Proposed ACL Fellows Program proposed by Ken Church and Kevin Knight, approved by ACL Exec 6/19/11 Here are the parameters of the proposed ACL Fellows Program: 0. The ACL constitution allows us to bestow the title of ACL Fellow on the most accomplished members of the association. 1. We will start with a list of founding Fellows, presented for approval to the ACL Exec. Current Exec members are excluded from the founding Fellows group. 2. We will award founding Fellows in October 2011, and use this event to publicize the ongoing ACL Fellows Program. 3. After 2011, candidates for Fellow must be nominated by an ACL member. The nominator need not be an ACL Fellow, only an ACL member. 4. To be eligible, a candidate must have been a member of ACL for the past three (3) consecutive years. This will encourage many people to maintain their ACL membership independent of conference participation. 5. Nominations are accepted by web form ("ACL Fellow Nomination Form", see attached). 6. Nominators contact two (2) additional recommenders and direct them to submit recommendations via web form ("ACL Fellow Recommendation Form", see attached). 7. ACL will not contact recommenders -- nominators are responsible for soliciting recommendation letters and following up. 8. The ACL Nominating Committee will review nominations and award Fellow titles. The Nominating Committee may edit the 20-word citations supplied by the nominators. The Nominating Committee will work without oversight of ACL Exec and without communication with the Exec. 9. All forms submitted by October 1 of a given year will be considered. Decisions will be made by December 1. After this, the Nominating Committee will be clear to work on its job of nominating Exec candidates. 10. We expect about 15 founding Fellows, 15 additional Fellows in year 2, 10 more Fellows in year 3, and then 4-8 Fellows per year in steady state, though this will depend heavily on the nominations we get. 11. Files will be carried over from year to year, so if a candidate is not accepted, re-consideration is possible. (continued next page)
Now here is a list of engineering requirements to make this program work! Excellent execution is critical for a program like this -- poor execution can make people irate. 1. An up-to-date list of Fellows (by year) must be maintained on the ACL Wiki. 2. Nomination and recommendation web forms must be programmed. 3. The ACL member portal needs to offer a way for a nominator to check the eligibility of a candidate (i.e., ACL member for past 3 consecutive years). - how can this be done? - ACL portal currently knows about all members - ACL portal currently knows who is paid up this year 4. The email address fellows@aclweb.org must be set up. 5. Someone must answer any questions sent to fellows@aclweb.org. 6. Every October: 6a. Someone must gather nominations and letters, package them up, and send them to the senior member of the Nominating Committee. 6b. The senior member of the Nominating Committee must distribute the cases to the rest of the Nominating Committee and drive to decisions by December 1. - who should the decisions be sent to? 7. Every December: 7a. Someone must create and print certificates for new Fellows (including name of new Fellow, 20-word citation, and signature of ACL President) and send those certificates by mail. 7b. Someone must send announcements of new Fellows to the ACL mailing list. 7c. Someone must post a list of new Fellows to the ACL Wiki front page news, and also augment the global Fellows list.
Association for Computational Linguistics Fellows Nomination Form The Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL) reserves the title of ACL Fellow for the most highly accomplished members of the association. The list of current ACL Fellows is found at www.aclportal.org/aclfellows. If you would like to nominate a candidate for Fellow, please fill out this form. To be eligible, a candidate must have been a member of the ACL for the past three (3) consecutive years and be nominated by a current ACL member. Please consult www.aclportal.org/members to check whether the candidate is eligible. A nominator must provide a comprehensive case for the candidate and solicit two (2) additional recommendations. Important: The nominator should direct the recommenders to fill out recommendation forms at www.acl.org/fellows/recommendations.html. ACL will not contact individual recommenders or solicit letters. All forms submitted by October 1 of a given year will be considered. Submitted forms will be kept confidential. Nominator name: Your name here. Nominator address: Your address here. Nominator email: Your email here. Candidate name: Candidate name here. Candidate address: Candidate address here. Candidate email: Candidate email here. Highest degree held by candidate, institution, and year: Post-degree positions held by the candidate, with dates: Candidate s most significant research contributions (5-10 publications, linguistic resources, software artifacts, patents, or other contributions):
Candidate s service activities: Proposed Fellow citation (20 words maximum): e.g., For significant contributions to the field of XYZ and the development of ABC. Recommender #1 name: name here. Recommender #1 address: address here. Recommender #1 email: email here. Recommender #2 name: name here. Recommender #2 address: address here. Recommender #2 email: email here. In my opinion, the candidate is: o exceptionally qualified o well qualified o somewhat qualified o not qualified Nomination letter. Please describe in detail the candidate s accomplishments, including an assessment of (1) specific contributions to computational linguistics, (2) standing relative to recognized leaders in the field, and (3) impact on other fields or society. Paste plain text, maximum equivalent of 4 pages: Paste plain text letter here SUBMIT Please address questions to fellows@aclweb.org
Association for Computational Linguistics Fellows Recommendation Form The Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL) reserves the title of ACL Fellow for the most highly accomplished members of the association. The list of current ACL Fellows is found at www.aclportal.org/aclfellows. If you have been contacted by a nominator and have agreed to provide a recommendation, please fill out this form. If you would like to make a nomination yourself, please go to www.aclportal.org/fellows/nominations.html. All forms submitted by October 1 of a given year will be considered. Submitted forms will be kept confidential. Recommender name: Your name here. Recommender address: Your address here. Recommender email: Your email here. Candidate name: Candidate name here. Nominated by: Name of ACL member who directed you to this recommendation form. In my opinion, the candidate is: o exceptionally qualified o well qualified o somewhat qualified o not qualified Recommendation letter. Please describe in detail the candidate s accomplishments, including an assessment of (1) specific contributions to computational linguistics, (2) standing relative to recognized leaders in the field, and (3) impact on other fields or society. Paste plain text, maximum equivalent of 4 pages: Paste plain text letter here SUBMIT Please address questions to fellows@aclweb.org