RESEARCH ISSUES PERTAINING TO BIRTH CENTERS A PROVIDERS PROSPECTIVE

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "RESEARCH ISSUES PERTAINING TO BIRTH CENTERS A PROVIDERS PROSPECTIVE"

Basil Thornton
5 years ago
Views:

1 RESEARCH ISSUES PERTAINING TO BIRTH CENTERS A PROVIDERS PROSPECTIVE Karen Pelote, CNM March 7, 2013 Midwifery Photos Courtesy of Sterner Turner Media and Thomas De Clerk

2 COMMUNITY OF HOPE FAMILY HEALTH AND BIRTH CENTER, WASHINGTON, D.C.

3 CLIENTS STORIES

4 GROUP

3% and in the District of Columbia only 14.4%.

5 BIRTH CENTER CARE IMPROVES BREASTFEEDING OUTCOMES Breast feeding has long lasting benefits on for the both baby and the mother. The CDC U.S Breastfeeding Report Card reports the National rate of six month exclusivity is 16.3% and in the District of Columbia only 14.4%. According to the National Immunization Survey Report published by the CDC in 2010 the national rates for African American Initiation is 54.4% FHBC rate for AA Initiation is 84% FHBC rate Six Month Exclusive (Only Breastmilk) Breastfeeding Rate - 46%

MIDWIFERY CARE AT BIRTH CENTERS IS SAFE Measure United States 1989 Birth Centers 2013 Cesarean Rate 31.8% 4.4% 6.1% Neonatal mortality 0.75/1000 0.3/1000 0.

6 MIDWIFERY CARE AT BIRTH CENTERS IS SAFE Measure United States 1989 Birth Centers 2013 Cesarean Rate 31.8% 4.4% 6.1% Neonatal mortality 0.75/ / /1000 Maternal mortality 14/100,000 * 0 0 *Live births Stapleton, 2013; Sakala, Childbirth Connection, 2008

MIDWIFERY CARE AT BIRTH CENTERS IMPACTS LIVES Such confidence, in turn, builds self-esteem and starts the young family off on thinking of pregnancy, birth, and family

7 MIDWIFERY CARE AT BIRTH CENTERS IMPACTS LIVES Such confidence, in turn, builds self-esteem and starts the young family off on thinking of pregnancy, birth, and family health as wellness, not disease. Client: The fact that they encourage you to be involved and responsible about you and your family s health

here. feeding Instead the of baby feeling all by like myself.

8 IMPACTING LIVES Client: I The made care this was baby, personalized, I delivered it feels this baby all by myself and now I am like a family here. feeding Instead the of baby feeling all by like myself. (FHBC Teen) pregnancy was a medical condition, I feel like it was an awesome natural event.

9 MIDWIFERY CARE AT BIRTH CENTERS AFFECT COSTS If even 10 percent (400,000) of the 4 million women who give birth in the U.S. each year delivered their babies in Birth Centers, the savings in facility fee payments alone would be at least $2.6 Billion Annually!

10 MIDWIFERY CARE AT BIRTH CENTERS DECREASE DISPARITY J Perinat Educ Spring; 17(2): For all U.S. women, the maternal death ratio is almost 5 times as high as it should be, and for African American women, it is more than 10 times what it should be.

birth center 94% of transfers to hospital were non-emergency e.g. prolonged labor Less than 1% (0.

11 TRANSFER RATES FROM OUTCOMES OF CARE IN BIRTH CENTERS 2013 During Labor 4.5% referred to hospital in labor prior to admission to birth center 12% referred to hospital in labor after admission to birth center 94% of transfers to hospital were non-emergency e.g. prolonged labor Less than 1% (0.9%, n=140) required emergency transfer during labor After Birth 2.0% of mothers transferred after giving birth (0.4% were emergency) 2.2% of infants transferred after birth (0.6% were emergency) Stapleton, 2013

12 CLINICAL ISSUES Premature Rupture Of Membranes Prolonged Labor Obesity

13 AREAS FOR FURTHER INVESTIGATION Benefits of group prenatal care Psychological benefits to clients and society Cost and reimbursement issues Disparity Clinical Issues

14 COMPLETING THE CIRCLE BIRTH CENTER MIDWIFERY Safe and Effective Economical Psychologically Beneficial

15 Birth Centers: The Best X! Kept Secret!

16 REFERENCES Stapleton, et. al.; Outcomes of Care in Birth Centers; Demonstration of a durable model. Journal of Midwifery & Women s Health January/February 2013 The CDC U.S Breastfeeding Report Card National Immunization Survey Report published by the CDC in (Accessed March 1, 2013) Sakala, Corry; Evidence-Based Maternity Care: What It Is and What It Can Achieve Childbirth Connection, 2008 Why is the National U.S. Cesarean Section Rate So High? (accessed March 1, 2013) Palmer, Cook, Courtot Comparing Models of Maternity Care Serving Women at Risk of Poor Birth Outcomes in Washington, DC p Alternative Therapies Sep/Oct (5) Rooks et.al.; Outcomes of Care in Birth Centers National Birth Center Study (reprinted from the New England Journal of Medicine 321: (December 28), 1989 Gaskin; Maternal Death in the United States: A Problem Solved or a Problem Ignored? J Perinat Educ Spring; 17(2): (retrieved from accessed March 1, 2013)

The Birth Center Experience Kitty Ernst, FACNM, MPH, DSc (hon) and Kate Bauer, MBA

The Birth Center Experience Kitty Ernst, FACNM, MPH, DSc (hon) and Kate Bauer, MBA Few innovations in health service promote lower cost, greater availability, and a high degree of satisfaction with a comparable