GUJARAT INTERNATIONAL FINANCE TEC-CITY COMPANY LIMITED Minutes of Pre-Bid Meeting of Request For Proposal (RFP) For Appointment of Consultant as an Independent Engineer (IE) for Multi Level Parking-2 (Project) in GIFT City on BOOT Basis. Held on December 16, 2013, 11:00 am at Board Room, GIFT Office, GIFT City, Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India-382355 The following members were present: GIFTCL Members Mr. Prakash Gaur Mr. Ganeshbabu Kolisetty Mr. Anil Kumar Naswa Mr. Ketan Pancholi Mr. Srinivasa Reddy Mr. Saumil Shah Prospective Bidders LEA Associates South Asia Pvt Ltd Frischmann Prabhu (I) Pvt. Ltd SAI Consulting Engineers Pvt. Ltd. STUP Consultant Pvt Ltd TATA Projects Ltd. Indian Register of Shipping Dongre PMC Pvt Ltd BPC Projects and Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Lockier Corporation Pvt Ltd Representative Mr. Naresh Gandhi Dr. Santosh A Jalihal Ms. Pooja Joshi Mr. Harshad Patel Mr.Ravi Dixit Mr. Jayesh Dave Mr. Harshad Kulkarni Mr. Uday Chandorikar Mr. Pranav Patel Mr. Dhruvil Patel Mr. Vijat Sheth Mr. Sahil Shah A pre-bid meeting was held on Monday, December 16, 2013 wherein prospective bidders for the Request for Proposal (RFP) for Appointment of Consultant as an Independent Engineer (IE) for Multi Level Parking-2 (Project) in GIFT City on BOOT Basis" participated. The meeting proceedings are summarized below: Page 1
1. Mr. Prakash Gaur, VP-Planning, Architecture and Environment, GIFT Project welcomed all the participants. 2. Dr. Ganesh Babu, VP- Infrastructure Planning, made a presentation to all the participants about Multi Level Parking Project, current status and Salient Features along with various ongoing and envisaged developments in the GIFT Project. 3. During the session, Mr. Prakash Gaur, Dr. Ganesh Babu, Mr. Anil Kumar Naswa and Mr. Ketan Pancholi provided clarifications to the various bidders on their written queries which were received by the GIFTCL. 4. Participants also sought clarification during an open question-answer session and suitable responses were provided to them. Queries received from prospective bidders along with response to the same (including Addenum-1) are attached at Annexure-A. VP-Planning, Architecture and Environment, GIFTCL extended vote of thanks to all the participants and concluded the pre-bid meeting. Date: 19 th December, 2013 Place: GIFT City, Gandhinagar Prakash Gaur HOD (PA&E) Page 2
Annexure-"A" Response to Queries Request for Proposal (RFP) Appointment of Consultant as an Independent Engineer (IE) for Multi Level Parking-2 (Project) in GIFT City on BOOT Basis" Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India Page 3
Sr. No. Query/ Suggestion RFP Reference Clarification Response 1 Page 11: The technical eligibility criteria states that the bidder should have experience of at least one MLP of 2000 equivalent car park spaces. we request you to kindly relax the criteria to 1000 equivalent car parks as there are very few MLPs in India with such a high car park spaces. Else this criteria can be equivalent to 2000 car parks (aggregate) Section 2: Instruction to Bidders; Clause 2.2 - Eligible Bidders; Page 11 Agreed to relax the Technical eligibility by considering the written request and requests received during pre bid meeting Please refer Addendum-1 2 Form FIN-2: Page 88; For man power requirement we request you to kindly specify the number of personnel required (for 2 projects) along with man month inputs for each position so that all the consultants can bid on the same criteria Section 5: Financial Proposal- Standard Forms; FIN-2 Detailed Break Up Of Financial Proposal; Page 88 Refer Data Sheet; 1.5 page no : 28 RFP conditions shall prevail. 3 please clarify that the construction stage for Project Phase 1 and Phase 2 will go on simultaneously. In such case 2 teams shall be required. Section 3: Terms of Reference; (B) Scope of work, Role & Functions of IE; Page 37 Construction stage for Project Phase 1 and Phase 2 will not start simultaneously. RFP conditions shall prevail. 4 it is noted that the final selection of the consultant shall be on least cost basis. We request you to kindly change the selection process to Qualify cum Cost basis selection (QCBS) for a better and competitive bidding. Data Sheet; 1.5.2 Financial Evaluation; Page 31 RFP Condition shall prevail. RFP conditions shall prevail. Page 4
Addendum-1 Request for Proposal (RFP) Appointment of Consultant as an Independent Engineer (IE) for Multi Level Parking-2 (Project) in GIFT City on BOOT Basis" Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India Page 5
Addendum Clause No. Original(Instead Of) Amendment ( Read As) Section 2: Instruction to Bidders; Clause 2.2 - Eligible Bidders; Page 11 Clause (2.2.5) Technical Eligibility Criteria: (a) The Bidder should have by itself (in the case of a single bidder) or collectively (in the case of a Consortium bidder) successfully acted as PMC/ Independent Engineer for design, implementation and management of at least one state-of-art ramp based multi level Parking(MLP) building of 2000 equivalent Car Park Spaces capacity or more with IPMS Technology during the last four years ending March 2013. (b) The bidder (single or consortium) need to submit the notarized copy of the work order and completion certificate from respective client for each project in support of their claim. Clause (2.2.5) Technical Eligibility Criteria: (a) The Bidder should have by itself (in the case of a single bidder) or collectively (in the case of a Consortium bidder) successfully acted as PMC/Independent Engineer for design, implementation and management of at least one state-of-art ramp based multi level Parking(MLP) building of 1000 equivalent Car Park Spaces capacity or more with IPMS Technology during the last four years ending March 2013. (b) The bidder (single or consortium) need to submit the notarized copy of the work order and completion certificate from respective client for each project in support of their claim. Page 6
Addendum Clause No. Original(Instead Of) Amendment ( Read As) Data Sheet, Clause No 1.5.1Technical Evaluation; sub clause No 1.5.1.2 sub criteria (1) Firms relevant experience ; (a)specific experience of the IE for development of MLP Data Sheet, Clause No 1.5.1 The Bidder should have by itself (in the case of a single bidder) or collectively (in the case of a Consortium bidder) successfully acted as PMC/Independent Engineer for design, implementation and management of at least one state-ofart ramp based multi level Parking(MLP) building of 2000 equivalent Car Park Spaces capacity or more with IPMS Technology during the last four years ending March 2013 Data Sheet, Clause No 1.5.1 The Bidder should have by itself (in the case of a single bidder) or collectively (in the case of a Consortium bidder) successfully acted as PMC/Independent Engineer for design, implementation and management of at least one state-ofart ramp based multi level Parking(MLP) building of 1000 equivalent Car Park Spaces capacity or more with IPMS Technology during the last four years ending March 2013 Page 7