UNITED NATIONS NAUONG игнвз W O R L D HEALTH ORGANIZATION ORGANISATION MONDIALE DE LA SANTÉ EXECUTIVE BOARD EBll/ 了紅 Z 15 January 1955 Eleventh Sesson ORIGINAL: ENGLISH A POSSIBLE METHOD OF DEALING WITH THE PROPOSAL OF THE REGIONAL С0Ш1ТТЕЕ FOE SOUTH-EAST ASIA EEGAEDING MAINTENANCE AND TRAVEL COSTS OF NATIONAL CANDIDATES ATTENDING NATIONAL COURSES 1. The Regonal Commttee for South-East Asa urged that the Organzaton serously reconsder the decson that t cannot fnance the travel costs and mantenance costs of natonal canddates attendng natonal courses organzed wth the help of WHO^ and further t stressed the opnon that these courses form a very valuable and economcal method of tranng^ although Governments often cannot afford to pay the canddates the out-of-pocket costs nvolved 广 2. A study of the queston ndcates that one of the problems of sendng canddates for tranng outsde ther own countres s the capacty of the underdeveloped countres to absorb tranng of ths nature # Ths absorptve capacty s determned by the lack of health personnel n the countres whch makes t dffcult to replace personnel on foregn fellowshps ; by the level of the techncal background of the canddates vhch makes t dffcult for them to proft suffcently from tranng abroad; by language dffcultes; of adaptng to foregn tranng. and by the dffculty In addton there are numerous advantages n tranng health workers n ther, ovn envronments > local problems. chef amongst them beng the easer adaptaton of technques to 3. To meet the problems stated above^ t s suggested that WHO mght develop a system of provdng a lmted subsdy to natonal health admnstratons to Ъе used for the purpose of fnancng natonal fellowshps «For example^ a 5-year plan for fnancal subsdy could be evolved whereby WHO n the frst year mght provde 50^ of the costs,.e. the WHO subsdy would be on a matchng bass wth a maxmum lmtaton; for the second year the 5 〇多 mght be reduced, to bof etc. as set forth n the followng table : 1 Document EBll/l7, page 5
EBll/74 page 2 WHO COUNTRY 1st year 50 实 2nd year _ 60* 3rd year 50* 70 多 rth year 20% 80 菸 5th year 10% 90 矢 After the ffth year Governments would Ъе expected to bear all expenses of the natonal fellowshps.
UNÍTED NATIONS NATIONS UNIES WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION EXECUTIVE BOARD Eleventh Sesson ORGANISATION MONDIALE DE LA SANTÉ EBll/74 Add.l z 17 January 1953 ORIGINAL: ENGLISH A POSSIBLE METHOD OF DEALING WITH THE PfDFOSAL OF THE REGIONAL COMMITTEE FOR SOUTH EAST ASI/ REGxRDING M^INTSK^NCS AND TRxVEL COSTS OF NATIONAL CANDIDATES ATTENDING NATIOK COURSES 4 Alternatve 2 The proposal whch appears n EBll/74 sets forth one method of reachng the am of the regonal commttee for South-East ^sa, although dfferent from that Commttee! s orgnal proposal, ^s the Board may wsh to consder n detal the specfc recommendaton of the regonal commttee, ths second alternatve s presented as a possble method of mplementng that recommendaton Durng I95I and 1952 a certan number of tranng courses wth nternatonal nstructors were held n whch half of the travel and the mantenance grants were pad from 丽〇 funds to the natonal partcpants These courses have been consdered by the countres concerned as of consderable advantage and usefulness to them for the followng reasons: (a) At a low cost to the government, vz. on the payment of half the travel cost of each natonal canddate, a very valuable tranng on a wde scale s obtaned. (b) Courses can be developed to meet a specfc need and prepare nurses and other auxlary personnel for partcular postons (c) The language dffcultes, wth whch students (from South East Asen countres) meet when sent abroad, s overcome. УЛеп such courses are organzed n ther om countres they "are gven n the language of the country. (d) The courses are adapted to local condtons and n the students 1 own envronment (e) The courses can be arranged n conjuncton wth an exstng project, f developed on a country bass Ths would not be possble n the case of nter-regonal courses
EBll/74 Add.1 page 2. The advantages accrung from such courses have evoked the countres of the South East Asa regon and stmulated assstance from WHO n the holdng of refresher courses n durng 1953 and 1954. a keen nterest n almost all requests from them for nursng and paedatrcs In the begnnng, refresher courses were organzed n the hope that the governments would provde the necessary stpends. Some courses were organzed on ths bass, but t had been found dffcult to get tranees to consent to attend the courses, because even wth the government contrbuton they were nvarably out of pocket and n most cases unable to meet the expenses on account of the low level of salares n ths regon. It, therefore, became mpossble to contnue to develop such courses and eventually t was decded to seek nternatonal assstance n the matter. 2 Proposed contrbuton of Governments It has been possble to obtan from governments half the travel costs for all the tranees, but no per dem allowances. In any case, the per dem allowance s so low n ths regon that no tranee could subsst on t and, therefore, they prefer not to attend the courses. 3. Proposed contrbuton of lyho ТШО was payng half the cost of travel and an absolute mnmum per dem of approxmately $2 n order that tranees should not be out of pocket and so refuse to attend the courses. 4. Comparatve costs - natonal courses versus nternatonal courses Every nternatonal fellowshp costs between $3,000 to $5,000 dependng on the countres of study, for twelve months. The natonal courses are normally run for a perod of about three months. The cost of nternatonal courses for a smlar.perod would be approxmately $1,500 per tranee. It s proposed, durng 1953 to tran 159 canddates at a cost to МЮ of $29,109. (The government wll contnue the payment of half the travel cost. ) In 1954, t s proposed to tran 9 canddates for a cost of See Annex 1
EBll/74 Add.l page 3 $17,103, The cost per tranee for these natonal courses, therefore, comes to $180 - II90, as compared to S,500 for the same perod for an nternatonal сourse It s, therefore, consderably cheaper to assst n natonal courses as compared to provdng nternatonal courses. 5. Under the crcumstances explaned above, the Regonal Commttee felt that ths system of natonal courses s suffcently mportant and economcal to be deservng of the small Ш0 subsdy whch s absolutely necessary to organze these courses, untl the local condtons mprove suffcently for governments to be able to bear a hgher percentage of the fnancal burden than they are dong at present. 6. It was the feelng of the Regonal Commttee that, f the Organzaton s unable to render these tranng facltes n the under-developed areas, t would seem to be falng ntone of ts prmary functons. It s, of course, to be understood that ths s a purely temporary measure for mprovng educaton and tranng facltes n certan under-developed countres untl such a tme when these countres are able to bear the full share of the costs of such courses. 7. The above suggestons are, therefore, n no way an attempt to get away from the fundamental prncple that the cost of natonal tranng should be borne by the natonal governments. Other Alternatves Another alternatve would be a dfferent combnaton of the percentage contrbutons of WHO and the governments to the natonal courses. Another possblty would be to ehange fran the system set forth n Alternatve 2 to the frst alternatve system descrbed n EB11.74, begnnng n 1955.
pageг-29,109 EBH/74-AdsSOUTH EAST ASIA REGION Grants of Travel and Mantenance Costs to natonals of the country for partcpaton n Refresher Courses. Years 1953-1954 Ccanty Project 1953 195Л Afghanstan Burma Ceylon )Inda findonesa ÍThaland School of Nursng 6 selected male nurses (Male) for 3 months MCH Refresher ;Course!Selected Nursng I Schools kch Refresher II Course MGH-ColOTÍbo & Kalutara Colombo School of Nursng Iftrsng Refresher Course MCH Refresher Course n Paedatrcs and Semnar MCH Refresher Course n Paedatrcs Refresher course n Nursng MCH-Bangkok Partculars Amount ; Furtí. Remarks Partculars AmountÎ Fund 4 partcpants for I 3 months jl4 selected nurses for 3 months 12 doctors and 12 nurses for 3 months :12 partcpants for 27 selected nurses for 3. months :24 partcpants for! 1 month 丨 24 partcpants for S 2 months 12 selected nurses I (6 for 6 "weeks and t for 2 months) 12 partcpants for 2 norths ; Total Reg. Т.Л. 1,330 I Reg. 880 ЗДЛ6 5,393 2,700 丨 Т.Л. 5,955 Reg. 2,270 2Л,51Р 4,590 t I t 3,8^0! «I j 1,705 丨! 1,890 I Т.Л. 6 selected male nurses 4 partcpants for 丨 880 3 months 1,330 Reg. 9 selected nurses 丨 2,023 for 3 months 2 doctors and 2 900 nurses for 3 months j 12 selected nurses 1,920 for 2 months 27 selected nurses 丨 5,955 for 5 months! 12 selected nurses 1,890 for 2 months j - 10 partcpants for 3 months Total Reg.. 2,205 I 14,898 2,205 Reg. -h Т.Л.