Minutes of the meeting of the Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education) held under the Chairmanship of Justice P.S. Patankar (Retd.) on Thursday, the 7th February 23 at. a.m. in the Conference Hall, Office of the Samiti, 3rd floor, Government Polytechnic Building, 49, Khenvadi, Bandra (E), Mumbai 4 5. Draft Minutes:- Following Members and Officers were present:. Shri S.B. Bhagwat, CB : Member 2. Dr. (Mrs.) Snehalata Deshmukh : Member 3. Dr. A.S. Vyas : Member Invitees: Shri I. S. Chahal, Member Secretary and Secretary, Medical Education and Drugs Department, Govt. of Maharashtra. Hence, leave of absence granted. Shri P.E. Gaikwad, Office Secretary, Shikshan Shulka Samiti was present in the meeting. Mrs. K.V. Sane, Desk Officer, Shikshan Shulka Samiti, Mumbai was present in the meeting. The copies of the agenda along with copies of the relevant documents were circulated to the Members. Item No. : To confirm and amrove the Minutes of the Meetinu of Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education) held on Thursdav the loth Januarv 23 at Conference Hall, Office of the Samiti. 3rd floor, Government Polvtechnic Buildins, 49, Kherwadi, Bandra [El, Mumbai 4 5 The Minutes of the Meeting of Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education) held on Thursday the loth January 23 at. a.m. at Conference Hall, Office of the Samiti, 3rd floor, Government Polytechnic Building, 49, Khenvadi, Bandra (E), Murr~bai - 4 5 are confirmed and approved.
2 SSS - Medical 7th February 23 Item No.2la): To review actions taken bv office on decisions arrived at in the previous meetina includina meetins held on loth Januarv,23. The action taken by the office on the decisions taken by the Samiti during its meeting held on Th~.~rsday, the loth January, 23, the details of the same are as follows: Meeting of loth Jan. 23 Item No': Item No' 2: (a a b,, Item NO. 3: Item NO, 4: Item No. 5: Actionable Points To convey the approval and confirmation of the Minutes of the Samiti. To appraise of the action taken by office and review of disposal of work for AY 22-3. Decide on the proposals received for approval of the fee structure for the courses started during AY 22-3: a) To consider and decide on proposals where there are no discrepancies. b) discrepancies were pointed out and are cleared by the Colleges/Institutes. C) TO consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies are yet to be pointed to the Colleges/Institutes. d) To consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies are not cleared by the Colleges/Institutes. e) To consider and decide on proposals under scrutiny of the office. To consider and decide the Review Application received from following colleges for fixation of fees for AY 22-3 PGD/BDS : YMT Dental College & Hospital P.G. Institution, Navi Mumbai 2) WtMSPG : Y.M.T. Homoeo~athic Medical College, Kharghar, Navi Mumbai 3) BPTH : DES College of Physiotherapy, Pune 'Onsider and decide about the of fee proposals of the Institutes/colleges those failed to submit proposals to Samiti for its consideration for AY 22-3 Action Taken by Off ice Minutes of the Samiti Published on the website of the Samiti on 6//23. 'The copy of said rr~inutes is also put up on the Notice Board on 6//23. Decision of the Samiti in respect of Clleges are published On the website & Notice Board on 6//23. Decision of the Samiti in respect of Samiti are published on the website & Notice Board on 6//23. Decision is conveyed to the respective colleges by a separate letter dated 2//23. Decision of the Samiti in respect of Samiti are published on the website & Notice Board on 6/23m
Meeting of loth Jan. 23 Item No. 6 (a) Actionable Points Letter dated 26/2/22 received from Police Inspector, Economic Offences wing, Amravati citing violation of Capitation Fees Act by Dr. Panjabrao Deshmukh Medical College, Amravati. Letter dated 6/2/22 received from Bhalchandra School of Nursing, Pune citing non approval of INC for RGNM course for AY 22-3. Letter dated 2//23 received from Vidarbha Regional Private Nursing School and Colleges Management Association, Nagpur regarding approval of final fees for RGNM course AY 22-3 of following institutes (Ref. WP No. as per decision of WP No. 325/22 In High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Nagpur Bench.) i) Sarvodaya Bhl-~miputra Bahuuddeshiya Vikas Mandal, Chandrapur ii) Tulja Bhavani Bahu-uddeshiya Sanstha's Shree Sai School of Nursing Umred, Nagpur iii) Sarvodaya Bhumiputra Bahuuddeshiya Vikas Mandal's Kasabai Nursing School, Wardha iv) Saraswati Ba huuddeshiya Shi kshan Sanshta's Saraswati Institute of Nursing Sciences and Research, Am ravati SSS - Medical 7th February 23 Action Taken by Office Decision of the Samiti in respect of Samiti are published on the website & Notice Board on 6//23. Decision is conveyed to the respective colleges by a separate letter dated 2//23. Decision of the Samiti in respect of Samiti are published on the website & Notice Board on 6//23. Decision is conveyed to the respective colleges by a separate letter dated 2//23. I I I Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is I Item To consider the report received from M/S.P.V.Page & Com/Chartered regarding Internal Audit for A.Y.27-8, 28-9. published on the website & Notice Board on 6//23, Decision is conveyed to the respective company by a separate letter dated 2//23. Any other matter with the permission to To discuss and decide in regarding Decision of the Samiti in respect of Hon'ble Member is published on the website & Notice Board on 6//23. Samiti noted it.
Itern No. 2(b): i > 4 SSS - Medical 7th February 23 To review disposal of work - Present Scenario for Academic Year 22-3. Chart showing No. of fees approval proposals received from the Institutes of Health Science Courses/Tnstitutes for Academic Year 22-3. E" u QI a m 2 e fi z 5 z a z Proposals 9 Nursing 388 388 99 289 252 28 29 29 2 RGNM Nursing 43 43 37 6 92 3 7 7 Rs. 3675d- 2 Dental Hygienist Rs. P575OJ- 22 Dental Mechanic Total 82 794 39 43 344 48 37 37 27 Rs. 6575/- Samiti noted it.
ii) 5 SSS - Medical 7th February 23 Pendancy of Revision of Applications for the month ending November 22 for the Academic Year 22-3. Sr. No. Stream No. of Revisions NO. of Revision decided PendanOl -- 2 MDJMS (PG) MedicalJMBBS 3 PG Dental 2 2 4 BDS 3 3 5 PG- Ayurved 6 Ayurved 7 PG. Homeopathic 8 Homeopathic 9 Physiotherapy MP-TH (PG.- lo Physiotherapy) Occupational l Therapy P.G. Occupational 2Therapy 3 PG - Unani ~ 4 Unani 5 BASLP 6 M.Sc.Nursing 7 P.B.B.Sc. Nursing 8 B.Sc.Nursing 9 Nursing 2 RGNMNursing 2 Dental Hygienist 22 Dental Mechanic Total Samiti noted it.
iii) 6 SSS - Medical 7th February 23 Pendancy of Revision of Applications for the month ending November 22 for the Academic Year 2-2. Sr. No. R.A.N.M. Stream No. of Revisions No. of Revision decided Pendancy Item No. 3: Samiti noted it. To decide on the pro~osals received for ap~roval of fees structure for the courses started durina Academic Year 22-3: Item No. 3Cal : To consider and decide on ~roposals where there are no discrepancies. and Item No. 3(bl : To consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies were ~ointed out and are cleared bv the Colleaes/Institutes. The Samiti considered the proposals of the following Colleges/Institutes for finalization of fee structure for the students who joined the course started during Academic Year 22-3. After deliberations, 'The Samiti decides to approve the final fee structure of the following Colleges/Institutes for the students who joined the course started during Academic Year 22-3. Figures are arrived at after considering the calculations drawn in the worksheet - calculation sheets of the respective colleges/institutes prepared by a Chartered Accountant. The students admitted in Academic Year 22-3 and there after continuing their studies will pay an enhanced fee of 5% each successive year as per the norms for 22-3 till completion of the course. For example if the fee approved is Rs.,,/- then 2" year, 3rd year and 4th year's student of the Health Science Colleges will be Rs.,5,/-. (Assuming course is of 4 years). Worksheet - Calculation sheets are available in the ofice. B.Sc. Nursing Sr. no. Code No. B.Sc.NS. Name of the Institute Jawahar Medical Foundation's Annasaheb Chudamar~ Patil, Dhule Final for course starting from 2-2 44 Final Fees for course from Ay 22-3 4 Demands 5
7 R.A.N.M. SSS - Medical 7th February 23 no. 'Ode No. Name of the Institute Final Fees Final Fees for course for course starting Starting from AY from AY 2-2 22-3 Demands 6 l2 3 4 l5 Bharat Ratna Mother Teresa Nursing School,Selu, Parbhani Mungsaji Maharaj Nursing School, Darwha, Yavatmal Mungsaji Maharaj Nursing ~choo~~~avatma~ Shree Vinaya kraobapu School of Nursing,Yavatmal Kalyan Institute of Nursing Education,Rajura, Chandrapur Binit Nursing Institute,Solapur G.B.Patil School of Nursing,Udgir,Latur Smt Saraswati Nursing School,Tondavli Aakar School of Nursing, Nagpur VKMF's Kurundwad Institute of Nursing Education,Kurundwad, Kol hapur Nasik Medico Training's College ofnursing,nashik L.D. H.T.Nursing School,Sawad, Hingoli Dr. Dalvi Memorial Hospital & Research Centre Nursing Training School,Nagpur Shree Swami Samartha Nursing School Ner (P),Yavatmal Vasundharabai Ghulkedkar Nursing School,Amravati 6 45 45 45 6 (Col led 5 536 7 6 6 6 72 6 6 -- 4-35 6466 3342 332 45 45 65 7 6 584 6 45 6 6 8828 756 72863 75453 9845 7786 49 867 (One Year) 85 687 7 45387 (One Year) 72863 89978
Sr. no. 6 7 Code No. Name of the Institute Dhanvantari Charitable Sanstha,Solapur Tulshiramji Shebe School of Nursing,Pusad, Yavatmal Final Fees for course starting from AY 2-2 7 45 SSS - Medical 7th February 23 I Final Fees I Starting from AY Institute Demands 8 Sharda Nursing School, Khapa, Bhandara 9 2 Bhakti Institute of Nursing, Pandharpur, Solapur Godavari College of Nursing, Jalgaon 65 2 2 Suretech College of Nursing, Nagpur 45 22 Vasantrao Naik Institute of Nursing,Jalna 23 RAlVM Laxmanrao Umak Memorial Nursing 4445 24 Hon.R.R.Patil Institute of Nursing Education,Sangli 25 26 27 28 Florence School of Nursing, Gad hinglaj, Kol hapur A ennn 'tjuuu Sai Nursing School,Malegaon, Nashik 4544 Nootan School of Nursing, Nandgaon, Raigad 6 Florences Nightingale Training College of Nursing, Sawangi, Wardha 55 I
9 R.G.N.M. SSS - Medical 7th February 23 Sr. no. 'Ode NO. Name of the Institute Final Fees for course starting from 2-2 Final Fees for course Demands fmmay Stalting 22-3 2 RGNM RGNM M.E.S.School of Nursing,Khed, Ratnagiri Smt. Sumitrabai Thakare Training College of Nursing, Yavatmal 35 4 37 45 39235 475 5 6 RGNM RGNM RGNM RGNM Chinguaai Institute of Nursing Education,Sangli Godavari College of Nursing, Jalgaon Florences Nightingale Training College of Nursing, Sawangi, Ward ha Gururaj School of Nursing,Pune 35 (Ad hoc) 2 55 3553 375 5 63 5 375 59577 6552 76 (RGNM) 75 (RAN M) The College/lnstitute viz. Gururaj School of Nursing, Pune teaching R.A.N.M. course are before the San-riti for finalisation of fee for Academic Year 22-3, but it is not possible to approve their fees for Academic Year 22-3 as permission for 22-3 course has been not granted by the Maharashtra Nursing Council, Mumbai. Note : R.A.N.M. aourse is of I 54 years and hence for the last six months half of the fee tbr I year can be charged wherever it is mentioned for I year aollected fee. Note : R.G. N. M. aourse is of 3 54 years and hence for the last six months half of the fees for 3 years can be charged. -: To consider and decide on proposals where discre~ancies are vet to be pointed out to the Colleqes/Institutes. Nil -: To consider and decide on proposals under scrutiny of the office. Office to scrutinize and place the proposals before the Samiti in due course.
Item No. 4l): Institution. Navi Mumbai Item No. 4(a): SSS - Medical 7th February 23 To consider and decide the Review A~~li~ation received from followina colleqes for fixation of fees for AY 22-3. Samiti heard Dr. Kokate - Principal and Mr. J.R. Dagole - Chartered Accountant on behalf of the aforesaid College/Institute. As per our resolution College/Institute has given notice to the Students/Parents and Dr. Surnal Raut and Dr. Reshma Sawla students are present. This is in respect of Post Graduate Dental course started during the Academic Year 22-3. The interim fee declared was Rs. 4,5,/-. The Institute was collected it. The Institute has demanded Rs. 4,2,4/-, but the Samiti has finalized the fee of Rs. 4,8,769/-. The Institute has pointed out the error in disallowing certain expenditure incurred by it. It has accepted that some expenses are correctly rejected. Considering all this it is now prayed that at least Rs. 4,5,/- fee may be granted. The students have no objections for it. The Institute has given letter dated 7/2/23 to that effect. We feel that it is quite reasonable. Hence we finalize the fee of Rs. 4,5,/- for students who joined the Post Graduate Dental course during the Academic Year 22-3. Office to take steps accordingly. Item No. 4(2): BDS3-YMT Dental Colleae and Hos~ital, Navi Mumbai Samiti heard Dr. Kokate - Principal and Mr. J.R. Dagole - Chartered Accountant on behalf of the aforesaid College/Institute. As per our resolution College/Institute has given notice to the Students/Parents, but none is present on behalf of students/parents. Copy of notice is produced. This is in respect of BDS course started during the Academic Year 22-3. The interim fee declared was Rs. 2,48,9/-. The Institute has demanded the fee of Rs. 2,49,7/-. But the Samiti has fnalized the fees of Rs. 2,47,2/- for the Academic Year 22-3. The Institute has pointed out the certain expenditure has wrongly not allowed. There is some substance in this. The Institute has now prayed that at least Rs. 2,48,9/- may be granted as fees, The Institute has given letter dated 7/2/23 to that effect. We feel that it is quite reasonable. Hence we finalize the fee of Rs. 2,48,9/- for students who joined the course of BDS during the Academic Year 22-3. Office to take steps accordingly.
SSS - Medical 7th February 23 Item No. 4(3: BHMSPG-YMT Homoeopathic Medical Colleae, Navi Mumbai Samiti heard Dr. Kokate - Principal and Mr. J.R. Dagole - Chartered Accountant on behalf of the aforesaid College/Institute. As per our resolution College/Institute has given notice to the Students/Parents, but none is present on behalf of students/parents. The copy of the notice is produced. This is in respect of B.H.M.S. course starting during Academic Year 22-3. The interim fee declared was Rs. 68,7/-. The Institute has demanded 68,9/-. We have finalized the fee of Rs. 64,95/- The Institute has pointed out that for Academic Year 2-2 fee finalized by the Samiti is Rs. 68,7/-. It is also pointed out there was error in proposal in stating development fee. It has now prayed that the fee of Rs. 68,7/- at least be granted. The letter dated 7/2/23 to effect is given. We feel that it is quite reasonable. Hence we finalize the fee of Rs. 68,7/- for students who joined the B.H.M.S. course during the Academic Year 22-3. Office to take steps accordingly. Item No. 4[4: DES Colleae of Phvsiotherapv, Pune Samiti heard Mr. D.A. Kulkarni, Life Member and Ms. Aparna Sadhale, Principal present on behalf of College/Institute As per our resolution College/Institute has given notice to the Students/Parents, but none is present on behalf of students/parents. The copy of the notice is produced. This is in respect of 9.P.-rh. course starting in Academic Year 22-3. The fee approved for Academic Year 2-2 of Rs. 72,/-. The fee approved for Academic Year 22-3 was Rs. 8,/-. The Institute has originally demanded fee of Rs. 9,/-. It has pointed out that the salary expenses of 7O/ ought not have deducted. There is some substance in it. The Institute has now given letter dated 7/2/23 stating that the fee of Rs. 85,/- may be declared. After deliberation, we feel that it is quite reasonable. Hence we approve the fee of Rs. 85,/- for students who joined the B.P.Th. course during the Academic Year 22-3. Office to take steps accordingly. Item No. 4(b): : Vishwastiva Nursina School, Niphad, Nashik This revision was filed on 3//22 for the course started in Academic Year 2-2. The course is of /2 years and the said course is already over. 'Therefore, this revision has become in fructuous. Hence dismissed.
Item No. 5: 2 SSS - Medical 7th February 23 To consider and decide on the letters received dated 7/2/23 received from MVPS's Institute of Nursinq Education, Nashik reaardina to finalizina the fee structure a Considered the letter dated 7/2/23 received from MVPS's Institute of N~~rsing Education, Nashik. Ofice to correct B.Sc./M.Sc. The fees already approved by the Samiti in its meeting held on 7//22. Office to take steps. Item No. 6: To consider the letter dated 7//23 received from Maharashtra Universitv of Health Sciences, Nashik demandins free Technical Education and Hiaher Education for Matana Students. Considered the letter dated 7//23 received from Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik. It is in respect of granting in exemption in payment of fees for the students belonging to 'Matang' samaj. This does not lie within the purview of this Samiti and it is for State Government to take decision. Office to communicate. Item No. 7: To consider the report received from MIS. P.V. Paae and Co., Chartered Accountants related to Internal Audit for Assessment Year 29-.2- and 2-2. To be considered in the next meeting., Item No. 8: Anv other matter with the permission to the Chiar. i Nil The next meeting of the Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education) would be held on Wednesday the 27th February 23 at. a.m. in the Meeting Hall, Office of the Samiti at 35, Government Polytechnic Building, 49, Kherwadi, Ali Yawar Jung Marg, Bandra (E) Mumbai 4 5. k./c Date: [ - 2.--- 4 CHAIRMAN