Management of ammunition in the Norwegian Defence sector by a database system Environment, Energy Security and Sustainability 2011 Hege Ringnes Dr. Oddvar Myhre Symposium and Exhibition
Kingdom of Norway Capital: Language: Oslo Norwegian Area: 385,525 km 2 148,747 sq mi Population: 4,9 millions Source: www.vol.no Source: Fjord Travels Norway
Norwegian Defence Sector 2011 Ministry of Defence The Norwegian Armed Forces Defence Research Establishment National Security Authority Defence Estate Agency Defence Staff Norwegian Army Home guard Royal Norwegian Navy Royal Norwegian Air Force Norwegian Joint Headquarters Defence Logistics Organization Defence Medical Service Defence Information Infrastructure Defence University College Intelligence Service Approx. 17 000 man-labor year Approx. 8 000 soldiers
The Norwegian Armed Forces Army Personnel 4340 Equipment 52 Leopard 2 A4NO 15 Leopard 1 A5NO 104 CV 9030 440 M-113 armoured vehicles 75 SISU/PASI armoured vehicles 31 Combat engineer vehicles 25 IVECO armoured vehicles Dingo 2 Other vehicles Navy Personnel 2360 Equipment 5 Nansen class frigate 6 Ula class submarines 3 Skjold class MTB 3 Oksøy class minehunters 3 Alta class minesweeper 2 logistic and support 20 combat boat 90 N 14 coast guard vessels Air Force Personnel 2685 Equipment 57 F-16 combat aircraft 12 Sea King 6 P-3 Orion 4 C-130J Hercules 6 Lynx helicopters 18 Bell 412 helicopters 3 DA-20 Jet Falcon 15 Saab Safari Home guard Personnel Peace-time forces: 530 Total forces: 45 000
The Norwegian Defence Environmental Management Information System (EMIS) The implementation of an environmental management system (EMS) in the Norwegian Defence started in 1999 A key element in this EMS was the establishment of The Norwegian Defence Environmental Database (NDED) All The Defence Agencies are obliged to report their environmental performance on these environmental aspects to the NDED: Energy use Fuel consumption (vehicles, vessels and aircrafts) Heating of buildings Generation of solid waste Water consumption Use of chemicals Pollution incidences Use of ammunition
The Norwegian Defence Environmental Database Tool (NDED) Collects data on consumption patterns and use of resources (environmental aspects) Relates resource-use to different activities; equipment; organizational units etc Calculates emissions, effluents and wastes (environmental impact) Objectives Environmental performance evaluations of military activities and operations Publish statistics on environmental performance relevant to stakeholders Continual improvement Management review Monitoring and correction Implement policy Planning Develop policy
Report on use of ammunition and explosives Live firing exercises serve many purposes and are an invaluable part of military training Each year more than 400 types of ammunition is used in Norwegian shooting ranges 700 shooting ranges with one or more targets ~ 30 million rounds fired per year 30 ammunition types constitute 90 % of the volume reported
Ammunition reporting - Web-based reporting Range officers are obliged to report on any use of ammunition and explosives, including operations abroad Mandatory reporting on use of ammunition and explosives Date, range officer and unit Training area, firing line and target area Ammunition data NATO catalogue number and LOT number Condition Rounds fired Number of UXOs, number of misfires, other irregularities More detailed reporting required in case of irregularities
Ammunition reporting - Web based reporting Continual NDED Environmental statistics website Regional env. manager Range officer Other internal stakeholders Defence logistics org. Ammunition safety Environmental decision support Accessible for decision-makers Reliable and factual Well-documented
Ammunition reporting - how to use the information from NDED Example 1: White phosphorus It is discovered that the use of artillery/mortar shells with white phosphorus is harmful to the environment and to the different animals living close to the firing range Picture of a crater created by 155mm artillery, smoke WP and remnants of WP Photo: FFI
Example 1 Environmental performance evaluation What types of ammunitions consist of white phosphorus? Where is it used? When is it used? In which amounts is it used? NDED
Example 1 Data input Shooting range Target area Date Ammunitiontype Rounds Range A A1 01.06.2010 Mortar, 81 mm smoke, WP 10 A2 01.06.2010 Artillery,155 mm smoke,wpm110 5 Range A A1 23.06.2010 Mortar, 81 mm smoke,wp 10 A2 23.06.2010 Artillery,155 mm smoke,wpm110 15 A1 10.08.2010 Artillery,155 mm smoke,wpm110 16 Range A A2 10.08.2010 Mortar, 81 mm smoke,wp 20 Sum Range A 76 Deposition in target area Explosives 1 % WP 16 % Copper 1 % Sum Range A Kg Explosives 15 WP 284 Copper 25 Steel 1 464 Sum 1 789 Steel 82 % All figures are fictitious Risk assessment: What is the environmental burden associated with this activity?
Ammunition reporting - how to use the information from NDED Example 2. Range management and clean up Source: MoD
Example 2 In screening purposes: how many shooting ranges are used regularly (of the 700)? what ammunition is used? what are the emissions? has the range an arrangement which restricts mobilization and spreading of contaminants? how is the composition of soil at the different ranges? NDED Identify the ranges which is heavily contaminated measuring actual environmental impact decision making/clean up: remove contaminated soil reduce bio-availability (covering/restricted access) restrict mobilization and spreading of contaminants green ammunition
Sessvollmoen training area Load (kg) Lead (Pb) 2 531 Copper (Cu) 657 Zink (Zn) 263 Antimony (Sb) 54 3 505 Limits 2 500 1 000 300 100 3 900 Load (kg) Lead (Pb) 256 Copper (Cu) 145 Zink (Zn) 21 Antimony (Sb) 2 424 Surveillance data (ug/l) Lead (Pb) 12,5 Copper (Cu) 8,7 Zink (Zn) 0,4 Antimony 0,0 Load (kg) Lead (Pb) 1 453 Copper (Cu) 752 Zink (Zn) 45 Antimony (Sb) 31 2 281 Limits 1 500 1 000 500 250 3 250 Load (kg) Lead (Pb) 36 Copper (Cu) 19 Zink (Zn) 2 Antimony (Sb) 0 57 All figures are fictitious Load (kg) Lead (Pb) 12 Copper (Cu) 6 Zink (Zn) 1 Antimony (Sb) 2 21 Aerial photo: http://www.norgeibilder.no
Conclusions Measuring environmental performance is a prerequisite for reducing the impact from the defense sector In the NDED all environmental data are collected The data in NDED are; Detailed Credible Well-documented Accessible Ammunition : Heavily polluted areas are easily identified Cost-effective clean-up Ensure ammunition safety
More information regarding environmental management in the Norwegian Defence can be found at the Ministry of Defence website (http://www.regjeringen.no/fd)