UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF TIN MINE TAILING SAND FOR GREENSAND CASTING MOULD AZHAR BIN ABDULLAH FK 2012 77
MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF TIN MINE TAILING SAND FOR GREENSAND CASTING MOULD By AZHAR BIN ABDULLAH Thesis Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia, in Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy October 2012
DEDICATION TO WHOM THEIR TRUE LOVE AND SUPPORT WERE BEHIND MY SUCCESS; MY FATHER, MOTHER, WIFE, SON, DAUGHTERS, BROTHERS, SISTERS AND TO THE SOUL OF MY GRANDFATHER, HJ KASIM, THE PERSON WHO ENCOURAGED ME TO PURSUE THIS STUDY. MAY ALLAH BLESS HIM AND GRANT HIM PEACE. ii
Abstract of thesis presented to the Senate of Universiti Putra Malaysia in fulfilment of the requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Chair: Faculty: MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF TIN MINE TAILING SAND FOR GREENSAND CASTING MOULD By AZHAR BIN ABDULLAH OCTOBER 2012 Professor Shamsuddin bin Sulaiman, PhD Engineering Tailing sand is the residue from tin extraction, containing between 94% to 99.5% silica. It is abundant especially in Kinta Valley of state of Perak, Klang Valley of state of Selangor and certain areas in Johor, Negeri Sembilan and Pahang in Peninsular Malaysia. Many abandon tailing sand dump areas are easily to access due to the reason of transportation of tin and at present most of them have been covered by bushes even though there are efforts to convert the land for agriculture, industrial and housing estate. The worst scenario is issue of illegal activities of tailing sand mining including sand stealing. The purpose of this research is to investigate the mechanical properties of tailing sand as aggregate for making greensand casting mould. Five samples from Tronoh and Tanjung Tualang in Perak state; Batang Berjuntai in Selangor; Jemaluang in Johor and Gambang in Pahang were gathered. iii
The experiments for this investigation are strictly obeying the American Foundrymen Society (AFS) standard of procedures. The investigation involved the process of; identifying locations for sampling of tailing sand with high content of silica in Peninsular Malaysia, conducting the mechanical sieve grading to identify the size spread, plotting the grain size distribution and calculating the average grain size. Further on with classifying the grain shape, the clay grade, the effects of controlled additions of clay (bentonite) and water and determining the working range on the mechanical moulding properties of tailing sand. The investigation involved comparing the mechanical properties of the tailing sand to mould sand taken from RCS Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd., the company supplying mould sand to the Proton Casting Plant, manufacturer of engine components in Malaysia and the requirement for foundry sand applications listed by Foseco Ferrous Foundryman s Handbook (Foseco). The size spread, grain size distribution, average grain size and grain shape of tailing sand matched the Foseco requirement and RCS, which are well sorted and uniform, within the required size (217 to 281 µm) and has sub angular with compound sphericity shape. Test on the clay grade showed that clay grade is between 0.47% -2.07%, which resembles the true clay value in the sand. Cylindrical test piece specimens dimensioning of Ø50 mm 50 mm in height from various sand clay-water ratios, were produced by applying three ramming blows of 6.666 kg each using Ridsdale-Dietert metric standard rammer. The specimens were tested for green compression strength using Ridsdale-Dietert universal sand strength machine and permeability number with Ridsdale-Dietert permeability meter. Before the iv
tests were conducted, the moisture content was measured using AND MX50 moisture analyser. The working range for samples with 2.9% by weight (wt) of water addition were at allowable clay content ranged from 2.5-5.0wt% where green compression strength ranged from 25 kn/m 2 to 43 kn/m 2 and permeability number from 63 to 225. The samples with 4.8wt% of water addition have the working range at the allowable clay content ranged from 4.0-6.5wt% where the green compression strength ranged from 35 kn/m 2 to 52 kn/m 2 and permeability number from 76 to 252. The working range for samples bonded with 3.8wt% of clay were at allowable moisture content ranged from 3.0-4.0wt% where the green compression strength ranged from 20 kn/m 2 to 48 kn/m 2 and permeability number from 90 to 255. If bonded with 7.4wt% clay, the allowable moisture content ranged from 3.5-6wt% where the green compression strength ranged from 33 kn/m 2 to 70 kn/m 2 and permeability number from 70 to 220. Finally, the investigation indicated that tailing sand is suitable as foundry sand for making greensand casting mould where the allowable clay and moisture content of tailing sand samples are within the range in application for making greensand casting mould for ferrous and non-ferrous metal. v
Abstrak tesis yang dikemukakan kepada Senat Universiti Putra Malaysia sebagai memenuhi keperluan untuk ijazah Doktor Falsafah. SIFAT-SIFAT MEKANIKAL PASIR BEKAS LOMBONG TIMAH UNTUK ACUAN TUANGAN PASIR LEMBAP Penyelia: Fakulti: Oleh AZHAR BIN ABDULLAH Oktober 2012 Professor Shamsuddin bin Sulaiman, PhD Kejuruteraan Pasir bekas lombong adalah sisa tinggalan dari pengambilan timah yang kandungan silikanya adalah di antara 94% hingga 99.5%. Ianya banyak terdapat terutamanya di Lembah Kinta di negeri Perak, Lembah Klang di negeri Selangor dan kawasan tertentu di negeri Johor, Negeri Sembilan dan Pahang di Semenanjung Malaysia. Kebanyakan longgokan pasir bekas lombong mudah untuk dijejaki disebabkan kemudahan untuk mengangkutkan timah dan sekarang kebanyakan telah dilitupi semak samun walaupun ada usaha untuk mengubahnya sebagai tapak pertanian, industri dan perumahan. Tujuan kajian ini adalah untuk menyiasat sifat-sifat mekanikal pasir bekas lombong sebagai aggregat untuk pembuatan acuan tuangan pasir lembap. Lima sampel dari Tronoh dan Tanjung Tualang di negeri Perak; Batang Berjuntai di negeri Selangor; Jemaluang di negeri Johor dan Gambang di negeri Pahang dikumpulkan vi
Penyelidikan dijalankan adalah mematuhi prosedur piawai dari American Foundrymen s Society (AFS). Penyelidikan ini melibatkan penentuan lokasi untuk pengambilan sampel pasir bekas lombong yang mengandungi kandungan silika yang tinggi di Semenanjung Malaysia, menjalankan pengredan ayakan mekanikal untuk menentukan sebaran saiz, agihan saiz bijian dan pengiraan purata saiz bijian. Seterusnya ialah pengkelasan bentuk bijian, gred tanah liat dan kesan-kesan bahan kawalan iaitu tanah liat (bentonite) dan air ke atas sifat-sifat mekanikal acuan pasir bekas lombong. Penyiasatan juga melibatkan perbandingan sifat-sifat mekanikal acuan pasir bekas lombong dengan pasir acuan yang diambil dari RCS Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd., syarikat yang membekalkan pasir acuan untuk Proton Casting Plant, pengeluar komponen injin kereta di Malaysia dan kehendak bagi applikasi pasir foundri yang disenaraikan oleh Foseco Ferrous Foundryman s Handbook (Foseco). Sebaran saiz, agihan saiz bijian, purata saiz bijian dan bentuk bijian adalah menepati kehendak Foseco dan RCS, dimana teragih seragam dengan baik, berada dalam saiz yang dikehendaki (217 µm ke 281 µm) dan mempunyai bentuk separa bersudut yang agak bulat. Ujian gred tanah liat menunjukkan mereka mempunyai peratus gred tanah liat yang boleh diterima iaitu antara 0.47% -2.07%. Spesimen ujian berbentuk selinder yang berukuran Ø50 mm 50 mm tinggi dari pelbagai nisbah pasir-tanah liat-air dihasilkan melalui hentaman 6.666 kg menggunakan Ridsdale-Dietert metric standard rammer. Spesimen kemudian diuji kekuatan mampatan lembap menggunakan Ridsdale-Dietert universal sand strength machine dan nombor ketelapan menggunakan Ridsdale-Dietert permeability meter. Sebelum ujian vii
dilaksanakan, kandungan kelembapan diukur menggunakan penganalisa kelembapan model AND MX50. Julat kerja bagi sampel yang ditambah air sebanyak 2.9% berdasarkan berat (wt) adalah pada kandungan tanah liat dibenarkan dari julat 2.5wt% ke 5.0wt% di mana kekuatan mampatan lembap berada pada julat 25 kn/m 2 ke 43 kn/m 2 dan nombor ketelapannya dari 63 ke 225. Jika sampel ditambah 4.8wt% air, julat kerjanya adalah pada kandungan tanah liat dibenarkan pada 4.0wt% ke 6.5wt% di mana kekuatan mampatan lembapnya berada pada 35 kn/m 2 ke 52 kn/m 2 dan nombor ketelapannya dari 76 ke 252. Julat kerja bagi sampel yang diikat dengan 3.8wt% tanah liat adalah pada kandungan kelembapan dibenarkan dari 3.0wt% ke 4.0wt% dimana kekuatan mampatan lembapnya dari 20 kn/m 2 ke 48 kn/m 2 dan nombor ketelapan adalah dari 90 ke 255. Jika diikat dengan 7.4wt% tanah liat, julat kerjanya berada pada kandungan kelembapan dibenarkan dari 3.5wt% ke 6wt% di mana kekuatan mampatan lembapnya dari 33 kn/m 2 ke 70 kn/m 2 dan nombor ketelapannya dari 70 ke 220. Akhir sekali, penyelidikan menunjukkan pasir bekas lombong adalah sesuai dijadikan pasir acuan bagi pembuatan acuan tuangan pasir lembap dengan kandungan tanah liat dan kelembapan yang dibenarkan adalah dalam julat yang biasa diamalkan dalam applikasi pembuatan acuan pasir tuangan lembap untuk logam ferus dan bukan ferus. viii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS In the name of Allah, most gracious, most merciful, all praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger, Muhammad SAW. I would like to express the most sincere appreciation to those who made this work possible; supervisor, member of supervisory committee, technicians, my family and friends. I would like to thank Prof. Dr. Shamsuddin Sulaiman for providing me the opportunity to complete my PhD studies under his valuable guidance, for the many useful advise and discussions, for his constant encouragement and guidance, and for co-authoring and reviewing some of my publications, where his practical experience and technical knowledge made this research and those publications more interesting and relevant. In addition, special thanks extend to the supervisory committee members; Dr. B.T. Hang Tuah bin Baharudin, Dr. M.K.A Ariffin and Dr. Vijay. I am grateful for their willingness to serve on my supervisory committee, constant encouragement, helpful advice and many fruitful discussions. I am grateful to Kementerian Pengajian Tinggi Malaysia for offering me the scholarship and FRGS for pursuing the PhD degree and for funding this research at Universiti Putra Malaysia. Thanks and acknowledgements to my parents, wife and children who deserve my deepest appreciation. I am grateful for the countless sacrifices they made to ensure that I could pursue my ambition and always being there for me. ix
Last but not the least; very thanks to all the technicians especially Mr. Saifuddin for their meaningful help during the experiments in the laboratories and also to Mr Ng Hwa Kian, Executive Director of RCS Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd., the company supplying mould sand to Proton Casting Plant for his kind contribution of RCS mould sand. x
I certify that a Thesis Examination Committee has met on 29 th October 2012 to conduct the final examination of Azhar Bin Abdullah on his thesis entitled Mechanical Properties of Tin Mine Tailing Sand for Greensand Casting Mould and the in accordance with the Universities and University College Act 1971 and the Constitution of the Universiti Putra Malaysia [P.U. (A) 106] 15 March 1998. The committee recommends that the student be awarded the Doctor of Philosophy. Members of the Thesis Examination Committee were as follows: Mohd Sapuan B. Salit, PhD Professor Faculty of Engineering Universiti Putra Malaysia (Chairman) Napsiah Bt. Ismail, Ph.D Professor Faculty of Engineering Universiti Putra Malaysia (Internal Examiner) Tang Sai Hong, Ph.D Associate Professor Faculty of Engineering Universiti Putra Malaysia (Internal Examiner) C.R. Chatwin, Ph.D Professor Department of Engineering and Design University of Sussex United Kingdom (External Examiner) SEOW HENG FONG, PhD Professor and Deputy Dean School of Graduate Studies Universiti Putra Malaysia Date: xi
This thesis was submitted to the Senate of the Universiti Putra Malaysia and has been accepted as fulfilment of the requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. The members of the supervisory committee were as follows: Shamsuddin bin Sulaiman, PhD Professor Faculty of Engineering Universiti Putra Malaysia (Chairman) B.T. Hang Tuah bin Baharudin, PhD Senior Lecturer Faculty of Engineering Universiti Putra Malaysia (Member) Mohd Khairol Anuar bin Mohd Ariffin, PhD Associate Professor Faculty of Engineering Universiti Putra Malaysia (Member) T.R.Vijayaram, PhD Principal Lecturer Faculty of Engineering and Technology (FET) Multimedia University (Member) BUJANG BIN KIM HUAT, PhD Professor and Dean School of Graduate Studies Universiti Putra Malaysia Date: xii
DECLARATION I declare that the thesis is my original work except for quotations and citations, which have been duly acknowledged. I also declare that it has not been previously, and is not concurrently, submitted for any other degree at Universiti Putra Malaysia or other institutions. AZHAR BIN ABDULLAH Date: 29 October 2012 xiii
TABLE OF CONTENTS DEDICATION ABSTRACT ABSRAK ACKNOWLEDGEMENT APPROVAL SHEETS DECLARATION LISTOF TABLES LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION Page Problem Statement 2 Objectives of the Research 4 Scope of the Work 4 Thesis Layout 5 2 LITERATURE REVIEW 2.1 Introduction 7 2.2 Sand Casting 8 2.2.1 Greensand 9 2.2.2 Drysand 11 2.2.3 Chemical Bonded Sand 12 2.3 Foundry Sand Minerals 13 ii iii vi ix xi xiii xxi xxiii xxvii 2.3.1 Silica Sand 14 2.3.2 Zircon Sand 16 2.3.3 Chromite Sand 16 2.3.4 Olivine Sand 18 2.3.5 Comparison of Foundry Sand Minerals 18 2.4 Silica Sand in Malaysia 19 2.4.1 Natural Silica 20 xiv
2.4.2 Tailing Sand 21 2.5 Mechanical Properties of Foundry Sand 2.5.1 Introduction 24 2.5.2 Mechanical Grading: Grain Size 25 Distribution and Average Grain Size 2.5.3 Classification of Grain Shape 30 2.5.4 Determination of Clay Grade 31 2.5.5 Moisture Test 32 2.5.6 Green Compression Strength 33 2.5.7 Permeability Number 35 2.5.8 Control Additions 37 2.5.8.1 Clay 37 2.5.8.2 Water 42 2.6 Summary 45 3 METHODOLOGY 3.1 Introduction 47 3.2 Assumption and Precautions 50 3.3 Sampling 51 3.4 Selection of Graded Fractions as Specimen 52 Sand 3.5 Mechanical Sieve Grading 52 3.5.1 Grain Size Distribution 54 3.5.2 Calculation of Average Grain Size 54 3.6 Classification of Grain Shape 55 3.7 Determination of Clay Grade 56 3.8 Preparation of the Mixture and Test Piece 57 3.9 Moisture Content 60 3.10 Green Compression Strength 60 3.11 Permeability Number 62 3.12 Making a Greensand Mould 64 xv
4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 4.1 Introduction 68 4.2 Grain Size Distribution 68 4.3 Average Grain Size 78 4.4 Grain Shape 81 4.5 Clay Grade 89 4.6 Green Compression Strength 90 4.6.1 Effect of Clay on the Green 90 Compression Strength 4.6.2 Effect of Moisture on the Green 97 Compression Strength 4.7 Permeability Number 103 4.7.1 Effect of Clay Content on the Permeability 103 Number 4.7.2 Effect of Moisture Content on the 109 Permeability Number 4.8 Working Range for Optimum Green Compression 116 Strength, Permeability Number, Allowable Clay and Moisture Content. 4.8.1 Tailing Sand Samples Added with 116 2.9wt% of Water 4.8.2 Tailing Sand Samples Added with 120 4.8wt% of Water 4.8.3 Tailing Sand Samples Bonded with 125 3.8wt% of Clay 4.8.4 Tailing Sand Samples Bonded with 130 7.4wt% of Clay 4.9 The Greensand Casting Mould 135 4.10 Summary 136 xvi
5 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION FOR FUTURE RESEARCH 5.1 Introduction 140 5.2 Conclusion 141 5.3 Thesis Contribution 143 5.4 Recommendation 143 REFERENCES 144 APPENDICES APPENDIX A: Chemical Composition and Reserve 152 of the Tailing Sand from the Identified Locations. APPENDIX B: Grain Shape of Mould Sand from RCS 153 Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd., AFS, Foseco and Other Tailing Sand Samples. APPENDIX C: Grain Size Distribution for Chelford 60 154 Silica Sand ((sand commonly used in the UK as a base sand and for resin bonded moulds and cores) APPENDIX D: Grain Size Distribution for Typical Grading 155 of Sand Suitable for Iron or Steel Casting according to Foseco Requirement. APPENDIX E: Grain Size Distribution for RCS 156 Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. APPENDIX F: Clay Content and Green Compression 157 Strength for Tailing Sand Samples Added with 2.9wt% and 4.8wt% of Water. APPENDIX G: Effects of Clay Content on Green 159 Compression Strength for Mould Sand from RCS Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. Added with 2.9wt% and 4.8wt% of Water. APPENDIX H: Green Compression Strength Curves for 160 xvii
Tailing Sand Samples Compared to RCS. Added with 2.9wt% and 4.8wt% water. APPENDIX I: Moisture Content and Green Compression 161 Strength for Tailing Sand Samples. Bonded with 3.8wt% and 7.4wt% of Clay. APPENDIX J: Effects of Moisture Content on Green 163 Compression Strength for RCS. Bonded with 3.8wt% and 7.4wt% of Clay. APPENDIX K: Green Compression Strength Curves of 164 Tailing Sand Samples Compared to RCS. Bonded with 3.8wt% and 7.48wt% Clay. APPENDIX L: Permeability Number for Tailing Sand 165 Samples. Added with 2.9wt% and 4.8wt% of Water. APPENDIX M: Effects of Clay Content on Permeability 167 Number for Mould Sand from RCS Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. Added with 2.9wt% and 4.8wt% of Water. APPENDIX N: Comparison on Permeability Curves for 168 Tailing Sand Samples with RCS. Added with 2.9wt% and 4.8wt% Water. APPENDIX O: Permeability Number for Tailing Sand 169 Samples. Bonded with 3.8wt% and 7.4wt% Clay. APPENDIX P: Effects of Moisture Content on the 171 Permeability Number for Mould Sand from RCS Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. Bonded with 3.8wt% and 7.4wt% Clay. APPENDIX Q: Comparison on Permeability Curves for 172 Tailing Sand Samples to RCS. Bonded with 3.8wt% and 7.4wt% Clay. xviii
APPENDIX R: Clay Content, Green Compression Strength 173 and Permeability Number for Tailing Sand Samples. Added with 2.9wt% and 4.8wt% of Water. APPENDIX S: Working Range for Optimum Green 177 Compression Strength, Permeability Number and Optimum Allowable Clay Content for Mould Sand from RCS Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. Added with 2.9wt% and 4.8wt% Water. APPENDIX T: Moisture Content, Green Compression 179 Strength and Permeability Number for Tailing Sand Samples. Bonded with 3.8wt% and 7.4wt% of Clay. APPENDIX U: Working Range for Optimum Green 183 Compression Strength, Permeability Number and Optimum Allowable Moisture Content for Mould Sand from RCS Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. Bonded with 3.8wt% and 7.4wt% Clay. APPENDIX V: Paper A: The Effect of Bentonite Clay on 185 Green Compression Strength for Tailing Sands from Old Tin Mines in Perak State, Malaysia for Making Greensand Casting Mould. APPENDIX W: Paper B: Effect of Moisture on the 191 Permeability of Tailing Sand Samples from Ex-Tin Mines in Perak State, Malaysia. APPENDIX X: Paper C: Testing for Green Compression 197 xix
Strength and Permeability on the Tailing Sand Samples Gathered from Ex Tin Mines in Perak State, Malaysia. BIODATA OF STUDENT 203 LIST OF PUBLICATIONS 204 xx