Subject: Clinical Competencies Policy No. 6 H pplicable to: Students Pages: 6 uthor: Student Promotions Committee Submitted Date: 2/28/11 Review: aculty Review Date: pproval: pproval Date: Replaces version Dated: BCKGROUND: The VM Council on Education requires that accredited colleges demonstrate entry level clinical competence. 11.3. Clinical competencies outcomes Veterinary graduates must have the basic scientific knowledge, skills and values to practice veterinary medicine, independently, at the time of graduation. t a minimum, graduates must be competent in providing entry level health care for a variety of animal species. The school/college must develop relevant measures and provide evidence that students/graduates have had adequate access to primary care cases and hands on experiences with live animals during the clinical year and must address clinical competencies in the following areas: 1. comprehensive patient diagnosis (problem solving skills), appropriate use of clinical laboratory testing, and record management 2. comprehensive treatment planning including patient referral when indicated 3. anesthesia and pain management, patient welfare 4. basic surgery skills, experience, and case management 5. basic medicine skills, experience, and case management 6. emergency and intensive care case management 7. health promotion, disease prevention/biosecurity, zoonosis, and food safety 8. client communications and ethical conduct 9. strong appreciation for the role of research in furthering the practice of veterinary medicine The University of Minnesota College of Veterinary Medicine assesses clinical competence in a number of ways. One is through longitudinal data collection by individual student in clinical rotations. Students are assessed on clinical competencies within three categories: knowledge, clinical skills and professionalism. These assessments factor into a student s rotation grade but are also used separately to determine clinical competency. The individual clinical competencies assessed at Minnesota are outlined in ppendix. They are mapped to the nine VM COE competencies as outlined in the 2007 accreditation visit self study report. POLICY: To assure clinical competence of graduates, students are required to demonstrate clinical competency in each of the areas outlined in ppendix before receiving a diploma. Deficiencies in clinical competence must be remediated and reassessed prior to the awarding of a diploma. Pages: 1 of 6
Deficiency in clinical competency is defined and managed in the following way: 1. Warning: student receiving a sore of deficient or failing in two rotation blocks in the same individual competency will receive a written notice including a reminder of the expectation/description of entry level clinical competency in that area(s). The student will receive a warning of the consequences of a third failure, will meet with the instructor(s) to review areas for improvement, and will consult with the cademic Dean regarding resources for remediation and to discuss options for development of proficiency. 2. Deficient clinical competence: fter failing the same competency a third time the following will occur: a. mentored but independent remediation will be coordinated through the Office of cademic ffairs. b. The remediation will be designed in consultation with the instructors who assessed the student as deficient and will address specific areas and recommendations for improvement. ppendix B outlines the reassessment process. c. The Student Progress Committee will be notified, will review the feedback from instructors and the preliminary remediation plan and may make additional recommendations. There will be an option to stop the clock or not depending on what is considered to be most effective in facilitating the remediation plan. Delay in graduation may be necessary pending the development of a deadline for demonstration of competency based on the individualized remediation plans. The remediation and reassessment plan will be made after review of the student s performance across time. In some cases subsequent competent performance in appropriate rotations will be used to demonstrate competency. In other cases, specific reassessment of the deficient competencies will be required. 3. student who earns a grade of D or in a rotation will be handled through the cademic Standing and Dismissal policy. If the student also has multiple deficient competencies, the SPC will determine which competencies can be remediated by retaking the rotation(s) and which competencies may require stand alone reassessment. 4. ny student who fails to demonstrate clinical competence as defined by this policy will not be granted a diploma and will be referred to the Student Promotions Committee for dismissal. *ny student who is doing remedial work or reassessment after the end of the spring semester of the clinical year will be required to register for a remediation rotation and will be responsible for tuition and other associated expenses. Pages: 2 of 6
ppendix = Outstanding. Consistently meets the highest level of expectation. Excellent knowledge base; takes an active role in the rounds; demonstrates knowledge through full participation; excellent ability to integrate and apply the knowledge; mature, compassionate, dedicated, skillful, committed, and excellent teamwork; and exceeds timely performance of tasks. B = Good to very good. Has a good to very good grasp of the information; solid ability to organize information, integrate, and make sound decisions; good ability to handle stress; compassionate and skillful patient care; and consistent timely performance of tasks C = Competent. cceptable performance; knowledge has gaps; organizational skills are adequate, and shows acceptable ability to work through a problem, integrate, and apply knowledge; some challenges handling stress and with human interaction; displays competent patient care D = Deficient. Knowledge has moderate gaps which may compromise patient care; somewhat disorganized, indecisive, confused, and disjointed; marginal ability to handle stress; somewhat immature, and has difficulty with human interaction; and may miss deadlines = ailing. Knowledge has significant gaps, greatly compromising patient care; very disorganized, indecisive, confused, and disjointed showing great difficulty working through obvious issues; exhibits serious problems in human interactions and ability to deliver patient care; and consistently misses deadlines General Rotation Evaluation 1. Knowledge: Knows how and willingness to show how Sources of Knowledge Data Gathering/ cquisition Basic Knowledge Exceptional at knowing where to look for sources to obtain knowledge and uses that knowledge with savvy. Demonstrates excellent knowledge of scientific literature relevant to cases under his/her care and accurately interprets this information. ctively gathers specific and relevant information from a variety of sources (e.g., history/physical exam, use of tests and diagnostic modalities, selection of appropriate tests, gains case history needed for care in a timely fashion) to fully understand the problem. Is often confused about where to look for sources to obtain knowledge and may not know how to use that knowledge in an astute manner. Is unaware of scientific literature relating to his/her clinical cases and/or is unable to accurately interpret this information. Seeks limited additional information to better understand problems; jumps to conclusions when gathering additional information is appropriate. Excels at demonstrating technical knowledge specific to the rotation and the application of clinical skills. Has a strong understanding of what he/she knows and does not know. Shows exceptional logic and knowledge in written interpretations and histories, case reports, discussion with faculty, and links observations from assessments to plans/discharge notes. ails to demonstrate technical knowledge specific to the rotation and the application of clinical skills. Has a basic understanding of what he/she knows and does not know. Presents only limited logic and knowledge in written interpretations and histories, case reports, discussion with faculty, and links observations from assessments to plans/discharge notes. Demonstrates complete knowledge of species specific information of species encountered in rotation (e.g. behavior, nutrition, handling, etc.) Lacks knowledge of species specific information of species encountered in rotation (e.g. behavior, nutrition, handling, etc.). Demonstrates complete knowledge of pathophysiology, etiology, epidemiology, immune response, etc. of diseases encountered in rotation. Lacks knowledge of pathophysiology, etiology, epidemiology, immune response, etc. of diseases encountered in rotation. Species Knowledge Disease Processes Rotation Specific Material: Knowledge (Please Describe) Comments: (Please add any comments regarding student s knowledge here.) 2. Clinical Skills: pplying the know how in a practical setting History Taking Demonstrates efficiency, thoroughness and accuracy in performing a Hx. Demonstrates ability to ask questions which are systematic, relevant, precise, objective, non leading and interactive with respect to information obtained. sks questions of clarification and corrects inconsistencies. Organizes historical information accurately in the medical record. Pages: 3 of 6
Physical Examination Clinical Decision Making (includes assessment of information) Diagnostic Plan Treatment Plan Organization of Information Procedures/Basic Clinical Skills Patient Care and Welfare Documentation and Written Communication Unable to gather hx data in an efficient, thorough, accurate manner. Does not ask relevant questions. Uses leading questions. Does not ask questions of clarification. Unable to organize Hx info accurately in the medical record." Demonstrates proficiency in performing a complete physical examination with efficiency, thoroughness and accuracy. ccurately identifies and records normal and abnormal findings. Unable to perform a complete, thorough, accurate physical examination. Misses significant findings. Does not recognize normal and abnormal findings. Displays outstanding ability at integrating relevant information to make sound clinical judgments. e.g. information from Hx, PE, lab data, imaging data, production data, scientific literature, etc. ormulates a complete problem list, accurately prioritizes problems, and accurately determines differential diagnoses. Makes appropriate modifications in response to change in patient status. Takes economic considerations (e.g., cost implications of decisions, making wise choices that make sense in terms of treatment and cost) at a level appropriate for a senior student. ails to integrate important clinical information,resulting in poor clinical judgment e.g. Hx, PE, lab data, imaging data, production data, scientific literature, etc. Unable to formulate a complete problem list, prioritize problems, and/or determine differential diagnoses. Does not make appropriate modifications as patient status changes. ails to take economic considerations (e.g., cost implications of decisions, making wise choices that make sense in terms of treatment and cost) when making decisions. Devises excellent diagnostic plans based on a strong knowledge base. Provides superior explanation and rationale for the diagnostic plan; explains the diagnostic plan in the context of a specific patient. Devises inadequate or incomplete diagnostic plans. ails to provide clear explanation and rationale for the diagnostic plan; does not explain the diagnostic plan in the context of a specific patient. Devises complete and accurate treatment plan. Provides superior explanation and rationale for the treatment plan; explains the treatment plan in the context of a specific patient. Devises inappropriate or incomplete treatment plans. ails to provide clear explanation and rationale for the treatment plan; does not explain the treatment plan in the context of a specific patient. Organizes information in a very systematic manner (e.g., discharge notes, POMR, etc.). Neglects to organize information in a reasonable manner. Demonstrates superior technical skills and is thorough and efficient in: obtaining histories; performing physical exams; specialty examination skills, anima handling, and is adept at basic procedures (e.g., drawing blood, inserting catheters, tissue handling, use of basic instruments, use of aseptic techniques, etc.), Demonstrates limited basic technical skills and is incomplete and inefficient at obtaining histories and performing physical exams. specialty examination skills, animal handling. Is not adept at, basic procedures (e.g., drawing blood, inserting catheters, tissue handling, use of basic instruments, use of aseptic techniques, etc. Provides excellent patient/client care. Pays vigilant attention to details, such as patient s comfort and nutrition. Ensures that treatments are done in a timely and accurate fashion. Readily recognizes changes in patient s condition and communicates changes to supervising clinicians. Provides substandard patient/client care. Does not consistently look after patient s comfort. Does not consider patient s nutritional care. Inconsistently administers treatments or provides inadequate treatment. ails to recognize and report important changes in patient s condition to supervising clinicians. Prepares medical records in an accurate, timely, and efficient manner; adept at using the system to enter medical records. Puts great effort into clearly communicating and documenting discharge information. Consistently, writes in a constructive and professional manner; adapts writing depending on the reader(e.g., other DVM s vs. client discharge records). Pages: 4 of 6
Tends to prepare medical records that are inaccurate/substandard, not timely, /or efficient; is not adept at using the system to enter medical records. Makes no particular effort to clearly communicate and document discharge information. Writes in an unclear, confusing manner that is hard to follow; fails to adapt writing depending on the reader (e.g., other DVM s vs. client discharge records). Rotation Specific Material: Clinical Skills (describe) Comments: (add comments regarding student s Clinical Skills here.) 3. Professionalism: Work habits, interpersonal maturity and skills, teamwork, commitment, initiative ttendance and Is always present and on time (with the possible exception of a true, documented emergency). lways performs tasks in a timely fashion and meets Punctuality deadlines. Does not meet attendance guidelines on syllabus. Has more than the allowed number of absences for the rotation. Consistently comes late to sessions. Consistently misses deadlines. Initiative and Willingly takes responsibility and ownership for own action and their consequences (e.g., seeks feedback, willingly admits mistakes). cceptance of Proactively follows up and follows through on case (pending data, response to treatment, etc.) Responsibility lways responds to ethical dilemmas in accordance with VM and legal standards lways readily assumes responsibility for equipment care and cleanliness. Cleans up after self. voids responsibility for own actions and their consequences (e.g., deflects blame, does not admit mistakes, resists feedback. ails to proactively follows up and follows through on case (pending data, response to treatment, etc.) Demonstrates behavior that is not in alignment with ethical with VM ethical standards and/or legal requirements Consistently fails to assume responsibility for equipment care and cleanliness. Does not clean up after self. Teamwork, Demonstrates excellent teamwork skills works cooperatively with VMC personnel and client enthusiasm and Conveys an exceptional can do spirit, a sense of optimism, ownership, and commitment and dedication. ttitude Toward Consistently demonstrates poor teamwork skills does not work cooperatively with VMC personnel and client Work Demonstrates a consistent sense of pessimism and/or lack of ownership, commitment dedication. Professional lways dresses in a professional manner. dheres to dress code. Exhibits excellent personal hygiene. ppearance Tends to be consistently casual in attire. Does not adhere to dress code. May have hygiene issues. Work Ethic and Exceeds commitments made to others (e.g., doctors, staff, clients). Dependability requently commits to things without following through, causing trust to be questioned. Care of lways readily assumes responsibility for equipment care and cleanliness. Cleans up after self. Equipment and Consistently fails to assume responsibility for equipment care and cleanliness. Does not clean up after self. Room ollow lways actively participates and asks questions to clarify assignments/priorities and carries out task as expected. Instructions Puts limited effort into asking questions to clarify assignments/priorities and/or consistently deviates from the instructions. Verbal Displays excellent communication skills with clients, peers, faculty, and staff, including the ability to initiate communication, gather information, build Communication relationships, give information, and close communication. Takes great care to demonstrate/communicate empathy and compassion. Displays substandard communication skills with clients, peers, faculty, and staff. Has trouble initiating communication, gathering information, building relationships, giving information, or closing communication. Consistently deficient in demonstrating/communicating empathy and compassion. Rotation specific Materials: Professionalism (Please Describe Comments: (Please add any comments regarding student s Professionalism here.) Pages: 5 of 6
ppendix B Reassessment Process ny student demonstrating deficient clinical competence as defined in the Clinical Competence ssessment Policy will be required to participate in the Reassessment Process. This process is outlines as follows: Deficient clinical competence will be documented in the student s file, including a listing of each clinical competency in which the student has demonstrated deficiency (as described in the Clinical Competence ssessment Policy). The Office of cademic and Student ffairs will contact the faculty who assigned the deficient scores in each of the competencies with deficiency to gather more detailed information about the nature of the deficiencies. This information will be used to counsel the student in the development of a remediation plan. Reassessment of deficient clinical competency will be scheduled within two months after notification of the student that reassessment will be required. The reassessment will be designed, administered, and evaluated by an independent faculty member (i.e. faculty who did not assign the previous deficient scores). The nature of the deficient competencies will determine the format of the reassessment but it may include written and/or oral presentation of clinical cases or demonstration of particular skills. The student will be required to pass the reassessment. If a student fails the reassessment, s/he will be given further time to remediate and a second reassessment will be scheduled If the student fails the second reassessment, additional time for remediation will be granted and a third reassessment will be scheduled. ny student who fails to pass the third reassessment attempt has not demonstrated clinical competency and will not be granted a diploma. Pages: 6 of 6