NYC Quarterly Labor Market Brief

Manhattan NYC Quarterly Labor Market Brief Employment and labor force highlights in New York City and its five boroughs This brief was prepared for the New York City Workforce Funders by NYCLMIS CUNY Graduate Center New York, NY nyclmis@gc.cuny.edu 212.817.2031

New York City Quarterly Brief In This Issue Contents NEW YORK CITY... 3 THE BRONX... 11 BROOKLYN... 17 MANHATTAN... 23 QUEENS... 29 STATEN ISLAND... 35 GLOSSARY... 41 About This quarterly report provides education and workforce development professionals with timely data about jobs, industries, in-demand skills, and workers in NYC and its five boroughs. This report is made possible with the generous support from the New York City Workforce Funders. The Center for Urban Research (CUR) at the CUNY Graduate Center undertakes basic research addressing the issues facing New York and other large cities. A common thread in CUR activities is to understand the broad forces shaping patterns of inequality, inter-group relations, and neighborhood life in large urban areas and how these trends influence and are influenced by political participation, civic engagement, and the role of government. CUR has three operating units: the CUNY Data Service, the CUNY Mapping Service, and the New York City Labor Market Information Service (NYCLMIS). The NYCLMIS at the City University of New York Graduate Center is the go-to resource for actionoriented intelligence about the labor market. We provide timely and accurate information about the labor market to help educators, workforce professionals, economic development organizations, and philanthropies make datadriven decisions that will help their students, customers, and constituencies achieve success in the labor market. We are dedicated to rigor, close collaboration with our clients, advancing the skills of the workforce, and contributing to a healthy economy. 2

Manhattan Quarterly Brief Labor Market Highlights 3.7% 2.5M 129K Unemployment Mar 2018 Jobs in the Borough Q3 2017 (Jul Sep) Job Ads Posted Online (Jan Mar) MANHATTAN New York City Labor Market Information Service 23

Manhattan Quarterly Brief Manhattan Unemployment 3.7% -0.2 +1.7K Borough Unemployment Rate (UR) Mar 2018 Percentage Point Decline in the UR Mar 2017 - Mar 2018 More Residents Found Jobs Over the Number Who Entered the Labor Force Mar 2017 - Mar 2018 Manhattan Unemployment Rate (UR) Compared to Other Boroughs Mar 2017- Mar 2018 MANHATTAN BRONX BROOKLYN QUEENS 5.0% 4.5% 4.0% 3.5% 3.0% 2.5% 7.5% 7.0% 6.5% 6.0% 5.5% 5.0% 4.5% 4.0% 6.3% 5.8% 5.3% 4.8% 4.3% 3.8% 5.6% 5.1% 4.6% 4.1% 3.6% 3.1% Mar-17 Jun-17 Sep-17 Dec-17 Mar-18 3.9% 6.1% 4.5% 3.9% 3.7% 5.8% 4.3% 3.7% Change over-the-year (in percentage points) -0.2-0.3-0.2-0.2 Manhattan Labor Force & Employment Change Mar 2017 Mar 2018 3.5K 3.0K 2.5K 2.0K 1.5K 1.0K 500 0 1.5K more people entered the labor force 3.2K more people gained employment Manhattan UR Compared to NYC, New York State & US Mar 2018 0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% Manhattan New York City 3.7% 4.2% STATEN ISLAND 6.1% 5.6% 5.1% 4.6% 4.1% 3.6% 4.5% 4.1% -0.4 New York State US 4.1% 4.8% Source Local Area Unemployment Statistics, New York State Department of Labor. Data not seasonally adjusted. 24

Manhattan Quarterly Brief Manhattan Employment 2.5M 89% +1.8% Jobs are Based in this Borough Q3 2017 (Jul Sep) Of Jobs in the Borough are in the Private Sector Q3 2017 Increase in Borough-Based Private Jobs Q3 2016 Q3 2017 (Jul Sep) Manhattan Jobs by Sector Q3 2017 848 1.7K 2.5K 3.4K 04.2K 5.1K 5.9K 6.8K 7.6K 8.5K 10.2K 9.3K 11.0K 11.9K 12.7K 13.6K 14.4K 15.3K 16.1K 17.0K 17.8K 18.7K 19.5K 20.4K 21.2K 22.0K 22.9K 23.7K 24.6K 25.4K 26.3K 27.1K 28.0K 28.8K 29.7K 30.5K 31.4K 32.2K 33.1K 33.9K 34.8K 35.6K 36.5K 37.3K 38.2K 39.0K 39.9K 40.7K 41.6K 42.4K 43.2K 44.1K 44.9K 45.8K 46.6K 47.5K 48.3K 49.2K 50.0K 50.9K 51.7K 52.6K 53.4K 54.3K 55.1K 56.0K 56.8K 57.7K 58.5K 59.4K 60.2K 61.1K 61.9K 62.8K 63.6K 64.4K 65.3K 66.1K 67.0K 67.8K 68.7K 69.5K 70.4K 71.2K 72.1K 72.9K 73.8K 74.6K 75.5K 76.3K 77.2K 78.0K 78.9K 79.7K 80.6K 81.4K 82.3K 83.1K 84.0K 84.8K 85.6K 86.5K 87.3K 88.2K 89.0K 89.9K 90.7K 91.6K 92.4K 93.3K 94.1K 95.0K 95.8K 96.7K 97.5K 98.4K 100.1K 99.2K 100.9K 101.8K 102.6K 103.5K 104.3K 105.2K 106.0K 106.8K 107.7K 108.5K 109.4K 110.2K 111.1K 111.9K 112.8K 113.6K 114.5K 115.3K 116.2K 117.0K 117.9K 118.7K 119.6K 120.4K 121.3K 122.1K 123.0K 123.8K 124.7K 125.5K 126.4K 127.2K 128.0K 128.9K 129.7K 130.6K 131.4K 132.3K 133.1K 134.0K 134.8K 135.7K 136.5K 137.4K 138.2K 139.1K 139.9K 140.8K 141.6K 142.5K 143.3K 144.2K 145.0K 145.9K 146.7K 147.6K 148.4K 149.2K 150.1K 150.9K 151.8K 152.6K 153.5K 154.3K 155.2K 156.0K 156.9K 157.7K 158.6K 159.4K 160.3K 161.1K 162.0K 162.8K 163.7K 164.5K 165.4K 166.2K 167.1K 167.9K 168.8K 169.6K 170.4K 171.3K 172.1K 173.0K 173.8K 174.7K 175.5K 176.4K 177.2K 178.1K 178.9K 179.8K 180.6K 181.5K 182.3K 183.2K 184.0K 184.9K 185.7K 186.6K 187.4K 188.3K 189.1K 190.0K 190.8K 191.6K 192.5K 193.3K 194.2K 195.0K 195.9K 196.7K 197.6K 198.4K 199.3K 200.1K 201.0K 201.8K 202.7K 203.5K 204.4K 205.2K 206.1K 206.9K 207.8K 208.6K 209.5K 210.3K 211.2K 212.0K 212.8K 213.7K 214.5K 215.4K 216.2K 217.1K 217.9K 218.8K 219.6K 220.5K 221.3K 222.2K 223.0K 223.9K 224.7K 225.6K 226.4K 227.3K 228.1K 229.0K 229.8K 230.7K 231.5K 232.4K 233.2K 234.0K 234.9K 235.7K 236.6K 237.4K 238.3K 239.1K 240.0K 240.8K 241.7K 242.5K 243.4K 244.2K 245.1K 245.9K 246.8K 247.6K 248.5K 249.3K 250.2K 251.0K 251.9K 252.7K 253.6K 254.4K 255.2K 256.1K 256.9K 257.8K 258.6K 259.5K 260.3K 261.2K 262.0K 262.9K 263.7K 264.6K 265.4K 266.3K 267.1K 268.0K 268.8K 269.7K 270.5K 271.4K 272.2K 273.1K 273.9K 274.8K 275.6K 276.4K 277.3K 278.1K 279.0K 279.8K 280.7K 281.5K 282.4K 283.2K 284.1K 284.9K 285.8K 286.6K 287.5K 288.3K 289.2K 290.0K 290.9K 291.7K 292.6K 293.4K 294.3K 295.1K 296.0K 296.8K 297.6K 298.5K 299.3K 300.2K 301.0K 301.9K 302.7K 303.6K 304.4K 305.3K 306.1K 307.0K 307.8K 308.7K 309.5K 310.4K 311.2K 312.1K 312.9K 313.8K 314.6K 315.5K 316.3K 317.2K 318.0K 318.8K 319.7K 320.5K 321.4K 322.2K 323.1K 323.9K 324.8K 325.6K 326.5K 327.3K 328.2K 329.0K 329.9K 330.7K 331.6K 332.4K 333.3K 334.1K 335.0K 335.8K 336.7K 337.5K 338.4K 339.2K 340.0K 340.9K 341.7K 342.6K 343.4K 344.3K 345.1K 346.0K 346.8K 347.7K 348.5K 349.4K 350.2K 351.1K 351.9K 352.8K 353.6K 354.5K 355.3K 356.2K 357.0K 357.9K 358.7K 359.6K 360.4K 361.2K 362.1K 362.9K 363.8K 364.6K 365.5K 366.3K 367.2K 368.0K 368.9K 369.7K 370.6K 371.4K 372.3K 373.1K 374.0K 374.8K 375.7K 376.5K 377.4K 378.2K 379.1K 379.9K 380.8K 381.6K 382.4K 383.3K 384.1K 385.0K 385.8K 386.7K 387.5K 388.4K 389.2K 390.1K 390.9K 391.8K 392.6K 393.5K 394.3K 395.2K 396.0K 396.9K 397.7K 398.6K 399.4K 400.3K 401.1K 402.0K 402.8K 403.6K 404.5K 405.3K 406.2K 407.0K 407.9K 408.7K 409.6K 410.4K 411.3K 412.1K 413.0K 413.8K 414.7K 415.5K 416.4K 417.2K 418.1K 418.9K 419.8K 420.6K 421.5K 422.3K 423.2K 424.0K 353K 293K 247K 235K 165K 161K 155K 151K 103K 102K 85K 74K 65K 63K 41K 25K 11K 7K Professional & technical services Finance & insurance Health care & social assistance Accommodation & food services Information Staffing agencies & waste mgmt services Retail trade Educational services Other services, except public admin. Public admin. Real estate & rental & leasing Wholesale trade Arts entertainment & recreation Company headquarters Construction Manufacturing Unclassified Transportation & warehousing Manhattan-Based Private Jobs Count Q3 2016 Q3 2017 Q3 2017 Q3 2016 2.19M 2.15M Largest Sectors in Manhattan Q3 2017 More than 1 in every 3 Manhattan jobs are in these 3 largest sectors. 14% 12% 10% Professional & Technical Finance & Insurance Manhattan Job Gains and Losses Q3 2016 Q3 2017 Top 3 sectors that grew the fastest 13% 11% 9% 7% 5% 3% 1% -1% Health Care & Social Services 9% 6% 5% Staffing agencies & waste mgmt. Company headquarters Information Bottom 3 sectors that grew most slowly or lost jobs 0% -1% -1% -2% -2% -3% -3% -4% -4% -5% -5% Construction -1% Transportation & warehousing Manufacturing -3% -5% Source NYCLMIS analysis of Quarterly Census of Employment & Wages Data Files, Private and Public Sector Employment, US Department of Labor Bureau of Labor Statistics. New York City Labor Market Information Service 25

Manhattan Quarterly Brief Manhattan Online Job Ads 129K 8% 46% Job Ads 1 Were Posted Online (Jan Mar) Of Online Job Ads Wanted Candidates with Less Than a Bachelor s Of Online Job Ads Wanted Bachelor s Degrees or Higher Not specified 45% Graduate 5% High school 6% Advertised Education Requirements Some college/ associate 2% Bachelor's 41% Manhattan Online Ad Volume by month Mar 2018 Feb 2018 Jan 2018 37.8K 39.5K Employers Who Posted the Most Online Ads Seeking Candidates with Less than Bachelor s 52.0K 12000% 24000% 36000% 48000% 0% 60000% 72000% 84000% 108000% 96000% 120000% 132000% 144000% 156000% 168000% 180000% 192000% 204000% 216000% 228000% 240000% 252000% 264000% 276000% 288000% 300000% 312000% 324000% 336000% 348000% 360000% 372000% 384000% 396000% 408000% 420000% 432000% 444000% 456000% 468000% 480000% 492000% 504000% 516000% 528000% 540000% 552000% 564000% 576000% 588000% 600000% 612000% 624000% 636000% 648000% 660000% 672000% 684000% 696000% 708000% 720000% 732000% 744000% 756000% 768000% 780000% 792000% 804000% 816000% 828000% 840000% 852000% 864000% 876000% 888000% 900000% 912000% 924000% 936000% 948000% 960000% 972000% 984000% 1008000% 996000% 1020000% 1032000% 1044000% 1056000% 1068000% 1080000% 1092000% 1104000% 1116000% 1128000% 1140000% 1152000% 1164000% 1176000% 1188000% 1200000% 1212000% 1224000% 1236000% 1248000% 1260000% 1272000% 1284000% 1296000% 1308000% 1320000% 1332000% 1344000% 1356000% 1368000% 1380000% 1392000% 1404000% 1416000% 1428000% 1440000% 1452000% 1464000% 1476000% 1488000% 1500000% 1512000% 1524000% 1536000% 1548000% 1560000% 1572000% 1584000% 1596000% 1608000% 1620000% 1632000% 1644000% 1656000% 1668000% 1680000% 1692000% 1704000% 1716000% 1728000% 1740000% 1752000% 1764000% 1776000% 1788000% 1800000% 1812000% 1824000% 1836000% 1848000% 1860000% 1872000% 1884000% 1896000% 1908000% 1920000% 1932000% 1944000% 1956000% 1968000% 1980000% 1992000% 2004000% 2016000% 2028000% 2040000% 2052000% 2064000% 2076000% 2088000% 2100000% 2112000% 2124000% 2136000% 2148000% 2160000% 2172000% 2184000% 2196000% 2208000% 2220000% 2232000% 2244000% 2256000% 2268000% 2280000% 2292000% 2304000% 2316000% 2328000% 2340000% 2352000% 2364000% 2376000% 2388000% 2400000% 2412000% 2424000% 2436000% 2448000% 2460000% 2472000% 2484000% 2496000% 2508000% 2520000% 2532000% 2544000% 2556000% 2568000% 2580000% 2592000% 2604000% 2616000% 2628000% 2640000% 2652000% 2664000% 2676000% 2688000% 2700000% 2712000% 2724000% 2736000% 2748000% 2760000% 2772000% 2784000% 2796000% 2808000% 2820000% 2832000% 2844000% 2856000% 2868000% 2880000% 2892000% 2904000% 2916000% 2928000% 2940000% 2952000% 2964000% 2976000% 2988000% 3000000% 3012000% 3024000% 3036000% 3048000% 3060000% 3072000% 3084000% 3096000% 3108000% 3120000% 3132000% 3144000% 3156000% 3168000% 3180000% 3192000% 3204000% 3216000% 3228000% 3240000% 3252000% 3264000% 3276000% 3288000% 3300000% 3312000% 3324000% 3336000% 3348000% 3360000% 3372000% 3384000% 3396000% 3408000% 3420000% 3432000% 3444000% 3456000% 3468000% 3480000% 3492000% 3504000% 3516000% 3528000% 3540000% 3552000% 3564000% 3576000% 3588000% 3600000% 3612000% 3624000% 3636000% 3648000% 3660000% 3672000% 3684000% 3696000% 3708000% 3720000% 3732000% 3744000% 3756000% 3768000% 3780000% 3792000% 3804000% 3816000% 3828000% 3840000% 3852000% 3864000% 3876000% 3888000% 3900000% 3912000% 3924000% 3936000% 3948000% 3960000% 3972000% 3984000% 3996000% 4008000% 4020000% 4032000% 4044000% 4056000% 4068000% 4080000% 4092000% 4104000% 4116000% 4128000% 4140000% 4152000% 4164000% 4176000% 4188000% 4200000% 4212000% 4224000% 4236000% 4248000% 4260000% 4272000% 4284000% 4296000% 4308000% 4320000% 4332000% 4344000% 4356000% 4368000% 4380000% 4392000% 4404000% 4416000% 4428000% 4440000% 4452000% 4464000% 4476000% 4488000% 4500000% 4512000% 4524000% 4536000% 4548000% 4560000% 4572000% 4584000% 4596000% 4608000% 4620000% 4632000% 4644000% 4656000% 4668000% 4680000% 4692000% 4704000% 4716000% 4728000% 4740000% 4752000% 4764000% 4776000% 4788000% 4800000% 4812000% 4824000% 4836000% 4848000% 4860000% 4872000% 4884000% 4896000% 4908000% 4920000% 4932000% 4944000% 4956000% 4968000% 4980000% 4992000% 5004000% 5016000% 5028000% 5040000% 5052000% 5064000% 5076000% 5088000% 5100000% 5112000% 5124000% 5136000% 5148000% 5160000% 5172000% 5184000% 5196000% 5208000% 5220000% 5232000% 5244000% 5256000% 5268000% 5280000% 5292000% 5304000% 5316000% 5328000% 5340000% 5352000% 5364000% 5376000% 5388000% 5400000% 5412000% 5424000% 5436000% 5448000% 5460000% 5472000% 5484000% 5496000% 5508000% 5520000% 5532000% 5544000% 5556000% 5568000% 5580000% 5592000% 5604000% 5616000% 5628000% 5640000% 5652000% 5664000% 5676000% 5688000% 5700000% 5712000% 5724000% 5736000% 5748000% 5760000% 5772000% 5784000% 5796000% 5808000% 5820000% 5832000% 5844000% 5856000% 5868000% 5880000% 5892000% 5904000% 5916000% 5928000% 5940000% 5952000% 5964000% 5976000% 5988000% 6000000% Most Requested Specialized Skills in Online Job Ads 36.054 72.108 108.162 144.216 0180.27 216.324 252.378 288.432 324.486 360.54 396.594 432.648 468.702 504.756 540.81 576.864 612.918 648.972 685.026 721.08 757.134 793.188 829.242 865.296 901.35 937.404 973.458 1009.512 1045.566 1081.62 1117.674 1153.728 1189.782 1225.836 1261.89 1297.944 1333.998 1370.052 1406.106 1442.16 1478.214 1514.268 1550.322 1586.376 1622.43 1658.484 1694.538 1730.592 1766.646 1838.754 1802.7 1874.808 1910.862 1946.916 1982.97 2019.024 2055.078 2091.132 2127.186 2163.24 2199.294 2235.348 2271.402 2307.456 2343.51 2379.564 2415.618 2451.672 2487.726 2523.78 2559.834 2595.888 2631.942 2667.996 2704.05 2740.104 2776.158 2812.212 2848.266 2884.32 2920.374 2956.428 2992.482 3028.536 3064.59 3100.644 3136.698 3172.752 3208.806 3244.86 3280.914 3316.968 3353.022 3389.076 3425.13 3461.184 3497.238 3533.292 3569.346 3641.454 3605.4 3677.508 3713.562 3749.616 3785.67 3821.724 3857.778 3893.832 3929.886 3965.94 4001.994 4038.048 4074.102 4110.156 4146.21 4182.264 4218.318 4254.372 4290.426 4326.48 4362.534 4398.588 4434.642 4470.696 4506.75 4542.804 4578.858 4614.912 4650.966 4687.02 4723.074 4759.128 4795.182 4831.236 4867.29 4903.344 4939.398 4975.452 5011.506 5047.56 5083.614 5119.668 5155.722 5191.776 5227.83 5263.884 5299.938 5335.992 5372.046 5444.154 5408.1 5480.208 5516.262 5552.316 5588.37 5624.424 5660.478 5696.532 5732.586 5768.64 5804.694 5840.748 5876.802 5912.856 5948.91 5984.964 6021.018 6057.072 6093.126 6129.18 6165.234 6201.288 6237.342 6273.396 6309.45 6345.504 6381.558 6417.612 6453.666 6489.72 6525.774 6561.828 6597.882 6633.936 6669.99 6706.044 6742.098 6778.152 6814.206 6850.26 6886.314 6922.368 6958.422 6994.476 7030.53 7066.584 7102.638 7138.692 7174.746 7246.854 7210.8 7282.908 7318.962 7355.016 7391.07 7427.124 7463.178 7499.232 7535.286 7571.34 7607.394 7643.448 7679.502 7715.556 7751.61 7787.664 7823.718 7859.772 7895.826 7931.88 7967.934 8003.988 8040.042 8076.096 8112.15 8148.204 8184.258 8220.312 8256.366 8292.42 8328.474 8364.528 8400.582 8436.636 8472.69 8508.744 8544.798 8580.852 8616.906 8652.96 8689.014 8725.068 8761.122 8797.176 8833.23 8869.284 8905.338 8941.392 8977.446 9049.554 9013.5 9085.608 9121.662 9157.716 9193.77 9229.824 9265.878 9301.932 9337.986 9374.04 9410.094 9446.148 9482.202 9518.256 9554.31 9590.364 9626.418 9662.472 9698.526 9734.58 9770.634 9806.688 9842.742 9878.796 9914.85 9950.904 9986.958 10023.012 10059.066 10095.12 10131.174 10167.228 10203.282 10239.336 10275.39 10311.444 10347.498 10383.552 10419.606 10455.66 10491.714 10527.768 10563.822 10599.876 10635.93 10671.984 10708.038 10744.092 10780.146 10852.254 10816.2 10888.308 10924.362 10960.416 10996.47 11032.524 11068.578 11104.632 11140.686 11176.74 11212.794 11248.848 11284.902 11320.956 11357.01 11393.064 11429.118 11465.172 11501.226 11537.28 11573.334 11609.388 11645.442 11681.496 11717.55 11753.604 11789.658 11825.712 11861.766 11897.82 11933.874 11969.928 12005.982 12042.036 12078.09 12114.144 12150.198 12186.252 12222.306 12258.36 12294.414 12330.468 12366.522 12402.576 12438.63 12474.684 12510.738 12546.792 12582.846 12654.954 12618.9 12691.008 12727.062 12763.116 12799.17 12835.224 12871.278 12907.332 12943.386 12979.44 13015.494 13051.548 13087.602 13123.656 13159.71 13195.764 13231.818 13267.872 13303.926 13339.98 13376.034 13412.088 13448.142 13484.196 13520.25 13556.304 13592.358 13628.412 13664.466 13700.52 13736.574 13772.628 13808.682 13844.736 13880.79 13916.844 13952.898 13988.952 14025.006 14061.06 14097.114 14133.168 14169.222 14205.276 14241.33 14277.384 14313.438 14349.492 14385.546 14457.654 14421.6 14493.708 14529.762 14565.816 14601.87 14637.924 14673.978 14710.032 14746.086 14782.14 14818.194 14854.248 14890.302 14926.356 14962.41 14998.464 15034.518 15070.572 15106.626 15142.68 15178.734 15214.788 15250.842 15286.896 15322.95 15359.004 15395.058 15431.112 15467.166 15503.22 15539.274 15575.328 15611.382 15647.436 15683.49 15719.544 15755.598 15791.652 15827.706 15863.76 15899.814 15935.868 15971.922 16007.976 16044.03 16080.084 16116.138 16152.192 16188.246 16260.354 16224.3 16296.408 16332.462 16368.516 16404.57 16440.624 16476.678 16512.732 16548.786 16584.84 16620.894 16656.948 16693.002 16729.056 16765.11 16801.164 16837.218 16873.272 16909.326 16945.38 16981.434 17017.488 17053.542 17089.596 17125.65 17161.704 17197.758 17233.812 17269.866 17305.92 17341.974 17378.028 17414.082 17450.136 17486.19 17522.244 17558.298 17594.352 17630.406 17666.46 17702.514 17738.568 17774.622 17810.676 17846.73 17882.784 17918.838 17954.892 17990.946 18027 15.7K 14.5K 13.2K 12.7K 11.9K 9.5K 7.7K 7.0K 6.6K 6.5K Project Management Budgeting Customer Service Sales Scheduling SQL Java Customer Contact Python Accounting 615 NYU Langone Health 263 NY Presbyterian Hospital 199 Allied Universal Security Systems 149 Memorial Sloan Kettering 111 Columbia University 96 Family Dollar Stores Inc. 95 Mt. Sinai 85 Marriott International 78 NYC Dept. Health 78 Ricoh Electronics 1 An ad is not a job opening. Some postings advertise several openings while others search for talent not connected to a specific opening. Still, this measure is among the best available for indicators of future hiring. Source NYCLMIS analysis of Labor Insights Burning Glass Technologies. 26

Manhattan Quarterly Brief Occupations Advertised the Most Online in Manhattan by Education Level 105 141 176 70 211 035 246 281 316 351 387 422 457 492 527 562 597 633 668 703 738 773 808 843 879 914 949 1.0K 984 1.1K 1.2K 1.3K 1.4K 1.5K 1.6K 1.7K 1.8K 1.9K 2.0K 2.1K 2.2K 2.3K 2.4K 2.5K 2.6K 2.7K 2.8K 2.9K 3.0K 3.1K 3.2K 3.3K 3.4K 3.5K 3.6K 3.7K 3.8K 3.9K 4.0K 4.1K 4.2K 4.3K 4.4K 4.5K 4.6K 4.7K 4.8K 4.9K 5.0K 5.1K 5.2K 5.3K 5.4K 5.5K 5.6K 5.7K 5.8K 5.9K 6.0K 6.1K 6.2K 6.3K 6.4K 6.5K 6.6K 6.7K 6.8K 6.9K 7.0K 7.1K 7.2K 7.3K 7.4K 7.5K 7.6K 7.7K 7.8K 7.9K 8.0K 8.1K 8.2K 8.3K 8.4K 8.5K 8.6K 8.7K 8.8K 8.9K 9.0K 9.1K 9.2K 9.3K 9.4K 9.5K 9.6K 9.7K 9.8K 10.0K 9.9K 10.1K 10.2K 10.3K 10.4K 10.5K 10.6K 10.7K 10.8K 10.9K 11.0K 11.1K 11.2K 11.3K 11.4K 11.5K 11.6K 11.7K 11.8K 11.9K 12.0K 12.1K 12.2K 12.3K 12.4K 12.5K 12.6K 12.7K 12.8K 12.9K 13.0K 13.1K 13.2K 13.3K 13.4K 13.5K 13.6K 13.7K 13.8K 13.9K 14.0K 14.1K 14.2K 14.3K 14.4K 14.5K 14.6K 14.7K 14.8K 14.9K 15.0K 15.1K 15.2K 15.3K 15.4K 15.5K 15.6K 15.7K 15.8K 15.9K 16.0K 16.1K 16.2K 16.3K 16.4K 16.5K 16.6K 16.7K 16.8K 16.9K 17.0K 17.1K 17.2K 17.3K 17.4K 17.5K 17.6K Web developers Paralegals & legal assistants Preschool teachers Medical & clinical lab techs Network support specialists # Job ads online NYC annual median wage Associate degree 687 148 132 117 2.0K $80.4K $58.7K $43.9K $52.8K $81.0K Tech support specialists Bookkeeping & accounting clerks Heavy truck drivers Health information technicians LPNs Some college or postsecondary certificate 1.3K 946 701 424 244 $57.8K $45.7K $47.5K $46.3K $55.3K Sales reps,wholesale trade & mfr. Secretaries & admin assistants Customer service reps Retail sales supervisors Exec. Secretaries & admin. assts. High school diploma or equivalent 1.9K 1.5K 1.3K 1.1K 5.0K $61.2K $42.7K $39.8K $48.4K $74.7K Retail salespeople Food prep workers & servers Restaurant cooks Maids & housekeeping cleaners Waiters & waitresses No formal equcation required 1.3K 330 274 216 182 $21.8K $21.8K $28.0K $40.4K $28.6K Sources NYCLMIS analysis of Labor Insights Burning Glass Technologies; Occupational Employment Statistics, 2017 Q1, New York State Department of Labor. Educational requirements are based on survey data collected by the US Bureau Labor of Statistics. New York City Labor Market Information Service 27

Manhattan Quarterly Brief Manhattan Workforce Demographics 25% 20% 14% Of Working Residents are 29 Years of Age or Younger Of Working Residents have a Bachelor s Degree or Higher Of Working Residents Only Earn up to $1,250/Month Resident Worker Age Distribution Resident Worker Education Distribution Age 29 or younger 25% 35% 33% Age 30-54 55% 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 9% 14% 20% 5% Age 55 or older 19% 0% Less than high school High school or equiv. Some college or associate Bachelor's or greater Resident Worker Income Distribution 00.010.020.030.040.050.060.070.080.090.10.110.120.130.140.150.160.170.180.190.20.210.220.230.240.250.260.270.280.290.30.310.320.330.340.350.360.370.380.390.40.410.420.430.440.450.460.470.480.490.50.510.520.530.540.550.560.570.580.590.60.610.620.630.640.650.660.670.680.690.70.710.720.730.740.750.760.770.780.790.8 1.7M Higher income (more than $3,333/m) 65% Commuting Patterns Work here Live outside 197K Live here Work outside 14% 21% Middle income ($1,251 - $3,333/m) Lower income ($1,250/m or less) 518K Live & work Here Source OnTheMap, U.S. Census Bureau, Center for Economic Studies. Focus on primary jobs. 28

Glossary Quarterly Brief Glossary Labor Force This term includes people of working age who are either employed or are unemployed and actively seeking employment. Unemployment Rate (UR) This is the number of people who are unemployed and actively seeking employment divided by the size of the labor force. This does not include people who are marginally attached to the labor force or discouraged from participating in it. Sector This term describes standardized broad groupings of employers by economic or commercial activity. Occupation Sometimes used interchangeably with job, this term describes standardized, detailed groupings of workers who carry out similar activities. Occupations are organized based on the work performed, and sometimes on skills, education, and training requirements. Job This is a broad term used to describe positions filled by employers. Depending on the context, it may be used interchangeably with occupations. Online Job Ads These are job announcements that are posted online. This report presents these data in aggregate to illustrate overall demand online. The ratio of online ads to actual job openings is not always 1:1. Moreover, not all jobs are equally represented online. Some industries and employers may advertise exclusively online. Some may prefer to recruit through word of mouth or through existing talent networks. Others may employ some combination of one or more of these techniques to identify talent. Specialized Skills These refer to the training and knowledge required to do perform a specific job. In aggregate, they can offer an indication of the type of work that is in-demand across sectors and occupations. Questions about this report? Contact: Pam Hoberman phoberman@gc.cuny.edu 212.817.2037 Yuemeng Zhang yzhang@gc.cuny.edu 212.817.2035 A special thanks to NYCLMIS staff Kasey Zapatka, Jaclyn Kelly, and Ronnie Kauder for their valuable contributions to this report, and to NYCLMIS Director, Lesley Hirsch, for her exceptional creativity and guidance. Assorted icons by Freepik and Neal Creative. NYC map design by Scott Citron. New York City Labor Market Information Service 41

Staten Island Quarterly Brief NEW YORK CITY LABOR MARKET INFORMATION SERVICE CUNY GRADUATE CENTER 365 FIFTH AVENUE, ROOM 6202 NEW YORK, NY 10016 www.gc.cuny.edu/lmis 212.817.2031 42