WIN-WIN-WIN APPROACHES TO ACCOUNTABLE CARE

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "WIN-WIN-WIN APPROACHES TO ACCOUNTABLE CARE"

Transcription

1 WIN-WIN-WIN APPROACHES TO ACCOUNTABLE CARE How Providers, Hospitals, Employers, and Patients Can All Benefit from Healthcare Payment and Delivery Reform Harold D. Miller President and CEO Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform

2 In Another Country, Passage of Landmark Legislation ACA Affordable Car Act Goal: Every citizen should have affordable transportation Method for Achieving the Goal: Give all citizens insurance that would cover the cost of new automobiles and repairs when needed 2

3 How to Control Spending on Cars If Insurance Is Paying? 3

4 To Control Spending, Payers Set Separate Fees for Each Car Part HCPCS Codes (Hierarchical Car Parts Compensation System) 4

5 Auto Workers Were Paid Based On How Many Parts They Installed HCPCS Codes (Hierarchical Car Parts Compensation System) AMA Automobile Manufacturing Association CPT System (Car Parts Tokens) 5

6 The Result for Drivers? Cars had many unnecessary parts Cars were readmitted to the factory 20% of the time to correct malfunctions This occurred despite requirements for accreditation of factories by the Joint Commission on Auto Creation and certification of auto workers by the National Committee on Quality Autos 6

7 Spending on Cars Grew Rapidly 7

8 What to Do? 8

9 What to Do? Cut Fees for Parts & Assembly Cut Fees for Parts & Assembly More Parts Were Used $ Factories Merged to Resist Fee Cuts $ $ 9

10 What to Do? Pay for Bundles Instead of Parts Driving Related Groups (DRGs) 10

11 Cost Per Bundle Declined, But More Expensive Bundles Used Small Engines Bigger Engines Really Big Engines Consumers were given bundles they didn t need 11

12 What to Do? Consumer-Directed Car Payment Consumer Share of Car Price $1,000 Copayment 10% Coinsurance w/$2,000 OOP Max $5,000 Deductible 12

13 Since Total Price Didn t Matter, Consumers Chose Expensive Cars Consumer Share of Car Price Price $18,000 Price $320,000 $1,000 Copayment $1,000 $1,000 10% Coinsurance w/$2,000 OOP Max $2,000 $2,000 $5,000 Deductible $5,000 $5,000 13

14 High Cost-Sharing Also Applied to Preventive Maintenance Consumer Share of Car Maintenance Cost Sharing High Deductible Preventive Maintenance Co-payment Full Cost 14

15 Resulting in Deferred Maintenance & Expensive Repairs Consumer Share of Car Maintenance Preventive Maintenance Deferred Maintenance Cost Sharing Co-payment Co-insurance High Deductible Full Cost No More Than Out-of-Pocket Limit 15

16 What to Do? Shared Savings Programs STEP 1 Continue Paying Factories & Workers Based on Parts STEP 2 Compare Cost of Parts and Award Shared Savings # of Parts x Cost of Parts < # of Parts x Cost of Parts % of Difference in Cost of Parts Compared to Other Cars If Minimum Savings Threshold and Quality Targets Were Met RESULT Some factories reduced parts but not enough to get shared savings Some factories spent more to meet quality targets than they received in shared savings Some factories left out parts where there were no quality measures Most factories and workers lost money and went back to business as usual 16

17 Was There a Better Way?

18 Pay for Complete Cars With Warranties, Not Parts & Repairs 18

19 Have People Pay the Last Dollar, Not the First Dollar for Cost-Share Consumer Share of Car Price Price $18,000 Price $320,000 $1,000 Copayment: $1,000 $1,000 10% Coinsurance w/$2,000 OOP Max: $2,000 $2,000 $5,000 Deductible: $5,000 $5,000 Highest-Value: $1,000 $303,000 19

20 Design Cost Sharing to Encourage Preventive Maintenance Consumer Share of Maintenance Value-Based Cost Sharing High Deductible Preventive Maintenance Deferred Maintenance No or Low Copay Co-insurance 20

21 Pay for What Consumers Need: Transportation, Not (Just) Cars $ Allow the flexibility to deliver services that best meet the individual s needs with accountability for controlling costs 21

22 In the U.S., A Historic Legislative Success ACA Affordable Care Act Goal: Every citizen should have affordable healthcare Method for Achieving the Goal: Give all citizens insurance that would cover the cost of healthcare services when needed 22

23 How to Control Spending on Care When Insurance Is Paying? 23

24 How to Control Spending on Care When Insurance Is Paying? Pay for Parts? 24

25 How to Control Spending on Care When Insurance Is Paying? Pay for Parts? Pay for Outcomes? 25

26 Diabetes: A Quarter-Trillion Dollar Problem Patient with Diabetes $176 Billion in Healthcare Spending $69 Billion in Reduced Productivity $245 Billion Total Cost Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Source: Economic Costs of Diabetes in the U.S. in 2012, Diabetes Care (Volume 36) April

27 What s America s Strategy for Reducing Cost, Improving Quality? Patient with Diabetes? $176 Billion in Healthcare Spending $69 Billion in Reduced Productivity $245 Billion Total Cost Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 27

28 Patient with Diabetes Occasional 15 Minute Visits With Overworked PCPs to Order Meds PCP 15 Minute Office Visit $73/visit Medications $176 Billion in Healthcare Spending $69 Billion in Reduced Productivity $245 Billion Total Cost Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 28

29 Patient with Diabetes With Limited Time & Resources, Is It Surprising Quality is Low? PCP 15 Minute Office Visit $73/visit Medications Quality Metrics Blood Sugar Cholesterol Blood Pressure Tobacco Use Aspirin Use Eye Exams Kidney Exams D5 <40% Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Source: Average D5 Composite Measures in Cincinnati and Minnesota Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 29

30 Patient with Diabetes PCP 15 Minute Office Visit $73/visit Medications Why Don t PCPs Do a Better Job? Quality Metrics Blood Sugar Cholesterol Blood Pressure Tobacco Use Aspirin Use Eye Exams Kidney Exams D5 <40% Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Source: Average D5 Composite Measures in Cincinnati and Minnesota Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 30

31 Patient with Diabetes More Time With Patients = Lower Revenues to PCP Practice PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Medications 20 minutes per $73 Level 3 E&M= 25% Less Revenue 25 minutes per $108 Level 4 E&M= 11% Less Revenue Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 31

32 Patient with Diabetes Proactive Outreach to Patients PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Medications to Improve Quality? $0 Payment Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 32

33 Patient with Diabetes Group Visits to Deliver Care PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Medications at Lower Cost? $0 Payment Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 33

34 Patient with Diabetes Hire a Nurse/Diabetes Educator to Help Patients Manage Health? PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Medications $0 Payment Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 34

35 Patient with Diabetes Call an Endocrinologist to Help PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Medications With Complex Patients? $0 Payment Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 35

36 Patient with Diabetes No Payment for Coordination of PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP PCPs and Specialists $0 Payment $0 Payment Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Medications Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 36

37 Patient with Diabetes Payers Do Pay for Office Visits PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications with Endocrinologists. $ Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 37

38 Patient with Diabetes Long Waits Due to Many Visits for Issues That Needed Only a Call PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications $ Month Wait for Visit Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 38

39 Patient with Diabetes And the Extra Copay May Deter the Patient From Making the Visit PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications $ Month Wait for Visit Extra Patient Copay Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 39

40 Patient with Diabetes If Patients Can t Afford Meds, All the Rest May Be in Vain PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay High Copay High Cost-Share Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 40

41 Patient with Diabetes We Don t Pay for All the Right Parts, And We Pay A Lot for the Repairs PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay High Copay Lower Payment $0 Payment $0 Payment $0 Payment $0 Payment $0 Payment High Cost-Share HIGH PAYMENT Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 41

42 Patient with Diabetes So Is It Any Surprise that Quality is Poor and Spending is High? PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay High Copay Quality Metrics Blood Sugar Cholesterol Blood Pressure Tobacco Use Aspirin Use Eye Exams Kidney Exams D5 <40% Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 42

43 Patient with Diabetes What Are Medicare and Private Health Plans Doing to Fix This? PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay High Copay Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 43

44 Patient with Diabetes Strategy 1: Force PCPs to Buy an EHR PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay High Copay Requiring EHRs Increases expenses for PCP practice Takes time away from office visits with patients PCP EHR and endocrinologist EHR may not be able to exchange data even if HIPAA barriers can be overcome Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 44

45 Patient with Diabetes Strategy 2: Bonuses/Penalties for Quality PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay High Copay $ P4P/VBP Quality Metrics Blood Sugar Cholesterol Blood Pressure Tobacco Use Aspirin Use Eye Exams Kidney Exams No additional resources to address the barriers preventing higher quality Unintended consequences of over-focus on metrics Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Hospitalizations & Death Due to Overtreatment Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 45

46 More Admits/Deaths Today Due to Low Blood Sugar Than High Hypoglycemia 1 Yr Mortality: 19.9% 30 Day Readmits: 16.3% Hyperglycemia 1 Yr Mortality: 17.1% 30 Day Readmits: 15.3% Source: National Trends in US Hospital Admissions for Hyperglycemia and Hypoglycemia Among Medicare Beneficiaries, 1999 to 2011 JAMA Internal Medicine May 17,

47 Patient with Diabetes PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay High Copay Strategy 3: Shared Savings Shared Savings $ $ No additional upfront resources to address the barriers preventing higher quality care Puts physicians at risk for services and costs they cannot control Non-Diabetes Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 47

48 Patient with Diabetes Strategy 4: Patient-Centered Medical Home PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay High Copay (Small) Monthly Payment Per Patient PCMH/ PMPM Monthly payment may be to small or inflexible to overcome service barriers No support for specialists Quality improvement or shared savings requirements may be unreasonable given size of monthly payment Bad Outcomes & High Spending Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 48

49 Patient with Diabetes A Better Way: Condition-Based Payment PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay CONDITION-BASED PAYMENT Diabetes-Related Costs Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 49

50 Patient with Diabetes Flexibility to Deliver Care Without Restrictions of FFS PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay CONDITION-BASED PAYMENT FLEXIBILITY ABOUT WHICH SERVICES TO DELIVER TO HELP PATIENTS STAY WELL Diabetes-Related Costs Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 50

51 Patient with Diabetes Accountability to Ensure Outcomes and Costs Improve PCP 15 Minute Office Visit Longer Office Visit Phone Call or Group Visit Nurse or Diabetes Educator Call to Specialist Endocrinologist Call w/ PCP Min. Office Visit Medications Low Copay CONDITION-BASED PAYMENT FLEXIBILITY ABOUT WHICH SERVICES TO DELIVER TO HELP PATIENTS STAY WELL ACCOUNTABILITY FOR MANAGING AVOIDABLE COSTS RELATED TO DIABETES AND IMPROVING OUTCOMES Diabetes-Related Costs Amputations Kidney Failure Hospitalizations ER Visits Blindness Premature Death Inability to Work Low Productivity Quality of Life Low Cost of Care Productivity 51

52 Can We Afford to Pay More for High-Quality, Coordinated Care When We re Trying to Reduce Healthcare Spending?

53 Most of the Money Today is Going to Hospitals, Not Doctors Source: Economic Costs of Diabetes in the U.S. in 2012, Diabetes Care (Volume 36) April 2013 Hospital Admissions (43%) Physicians (9%) 53

54 Could We Afford to Spend 20% More on Better Care Management? Hospital Admits Physicians +20% 54

55 A Small Reduction in Expensive Complications Saves A Lot of $$$ Hospital Admits -6% Physicians +20% 55

56 20% More $ on Care Mgt + 6% Fewer Admits = Lower Total $ -1% Hospital Admits -6% Physicians +20% 56

57 Upfront Investment Is Needed, Targeted by Docs to Achieve Impact -1% Hospital Admits -6% Physicians +20% 57

58 Today: Reactive Care for Chronic Disease, Many Hospitalizations CURRENT $/Patient # Pts Total $ Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 Hospitalizations Admissions $10, $2,500,000 Specialist $ $100,000 Total Spending 500 $2,900, Moderately Severe Chronic Disease Patients PCP paid only for periodic office visits Patients do not take maintenance medications reliably 50% of patients are hospitalized each year for exacerbations Specialist only sees patient during hospital admissions 58

59 Is There a Better Way? CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs?? PCP $ $300,000?? Hospitalizations?? Admissions $10, $2,500,000?? Specialist $ $100,000?? Total Spending 500 $2,900,000?? 59

60 Pay the PCP for Proactive Care Management CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Hospitalizations Admissions $10, $2,500,000 Specialist $ $100,000 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 60

61 Pay the Specialist to Co-Manage The Patient s Care CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % Hospitalizations Admissions $10, $2,500,000 Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 61

62 Provide Nursing Support For Patient Education & Care Mgt CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Hospitalizations Admissions $10, $2,500,000 Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 62

63 Can We Afford to Double Spending on Ambulatory Care? CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Admissions $10, $2,500,000 Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 63

64 Yes, If It Succeeds In Reducing Hospitalizations CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Admissions $10, $2,500,000 $10, $2,150,000-14% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900, $2,830, % 64

65 Improved Chronic Disease Mgt Can Potentially Generate Large Savings CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Admissions $10, $2,500,000 $10, $1,500,000-40% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900, $2,180,000-25% 65

66 But What About the Hospital? CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Admissions $10, $2,500,000 $10, $1,500,000-40% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900, $2,180,000-25% 66

67 What Should Matter to Hospitals is Margin, Not Revenues (Volume) 67

68 $000 Hospital Costs Are Not Proportional to Utilization Cost & Revenue Changes With Fewer Patients 20% reduction in volume 7% reduction in cost $1,000 $980 $960 $940 $920 $900 $880 $860 $840 $820 $800 Costs. #Patients 68

69 $000 Reductions in Utilization Reduce Revenues More Than Costs Cost & Revenue Changes With Fewer Patients 20% reduction in volume 7% reduction in cost 20% reduction in revenue $1,000 $980 $960 $940 $920 $900 $880 $860 $840 $820 $800 Revenues Costs #Patients 69

70 $000 Causing Negative Margins for Hospitals Cost & Revenue Changes With Fewer Patients Payers Will Be Underpaying For Care If Admissions, Readmissions, Etc. Are Reduced $1,000 $980 $960 $940 $920 $900 $880 $860 $840 $820 $800 Revenues Costs #Patients 70

71 $000 But Spending Can Be Reduced Without Bankrupting Hospitals Cost & Revenue Changes With Fewer Patients Payers Can $1,000 Still Save $ $980 Without Causing $960 Negative Margins $940 for Hospital $920 $900 $880 Revenues $860 Costs $840 $820 $800 #Patients 71

72 How Can 40% Fewer Admissions Be a Win for the Hospital? CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Admissions $10, $2,500,000 $10, $1,500,000-40% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900, $2,180,000-25% 72

73 Analyze the Hospital s Cost Structure CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 Total $10, $2,500,000 Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 73

74 What Happens to Hospital Finances When Admissions Go Down? CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 Total $10, $2,500, Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 74

75 Continue to Cover the Fixed Costs CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 Total $10, $2,500, Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 75

76 Save on Variable Costs With Fewer Patients CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $3,700 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 Total $10, $2,500, Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 76

77 Increase the Hospital s Contribution Margin CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total $10, $2,500, Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 77

78 Hospital Gets Less Total Revenue, But is Better Off Financially CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total $10, $2,500, $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900,000 78

79 And the Payer Still Spends Less CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total $10, $2,500, $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900, $2,817,500-3% 79

80 Win-Win-Win: Better Care, Higher Physician Pay, Lower Spending CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Providers Win Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 Hospital Wins Payer Wins $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total $10, $2,500, $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900, $2,817,500-3% 80

81 What Payment Model Supports This Win-Win-Win Approach? CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total $10, $2,500, $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900, $2,817,500-3% 81

82 You Don t Want to Try and Renegotiate Individual Fees CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total $10, $2,500,000 $14, $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending 500 $2,900, $2,817,500-3% 82

83 Look at What is Being Spent Today in Total on the Patient s Condition CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total 250 $2,500, $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending $5, $2,900, $2,817,500-3% 83

84 Tell the Payer You ll Do It For Less Than They re Spending Today CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total 250 $2,500, $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending $5, $2,900,000 $5, $2,817,500-3% 84

85 Use That Budget to Pay Doctors & Hospitals What They Really Need CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300, $450, % Specialist 500 $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300,000 $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total $2,500,000 $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending $5, $2,900,000 $5, $2,817,500-3% 85

86 Condition-Based Payment Puts the Providers in Charge of Care & Pmt CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300, $450, % Specialist 500 $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300,000 $680, % Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total $2,500,000 $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending $5, $2,900,000 $5, $2,817,500-3% 86

87 Shared Savings Doesn t Solve the Problems with FFS No actual change in payment to the physicians No funding for the nurse No payment for phone calls instead of office visits No flexibility to proactive outreach instead of reactive care Arbitrary share of savings may not be sufficient to cover higher costs of care or losses from FFS revenue <50% of savings is not adequate if >50% of costs are fixed 87

88 Condition-Based Payment Allows A Win-Win-Win Solution CURRENT FUTURE $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Pt # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs PCP $ $300,000 $ $450, % Specialist $ $150, % RN Care Mgr $80,000 Total $300, $680, % Providers Win Hospitalizations Hospital Fixed $6,000 60% $1,500,000 Hospital Wins Payer Wins $1,500,000-0% Hosp. Variable $3,700 37% $925,000 $555,000-40% Hosp. Margin $300 3% $75,000 $82, % Total $10, $2,500, $2,137,500-15% Specialist (Inpt) $ $100,000 $0 Total Spending $5, $2,900,000 $5, $2,817,500-3% 88

89 What About Proceduralists?

90 Example: Reducing Avoidable Procedures TODAY $/Patient # Pts Total $ Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 Procedures $ $120,000 Subtotal $150,000 Hospital Pmt $7, $1,400,000 Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 Optional Procedure for a Condition Physician evaluates all patients Physician performs procedure on 2/3 of evaluated patients Up to 10% of procedures may be avoidable through patient choice or alternative treatment 90

91 Under FFS, Fewer Procedures=> Losses for Physicians and Hospitals TODAY w/ UTILIZATION CTRL $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $30,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $138,000-8% Hospital Pmt $7, $1,400,000 $7, $1,260,000-10% Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 $1,398,000-10% 91

92 Is There a Better Way? TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000??? Procedures $ $120,000??? Subtotal $150,000???? Hospital Pmt $7, $1,400,000??? Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000??? 92

93 Pay Physicians to Manage Patient Care, Not to Do Procedures TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt $7, $1,400,000 $7, $1,260,000-10% Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 $1,413,000-9% Better Payment for Condition Management Physician paid adequately to engage in shared decision making process with patients and given the decision support tools to ensure quality 93

94 Physicians Could Be Paid More While Still Reducing Total $ TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt $7, $1,400,000 $7, $1,260,000-10% Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 $1,413,000-9% 94

95 What About the Hospital? TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt $7, $1,400,000 $7, $1,260,000-10% Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 $1,413,000-9% 95

96 To Create a Win for the Hospital, Determine the Cost Structure TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 Margin $350 5% $70,000 Subtotal $7, $1,400, Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 96

97 Preserve Revenues Needed for Fixed Costs TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 $700,000-0% Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 Margin $350 5% $70,000 Subtotal $7, $1,400, Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 97

98 Save on Variable Costs With Fewer Procedures TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 $700,000-0% Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 $567,000-10% Margin $350 5% $70,000 Subtotal $7, $1,400, Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 98

99 Improve Contribution Margin TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 $700,000-0% Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 $567,000-10% Margin $350 5% $70,000 $71,400 +2% Subtotal $7, $1,400, Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 99

100 And The Payer Still Saves Money TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 $700,000-0% Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 $567,000-10% Margin $350 5% $70,000 $71,400 +2% Subtotal $7, $1,400, $1,338,400-4% Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 $1,491,400-4% 100

101 I.e., Win-Win-Win for Physician, Hospital, and Payer TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45,000 Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt Physician Wins Hospital Wins Payer Wins Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 $700,000-0% Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 $567,000-10% Margin $350 5% $70,000 $71,400 +2% Subtotal $7, $1,400, $1,338,400-4% Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 $1,491,400-4% 101

102 Pay Based on the Patient s Condition, Not on the Procedure TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 Procedures $ $120,000 Subtotal $150,000 Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 Margin $350 5% $70,000 Subtotal $7, $1,400,000 Total Pmt/Cost $5, $1,550,

103 Plan to Offer Care of the Condition at a Lower Cost Per Patient TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 Procedures $ $120,000 Subtotal $150,000 Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 Margin $350 5% $70,000 Subtotal $7, $1,400,000 Total Pmt/Cost $5, $1,550,000 $4, $1,491,400-4% 103

104 Use the Payment as a Budget to Redesign Care TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 Procedures $ $120,000 Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 Margin $350 5% $70,000 Subtotal $7, $1,400,000 $1,338,400-4% Total Pmt/Cost $5, $1,550,000 $4, $1,491,400-4% 104

105 And Let the Health System Decide How It Should Be Paid TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45, % Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000-10% Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 $700,000-0% Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 $567,000-10% Margin $350 5% $70,000 $71,400 +2% Subtotal $7, $1,400,000 $1,338,400-4% Total Pmt/Cost $5, $1,550,000 $4, $1,491,400-4% 105

106 Would Shared Savings Achieve the Same Thing? 106

107 Same Example As Before Year 0 Physician Svcs Evaluations $30,000 Procedures $120,000 Subtotal $150,000 Hospital Pmt Procedures $1,400,000 Subtotal $1,400,000 # Patients $/Patient 300 $ $ $7,000 Optional Procedure for a Condition Physician evaluates all patients Physician performs procedure on 2/3 of evaluated patients Up to 10% of procedures may be avoidable through patient choice or alternative treatment Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 Savings 107

108 Year 1: Physicians & Hospitals Both Lose With Fewer Procedures) Year 0 Year 1 Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $30,000 $30,000 Procedures $120,000 $108,000 $0 Subtotal $150,000 $138,000-8% Hospital Pmt Procedures $1,400,000 $1,260,000 Reduce Procs by 10% Year 1: Lower Revenue for Docs & Hospital Subtotal $1,400,000 $1,260,000-10% Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 $1,398,000-10% Savings $152,

109 Physician Svcs Year 2: Losses Are Lower If Shared Savings Are Paid (No) Year 0 Year 1 Chg Year 2 Chg Evaluations $30,000 $30,000 $30,000 Procedures $120,000 $108,000 $108,000 Shared Savings $0 $12,000 Subtotal $150,000 $138,000-8% $150,000 0% Hospital Pmt Procedures $1,400,000 $1,260,000 $1,260,000 Shared Savings $64,000 Subtotal $1,400,000 $1,260,000-10% $1,324,000-5% Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 $1,398,000-10% $1,474,000-5% Savings $152,000 $76,000 Reduce Procs by 10% Year 1: Lower Revenue for Docs & Hospital Year 2: Shared Savings Offsets Some Losses 109

110 But Physicians and Hospitals Still Have Net 2-Year Losses Year 0 Year 1 Chg Year 2 Chg Cumulative Physician Svcs Evaluations $30,000 $30,000 $30,000 Procedures $120,000 $108,000 $108,000 Shared Savings $0 $12,000 Subtotal $150,000 $138,000-8% $150,000 0% -$12,000-4% Hospital Pmt Procedures $1,400,000 $1,260,000 $1,260,000 Shared Savings $64,000 Subtotal $1,400,000 $1,260,000-10% $1,324,000-5% -$216,000-8% Total Pmt/Cost $1,550,000 $1,398,000-10% $1,474,000-5% $228,000 Savings $152,000 $76,000-7% 110

111 It s Even Worse Than That There is no shared savings payment at all if a minimum total savings level is not reached If there is a shared savings payment, it s reduced if quality thresholds aren t met, even if the quality measures have nothing to do with where savings occurred The shared savings payment ends at the end of the 3-year contract period, even if utilization remains lower, and the payer keeps 100% of the savings in future years 111

112 Condition-Based Payment Defines The Right Way to Share Savings TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Physician Svcs Evaluations $ $30,000 $ $45, % Procedures $ $120,000 $ $108,000-10% Subtotal $150,000 $153,000 +2% Hospital Pmt Fixed Costs $3,500 50% $700,000 $700,000-0% Variable Costs $3,150 45% $630,000 $567,000-10% Margin $350 5% $70,000 $71,400 +2% Subtotal $7, $1,400,000 $1,338,400-4% Total Pmt/Cost $5, $1,550,000 $4, $1,491,400-4% 112

113 Savings from Shifting to Lower Cost Procedures and Settings Maternity Care Vaginal delivery instead of C-Section Term delivery instead of early elective delivery Delivery in birth center instead of hospital Back Pain Less radical surgery Physical therapy instead of surgery Chest Pain History and exam before imaging Lower cost imaging Non-invasive imaging instead of invasive imaging Medical management instead of invasive treatment 113

114 Higher Condition-Based Payment For Higher-Acuity Patients TODAY TOMORROW $/Patient # Pts Total $ $/Patient # Pts Total $ Chg Higher-Acuity Evaluations $ $15, $741 Procedures $ $81, % Fixed Costs $472,500 $472,500 0% Variable Costs $3, $425,250 $382,725-10% Hosp. Margin $47,250 $48,668 +3% Total Payment $6, $1,041,000 $6, $1,014,975-3% Lower-Acuity Evaluations $ $15, $455 Procedures $ $45, $68, % Fixed Costs $262,500 $262,500-0% Variable Costs $3, $236,250 $212,625-10% Hosp. Margin $26,250 $27,038 +3% Total Payment $3, $585,000 $3, $570,375-3% 114

115 Opportunities for Reducing Spending Exist in Every Specialty Cardiology Orthopedic Surgery Psychiatry OB/GYN Opportunities to Improve Care and Reduce Cost Use less invasive and expensive procedures when appropriate Reduce infections and complications Use less expensive post-acute care following surgery Reduce ER visits and admissions for patients with depression and chronic disease Reduce use of elective C-sections Reduce early deliveries and use of NICU 115

116 Fee-for-Service Creates Barriers to Redesigning Care Cardiology Orthopedic Surgery Psychiatry OB/GYN Opportunities to Improve Care and Reduce Cost Use less invasive and expensive procedures when appropriate Reduce infections and complications Use less expensive post-acute care following surgery Reduce ER visits and admissions for patients with depression and chronic disease Reduce use of elective C-sections Reduce early deliveries and use of NICU Barriers in Current Payment System Payment is based on which procedure is used, not the outcome for the patient No flexibility to increase inpatient services to reduce complications & post-acute care No payment for phone consults with PCPs No payment for RN care managers Similar/lower payment for vaginal deliveries 116

117 There Are Win-Win-Win Solutions Through Better Payment Systems Cardiology Orthopedic Surgery Psychiatry Opportunities to Improve Care and Reduce Cost Use less invasive and expensive procedures when appropriate Reduce infections and complications Use less expensive post-acute care following surgery Reduce ER visits and admissions for patients with depression and chronic disease Barriers in Current Payment System Payment is based on which procedure is used, not the outcome for the patient No flexibility to increase inpatient services to reduce complications & post-acute care No payment for phone consults with PCPs No payment for RN care managers Solutions via Accountable Payment Models Condition-based payment covering CABG, PCI, or medication management Episode payment for hospital and post-acute care costs with warranty Joint conditionbased payment to PCP and psychiatrist OB/GYN Reduce use of elective C-sections Reduce early deliveries and use of NICU Similar/lower payment for vaginal deliveries Condition-based payment for total cost of delivery in low-risk pregnancy 117

118 Examples from Other Specialties Neurology Gastroenterology Oncology Radiology Opportunities to Improve Care and Reduce Cost Avoid unnecessary hospitalizations for epilepsy patients Reduce strokes and heart attacks after TIA Reduce unnecessary colonoscopies and colon cancer Reduce ER/admits for inflammatory bowel d. Reduce ER visits and admissions for dehydration Reduce anti-emetic drug costs Reduce use of high-cost imaging Improve diagnostic speed & accuracy Barriers in Current Payment System No flexibility to spend more on preventive care No payment to coordinate w/ cardio No flexibility to focus extra resources on highest-risk patients No flexibility to spend more on care mgt No flexibility to spend more on preventive care Payment based on office visits, not outcomes Low payment for reading images & penalty for 2x Inability to change inapprop. orders Solutions via Accountable Payment Models Condition-based payment for epilepsy Episode or conditionbased payment for TIA Population-based payment for colon cancer screening Condition-based pmt for IBD Condition-based payment including non-oncolytic Rx and ED/hospital utilization Global payment for imaging costs Partnership in condition-based payments 118

119 You Can t Fix Fee-for-Service With Small Add-On Payments P4P PMPM Shared Savings Shared Savings FFS No payment for services that will benefit patients Lower revenues from reducing avoidable costs FFS FFS FFS 119

120 What Takes the Time/Expertise of an Oncology Practice? New Patient 6 Months of Treatment Post-Tx Follow-Up 120

121 What Generates Revenues for an Oncology Practice? New Patient 6 Months of Treatment Post-Tx Follow-Up 121

122 Mismatch Between Revenues and Patient Care in Oncology New Patient 6 Months of Treatment Post-Tx Follow-Up 122

123 Condition-Based Payment Developed by Oncologists New Patient Payment Tx Month Pmt Tx Month Pmt Tx Month Pmt Tx Month Pmt Tx Month Pmt Tx Month Pmt Higher Payments For More Complex Pts Non-Tx Mo. $ Non-Tx Mo. $ Non-Tx Mo. $ New Patient 6 Months of Treatment Post-Tx Follow-Up 123

124 How Does All of This Fit Into ACOs? 124

125 Starting With The Patients.. PATIENTS Heart Disease Diabetes Back Pain Pregnancy 125

126 Each Patient Should Choose & Use a Primary Care Practice PATIENTS Heart Disease Diabetes Back Pain Pregnancy Primary Care Practice 126

127 Which Takes Accountability for What PCPs Can Control/Influence MEDICARE/HEALTH PLAN PATIENTS Heart Disease Diabetes Back Pain Pregnancy Accountable Medical Home Primary Care Practice Accountability for: Avoidable ER Visits Avoidable Hospitalizations Unnecessary Tests Unnecessary Referrals 127

128 With a Medical Neighborhood to Consult With on Complex Cases MEDICARE/HEALTH PLAN PATIENTS Heart Disease Diabetes Back Pain Pregnancy Accountable Medical Home Primary Care Practice Endocrinology, Neurology, Psychiatry Accountable Medical Neighborhood Accountability for: Unnecessary Tests Unnecessary Referrals Co-Managed Outcomes 128

129 ..And Specialists Accountable for the Conditions They Manage PATIENTS Heart Disease Diabetes Back Pain Pregnancy Accountable Medical Home MEDICARE/HEALTH PLAN Primary Care Practice Endocrinology, Neurology, Psychiatry Accountable Medical Neighborhood Accountability for: Unnecessary Tests Unnecessary Procedures Infections, Complications Cardiology Group Orthopedic Group OB/GYN Group Heart Episode/ Condition Pmt Back Episode/ Condition Pmt Pregnancy Management Pmt 129

130 That s Building the ACO from the Bottom Up PATIENTS Heart Disease Diabetes Back Pain Pregnancy Accountable Medical Home MEDICARE/HEALTH PLAN Primary Care Practice Endocrinology, Neurology, Psychiatry Accountable Medical Neighborhood Accountable Payment Models Cardiology Group Orthopedic Group OB/GYN Group ACO Heart Episode/ Condition Pmt Back Episode/ Condition Pmt Pregnancy Management Pmt 130

131 Shared Savings ACOs Can t Truly Change Care Delivery or Payment Fee-for-Service Payment PATIENTS Diabetes Heart Disease Back Pain Pregnancy Primary Care MEDICARE/HEALTH PLAN Endocrine Neurology Psychiatry Cardiology Expensive IT Systems ACO Orthopedics Shared Savings Payment Shared Savings Bonus Nurse Care Managers OB/GYN 131

132 A True ACO Can Take a Global Payment And Make It Work PATIENTS Heart Disease Diabetes Back Pain Pregnancy MEDICARE, MEDICAID, or EMPLOYER Accountable Medical Home Primary Care Practice Endocrinology, Neurology, Psychiatry ACO Accountable Medical Neighborhood Risk-Adjusted Global Payment Cardiology Group Orthopedic Group OB/GYN Group Heart Episode/ Condition Pmt Back Episode/ Condition Pmt Pregnancy Management Pmt 132

133 You Don t Need a Big Health System to Manage Global Payment Independent PCPs & Specialists Managing Global Payments Northwest Physicians Network (NPN) in Tacoma, WA is an IPA with 109 PCPs and 345 specialists in 165 practices (average size: 2.4 MDs/practice). NPN accepts full or partial risk capitation contracts, operates its own Medicare Advantage plan, and does third party administration for self-insured businesses. North Texas Specialty Physicians, a 600 physician multi-specialty IPA in Fort Worth, set up its own Medicare Advantage PPO plan and uses revenues from the health plan and capitation contracts to pay its PCPs 250% of Medicare rates and provides high quality, coordinated care to patients. Joint Contracting by MDs & Hospitals for Global Payments The Mount Auburn Cambridge IPA (MACIPA) and Mount Auburn Hospital jointly contract with three major Boston-area health plans for full-risk capitation. The IPA is independent of the hospital; they coordinate care with each other without any formal legal structure

134 Four Things Needed For Win-Win-Win Solutions 134

135 Four Things Needed For Win-Win-Win Solutions 1. Defining the Change in Care Delivery How can care be redesigned to improve quality and reduce costs? 135

136 How to Find Savings Opportunities? Ask Physicians I have zero control over utilization or studies ordered. I don t get paid for calling a referring doctor and telling him/her the imaging test is worthless. Radiologist in Maine Patients often need to be in extended care to receive antibiotics because Medicare doesn t pay for home IV therapy. Patient stays in the hospital for 3 days to justify a nursing home/rehab stay. Orthopedist at AMA HOD Meeting I strongly suspect overutilization of abdominal CT scans in the ER and in the hospital; CT scans lead to further CT scans to follow up lung and adrenal nodules. The hospital focuses on length of stay, but never looks at appropriateness of radiologic studies. Internist at AMA HOD Meeting I do many unnecessary colonoscopies on young men. Give every PCP an anuscope to allow diagnosis of bleeding hemorrhoids in the office. Gastroenterologist in Maine 136

137 Opportunities Vary (Significantly) By Region Bad Backs in Grand Rapids? Bad Hearts in Detroit? Michigan 137

138 Four Things Needed For Win-Win-Win Solutions 1. Defining the Change in Care Delivery How can care be redesigned to improve quality and reduce costs? 2. Analyzing Expected Costs and Savings What will there be less of, and how much does that save? What will there be more of, and how much does that cost? Will the savings offset the costs on average? 138

139 A Critical Element is Shared, Trusted Data Healthcare Providers need to know the current utilization and costs for their patients and the likely impact of care changes to know whether the payment amount will cover the costs of delivering redesigned care to the patients Purchasers/Payers needs to know the current utilization and costs to know whether the proposed payment amount is a better deal than they have today Both sets of data have to match in order for providers and payers to agree on the new approach! 139

140 Four Things Needed For Win-Win-Win Solutions 1. Defining the Change in Care Delivery How can care be redesigned to improve quality and reduce costs? 2. Analyzing Expected Costs and Savings What will there be less of, and how much does that save? What will there be more of, and how much does that cost? Will the savings offset the costs on average? 3. Designing a Payment System That Supports Change Flexibility to change the way care is delivered Accountability for costs and quality/outcomes related to care Adequate payment to cover lowest-achievable costs Protection for the provider from insurance risk 140

141 Healthcare Spending Accountability Must Be Focused on What Each Provider Can Influence Spending the Physician Cannot Control e.g., PCPs can t reduce surgical site infections e.g., surgeons can t prevent diabetic foot ulcers e.g., oncologists can t prevent cancer Spending the Physician Can Control or Influence e.g., PCPs can help diabetics avoid amputations e.g., surgeons can reduce surgical site infections e.g., oncologists can reduce complications from drug toxicity 141

142 Four Things Needed For Win-Win-Win Solutions 1. Defining the Change in Care Delivery How can care be redesigned to improve quality and reduce costs? 2. Analyzing Expected Costs and Savings What will there be less of, and how much does that save? What will there be more of, and how much does that cost? Will the savings offset the costs on average? 3. Designing a Payment System That Supports Change Flexibility to change the way care is delivered Accountability for costs and quality/outcomes related to care Adequate payment to cover lowest-achievable costs Protection for the provider from insurance risk 4. Implementing the Payment and Care Delivery Changes All payers need to change the payment system All providers need to accept the payments and change care delivery 142

143 Designing Win-Win Approaches Requires Collaboration & Trust Hospitals Physicians Post-Acute Purchasers WIN-LOSE WIN-LOSE WIN-WIN 143

144 One Payer Changing Is Not Enough Payer Better Payment & Benefits Payer Current Payment & Benefits Provider Current Payment & Benefits Payer Patient Patient Patient Provider is only compensated for changed practices for the subset of patients covered by participating payers 144

145 All Payers Need to Change to Enable Providers to Transform Payer Better Payment & Benefits Payer Better Payment & Benefits Provider Better Payment & Benefits Payer Patient Patient Patient 145

146 Payers Need to Truly Align to Allow Focus on Better Care Payer Better Payment System A Payer Better Payment System B Provider Better Payment System C Payer Patient Patient Patient Even if every payer s system is better than it was, if they re all different, providers will spend too much time and money on administration rather than care improvement 146

147 State/Medicare Multi-Payer Primary Care Demonstration Medicare Private Payer Private Payer Medicaid PMPM PMPM PMPM PMPM Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice 147

148 Michigan Multi-Payer Primary Care Demonstration Medicare Medicaid BCBSM Priority Health Other Payers PMPM PMPM Higher E&M + G-Codes PMPM + G-Codes $0 Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice 148

149 Differences in Payment and in the Definitions of Payments Medicare Medicaid BCBSM Priority Health Other Payers PMPM PMPM Higher E&M + G-Codes PMPM + G-Codes $0 Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice MiPCT Care Management Billing Collaborative Problem: MiPCT participating practices are underutilizing the available billing codes for care management services. Further, the descriptions and requirements for care management codes differ among payers. 149

150 Help for PCPs Comes With Increased Administrative Burden Medicare Medicaid PMPM This is Collaboration? PMPM BCBSM Higher E&M + G-Codes Priority Health PMPM + G-Codes Other Payers $0 Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice Primary Care Practice MiPCT Care Management Billing Collaborative Problem: MiPCT participating practices are underutilizing the available billing codes for care management services. Further, the descriptions and requirements for care management codes differ among payers. 150

151 A Neutral Facilitator is Needed to Achieve a Common Approach PAYER A Payment Definition 1 PAYER B Payment Definition 1 PAYER C Payment Definition 1 Neutral Facilitator (ideally with trusted data analytics) PROVIDER A Payment Definition 1 PROVIDER B Payment Definition 1 PROVIDER C Payment Definition 1 151

152 Example of Multi-Stakeholder Approach to Payment Reform Alliance for Health Michigan Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement Employers Unions West Michigan Payment Design Workgroup Primary Care Physicians Specialists Health Plans 152

153 Current Payment for Primary Care CURRENT PAYMENT PRIMARY CARE Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Office Visits for Preventive Services Payer Payer Payer Office Visits for Chronic Disease Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues 153

154 Current Non-Payment for Primary Care CURRENT PAYMENT PRIMARY CARE Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Office Visits for Preventive Services Payer Payer Payer NO PAYMENT NO PAYMENT Outreach Calls for Preventive Services Proactive Care Mgt for Chronic Disease Office Visits for Chronic Disease Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues 154

155 What Is Not Paid For Is Exactly What s Needed to Improve Quality CURRENT PAYMENT PRIMARY CARE Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Payer Payer Payer NO PAYMENT NO PAYMENT Office Visits for Preventive Services Outreach Calls for Preventive Services Proactive Care Mgt for Chronic Disease Office Visits for Chronic Disease Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Preventive Care Quality Chronic Disease Mgt Quality 155

156 A Better Approach: Flexible Payment Instead of E&M Payment PRIMARY CARE Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services PROPOSED PAYMENT Office Visits for Preventive Services Outreach Calls for Preventive Services Proactive Care Mgt for Chronic Disease Office Visits for Chronic Disease Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Monthly Core Primary Care Services Payment Payer Payer Payer 156

157 SIZE OF MONTHLY PER-PATIENT PAYMENT High Payment for Small # of Patients Size of Monthly Payment Should Differ Based on Patient Health Small Payment for Large # of Patients No Chronic Disease and No Major Risk Factors Larger Payment for Subset of Patients Needing More Proactive Care One Chronic Disease or Major Risk Factors Still Larger Payment for Subset of Patients Needing Even More Proactive Care Two Chronic Diseases or One Chronic Dis. and Major Risk Factors PATIENT HEALTH ISSUES Complex and High-Risk Patients 157

158 A Better Benefit Design For Patients BENEFIT DESIGN Patient enrolls as a member of the primary care practice, but has no restrictions on other care Patient has no copays for visits related to either preventive care or chronic disease care from this practice Patient only pays cost-sharing for acute issues PRIMARY CARE Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Office Visits for Preventive Services Outreach Calls for Preventive Services Proactive Care Mgt for Chronic Disease Office Visits for Chronic Disease Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Monthly Core Primary Care Services Payment PROPOSED PAYMENT Payer Payer Payer 158

159 Better Payment for the Medical Neighborhood (Specialists) SPECIALIST PMT Payments for telephone calls & s for PCP consults with specialists they work with Sharing of the monthly core payment if the specialist is co-managing the patient with the PCP Transfer of monthly payment to specialist for some patients PRIMARY CARE Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Office Visits for Preventive Services Outreach Calls for Preventive Services Proactive Care Mgt for Chronic Disease Office Visits for Chronic Disease Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Monthly Core Primary Care Services Payment PROPOSED PAYMENT Payer Payer Payer 159

160 Accountability for Spending and Quality That PCPs Can Control ACCOUNTABILITY Monthly payment would be adjusted up or down based on quality and avoidable utilization Quality of preventive care Quality of chronic disease care Avoidable ER utilization High-tech imaging Specialty referrals PRIMARY CARE Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Office Visits for Preventive Services Outreach Calls for Preventive Services Proactive Care Mgt for Chronic Disease Office Visits for Chronic Disease Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Monthly Core Primary Care Services Payment PROPOSED PAYMENT Payer Payer Payer 160

161 This is Different Than Current PCMH Programs Current PCMH Model NEW MODEL P4P/Shared Savings PMPM for Care Management Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Office Visits for Preventive Services Office Visits for Chronic Disease Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Performance Adjustment Core Primary Care Services Payment 161

162 It s Also Different from Traditional PCP Capitation Programs Current PCMH Model NEW MODEL PCP Capitation P4P/Shared Savings PMPM for Care Management Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Office Visits for Preventive Services Office Visits for Chronic Disease Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Performance Adjustment Core Primary Care Services Payment P4P Primary Care Capitation 162

163 It s Better Than Current PCMH or Capitation Current PCMH Model P4P/Shared Savings Most practice revenue still comes from office visits Fewer office PMPM for Care Management Tests & Procedures for Preventive visits = lower Services revenue, even Office Visits for Preventive with PMPM Services Patient Office Visits still for Chronic discouraged Disease Issues Tests from& Procedures office visits for Chronic by copays Disease Mgt Patients Office Visits must forbe attributed Acute Issues based Tests on & claims Procedures for Acute Issues NEW MODEL (PARTIAL CAPITATION) Tests PCP & Procedures for Acute practice Issues receives predictable, Office Visits for flexible Acute Issues payment Tests for & patient Procedures mgt for Chronic Disease Mgt Tests Higher & Procedures payment for Preventive for patients Services with greater needs Employer only pays more if patient needs or Performance Adjustment receives more Core Primary Care Services servicespayment Patient enrolls only for prev. & chronic care PCP Capitation P4P No incentive for PCP practice to see patient for acute needs Payment is the same for patients with high needs as low needs Primary Care Employer Capitation is paying even if patient needs few services Patients must enroll for all services 163

164 All Stakeholders Worked Together To Develop a Win-Win Solution NEW MODEL Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Performance Adjustment Core Primary Care Services Payment Employers Unions Alliance for Health Michigan Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement West Michigan Payment Design Workgroup Health Plans Primary Care Physicians Specialists 164

165 Will Payers Implement It? NEW MODEL Tests & Procedures for Acute Issues Office Visits for Acute Issues Tests & Procedures for Chronic Disease Mgt Tests & Procedures for Preventive Services Performance Adjustment Core Primary Care Services Payment Employers Unions Alliance for Health Michigan Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement West Michigan Payment Design Workgroup? Health Plans? Primary Care Physicians Specialists 165

166 What s the Patient s Role and Accountability? Patient Payment System Provider Ability and Incentives to: Keep patients well Avoid unneeded services Deliver services efficiently Coordinate services with other providers 166

167 Benefit Design Changes Are Also Critical to Success Ability and Incentives to: Improve health Take prescribed medications Allow a provider to coordinate care Choose the highest-value providers and services Benefit Design Patient Payment System Provider Ability and Incentives to: Keep patients well Avoid unneeded services Deliver services efficiently Coordinate services with other providers 167

168 Barriers In Current Benefit Designs Co-pays, co-insurance, and high deductibles discourage or prevent patients from using primary care, preventive treatments, and chronic disease maintenance medications 168

169 Example: No Coordination of Pharmacy & Medical Benefits Single-minded focus on reducing costs here......often results in higher spending on hospitalizations Pharmacy Benefits Medical Benefits Drug Costs Hospital Costs Physician Costs High copays for brand-names when no generic exists Doughnut holes & deductibles Principal treatment for most chronic diseases involves regular use of maintenance medication Other Services 169

170 Barriers In Current Benefit Designs Co-pays, co-insurance, and high deductibles discourage or prevent patients from using primary care, preventive treatments, and chronic disease maintenance medications Co-pays, co-insurance, and high deductibles provide little or no incentive for patients to choose the highest-value providers for expensive services 170

171 Airfare Choices from Boston to Cleveland Boston? Cleveland USAirways 1-Stop Coach $622 United Non-Stop Coach $1,107 United Non-Stop First Class $1,355 Airfares for July 6-7, 2011 as of 6/26/11 171

172 What If We Paid for Travel the Way We Pay for Healthcare? Boston? Cleveland Consumer Share of Travel Cost USAirways 1-Stop Coach $622 United Non-Stop Coach $1,107 United Non-Stop First Class $1,355 Airfares for July 6-7, 2011 as of 6/26/11 172

173 Flat Copayments: First Class Fare Wins Boston? Cleveland Consumer Share of Travel Cost USAirways 1-Stop Coach $622 United Non-Stop Coach $1,107 United Non-Stop First Class $1,355 $100 Copayment: $100 $100 $100 Airfares for July 6-7, 2011 as of 6/26/11 173

174 Coinsurance: First Class Fare Probably Wins Boston? Cleveland Consumer Share of Travel Cost USAirways 1-Stop Coach $622 United Non-Stop Coach $1,107 United Non-Stop First Class $1,355 $100 Copayment: $100 $100 $100 10% Coinsurance: $62 $111 $136 Airfares for July 6-7, 2011 as of 6/26/11 174

175 High Deductible: First Class Fare Wins Boston? Cleveland Consumer Share of Travel Cost USAirways 1-Stop Coach $622 United Non-Stop Coach $1,107 United Non-Stop First Class $1,355 $100 Copayment: $100 $100 $100 10% Coinsurance: $62 $111 $136 $500 Deductible: $500 $500 $500 Airfares for July 6-7, 2011 as of 6/26/11 175

176 Price Difference: Lowest Coach Fare Wins Boston? Cleveland Consumer Share of Travel Cost USAirways 1-Stop Coach $622 United Non-Stop Coach $1,107 United Non-Stop First Class $1,355 $100 Copayment: $100 $100 $100 10% Coinsurance: $62 $111 $136 $500 Deductible: $500 $500 $500 Lowest Coach Fare: $0 $485 $733 Airfares for July 6-7, 2011 as of 6/26/11 176

177 Where Will You Get Your Knee Replaced? Knee Joint Replacement Consumer Share of Surgery Cost Price #1 $20,000 Price #2 $25,000 Price #3 $30,

178 Where Will You Get Your Knee Replaced? Knee Joint Replacement Consumer Share of Surgery Cost Price #1 $20,000 Price #2 $25,000 Price #3 $30,000 $1,000 Copayment: $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 10% Coinsurance $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 w/$2,000 OOP Max: $5,000 Deductible: $5,000 $5,000 $5,

179 Where Will You Get Your Knee Replaced? Knee Joint Replacement Consumer Share of Surgery Cost Price #1 $20,000 Price #2 $25,000 Price #3 $30,000 $1,000 Copayment: $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 10% Coinsurance w/$2,000 OOP Max: $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $5,000 Deductible: $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 Highest-Value: $0 $5,000 $10,

180 Current Transparency Efforts Are Focused on Procedure Price Payment for Procedure Provider 1: $25,000 dded Provider 2: $23,000-8% 180

181 Payment for Procedure Provider 1: What Hidden Costs Accompany the Lower Price? Payment and Rate of Complications $25,000 $30,000 2% Provider 2: $23,000 $30,000 10% -8% 181

182 Payment for Procedure Provider 1: Total Spending May Be Higher With the Lower Price Provider Payment and Rate of Complications Average Total Payment $25,000 $30,000 2% $25,600 Provider 2: $23,000 $30,000 10% $26,000-8% +2% Provider 2 has a lower starting price, but is more expensive when lower quality is factored in 182

183 Bundled/Warrantied Pmts Allow Comparing Apples to Apples Payment for Procedure Provider 1: Provider 2: Payment and Rate of Complications Bundled/ Episode Payment 2% $25,600 10% $26,000 +2% Bundled prices show that Provider 1 is the higher-value provider 183

184 Why Is It So Much Cheaper to Fly to Pittsburgh Than Cleveland? Boston? Cleveland Non-Stop Coach Fare: $1,107 Boston? Pittsburgh Non-Stop Coach Fare: $188 Airfares for July 6-7, 2011 as of 6/26/11 184

185 Is It The Shorter Distance? 551 Air Miles Boston Cleveland Non-Stop Coach Fare: $1,107? Boston? Pittsburgh 483 Air Miles Non-Stop Coach Fare: $188 Airfares for July 6-7, 2011 as of 6/26/11 185

186 Or Greater Competition? NON- COMPETITIVE MARKET Boston Choice: United Non-Stop: $1,107 (No other non-stop choice)? Cleveland COMPETITIVE MARKET Airfares for July 6-7, 2011 as of 6/26/11 Boston? Pittsburgh Choice #1: Delta Non-Stop: $188 Choice #2: JetBlue Non-Stop: $188 Choice #3: USAirways Non-Stop: $

187 Which Is More Likely to Generate True Price Competition? MD MD MD ONE BIG ACO DO MD DO DO MD DO MD DO MD DO MD DO MD DO DO MD DO MD DO MD DO DO MD DO MD DO MD DO MD HOSPITAL HOSPITAL VS HOSPITAL MD Hospital ACO HOSPITAL HOSPITAL MD MD MD Physician Group ACO DO MD DO DO MD DO MD DO MD DO DO MD DO MD DO MD DO MD IPA ACO DO MD DO DO MD DO MD DO MD DO 187

188 What Do Michigan Communities Need for Higher Value Care? 188

189 Better Payment Systems and Benefit Designs from All Payers Engagement of Purchasers Alignment of Multiple Payers Value-Driven Payment /Benefits Benefit Design Payment System Design 189

190 Dramatically Better Care Delivery Supported by Better Payment Engagement of Purchasers Alignment of Multiple Payers Value-Driven Payment /Benefits Benefit Design Payment System Design Value-Driven Delivery Systems Technical Assistance to Providers Design & Delivery of Care Provider Organization/ Coordination 190

191 Educated and Engaged Consumer Education/ Engagement Consumers Education Materials Consumer Education/ Engagement Engagement of Purchasers Alignment of Multiple Payers Value-Driven Payment /Benefits Benefit Design Payment System Design Value-Driven Delivery Systems Technical Assistance to Providers Design & Delivery of Care Provider Organization/ Coordination 191

192 Data and Analysis Available to Consumer Education/ Engagement Everyone Education Materials Consumer Education/ Engagement Data and Analytics Data Collection & Analysis Public Reporting Engagement of Purchasers Alignment of Multiple Payers Value-Driven Payment /Benefits Benefit Design Payment System Design Value-Driven Delivery Systems Technical Assistance to Providers Design & Delivery of Care Provider Organization/ Coordination 192

193 And a Mechanism for Bringing All the Pieces Together Consumer Education/ Engagement Education Materials Consumer Education/ Engagement Data and Analytics Data Collection & Analysis Public Reporting Regional Health Improvement Collaborative Engagement of Purchasers Alignment of Multiple Payers Value-Driven Payment /Benefits Benefit Design Payment System Design Value-Driven Delivery Systems Technical Assistance to Providers Design & Delivery of Care Provider Organization/ Coordination 193

194 All Stakeholders Must Be Involved for Win-Win-Win Solutions Physicians and Other Providers Hospitals and Post-Acute Care Regional Health Improvement Collaborative Purchasers and Payers Patients and Families 194

195 Learn More About Win-Win-Win Payment and Delivery Reform Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform 195

196 For More Information: Harold D. Miller President and CEO Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform (412)

197 APPENDIX

198 For Most Employees, the Employer is the Insurer, Not a Health Plan Source: Employer Health Benefits 2012 Annual Survey. The Kaiser Family Foundation and Health Research and Educational Trust 198

199 Companies With <1,000 Workers Take Total Healthcare Cost Risk Sources: Employer Health Benefits 2012 Annual Survey. The Kaiser Family Foundation and Health Research and Educational Trust; State-Level Trends in Employer- Sponsored Health Insurance, April State Health Access Data Assistance Center and Robert Wood Johnson Foundation 199

200 For Self-Funded Employers, The Health Plan is Just a Pass Through Purchaser Payment Self- Funded Purchasers ASO Health Plan (No Risk) Provider Claims Providers 200

201 Little Incentive for Health Plans to Support True Payment Reforms Purchaser Payment Self- Funded Purchasers ASO Health Plan (No Risk) Provider Claims Providers True Payment Reform Means: Health plan incurs the costs of implementing new payment models Purchaser gains all the savings from reduced utilization and spending (because all claims are passed through) 201

202 What We Need Are Purchaser-Provider Partnerships Self- Funded Purchasers Better Payment and Benefit Structure Lower Cost, Higher Quality Care Providers Purchasers and Patients win if: Provider keeps employees healthy Provider delivers high-quality care at low prices Provider wins if: Patients stay healthy and need less care Purchaser pays adequately for high-quality care to those who need it 202

203 Purchasers and Physicians Have Common Interests, But Don t Know It We ve started talking directly to physicians, and we ve discovered that what they want to sell is what we want to buy Cheryl DeMars CEO, The Alliance (Employer Coalition in Wisconsin) 203

204 Health Plan Implements Changes Purchasers/Providers Agree On Health Plans Implementation Self- Funded Purchasers Better Payment and Benefit Structure Lower Cost, Higher Quality Care Providers 204

205 National Companies Are Moving in This Direction Self- Funded Purchasers Better Payment and Benefit Structure Lower Cost, Higher Quality Care Providers Purchasers and Patients win if: Provider keeps employees healthy Provider delivers high-quality care at low prices Provider wins if: Patients stay healthy and need less care Purchaser pays adequately for high-quality care to those who need it 205

BETTER CARE AT LOWER COST THROUGH PHYSICIAN LEADERSHIP

BETTER CARE AT LOWER COST THROUGH PHYSICIAN LEADERSHIP BETTER CARE AT LOWER COST THROUGH PHYSICIAN LEADERSHIP Redesigning Care Delivery, Payment Systems, & Benefit Designs so Physicians, Hospitals, Patients, & Purchasers All Benefit Harold D. Miller President

More information

REDESIGNING HEALTH CARE FROM THE BOTTOM UP INSTEAD OF FROM THE TOP DOWN

REDESIGNING HEALTH CARE FROM THE BOTTOM UP INSTEAD OF FROM THE TOP DOWN REDESIGNING HEALTH CARE FROM THE BOTTOM UP INSTEAD OF FROM THE TOP DOWN Supporting Collaborative Regional Approaches to Sustainable High-Value Healthcare Harold D. Miller President and CEO Center for Healthcare

More information

WIN-WIN-WIN APPROACHES TO ACCOUNTABLE CARE How Physicians, Hospitals, Patients, and Payers Can All Benefit From Healthcare Payment & Delivery Reform

WIN-WIN-WIN APPROACHES TO ACCOUNTABLE CARE How Physicians, Hospitals, Patients, and Payers Can All Benefit From Healthcare Payment & Delivery Reform WIN-WIN-WIN APPROACHES TO ACCOUNTABLE CARE How Physicians, Hospitals, Patients, and Payers Can All Benefit From Healthcare Payment & Delivery Reform Harold D. Miller President and CEO Center for Healthcare

More information

The Official Definition FROM VOLUME TO VALUE: and How to Get There. What is an Accountable Care Organization?

The Official Definition FROM VOLUME TO VALUE: and How to Get There. What is an Accountable Care Organization? FROM VOLUME TO VALUE: Better Ways to Pay for Health Care, and How to Get There Harold D. Miller Executive Director Center for Healthcare Quality and Reform and President and CEO Network for Regional Healthcare

More information

Pathways for Physician Success in Accountable Care Organizations

Pathways for Physician Success in Accountable Care Organizations Pathways for Physician Success in Accountable Care Organizations and Healthcare Reform Harold D. Miller Executive Director Center for Healthcare Quality and Reform July 16, 2011 Everybody s Talking About

More information

CREATING A PHYSICIAN-LED HEALTHCARE FUTURE Better Care for Patients, Lower Healthcare Spending, & Financially Viable Physician Practices & Hospitals

CREATING A PHYSICIAN-LED HEALTHCARE FUTURE Better Care for Patients, Lower Healthcare Spending, & Financially Viable Physician Practices & Hospitals CREATING A PHYSICIAN-LED HEALTHCARE FUTURE Better Care for Patients, Lower Healthcare Spending, & Financially Viable Physician Practices & Hospitals Harold D. Miller President and CEO Center for Healthcare

More information

Creating a Patient-Centered Payment System to Support Higher-Quality, More Affordable Health Care. Harold D. Miller

Creating a Patient-Centered Payment System to Support Higher-Quality, More Affordable Health Care. Harold D. Miller Creating a Patient-Centered Payment System to Support Higher-Quality, More Affordable Health Care Harold D. Miller First Edition October 2017 CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY... i I. THE QUEST TO PAY FOR VALUE

More information

CREATING A PATIENT-CENTERED PAYMENT SYSTEM

CREATING A PATIENT-CENTERED PAYMENT SYSTEM CREATING A PATIENT-CENTERED PAYMENT SYSTEM Better Care for Patients, Lower Healthcare Spending, & Financially Viable Physician Practices & Hospitals Harold D. Miller President and CEO Center for Healthcare

More information

WIN-WIN-WIN APPROACHES TO ACCOUNTABLE CARE How Physicians, Hospitals, Patients, and

WIN-WIN-WIN APPROACHES TO ACCOUNTABLE CARE How Physicians, Hospitals, Patients, and WIN-WIN-WIN APPROACHES TO ACCOUNTABLE CARE How Physicians, Hospitals, Patients, and Payers Can All Benefit from Better Healthcare Payment Systems Harold D. Miller President and CEO Center for Healthcare

More information

Making the Business Case

Making the Business Case Making the Business Case for Payment and Delivery Reform Harold D. Miller Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform To learn more about RWJFsupported payment reform activities, visit RWJF s Payment

More information

MACRA for Critical Access Hospitals. Tuesday, July 26, 2016 Webinar

MACRA for Critical Access Hospitals. Tuesday, July 26, 2016 Webinar MACRA for Critical Access Hospitals Tuesday, July 26, 2016 Webinar MACRA presenters Harold D. Miller, President & CEO CHQPR Claudia Sanders, Sr. Vice President, Policy Development Andrew Busz, Policy Director,

More information

CREATING PHYSICIAN-FOCUSED ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT MODELS

CREATING PHYSICIAN-FOCUSED ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT MODELS CREATING PHYSICIAN-FOCUSED ALTERNATIVE PAYMENT MODELS Better Care for Patients, Lower Cost for Payers, and Financially Viable Physician Practices Harold D. Miller President and CEO Center for Healthcare

More information

ACOs: California Style

ACOs: California Style ACOs: California Style ACO Congress John E. Jenrette, M.D. Chief Executive Officer Sharp Community Medical Group November 2, 2011 California Style California Style A CO California Style California Style

More information

2015 Annual Convention

2015 Annual Convention 2015 Annual Convention Date: Tuesday, October 13, 2015 Time: 8:00 am 9:30 am Location: Gaylord National Harbor Resort and Convention Center, National Harbor 10 Title: Activity Type: Speaker: Opportunities

More information

OMC Strategic Plan Final Draft. Dear Community, Working together to provide excellence in health care.

OMC Strategic Plan Final Draft. Dear Community, Working together to provide excellence in health care. Dear Community, Working together to provide excellence in health care. This mission statement, established nearly two decades ago, continues to be fulfilled by our employees and medical staff. This mission

More information

Physician Compensation in an Era of New Reimbursement Models

Physician Compensation in an Era of New Reimbursement Models 2014 IHA Annual Membership Meeting Physician Compensation in an Era of New Reimbursement Models Taryn E. Stone Ice Miller LLP (317) 236-5872 taryn.stone@ Agenda Background New Reimbursement Models Trends

More information

Specialty Payment Model Opportunities Assessment and Design

Specialty Payment Model Opportunities Assessment and Design Approved for Public Release. Distribution Unlimited.14.2286. CMS Alliance to Modernize Healthcare (CAMH) Specialty Model Opportunities Assessment and Design Cardiology Technical Expert Panel April 8, 2014

More information

KNOW YOUR BATNA: SHARED RISK AND FUTURE PAYMENT SYSTEMS DISCLOSURES OBJECTIVES

KNOW YOUR BATNA: SHARED RISK AND FUTURE PAYMENT SYSTEMS DISCLOSURES OBJECTIVES KNOW YOUR BATNA: SHARED RISK AND FUTURE PAYMENT SYSTEMS Stanley W. Stead, M.D., M.B.A. President, Stead Health Group, Inc. Section Chair, ASA Section on Professional Practice AMA Relative Value Update

More information

Medicaid Payment Reform at Scale: The New York State Roadmap

Medicaid Payment Reform at Scale: The New York State Roadmap Medicaid Payment Reform at Scale: The New York State Roadmap ASTHO Technical Assistance Call June 22 nd 2015 Greg Allen Policy Director New York State Medicaid Overview Background and Brief History Delivery

More information

Post Acute Continuum Lessons Learned from Geisinger s ProvenHealth Navigator

Post Acute Continuum Lessons Learned from Geisinger s ProvenHealth Navigator Post Acute Continuum Lessons Learned from Geisinger s ProvenHealth Navigator Janet Tomcavage, RN, MSN VP Health Services, Geisinger Health Plan Danville, PA February 3, 2012 Patient-centered primary care

More information

Transitions of Care: Primary Care Perspective. Patrick Noonan, DO

Transitions of Care: Primary Care Perspective. Patrick Noonan, DO Transitions of Care: Primary Care Perspective Patrick Noonan, DO Disclosures None Bio Outpatient primary care internist at New Pueblo Medicine Completed residency at the University of Iowa Graduated from

More information

HealthPartners and the Triple Aim. IHI Open School August 23, 2012 Beth Waterman, RN MBA Chief Improvement Officer HealthPartners

HealthPartners and the Triple Aim. IHI Open School August 23, 2012 Beth Waterman, RN MBA Chief Improvement Officer HealthPartners HealthPartners and the Triple Aim IHI Open School August 23, 2012 Beth Waterman, RN MBA Chief Improvement Officer HealthPartners HealthPartners Not for profit, consumer governed Integrated care and financing

More information

ACOs the Medicare Shared Savings Program And Other Healthcare Reform Payment Methods

ACOs the Medicare Shared Savings Program And Other Healthcare Reform Payment Methods A unique vision for an ever-changing healthcare environment ACOs the Medicare Shared Savings Program And Other Healthcare Reform Payment Methods Presented by Joe Laden, President, ORVA, LLC The Environment

More information

CSO HIMSS Spring Conference 2013 Expanding Meaningful Use to the Point of Care

CSO HIMSS Spring Conference 2013 Expanding Meaningful Use to the Point of Care CSO HIMSS Spring Conference 2013 Expanding Meaningful Use to the Point of Care Glenn Loomis, MD President & CEO & M. Todd Philippe, MD Physician Superuser St. Elizabeth Physicians CSOHIMSS 2013 Slide 0

More information

Next Generation Physician Compensation Design in a Schizophrenic Payer Environment

Next Generation Physician Compensation Design in a Schizophrenic Payer Environment Next Generation Physician Compensation Design in a Schizophrenic Payer Environment Presented to: 2015 Spring Managed Care Forum Friday, April 24, 2015 Today s agenda Setting the Stage Why are we Here?

More information

GIC Employees/Retirees without Medicare

GIC Employees/Retirees without Medicare GIC Active Employees & Retirees without Medicare 7/1/18 GIC Employees/Retirees without Medicare HMO Summary of Benefits Chart This chart provides a summary of key services offered by your Health New England

More information

A Practical Approach Toward Accountable Care and Risk-Based Contracting: Design to Implementation

A Practical Approach Toward Accountable Care and Risk-Based Contracting: Design to Implementation A Practical Approach Toward Accountable Care and Risk-Based Contracting: Design to Implementation Daniel J. Marino, President/CEO, Health Directions Asad Zaman, MD June 19, 2013 Session Objectives Establish

More information

Outpatient Hospital Facilities

Outpatient Hospital Facilities Outpatient Hospital Facilities Chapter 6 Chapter Outline Introduce students to 1. Different outpatient facilities 2. Different departments involved in the reimbursement process 3. The Chargemaster 4. Terminology

More information

Topics for Today s Discussion

Topics for Today s Discussion MICAH Quality Network Population Insights Reporting and 2017 2018 PG5 P4P Program Year Updates Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Hospital Incentive Programs August 18 th, 2017 Topics for Today s Discussion

More information

7/7/17. Value and Quality in Health Care. Kevin Shah, MD MBA. Overview of Quality. Define. Measure. Improve

7/7/17. Value and Quality in Health Care. Kevin Shah, MD MBA. Overview of Quality. Define. Measure. Improve Value and Quality in Health Care Kevin Shah, MD MBA 1 Overview of Quality Define Measure 2 1 Define Health care reform is transitioning financing from volume to value based reimbursement Today Fee for

More information

Exhibit 1. Medicare Shared Savings Program: Year 1 Performance of Participating Accountable Care Organizations (2013)

Exhibit 1. Medicare Shared Savings Program: Year 1 Performance of Participating Accountable Care Organizations (2013) Exhibit 1. Medicare Shared Savings Program: Year 1 Performance of Participating Accountable Care Organizations (2013) 24 percent (52 ACOs) earned shared savings bonus 27 percent (60 ACOs) reduced spending,

More information

Central Ohio Primary Care (COPC) Spotlight on Innovation

Central Ohio Primary Care (COPC) Spotlight on Innovation Central Ohio Primary Care (COPC) Spotlight on Innovation BY BETTER MEDICARE ALLIANCE MARCH 2017 Central Ohio Primary Care Spotlight on Innovation 1 Central Ohio Primary Care (COPC) Spotlight on Innovation

More information

HEALTH CARE REFORM IN THE U.S.

HEALTH CARE REFORM IN THE U.S. HEALTH CARE REFORM IN THE U.S. A LOOK AT THE PAST, PRESENT AND FUTURE Carolyn Belk January 11, 2016 0 HEALTH CARE REFORM BIRTH OF THE AFFORDABLE CARE ACT Health care reform in the U.S. has been an ongoing

More information

Population Health or Single-payer The future is in our hands. Robert J. Margolis, MD

Population Health or Single-payer The future is in our hands. Robert J. Margolis, MD Population Health or Single-payer The future is in our hands Robert J. Margolis, MD Today s problems Interim steps Population health Alternatives Conclusions Outline $3,000,000,000,000 $1,000,000,000,000

More information

MAKING PROGRESS, SEEING RESULTS

MAKING PROGRESS, SEEING RESULTS MAKING PROGRESS, SEEING RESULTS VALUE-BASED CARE REPORT HUMANA.COM/VALUEBASEDCARE Y0040_GCHK4DYEN 1117 Accepted 2 Americans are sick and getting sicker, with millions of us living with chronic conditions

More information

The New World of Value Driven Cardiac Care

The New World of Value Driven Cardiac Care 1 The New World of Value Driven Cardiac Care Disclosures MPA Healthcare Solutions is an analytic health care consultancy that provides clients with insight into clinical performance; aids them in the evaluation,

More information

Succeeding with Accountable Care Organizations

Succeeding with Accountable Care Organizations Succeeding with Accountable Care Organizations The Point B Webinar Series October 25, 2011 Today s Discussion Key ACO trends and emerging models Critical success factors for building an ACO Developing

More information

Rural and Independent Primary Care.

Rural and Independent Primary Care. Rural and Independent Primary Care www.caravanhealth.com Agenda 2015 Results from Rural ACO Participants Fundamental population health programs. Overview of additional rural value-based payments Opportunities

More information

New Jersey Medicaid Medical Home Demonstration Project Report to the Legislature

New Jersey Medicaid Medical Home Demonstration Project Report to the Legislature New Jersey Medicaid Medical Home Demonstration Project Report to the Legislature November 2012 Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services NJ Department of Human Services Introduction In September,

More information

Employer Breakout Session Payment Change in Ohio: What it Means for Employers

Employer Breakout Session Payment Change in Ohio: What it Means for Employers Employer Breakout Session Payment Change in Ohio: What it Means for Employers Moderators Jeff Biehl, Health Collaborative of Greater Columbus Frank A. Johnson, Maine Health Management Coalition Who is

More information

ESSENTIAL STRATEGIES IN MEDI-CAL PAYMENT REFORM. Richard Popper, Director, Medicaid & Duals Strategy August 3, 2017

ESSENTIAL STRATEGIES IN MEDI-CAL PAYMENT REFORM. Richard Popper, Director, Medicaid & Duals Strategy August 3, 2017 ESSENTIAL STRATEGIES IN MEDI-CAL PAYMENT REFORM Richard Popper, Director, Medicaid & Duals Strategy August 3, 2017 1 DISCLAIMER The enclosed materials are highly sensitive, proprietary and confidential.

More information

Population Health: Tamara Cull, MSW, LCSW, ACM National Director, Care Management, Value Based Programs and Operations November, 2014

Population Health: Tamara Cull, MSW, LCSW, ACM National Director, Care Management, Value Based Programs and Operations November, 2014 In the Hospital and Health System ACO Tamara Cull, MSW, LCSW, ACM National Director, Care Management, Value Based Programs and Operations November, 2014 What We ll Be Discussing Who is CHI What are we

More information

Understanding the Initiative Landscape in Medi-Cal. IHA Stakeholder Meeting September 23, 2016 Sarah Lally, Project Manager

Understanding the Initiative Landscape in Medi-Cal. IHA Stakeholder Meeting September 23, 2016 Sarah Lally, Project Manager Understanding the Initiative Landscape in Medi-Cal IHA Stakeholder Meeting September 23, 2016 Sarah Lally, Project Manager Agenda Welcome / Introduction Sarah Lally, Project Manager Inland Empire Health

More information

UnitedHealth Center for Health Reform & Modernization September 2014

UnitedHealth Center for Health Reform & Modernization September 2014 Health Reform & Modernization September 2014 2014 UnitedHealth Group. Any use, copying or distribution without written permission from UnitedHealth Group is prohibited. Overview Why Focus on Primary Care?

More information

Consumer Preferences, Hospital Choices, and Demand-side Incentives

Consumer Preferences, Hospital Choices, and Demand-side Incentives Consumer Preferences, Hospital Choices, and Demand-side Incentives David I Auerbach, PhD Director of Research, Massachusetts Health Policy Commission Co-authors: Amy Lischko, Susan Koch-Weser, Sarah Hijaz

More information

Healthcare Reimbursement Change VBP -The Future is Now

Healthcare Reimbursement Change VBP -The Future is Now Healthcare Reimbursement Change VBP -The Future is Now 1 On the Move Volume/ Fee-for-Service Fee-for-service reimbursement High quality not rewarded No shared financial risk Stand-alone systems can thrive

More information

THE ALPHABET SOUP OF MEDICAL PAYMENTS: WHAT IS MACRA, VBP AND MORE! Lisa Scheppers MD FACP Margo Ferguson MT MSOM

THE ALPHABET SOUP OF MEDICAL PAYMENTS: WHAT IS MACRA, VBP AND MORE! Lisa Scheppers MD FACP Margo Ferguson MT MSOM THE ALPHABET SOUP OF MEDICAL PAYMENTS: WHAT IS MACRA, VBP AND MORE! Lisa Scheppers MD FACP Margo Ferguson MT MSOM THE REASON FOR CHANGE VOLUME TO VALUE Fee-for-service PAYMENT Bundled, Shared Patient FOCUS

More information

Christi McCarren, SVP, Retail Health & Community Based Care Lynnell Hornbeck, Manager, Home Health

Christi McCarren, SVP, Retail Health & Community Based Care Lynnell Hornbeck, Manager, Home Health Christi McCarren, SVP, Retail Health & Community Based Care Lynnell Hornbeck, Manager, Home Health Webinar: Northwest Regional Telehealth Resource Center October 27, 2016 1 MultiCare Health System MultiCare

More information

Ohio Department of Medicaid

Ohio Department of Medicaid Ohio Department of Medicaid Joint Medicaid Oversight Committee March 19, 2015 John McCarthy, Medicaid Director 1 Payment Reform Care Management Quality Strategy Today s Topics Managed Care Performance

More information

The Alternative Quality Contract (AQC): Improving Quality While Slowing Spending Growth

The Alternative Quality Contract (AQC): Improving Quality While Slowing Spending Growth The Alternative Quality Contract (AQC): Improving Quality While Slowing Spending Growth Dana Gelb Safran, ScD Senior Vice President, Performance Measurement and Improvement Presented at: MAHQ 16 April

More information

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) The Harvard Pilgrim Independence Plan SM

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) The Harvard Pilgrim Independence Plan SM Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) The Harvard Pilgrim Independence Plan SM Plan Year: July 2010 June 2011 Background The Harvard Pilgrim Independence Plan was developed in 2006 for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts

More information

Healthy Aging Recommendations 2015 White House Conference on Aging

Healthy Aging Recommendations 2015 White House Conference on Aging Healthy Aging Recommendations 2015 White House Conference on Aging Chronic diseases are the leading causes of death and disability in the U.S. and account for 75% of the nation s health care spending.

More information

Using Data for Proactive Patient Population Management

Using Data for Proactive Patient Population Management Using Data for Proactive Patient Population Management Kate Lichtenberg, DO, MPH, FAAFP October 16, 2013 Topics Review population based care Understand the use of registries Harnessing the power of EHRs

More information

Eliminating Excessive, Unnecessary, and Wasteful Expenditures: Getting to a High Performance U.S. Health System

Eliminating Excessive, Unnecessary, and Wasteful Expenditures: Getting to a High Performance U.S. Health System Eliminating Excessive, Unnecessary, and Wasteful Expenditures: Getting to a High Performance U.S. Health System Karen Davis President, The Commonwealth Fund IOM Workshop Series: The Policy Agenda September

More information

The Business Case for Registered Dietitian Nutritionists in Value-based Health Care. Value. Compensation 3/3/2015

The Business Case for Registered Dietitian Nutritionists in Value-based Health Care. Value. Compensation 3/3/2015 The Business Case for Registered Dietitian Nutritionists in Value-based Health Care Meredith Alger, MS, RDN, LD South Carolina Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics March 4, 2015 Value How do you value yourself

More information

From Reactive to Proactive: Creating a Population Management Platform

From Reactive to Proactive: Creating a Population Management Platform Session D9 / E9 From Reactive to Proactive: Creating a Population Management Platform Richard Gitomer, MD Director, Brigham and Women s Primary Care Center of Excellence Vice Chair, Primary Care, Dept.

More information

Succeeding in a New Era of Health Care Delivery

Succeeding in a New Era of Health Care Delivery March 14, 2012 Succeeding in a New Era of Health Care Delivery Building Value-Based Partnerships LeadingAge Pennsylvania Kathleen Griffin, PhD, National Director Post-Acute and Senior Services 1 Your Presenter

More information

Administrators. Medical Directors. 61% The negative impact on our hospital-based program s. 44% We will need to consider the most appropriate or most

Administrators. Medical Directors. 61% The negative impact on our hospital-based program s. 44% We will need to consider the most appropriate or most 2016 This annual survey, which began in 2009, provides key insight into nationwide developments in the business of cancer care. To better capture information from its multidisciplinary membership, this

More information

The Cost of Care: Understanding the Next Generation of Payment Models

The Cost of Care: Understanding the Next Generation of Payment Models The Cost of Care: Understanding the Next Generation of Payment Models Presented by: Debbie Welle Powell, MPA, Vice President Sisters of Charity Health System and Exempla Healthcare September 27 th, 2012

More information

Click to edit Master title style

Click to edit Master title style Preventing, Detecting and Managing Chronic Disease for Medicare Kenneth E. Thorpe, Ph.D. Robert W. Woodruff Professor and Chair of the Department of Health Policy & Management, Rollins School of Public

More information

MACRA & Implications for Telemedicine. June 20, 2016

MACRA & Implications for Telemedicine. June 20, 2016 MACRA & Implications for Telemedicine June 20, 2016 Presentation Overview Introductions Deep Dive Into MACRA Implications for Telemedicine Questions Growth in Value-Based Care Over Next Two Years Growth

More information

Physician Alignment Strategies and Options. June 1, 2011

Physician Alignment Strategies and Options. June 1, 2011 Physician Alignment Strategies and Options June 1, 2011 1 Today s Discussion Review physician-hospital alignment objectives Understand the changing paradigm Evaluate alignment strategies for a new delivery

More information

Is HIT a Real Tool for The Success of a Value-Based Program?

Is HIT a Real Tool for The Success of a Value-Based Program? Is HIT a Real Tool for The Success of a Value-Based Program? Sally Montes, MPH, RHIA, CCHP President, SM & Associates, Inc. smontes@sm-asociados.com (787) 306-1149 President, PR HFMA Chapter INTRODUCTION

More information

Value-Based Reimbursements are Here: Are you Ready?

Value-Based Reimbursements are Here: Are you Ready? Value-Based Reimbursements are Here: Are you Ready? White Paper ELLIS MAC KNIGHT, MD Senior Vice President/CMO Published by Becker s Hospital Review April 2016 White Paper Value-Based Reimbursements are

More information

Improving Care and Managing Costs: Team-Based Care for the Chronically Ill

Improving Care and Managing Costs: Team-Based Care for the Chronically Ill Improving Care and Managing Costs: Team-Based Care for the Chronically Ill Cathy Schoen Senior Vice President The Commonwealth Fund www.commonwealthfund.org cs@cmwf.org High Cost Beneficiaries: What Can

More information

Reducing Readmissions: Potential Measurements

Reducing Readmissions: Potential Measurements Reducing Readmissions: Potential Measurements Avoid Readmissions Through Collaboration October 27, 2010 Denise Remus, PhD, RN Chief Quality Officer BayCare Health System Overview Why Focus on Readmissions?

More information

MIPS, MACRA, & CJR: Medicare Payment Transformation. Presenter: Thomas Barber, M.D. May 31, 2016

MIPS, MACRA, & CJR: Medicare Payment Transformation. Presenter: Thomas Barber, M.D. May 31, 2016 MIPS, MACRA, & CJR: Medicare Payment Transformation Presenter: Thomas Barber, M.D. May 31, 2016 Michael Porter- Value Based Care Delivery, Annals of Surgery 2008 Principals: Define Value as a Goal Care

More information

What s Wrong with Healthcare?

What s Wrong with Healthcare? What s Wrong with Healthcare? Dan Murrey, MD, MPP Chief Executive Officer Agenda What s wrong with healthcare in the US? What would make it better? How can you help? What s wrong with US healthcare? What

More information

Ambulatory Care Practice Trends and Opportunities in Pharmacy

Ambulatory Care Practice Trends and Opportunities in Pharmacy Ambulatory Care Practice Trends and Opportunities in Pharmacy David Chen, R.Ph., M.B.A. Senior Director Section of Pharmacy Practice Managers ASHP Objectives Describe trends in health system pharmacy reported

More information

So How Do You Convince Your Hospital Leadership Your Idea is Best for Patient Care? Mission, Quality, Cost, and Standardization

So How Do You Convince Your Hospital Leadership Your Idea is Best for Patient Care? Mission, Quality, Cost, and Standardization So How Do You Convince Your Hospital Leadership Your Idea is Best for Patient Care? Mission, Quality, Cost, and Standardization Robert M. Insoft, MD, FAAP Senior Vice President, Quality & Medical Affairs

More information

Value model in the new healthcare paradigm: Producing value at a single specialty center.

Value model in the new healthcare paradigm: Producing value at a single specialty center. Value model in the new healthcare paradigm: Producing value at a single specialty center. State of Spine Surgery Think Tank June 17, 2017 Catherine MacLean, MD, PhD Chief Value Medical Officer Center for

More information

Improving Health Care Quality and Reducing Costs through Payment and Delivery System Reform

Improving Health Care Quality and Reducing Costs through Payment and Delivery System Reform Improving Health Care Quality and Reducing Costs through Payment and Delivery System Reform Harold D. Miller President and CEO Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement and Executive Director Center

More information

Quality Measurement, Population Health and Payment Reform

Quality Measurement, Population Health and Payment Reform Quality Measurement, Population Health and Payment Reform The Move from Volume to Value Dale W. Bratzler, DO, MPH, FACOI, FIDSA Professor, Colleges of Medicine and Public Health Associate Dean, College

More information

Community Health Workers: ACA and Redesign Funding Opportunities

Community Health Workers: ACA and Redesign Funding Opportunities Community Health Workers: ACA and Redesign Funding Opportunities What are the Goals of the Affordable Care Act and Redesign? Increased Coverage Better Population Health Higher Quality, More-Patient Centered

More information

Why Every SNF Should Be Offering Telemedicine For Its Residents or Transforming SNF Care Through Telemedicine

Why Every SNF Should Be Offering Telemedicine For Its Residents or Transforming SNF Care Through Telemedicine PACAH 2018 Spring Conference John Whitman, MBA, NHA The Wharton School Tapestry TeleHealth The TRECS Institute Why Every SNF Should Be Offering Telemedicine For Its Residents or Transforming SNF Care Through

More information

Performance Measurement Work Group Meeting 10/18/2017

Performance Measurement Work Group Meeting 10/18/2017 Performance Measurement Work Group Meeting 10/18/2017 Welcome to New Members QBR RY 2020 DRAFT QBR Policy Components QBR Program RY 2020 Snapshot QBR Consists of 3 Domains: Person and Community Engagement

More information

Balancing State, Federal and Internal Bundle Payment Initiatives

Balancing State, Federal and Internal Bundle Payment Initiatives Balancing State, Federal and Internal Bundle Payment Initiatives Vanderbilt University Medical Center Brittany Cunningham, MSN, RN, CSSBB Director, Episodes of Care Key Take Aways What are the different

More information

IMPLEMENTATION OF INTEGRATED CARE FROM A LEADERSHIP PERSPECTIVE. Tennessee Primary Care Association Annual Conference October 25 26, 2012.

IMPLEMENTATION OF INTEGRATED CARE FROM A LEADERSHIP PERSPECTIVE. Tennessee Primary Care Association Annual Conference October 25 26, 2012. IMPLEMENTATION OF INTEGRATED CARE FROM A LEADERSHIP PERSPECTIVE Tennessee Primary Care Association Annual Conference October 25 26, 2012 Outline I. Brief Overview of Cherokee (Who are we?) II. The Integrated

More information

The Future of Healthcare Credit Analysis - Seven Emerging Ratios

The Future of Healthcare Credit Analysis - Seven Emerging Ratios The Future of Healthcare Credit Analysis - Seven Emerging Ratios Kevin F. Fitch Director, Strategic Financial Planning & Analysis Adam D. Lynch Vice President Robert A. Henley Director, Analytics Learning

More information

We can never insure one-hundred percent of the population against one-hundred percent of the hazards and vicissitudes of life. Franklin D.

We can never insure one-hundred percent of the population against one-hundred percent of the hazards and vicissitudes of life. Franklin D. Medicare Explained We can never insure one-hundred percent of the population against one-hundred percent of the hazards and vicissitudes of life. Franklin D. Roosevelt comments on signing The Social Security

More information

Yes, for all plans, see or call for a list of network providers.

Yes, for all plans, see   or call for a list of network providers. Important Questions (Massachusetts ) (New England ) (National ) What is the overall $0.00 Are there other s for specific? Is there an out of pocket limit on my expenses? What is not included in the out

More information

Monica E. Oss, Chief Executive Officer, OPEN MINDS CBHC Annual Conference September 29, 2012 / 10:00 am

Monica E. Oss, Chief Executive Officer, OPEN MINDS CBHC Annual Conference September 29, 2012 / 10:00 am Monica E. Oss, Chief Executive Officer, OPEN MINDS CBHC Annual Conference September 29, 2012 / 10:00 am Why the demand for coordinated care? What factors are shaping emerging models? What are the emerging

More information

Workhorse or Unicorn: Incentive Realignment and Health Improvement After One Year of ACOs. Objectives

Workhorse or Unicorn: Incentive Realignment and Health Improvement After One Year of ACOs. Objectives Session L23 These presenters have nothing to disclose Workhorse or Unicorn: Incentive Realignment and Health Improvement After One Year of ACOs By James E. Orlikoff and Len Nichols Sunday, December 9,

More information

Annual Notice of Changes for 2017

Annual Notice of Changes for 2017 Network PlatinumPlus (PPO) offered by Network Health Insurance Corporation Annual Notice of Changes for 2017 You are currently enrolled as a member of Network PlatinumPlus. Next year, there will be some

More information

Gateway to Practitioner Excellence GPE 2017 Medicaid & Medicare

Gateway to Practitioner Excellence GPE 2017 Medicaid & Medicare Gateway to Practitioner Excellence GPE 2017 Medicaid & Medicare Recognizing and Rewarding Excellent Practices Improving the Health of Gateway Members PRACTICE ELIGIBILITY (see PCMH slide #27 for separate

More information

New Models of Care: Diabetes and the Triple Aim

New Models of Care: Diabetes and the Triple Aim Robert Gabbay MD, PhD, FACP Chief Medical Officer Joslin Diabetes Center Harvard Medical School Boston, MA The Triple Aim New Models of Care: Diabetes and the Triple Aim Healthcare is changing, what does

More information

04/08/2015. Thinking Beyond the Hospital Walls: Readmission Reduction Strategies for Pharmacists. Pharmacist Objectives. Technician Objectives

04/08/2015. Thinking Beyond the Hospital Walls: Readmission Reduction Strategies for Pharmacists. Pharmacist Objectives. Technician Objectives 1 2 Thinking Beyond the Hospital Walls: Readmission Reduction Strategies for Pharmacists Stacey Zorska, Pharm.D., MHA Director of Pharmacy Services Southwest General Middleburg Heights, OH Pharmacist Objectives

More information

MACRA Fall into Place. By Stephanie Cecchini, CPC, CEMC, CHISP, AAPC Fellow, AAPC MACRA Prof

MACRA Fall into Place. By Stephanie Cecchini, CPC, CEMC, CHISP, AAPC Fellow, AAPC MACRA Prof MACRA Fall into Place By Stephanie Cecchini, CPC, CEMC, CHISP, AAPC Fellow, AAPC MACRA Prof About the Presenter https://www.linkedin.com/in/stephaniececchini 2 Introduction Love it Hate it Don t know a

More information

The Evolving Landscape of Healthcare Payment: Incentive Programs and ACO Model Optimization. Quality Forum August 19, 2015

The Evolving Landscape of Healthcare Payment: Incentive Programs and ACO Model Optimization. Quality Forum August 19, 2015 The Evolving Landscape of Healthcare Payment: Incentive Programs and ACO Model Optimization Quality Forum August 19, 2015 Ross Manson rmanson@eidebailly.com 701.239.8634 Barb Pritchard bpritchard@eidebailly.com

More information

TRADITIONAL PPO PLAN FT. LAUDERDALE $10/20%/40% RX PROVIDED BY AETNA LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY EFFECTIVE JANUARY 1, 2018 AETNA INC.

TRADITIONAL PPO PLAN FT. LAUDERDALE $10/20%/40% RX PROVIDED BY AETNA LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY EFFECTIVE JANUARY 1, 2018 AETNA INC. TRADITIONAL PPO PLAN FT. LAUDERDALE $10/20%/40% RX PROVIDED BY AETNA LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY EFFECTIVE JANUARY 1, 2018 AETNA INC. CPOS II DEDUCTIBLE, COPAYS/COINSURANCE AND DOLLAR MAXIMUMS and Aligned Deductible

More information

Critical Access Hospital Quality

Critical Access Hospital Quality Critical Access Hospital Quality Current Performance and the Development of Relevant Measures Ira Moscovice, PhD Mayo Professor & Head Division of Health Policy & Management School of Public Health, University

More information

Becoming a Champion of Physician and Hospital Alignment: Focusing on Length of Stay, Discipline and Standards of Care

Becoming a Champion of Physician and Hospital Alignment: Focusing on Length of Stay, Discipline and Standards of Care Becoming a Champion of Physician and Hospital Alignment: Focusing on Length of Stay, Discipline and Standards of Care Marc Tucker, DO Senior Director Audit, Compliance & Education AHA Solutions, Inc.,

More information

Transitioning to a Value-Based Accountable Health System Preparing for the New Business Model. The New Accountable Care Business Model

Transitioning to a Value-Based Accountable Health System Preparing for the New Business Model. The New Accountable Care Business Model Transitioning to a Value-Based Accountable Health System Preparing for the New Business Model Michael C. Tobin, D.O., M.B.A. Interim Chief medical Officer Health Networks February 12, 2011 2011 North Iowa

More information

Risk Adjusted Diagnosis Coding:

Risk Adjusted Diagnosis Coding: Risk Adjusted Diagnosis Coding: Reporting ChronicDisease for Population Health Management Jeri Leong, R.N., CPC, CPC-H, CPMA, CPC-I Executive Director 1 Learning Objectives Explain the concept Medicare

More information

Cathy Schoen. The Commonwealth Fund Grantmakers In Health Webinar October 3, 2012

Cathy Schoen. The Commonwealth Fund  Grantmakers In Health Webinar October 3, 2012 Innovating Care for Chronically Ill Patients Cathy Schoen Senior Vice President The Commonwealth Fund www.commonwealthfund.org cs@cmwf.org Grantmakers In Health Webinar October 3, 2012 Chronically Ill:

More information

SUCCESS IN A VALUE - BASED PAYMENT ARRANGMENT

SUCCESS IN A VALUE - BASED PAYMENT ARRANGMENT SUCCESS IN A VALUE - BASED PAYMENT ARRANGMENT October 3 rd, 2017 David Evangelista MediSys Health Network 1 Who is MediSys? Jamaica Hospital is a 431-bed not-for profit teaching hospital. Jamaica is a

More information

2016 Medical Plan Comparison Chart

2016 Medical Plan Comparison Chart 2016 Medical Plan Comparison Chart WellStar Health System is committed to helping you control healthcare costs while providing more choices and personal control over your healthcare coverage through the

More information

Welcome to Regence! Meet your employer health plan

Welcome to Regence! Meet your employer health plan is an Independent Licensee of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association Regence BlueCross BlueShield of Utah Welcome to Regence! Meet your employer health plan 1 Health insurance is a big, wonderful benefit.

More information

Optima Health Provider Manual

Optima Health Provider Manual Optima Health Provider Manual Supplemental Information For Ohio Facilities and Ancillaries This supplement of the Optima Health Ohio Provider Manual provides information of specific interest to Participating

More information

TKG Health Systems Advisory Panel Meeting. Healthcare in 2017: Trends & Hot Topics. Tuesday, March 24 th, 2017 Gaylord Texan Resort, Grapevine, TX

TKG Health Systems Advisory Panel Meeting. Healthcare in 2017: Trends & Hot Topics. Tuesday, March 24 th, 2017 Gaylord Texan Resort, Grapevine, TX TKG Health Systems Advisory Panel Meeting Healthcare in 2017: Trends & Hot Topics Tuesday, March 24 th, 2017 Gaylord Texan Resort, Grapevine, TX Executive Summary Key Trends The transition to value-based

More information