data to assess the ACO s performance on ACO-11 (the quality measure that assesses the use of Certified EHR technology by ECs in the ACO). Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Alignment with the Quality Payment Program 39

Quality Payment Program Resources Quality Payment Program Education & Tools webpage https://qpp.cms.gov/resources/education Quality Payment Program Fact Sheet Advancing Care Information Fact Sheet Scores for Improvement Activities in MIPS APMs in the 2017 Performance Period https://qpp.cms.gov/docs/qpp_apms_and_improvement_activities.pdf Quality Payment Program Events page: Medicare Shared Savings Program in the Quality Payment Program webinar https://www.cms.gov/medicare/quality-initiatives-patient-assessment- Instruments/Value-Based-Programs/MACRA-MIPS-and-APMs/APMs-in-The Quality-Payment-Program-for-Shared-Savings-Program-SSP-webinar-slides.pdf Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Alignment with the Quality Payment Program 40

Public Reporting CMS ACO Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Public Reporting 41

CMS All ACO measures are available for public reporting. Performance year results, which include financial and quality results, are publicly reported on data.cms.gov. In late 2018, a subset of measures collected via the CMS Web Interface and CAHPS for ACOs Survey for the 2017 reporting period may be displayed on Physician Compare: https://www.medicare.gov/physiciancompare. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Public Reporting 42

ACO ACOs must make the following available on the ACO s own website, on a designated web page for public reporting: General and organizational information Shared savings and losses information Performance on quality measures ACO Public Reporting Guidance is posted on the Shared Savings Program website via the following link: https://www.cms.gov/medicare/medicare-fee-for-service Payment/sharedsavingsprogram/Statutes-Regulations Guidance.html* *The public reporting guidance document currently available online does not yet include 2016 and 2017 quality reporting. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Public Reporting 43

Timeline, Resources, and Assistance Overview Education & Outreach Webinars Resources Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Timeline, Resources, and Assistance 44

Overview Reporting Period Summer/Fall 2017 Winter 2017-2018 Spring 2018 Summer 2018 2017 reporting period ACOs need to set up necessary accounts for quality reporting via the CMS Must have system access before CMS Web Interface opens CMS Web Quality measures validation audit in progress for select ACOs CMS calculates 2017 ACO Quality Reports and quality measures validation audit Web Interface Interface Patient claims-based and results will be ACOs need to select CMS approved vendor to administer the CAHPS for ranking file is made available CAHPS for ACOs Survey in field beginning in ACO-11 Use of Certified EHR Technology (send ACI performance data by March delivered Quality measures validation audit lessons learned webinar ACOs Survey November CMS Web 31, 2018) Interface opens for Patient Ranking files, training, then 8 weeks for reporting and submission of data to CMS Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Timeline, Resources, and Assistance 45

Education & Outreach Webinars Reporting Period 2017 reporting period Winter 2016 Measure Information Forms for Spring/Sum mer 2017 Webinar series in preparation Fall 2017 Sampling methodology made Winter 2017-2018 CMS Web Interface data Spring 2018 CMS Web Interface lessons Summer 2018 2017 financial and quality results claims-based for 2017 available on collection learned webinar (late measures reporting and the QPP support calls webinar summer) made 2017 quality website during available measures submission Audit Lessons period Training learned from webinar audit findings webinar Please stay tuned to the ACO Spotlight Newsletter and the Quality Payment Program website for announcements. Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Timeline, Resources, and Assistance 46

Resources Shared Savings Program website http://cms.gov/medicare/medicare-fee-for-service Payment/sharedsavingsprogram/Quality_Measures_Standards.html Shared Savings Program ACO Portal https://portal.cms.gov Quality webinars (all are recorded and posted on the Shared Savings Program ACO Portal) Quality Payment Program website https://qpp.cms.gov/education CMS Web Interface documentation (located in the Quality Measures Specifications zip file under the Documents and Download heading, For Registries, Qualified Clinical Data Registries, and EHR Vendors ) Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Timeline, Resources, and Assistance 47

Resources For questions related to the CMS Web Interface or quality measures Contact the QualityNet Help Desk and identify yourself as a representative from an ACO. E-mail: qnetsupport@hcqis.org Phone: (866) 288-8912 TTY: (877) 715-6222 Fax: (888) 329 7377 Monday Friday 7 a.m. - 7 p.m. CT Medicare Shared Savings Program E-mail: SharedSavingsProgram@cms.hhs.gov For questions related to the Quality Payment Program, MIPS, MACRA, and APMs Email: qpp@cms.hhs.gov Phone: (866) 288-8292 Monday Friday, 8 a.m. 8 p.m. ET Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Timeline, Resources, and Assistance 48

QUESTION & ANSWER SESSION Medicare Shared Savings Program Quality Measurement and Reporting Kickoff Q&A 49