Engaging Physicians in Leading Quality Improvement

Transcription

1 Engaging Physicians in Leading Quality Improvement Carol Peden, MB ChB, MD, MPH Felipe Osorno, MSCEP Kaveh Houshmand Azad, MSCIE Keck Medicine of USC University of Southern California Los Angeles

2 Disclosures Carol Peden is a shareholder in Fidelity Health and a Fellow and Faculty of IHI. We have no other relevant financial rela;onships with the products or services described, reviewed, evaluated or compared in this presenta;on. Carol Peden, MB ChB, MD, MPH Felipe Osorno, MSCEP Kaveh Houshmand Azad, MSCIE 2

3 OBJECTIVES OF THIS SESSION 1 - To understand how to develop a strategy and framework to create a program for physicians in leadership and quality improvement 2 - To understand how to implement a framework to enable physicians to lead quality and performance improvement projects 3 3 To learn from success stories from our physician quality and improvement program, as well as lessons learned

4 Keck Medicine of USC 3 Hospitals 619 Beds 60+ Clinics 4,000+ Employees 1300 Faculty and Scien;sts 9000 Clinical Trials 900 Residents $1.6B Net Revenue Born in

5 CMI We see some of the sickest pa]ents in the na]on 2.96 Keck Medical Center of USC 2.78 City of Hope 2.72 Sylvester Cancer Center 2.53 Univ. of Maryland Medical Center 2.50 Cleveland Clinic 2.46 MoffiQ Cancer Center 2.43 Stanford Health 2.34 Mayo Clinic 2.27 UCLA Health (Ronald Reagan) 2.11 UCSF Medical Center 1.92 Johns Hopkins Medicine 5 Source: UHC, Q32016 Q22017 CMI = Case Mix Index

6 Innovation at Keck First FDA-Approved High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound Surgical Abla]on for Kidney & Prostate Cancer First to Offer Bronchial Thermoplasty Outpa]ent Treatment for Severe Asthma First to Treat Uncontrolled Epilepsy with FDA- Approved Responsive Neuros]mula]on System Charles Heidelberger, first associate director for basic research at USC Norris Comprehensive Cancer Center and of 5-Fluorouracil, the most widely used cancer chemotherapy drug First Implantable Ar]ficial Re]na to Restore Vision from Re]ni]s Pigmetosa First to Establish Rela]onship of Cancer and Epigene]c DNA Methyla]on 6

7 Keck s Revenue Growth An Academic Start Up Revenue has tripled in 6 years reached 1.6B in 2017 $1,600 30% growth in the last 2 fiscal years $1,400 $1.5B $1,200 $1.31B $1,000 $1.15B $800 $790M $600 $400 $460M $550M $620M $200 $

8 Los Angeles Health Care Significant Medi-cal (37% of LA County and 33% of CA) and Medicare pa;ent popula;on Los Angeles is one of the least consolidated health systems in the US Marked demographic diversity 8

9 Health Spending Per Capita Per State 2014 (most recent data) Source: Kaiser Family FoundaOon hpps:// capita 9

10 From a For-Profit Hospital to an Academic Medical Center in a changing healthcare world Challenges! Culture Developing data infrastructure LiQle improvement infrastructure Rapid growth and developing systems 10

11 Who we are? Carol Peden, Physician anesthesiologist and intensivist 30 years frontline clinical experience, IHI Fellow and Faculty, experience of designing and leading QI projects and curricula around the world. Felipe Osorno, MIT Chemical Engineer, 6 years in consul;ng at McKinsey, Lean and Six Sigma Trained, experience and passion in crea;ng systems to empower frontline staff to improve value. Kaveh Houshmand Azad, MSc Industrial Engineering, 10 years of experience in healthcare performance improvement 11

12 Getting Physicians Engaged in Improvement Why this program for us now? Growth and Infrastructure Value in healthcare Transforma;onal change The issues all healthcare organiza;ons are facing 12

13 We are all facing similar challenges Changes in reimbursement models V VALUE Need for change Rising supply and labor costs End-to- End Bundles Waste in internal processes Varia]on among providers 13

14 Burnout 14 West et al Lancet 2016;388: Salyers et al Journal of General Internal Medicine 2016

15 15 Strategies to reduce physician burnout Acknowledging and assessing the problem Recognizing the behaviors of leaders that can increase or decrease burnout Using a systems approach to develop targeted interven;ons to improve efficiency and reduce clerical work Cul;va;ng community at work Using rewards and incen;ves strategically Assessing whether the organiza;ons ac;ons are aligned with the stated values and mission Implemen;ng organiza;onal prac;ces and policies that promote flexibility and work-life balance Providing resources to help individuals promote selfcare Suppor;ng organiza;onal science (Study the factors in your own ins;tu;on that contribute to the problem, and invest in solu;ons.) hpps://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/mayo-clinic-reversing-physician-burnout-using-nine-strategies-to-promote-well-being/

16 Achieving The Quadruple Aim Improved Pa]ent Outcomes Improved Care Giver Experience Lower Cost of Care Improved Pa]ent Experience 16

17 Why not a multidisciplinary team approach? Culture No medical school training (to date) in QI at USC Time LiQle established infrastructure Need to rapidly develop a cohort of leaders who could then work with their teams 17

18 Our System-Wide Strategy Culture of Improvement Data Availability and Transparency Building Capabili]es System-Wide Improvement Specialty-Level Improvement Engaged Physicians 18

19 Designing the program Approach from both Lean and Model for Improvement Using background research and the team s experience Lean Thinking hpp:// 19 Model for improvement developed by Associates in Process Improvement

20 Experience and Learning 20 hpps:// hpps://paoentsikkerhed.dk/content/uploads/2016/02/psskatalog_uk_www.pdf hpps://

21 The Secret Sauce Early engagement of a physician leader who can listen, engage, and lead other colleagues to be an early adopter They must be equipped with the training and tools to lead others, require dedicated protected ;me, and the autonomy to coordinate and implement changes The engaged physician leader requires training in governance, leadership and medical economics and mentorship American Journal of Medical Quality 2017.

22 EPOCH Aim and Theory Mo;va;on and focus Community of prac;ce Measurement & data feedback QI skills training Evidence based interven;ons Front-line clinical staff will be enabled to achieve improvements in care for patients undergoing Emergency Surgery which will lead to improved outcomes MDT approach 22 EPOCH Trial: Enhanced Peri-Opera;ve Care for High-risk Pa;ents 1.5M /90 Hospitals

23 Ethnography and physician engagement Because historically we as surgeons would finish an emergency and ouen leave the opera;ng theatre to write the opera;on notes, and then ouen the consultant would leave, and the registrar might come back to see what is going on, but ouen you would find out the next morning where the pa;ent had gone. Whereas this now, gevng us into more of a culture of: Is this pa;ent high risk? Should they go to intensive care? What is our plan of management? Do we extubate? Those kind of things are conversa;ons I think we should have. (Surgical Fellow Hospital 2) 23 EPOCH Trial Sociology of Health and Illness 2017;39:

24 24 How to make change happen

25 What does engagement really mean to physicians? 1. Respect for my competency and skills 2. Feeling that my opinions are valued 3. Good rela;onships with my medical colleagues 4. Good work/life balance 5. A voice in how my ;me is structured and used 6. Fair compensa;on 7. Good rela;onships with non-clinical staff 8. A broader sense of meaning in my work 9. A voice in clinical opera;ons and processes 10. Opportuni;es to expand my skills and learn new skills 25 From: Increasing Physician Engagement: start with what s important to physicians. Robert Stark The journal of medical pracoce management 2014;30:171-5

26 How was our program developed? SPONSORS HIP Health System Leadership Value Improvement Office ( Lean Team ) + Center for Health System Innova;on DESIGN SELECTION Department Chairs Value Improvement Office ( Lean Team ) + Center for Health System Innova;on DELIVERY

27 Why it was designed this way? To help clinicians understand the components of value To equip them with improvement science tools To provide leadership development To educate on change management concepts To provide basics on organiza;onal strategy and goals To demonstrate how to use and inves;gate ins;tu;onal data e.g. Vizient To help foster research and publica;on in quality improvement To support selec;on and development of a project on which to apply these skills 27

28 Program Structure Day Day Adult Learning principles Including game and simula;ons 1 2 1:1 coaching sessions Quality and Lean Introduc]on System Thinking A3 and PDSA Project Selec]on Value Stream Map Run Charts Root Cause Analysis Data Support Day Publica]on Benchmarking Sustainability Change Management Innova]on Stakeholder Analysis Leadership Day

29 Introduction to the program Selec;ng and scoping poten;al projects Selec;ng and calcula;ng project metric(s) Forming project teams Mapping processes Root Cause Analysis Developing countermeasures Implemen;ng countermeasures Communica;ng the project with other stakeholders Re-measuring project metrics Making necessary adjustments Finalizing the presenta;on Cohort Selec]on Oct 16 Nov 16 Dec 16 Jan 17 Feb 17 Mar 17 Apr 17 May 17 Jun 17 Jul 17 Aug 17 Sep 17 Oct 17 Nov 17 QIPI day 1 QIPI day 2 QIPI day 3 QIPI day 4 Ongoing coaching and data support Sharing the result and learnings 29

30 Educating and Inspiring our Staff - QIPI Crea;ng a collabora;ve and posi;ve off-site experience Fast paced learning Fast paced learning and applica;on of tools and applica;on of tools Crea;ng a collabora;ve and posi;ve off-site experience Invited Invited guest speakers guest to enrich the learning experience speakers to enrich Opportuni;es for the learning publica;ons Opportuni;es experience for publica;ons 30

31 Summary of successful projects Dr. Jay Hudgins Improve % of transfused cases vs. type and screen orders Dr. Michael Johns Improve Pa;ent throughput in OHNS clink Dr. Benjamin Emanuel Improve door ;me to CT/MRI ;me for stroke pa;ents Dr. Armand Dorian Appropriate Pa;ent Status Determina;on at ;me of Admission Dr. Brigney DeClerck Improving EMR U;liza;on/ efficiency in dermatology clinics Dr. Naomi Schechter Improving pa;ent transfers to Norris Radia;on Oncology Dr. Jehni S. Robinson Improve pa;ent cycle ;me in Family Medicine clinic 31

32 32 Recognitions and presentations

33 Other QI physician engagement projects at KMUSC Care Delivery Redesign A mul;disciplinary approach lead by healthcare administrators with engaged physicians, and supported by the Value Improvement Office Surgical Quality Improvement Officers A physician led program, funded by the Department of Surgery with nominated surgical and anesthesiology leads, supported to work on their own improvement programs with financial compensa;on. QI Mentoring and data analy;cs support provided. 33

34 Recipe for Care Delivery Redesign Key Ingredients: q Physician Champions q Mid-Level Providers q Allied Health Professionals q Ancillary Services q Administra;ve Support q Execu;ve Engagement q Data Transparency q Shared Vision for Success Steps: 1. Align on Burning Plaxorm 2. Iden;fy Key Opportuni;es 3. Gauge Readiness & Build Core Teams 4. Engage in Cri;cal Review 5. Create Environment for Change 6. Facilitate Cross-Collabora;on 7. Sustain, Share, & Expand 34

35 Steps 1. Align on Burning Plaiorm Our Shared Challenge: 2. Iden;fy Key Opportuni;es 3. Gauge Readiness & Build Core Teams Q+S+A $ 4. Engage in Cri;cal Review 5. Create Environment for Change 6. Facilitate Cross-Collabora;on 7. Sustain, Share, & Expand Key Ingredients at Work Assess Current State and Benchmark Engage Clinical Leaders in the Why? Create A Shared Vision 35

36 Steps 1. Align on Burning Plaxorm 2. Iden]fy Key Opportuni]es 3. Gauge Readiness & Build Core Teams 4. Engage in Cri;cal Review 5. Create Environment for Change 6. Facilitate Cross-Collabora;on 7. Sustain, Share, & Expand Key Ingredients at Work Use Data to Discover Gaps Iden;fy Exis;ng Improvements in Progress Select Focus Cohort 36

37 Steps 1. Align on Burning Plaxorm 2. Iden;fy Key Opportuni;es 3. Gauge Readiness & Build Core Teams 4. Engage in Cri;cal Review 5. Create Environment for Change 6. Facilitate Cross-Collabora;on 7. Sustain, Share, & Expand Key Ingredients at Work Assess Readiness for Change Iden;fy Champions in Key Areas Ask Who Else Should Be Involved 37

38 Steps 1. Align on Burning Plaxorm 2. Iden;fy Key Opportuni;es 3. Gauge Readiness & Build Core Teams 4. Engage in Cri]cal Review 5. Create Environment for Change 6. Facilitate Cross-Collabora;on 7. Sustain, Share, & Expand Key Ingredients at Work Combine Clinical and Financial Data Cri;cally Review Every Day, Every Care Decision Iden;fy Process Failures Across Disciplines 38

39 Steps 1. Align on Burning Plaxorm 2. Iden;fy Key Opportuni;es 3. Gauge Readiness & Build Core Teams 4. Engage in Cri;cal Review 5. Create Environment for Change 6. Facilitate Cross-Collabora;on 7. Sustain, Share, & Expand Key Ingredients at Work Assemble Impacted Stakeholders Create Safe Space to Share Encourage Difficult Discussions 39

40 Steps 1. Align on Burning Plaxorm 2. Iden;fy Key Opportuni;es 3. Gauge Readiness & Build Core Teams 4. Engage in Cri;cal Review 5. Create Environment for Change 6. Facilitate Cross-Collabora]on 7. Sustain, Share, & Expand Key Ingredients at Work Share Findings from Cri;cal Reviews Iden;fy Cross-Func;onal Teams Launch Short- and Long-term Improvements 40

41 Steps 1. Align on Burning Plaxorm 2. Iden;fy Key Opportuni;es 3. Gauge Readiness & Build Core Teams 4. Engage in Cri;cal Review 5. Create Environment for Change 6. Facilitate Cross-Collabora;on 7. Sustain, Share, & Expand Key Ingredients at Work Monitor and Share Performance Learn from Successes and Failures Create Organiza;onal Awareness 41

42 Steps 1. Align on Burning Plaxorm 2. Iden;fy Key Opportuni;es 3. Gauge Readiness & Build Core Teams 4. Engage in Cri;cal Review 5. Create Environment for Change 6. Facilitate Cross-Collabora;on 7. Sustain, Share, & Expand Key Ingredients at Work Share Findings from Cri;cal Reviews Iden;fy Cross-Func;onal Teams Launch Short- and Long-term Improvements 42

43 Department of Surgery Quality Officers Program Supported and funded by Chair of Surgery Financial incen;ve Significant data and QI support One mee;ng a month of group Some QI training Focus on development of leaders Financial calcula;ons to jus;fy ROI Celebra;on of success 43

44 DOS Quality Officers Desired Outcome Forum to share quality data & ini]a]ves Engage, mentor, & train officers on quality & performance improvement Lead and implement quality & performance improvement project within the division and scale to other divisions 44

45 Performance Improvement Process 1 month 2-4 months 2 months 3-6 months 1 month IDENTIFICATION OF PROJECT INVESTIGATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION AUDIT/MODIFY/ITERATE REPORT Process for Performance Improvement (1 year Timeframe) Quality Outcomes Operational Inefficiencies Regulations Research Cost Quality Outcomes Operational Inefficiencies Research Cost Value = Quality Cost 45

46 Using measurement and local data to inform and drive improvement Process and Outcome data Crea;ng a buzz, a campaign, energy the wish to be part of something Ini;al QI training, follow up, regular review and sharing with stakeholders Basic training in QI techniques, data and support 46

47 Hypothesis Sample Project: Increasing Efficiency & Decreasing Length of Stay in Vascular Surgery Project iden;fied by surgeons, engaged AQending and Division Chief Increasing iden;fica;on and early management of avoidable delays will decrease length of stay focus on pa;ents with O/E ra;o > 1 day Overlapping project between Surgical Quality Officers and Care Redesign Results 47

48 48 Current Process

49 49 Proposed New Process for Workflow

50 Surgical Quality Officers; Reflection -what we will do differently in the next iteration Involve Anesthesiology Compensa;on linked to aqendance Projects more clearly linked to organiza;onal goals More formal ;me in QI training Less of a research approach to data, less retrospec;ve analysis more use of sampling and run charts Greater involvement of hospital QI department More celebra;on and promo;on of success 50

51 51 We ve shared our experience. What does some of the research say.

52 Lessons from McLeod Hospital s Transformation Ask doctors to lead mantra is physician-led, data-driven, evidence based Ask doctors what they want to work on Make it easy for doctors to lead and to par;cipate Recogni;on for doctors who lead Support for medical staff leaders with courage Opportuni;es to learn and grow Gosfeld AG, Reinertsen JL (2010). Achieving Clinical Integra;on with Highly Engaged Physicians. Unpublished manuscript in Medical Engagement too important to be lek to chance Clark J. The King s Fund 2012 hpp:// hhpps:// 52

53 Consider Behavioral Economics Ann Intern Med 2016;164:

54 How do you get clinicians involved in quality improvement? Improving quality is part of doctors professional iden;tytapping into this can be a powerful mo;vator for change Clinician led quality improvement can lead to greater standardiza;on, more equitable care, greater quality control, improved pa;ent sa;sfac;on and beqer pa;ent outcomes QI must be aligned with resource alloca;on, supported by professional training, commissioning and regula;on and integrated into service management QI to be sustainable must be integrated with organiza;onal direc;on and resources 54

55 1. Consider your organiza;ons track record emphasize why this program will succeed how is it different? 2. Give doctors ;me and resources to ac;vely engage 3. Explana;ons of the purpose of the program should be phrased to reflect priori;es and concerns of clinicians 4. Evidence of efficacy local evidence will help 5. External exper;se where possible to add credibility 6. Local program champions (credibility with other clinicians) 7. Management involvement in a posi;on to support clinicians 55 Seven Themes for Medical Engagement Medical Engagement in organisaoon wide safety and quality improvement programmes. Parand et al Qual Saf Health Care 2010;19:e44

56 Harness Passion What is their passion, what is their clinical desire? Is it to be the best gastroenterologist ever how can you help them get there? To have the lowest mortality for sepsis how can your QI work get them there? Ask how can I help you.. be the best doctor have the best team.. save the most pa;ents? 56

57 In Summary We have designed and led a number of programs which engage and develop physicians in improvement leadership We will modify the next round of these programs based on our experience and feedback We have seen tangible improvements, ROI and joy in work increase for physicians and their teams 57

58 THANK YOU! THE KECK EFFECT ENGAGED PHYSICIANS IMPROVING THE QUALITY OF OUR CARE 58